Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for being upset over a 3 year lie by omission

110 replies

SheNeedsSleep · 18/07/2023 16:45

Just to premise I do feel I am at fault for being as upset as I am but I really am not sure if the hurt I feel is reasonable or I am just an insecure wreck.

I married DH at the start of 2020 and we have a son 13m together. Recently since returning to work I have been struggling being away from my son and returning to a demanding role and taking on others emotional burdens, which comes as standard in my line of work. This I feel has led to me having minimal sleep and horrific nightmares that feel so real and are often relating to loss, death and infidelity (this is not something I find myself ever really thinking about consciously).

The reason I mention the dreams is I had a dream I found a ton of photos of my husband and a stripper, which felt so real as in the dream I was upset and went to bed so when I woke up for a moment i thought it was real. This was odd to me as when we married he went to a stag trip skiing abroad and I went to a cheesy club in Brighton, nothing seedy and no strippers. I mentioned this to be husband and we laughed about how silly it was. He then made a comment later in the day saying he never said to me he did or didn't have a stripper at his stag do. This confused me as at the time I asked what they got up to and he told me drinking and skiing. When pushed he admitted to going to a strip club and having a private dance.

I feel really bothered that he never told me. Is it normal for husbands to hide this to avoid upsetting their wives? I ask as all my married friends told their partners if they had strippers and were open. Also, every one of them had strippers in group settings, none had a private dance which is also messing with my head.

I am hoping I'm just over reacting but I can't shake this feeling that I should be upset and this is a red flag. He has apologised and promised he didnt enjoy it and he's not hiding anything else.

For context he has lied by omission a few times but nothing serious, I'm not sure he considers it lying.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mrstiggytinkle · 22/07/2023 11:15

In response to all of this you're going to learn how to lap dance for him too.

Mind boggles.

SheNeedsSleep · 20/07/2023 17:44

Hopelesscynic · 20/07/2023 17:14

"promised he didnt enjoy it"

And you believe this?

Had he gone alone I imagine its intimate and sexy. I imagine she looked incredible and danced amazingly. But let's be honest 3 minutes with your friends laughing at you round the corner probably isn't the most turned on he's ever been. I also watched tutorials as I'm still determined if I'm cancer free to learn to do one it's mainly visual and teasing and the instructors explained how to dance without sitting on his privates (I imagine a lot of strippers aren't attractive to the man and would rather not). I feel better now and I do believe he found it embarrassing and awkward.

Also directly questioned he's not the best liar and he was really honest so not sure what else to tell you except I believe him x

OP posts:
Hopelesscynic · 20/07/2023 17:14

"promised he didnt enjoy it"

And you believe this?

GoodChat · 20/07/2023 16:39

Fair enough OP. His explanation does make sense, to be fair, and it sounds like his not telling you wasn't him trying to be deceitful.

I'm glad you spoke properly about it.

SheNeedsSleep · 20/07/2023 16:37

ReleasetheCrackHen · 20/07/2023 16:20

Yeah, OP should be made aware of the possibilities from women like me who have been there and done that lap dancing gig. Not from other women who have never been there and never done it.

You said lap dances are dry humping
Im saying we do not dry hump the customers.
That’s not part of a bog standard lap dance.

Thank you your responses and your experience really helped me feel better about the whole thing! X

OP posts:
SheNeedsSleep · 20/07/2023 16:35

ReachForTheMars · 20/07/2023 13:35

Yeah, but he had kept silent for years.

After that long, what possible good would come from telling her? He got away with it.

Telling someone to ease your own guilt is poor judgement. Guilt is his punishment and he should have lived with it rather than told her so long after. Thre is literally no benefit to OP knowing. He wasnt feeling guilty all day every day for years. He lived with any guilt back then in the aftermath. Why? Because he thought he had something to lose. He has now decided that risk is lower now and worth offloading. Thats why its cruel.

So I did update but thought I'd add one to this. My husband assumed I had something at mine and didn't say anything. When I bought up the dream I explained about it and how weird as he never had one. His mind set was this at the time he felt I wouldn't have told him if I had a stripper so thought we were omitting details. When I directly made a statement his options were to tell the truth or lie. He did not want to lie to me.

He has been very understanding of my hurt and I'm not going to throw it all away over a 3 minute topless dance he barely remembers. I fixated on this so I didn't have to think about my health or the outcomes of my current tests.

I think we can all agree he maybe should have potentially admitted to it 3 years ago, said no to a lapdance at the time or given me a chance to book tickets to magic Mike before we got married to even it out 😁

I feel happy with the outcome and if it was a brothel his friends apparently didn't fork out for the full package so we are all good 🤭

OP posts:
ReleasetheCrackHen · 20/07/2023 16:20

GameOverBoys · 20/07/2023 07:33

‘Like I’ve told you’ 😂
I think you are very sure that your interpretation of the definition is correct I think otherwise. It’s not for you to tell me. It’s a discussion. TBH it’s also pretty irrelevant. Non of us really know what happened but we do know men often minimise the events and the OP should be aware of what the possibilities are.

Yeah, OP should be made aware of the possibilities from women like me who have been there and done that lap dancing gig. Not from other women who have never been there and never done it.

You said lap dances are dry humping
Im saying we do not dry hump the customers.
That’s not part of a bog standard lap dance.

ReachForTheMars · 20/07/2023 13:35

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 18/07/2023 17:28

She literally mentioned it first.

It's more likely she brought it up, he laughed about it but then thought about it, felt bad and decided to come clean rather than some evil, calculated move!

Yeah, but he had kept silent for years.

After that long, what possible good would come from telling her? He got away with it.

Telling someone to ease your own guilt is poor judgement. Guilt is his punishment and he should have lived with it rather than told her so long after. Thre is literally no benefit to OP knowing. He wasnt feeling guilty all day every day for years. He lived with any guilt back then in the aftermath. Why? Because he thought he had something to lose. He has now decided that risk is lower now and worth offloading. Thats why its cruel.

GameOverBoys · 20/07/2023 07:33

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/07/2023 23:24

Hmm, my experience and the definition you posted says otherwise.

To simulate sexual intercourse without the genitalia directly touching, i.e. while wearing clothes, or by rubbing the genitals against something else.

something else= can be fingers, hands. It just cannot be genitals.
usually snogging is involved, and dry humping is always mutual.

So the fact a lap dance isn’t mutual touching and does not simulate intercourse means it’s by definition not dry jumping as I have repeatedly told you.

And I also let you know that there isn’t even any one sided “humping” of a dancer on the man she is performing a lap dance for. It’s all about the look but don’t touch titillation.

Lap dances are not dry humps.

‘Like I’ve told you’ 😂
I think you are very sure that your interpretation of the definition is correct I think otherwise. It’s not for you to tell me. It’s a discussion. TBH it’s also pretty irrelevant. Non of us really know what happened but we do know men often minimise the events and the OP should be aware of what the possibilities are.

AutieNOT0tie · 20/07/2023 06:04

I'd be angry he didn't tell me but not sure it would be something to end the marriage over. I'm guessing he didn't want to rock the boat in lead up to wedding. Not technically a lie but definitely not honest. He probably saw this as an opportunity to let you know.

bozzabollix · 20/07/2023 05:51

It wouldn’t be a marriage breaker for me as it’s probably down to peer pressure rather than anything else, but I’d still massively hit the roof and be furious for a long time. My issue would be the way he couldn’t say no, and the commodification of women’s bodies, especially with the trafficking element. I’d be finding a few documentaries on the subject and making him watch them.

So rather than wonder about whether you’re in the right feeling uncomfortable be honest about how shitty his behaviour was and how it’s made you feel. Make him never want to do it again.

It’s funny how you don’t feel you have a right to being furious without validation from us mumsnetters, you feel how you feel and there’s bloody good reason for it, trust those feelings.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 20/07/2023 05:23

Sleepydoor · 20/07/2023 01:17

This made no sense whatsoever.

Yes well it requires a bit of real world experience to make sense.

Sleepydoor · 20/07/2023 01:17

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/07/2023 23:24

Hmm, my experience and the definition you posted says otherwise.

To simulate sexual intercourse without the genitalia directly touching, i.e. while wearing clothes, or by rubbing the genitals against something else.

something else= can be fingers, hands. It just cannot be genitals.
usually snogging is involved, and dry humping is always mutual.

So the fact a lap dance isn’t mutual touching and does not simulate intercourse means it’s by definition not dry jumping as I have repeatedly told you.

And I also let you know that there isn’t even any one sided “humping” of a dancer on the man she is performing a lap dance for. It’s all about the look but don’t touch titillation.

Lap dances are not dry humps.

This made no sense whatsoever.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/07/2023 23:24

GameOverBoys · 19/07/2023 19:51

Dry hump definition according to Google- To simulate sexual intercourse without the genitalia directly touching, i.e. while wearing clothes, or by rubbing the genitals against something else.

No fingering, orgasms or snogging involved

Hmm, my experience and the definition you posted says otherwise.

To simulate sexual intercourse without the genitalia directly touching, i.e. while wearing clothes, or by rubbing the genitals against something else.

something else= can be fingers, hands. It just cannot be genitals.
usually snogging is involved, and dry humping is always mutual.

So the fact a lap dance isn’t mutual touching and does not simulate intercourse means it’s by definition not dry jumping as I have repeatedly told you.

And I also let you know that there isn’t even any one sided “humping” of a dancer on the man she is performing a lap dance for. It’s all about the look but don’t touch titillation.

Lap dances are not dry humps.

GameOverBoys · 19/07/2023 19:51

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/07/2023 18:10

Definitions for you do seem a bit different from the common definition of things. Did ya miss the (hopefully) in my sentence in regards to dry hump orgasms?

Being factual about my past experience isn’t being defensive.

I know some clubs are both a strip clubs and brothels. However, you are literally speculating and exaggerating by implying that the OP’s stag do took him to not just a strip club. Classiness of the joint has nothing to do with it btw.

Dry hump definition according to Google- To simulate sexual intercourse without the genitalia directly touching, i.e. while wearing clothes, or by rubbing the genitals against something else.

No fingering, orgasms or snogging involved

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/07/2023 18:10

GameOverBoys · 19/07/2023 13:51

For me a dry hump doesn’t have to include those elements I’m not sure why you think everyone who has a bit of a dry hump has an orgasm? I understand why you feel defensive of your profession but I’m sure as someone who has worked in the industry you know that in different places and especially Europe the standards are different and it’s no exaggeration to say that they are brothels (sex from sex works on the premises). Maybe Austria is different or this place was a bit classier but you know it goes on very prolifically.

Definitions for you do seem a bit different from the common definition of things. Did ya miss the (hopefully) in my sentence in regards to dry hump orgasms?

Being factual about my past experience isn’t being defensive.

I know some clubs are both a strip clubs and brothels. However, you are literally speculating and exaggerating by implying that the OP’s stag do took him to not just a strip club. Classiness of the joint has nothing to do with it btw.

GameOverBoys · 19/07/2023 13:51

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/07/2023 13:32

Well I never “humped” a customer when I danced. There’s not that kind of action going on.

Even if we did “hump” the customers in a one sided sort of way, it’s still not a dry hump as it is missing key elements:

  • mutual touching and kissing
  • fingering/hand job
  • orgasm for (hopefully) both of you h while still dressed- his more messy of course

It was a typical stag do where the grooms men had paid a dancer to do a lap dance for the stag. I feel honestly like many posters are building Everest out of a molehill. I’m fine with it bothering some women, but there’s no need to make it out as something much more intimate and significant than it is or to imply he was in a brothel.

For me a dry hump doesn’t have to include those elements I’m not sure why you think everyone who has a bit of a dry hump has an orgasm? I understand why you feel defensive of your profession but I’m sure as someone who has worked in the industry you know that in different places and especially Europe the standards are different and it’s no exaggeration to say that they are brothels (sex from sex works on the premises). Maybe Austria is different or this place was a bit classier but you know it goes on very prolifically.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/07/2023 13:32

GameOverBoys · 19/07/2023 10:44

A dry hump is often exactly what it is even in the UK. They can’t touch the dancers but they can touch them.
European ‘strip clubs’ are often a front for brothels and the rules are very different. Don’t know specifically about Austria.

Well I never “humped” a customer when I danced. There’s not that kind of action going on.

Even if we did “hump” the customers in a one sided sort of way, it’s still not a dry hump as it is missing key elements:

  • mutual touching and kissing
  • fingering/hand job
  • orgasm for (hopefully) both of you h while still dressed- his more messy of course

It was a typical stag do where the grooms men had paid a dancer to do a lap dance for the stag. I feel honestly like many posters are building Everest out of a molehill. I’m fine with it bothering some women, but there’s no need to make it out as something much more intimate and significant than it is or to imply he was in a brothel.

GameOverBoys · 19/07/2023 10:44

ReleasetheCrackHen · 18/07/2023 18:00

“Sexual contact” 🤣
It’s not like he got a hand job or a dry hump.

A dry hump is often exactly what it is even in the UK. They can’t touch the dancers but they can touch them.
European ‘strip clubs’ are often a front for brothels and the rules are very different. Don’t know specifically about Austria.

SheNeedsSleep · 19/07/2023 10:36

Thank you all. We did talk it through. I believe he didn't pay for it, he found it embarrassing and explained the extend of the dance which wasnt quite as graphic as i feared. He is quite a shy person and I don't think having spoken to him i need to worry. He also thought I had a stripper or butler in the buff but didn't tell him so he felt guilty. Most his friends are married so it's unlikely he's going to another stag and he said he'd happily skip any stag dos if I was worried which I'm not sure I am now.

To clarify he has in the past not mentioned things that would have upset me e.g. an ex tried to get into contact and he turned her away nearer the start if our relationship. He's not big on hiding things so at the time I saw the text and he then explained.

I also failed to mention im currently undergoing diagnostic tests to rule out the big C so I do think I put a lot of fear onto this issue to focus on something.

I am happy with the outcome and if the tests come back negative it may motivate me to learn to try and give a lap dance. If I can't erase that he had one perhaps I can be the best on eh?🤭

Thank you all for your insight and support x

OP posts:
CakeyBakeyHeart · 19/07/2023 08:07

Didimum · 18/07/2023 19:23

You do know what private dances often entail, right?

A beating in the back alley if you touch the dancers?

StopStartStop · 19/07/2023 07:58

A 'red flag' is a warning. The private dance secrecy has gone further than that. So what is it? A red sheet? A red line?

The line has been crossed.

He's a good husband, he has not told me things before to I think protect my feelings.

Now, that's a red flag.

Can you trust him? No, of course not. He lies; he lies by omission.

many of the posters saying that they would never feel the same about their husbands simply don't know what their husbands have got up to

I agree. But I'm not optimistic about relationships where men ignore their partners' boundaries. You don't have to explicitly to state 'You mustn't have private dances from strippers' - that should be taken as read.

SilverArch · 19/07/2023 07:35

I went through a horrible stressful time in my life where I kept having the same horrible nightmare over and over again. I reduced the stress in my life and the nightmares went away.

There is no way I would end a marriage for a lap dance 3 years ago on a stag night which he has now told you about. I mean if it had been a night of total drunken debauchery - and I have heard many worse tales of what went on on stag nights than this - he would never even have mentioned it.

Lots of mumsnetters are outraged about things like this. Judging by the prevalence of these establishments, I can guarantee that many of the posters saying that they would never feel the same about their husbands simply don't know what their husbands have got up to. And, in reality, most of them would not even contemplate leaving their husbands despite their brave words to other women about it.

The stress that you are feeling now would be much worse if you were a sole parent. I have a responsible professional role and my husband spent a not inconsiderable time abroad for work when our children were very small so I was like a sole parent for weeks at a time and it was pretty grim. (He did shout me a trip to a far flung destination as a thank you for those times.) I think you just need to put the whole incident behind you and move on.

notanotherclairebear · 19/07/2023 07:12

The private dance would bother me in that I think it's gross, but not because I think it's being unfaithful and I certainly wouldn't question an otherwise good marriage over it.

Gently, the awful nightmares that you're having sound like you might benefit from speaking to someone. At the risk of sounding like a couch psychologist I had very similar, crippling nightmares which began to tip into conscious thoughts during they day. I was eventually diagnosed with post-natal depression and wouldn't wish those feelings on anyone so, if you feel like it may help, consider making an appointment with your GP or HV

notanotherclairebear · 19/07/2023 07:07

R*eleasetheCrackHen
"Yeah, I’m naive but I’ve been a stripper in a full nude club that including doing lap dances. There is nothing to be jealous of, honestly. 🤣😂 now you get two silly laughing emojis."
*
Aaaaaaaaaaaand mic drop 🎤 👏🏼 🤣🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread