Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is DDs ex being unfair

470 replies

warpeacelove · 18/07/2023 16:19

Hi,
So I'm not sure if I am being biased and just worried about DD. DD is 21, just graduated uni, she has a job lined up for September (civil service grad scheme). She is usually a very smart, logical, loving girl.
She came home last week, distraught, she and her boyfriend of a year and a half had broken up, didn't want to talk about why and I didn't pry.
Last night she was extremely quiet, had been out in the afternoon, didn't want dinner etc.
This morning she came into my room, 5am sobbing, DH took himself to the guest room and she told me is 12 weeks pregnant, she went to her scan yesterday alone etc. She told me she had done a pregnancy test last week but didn't think she was as far along, her periods are irregular, she has the implant etc. She then said that her ex has blocked her everywhere, she doesn't want their mutual friends to get involved so could I message him and say its important.
He eventually replied, and it turned out DD has failed to give me really important information, she cheated on him, DD has now told me it happened once, on a holiday 4 weeks ago with one of her uni societies , there is no way the baby's dad is anyone other than her ex.
He is refusing to hear DD, I ended up having to tell him on a phone call that DD is pregnant to which he said "probably not mine and If it is I don't care".
Now I know DD messed up badly, she shouldn't have cheated but right now she clearly needs support. We live in the North West she studied in and in theory will be working in London, so if she goes back for the job she will have no support at all. I ended up calling in sick to my own work as DD was so upset I couldn't leave her alone, she has spent all day sad in bed.
She doesn't want an abortion, also doesn't want to do it totally alone, doesn't expect her ex to forgive her or get back together but atleast be there for his child.
I'm trying to convince her to just stay at home, give the job up, DH and I can support her for a year or two, then she can find something locally and we can support her. She isn't convinced, doesn't think there will be many jobs her Politics and Economics degree will be useful for in the rural north west (was thinking maybe local council or similar).
Is DDs ex being unnecessarily unfair? Or does DD deserve all she is getting, she did cheat after all!!
I'm terrified for her so goodness knows how awful she will be feeling!!

OP posts:
StellaJohanna · 18/07/2023 19:19

I'm worried for the OP. If DD decides to go ahead with the pregnancy, unless her DD has a complete personality change, OP and her DH will be financing and taking care of this child and DD for the foreseeable future! Rents are sky high. There are no council houses to hand out!

ikno · 18/07/2023 19:18

Is DDs ex being unnecessarily unfair?

eh? I get that you’re going through a hard time but I think you’re putting unnecessary pressure on her ex. He’s allowed to split up with her, that’s not being “unnecessarily unfair”, what more is he supposed to do? There’s nothing stopping her from moving back to London and house sharing. She doesn’t HAVE to live with him. The solution to this is not him taking her back.

The pregnancy is a separate matter. If he’s the father she can go through CMS but she can’t force him to be in her life.

If she continues with the pregnancy I’d highly recommend she drops the civil service role. They run that grad scheme every year and it lasts 3 years - it’s an intensive scheme designed to propel people forward in a short time so it will be high pressure and she will be based in different departments and locations so it will not be stable. I doubt she will get the most out of it if she’s spending part of those 3 years on maternity leave. It would be better for her to have the child and join CS. She would be better off even getting a non graduate role at civil service, as at least she will be more likely to be able to get flexible working.

Likewhatever · 18/07/2023 19:15

She has her head in the sand OP and she needs to face reality, and quickly, The ex isn’t interested - I don’t blame him - so however much she wants him to be involved, he isn’t going to be.

Unless you see yourself as unpaid full time childcare for the foreseeable I wouldn’t be too supportive of her keeping the baby. Sorry, I know that sounds harsh, but she hasn’t shown herself to be responsible enough for parenthood without a lot of support. Are you and your DH really up for that?

Beautiful3 · 18/07/2023 19:13

Honestly I'd be encouraging her to get an abortion. Having it and becoming dependent on her mum, would be terrible for her. She's so young and still has the world to see. You need to forget about the ex, he's never going to get involved. Encourage her to get rid. She can have children later on, when she has a committed partner and financially stable.

thedancingbear · 18/07/2023 19:11

Mikimoto · 18/07/2023 19:06

Which mistake are you referring to - the first affair, the second affair, the cocaine, the binge drinking or the pregnancy?

The pregnancy. Everything else is pretty trivial. Kids drinking, doing drugs and shagging is as old as the hills. Nothing to suggest she won’t be a lovely to someone when she’s older.

why stick the boot into a young woman when she’s down? What does it say about you?

TiaraBoo · 18/07/2023 19:11

To answer the original question, I don’t think ex is ‘reacting’ unreasonably. once he’s calmed down the sharing the information on the dating scan should prepare him that he will be a father.
Once baby is born and a DNA test confirms he is a father, then it would be unreasonable for him not to have something to do with the baby. But what would that ‘something’ be? They could be at opposite ends of the country and he also won’t be supporting your DD if that’s what she’s looking for as well.

If it was my DD, I’d want her to be clear on what her future life /future options will look like and how will she do that looking after a baby as a single parent.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/07/2023 19:10

ThinWomansBrain · 18/07/2023 18:21

At 21 she is an adult and the choice is hers to make.

If so adult, maybe she should stop lying, sleeping around, drinking heavily while pregnant, and behaving like a stroppy teenager in 'refusing' to speak to OP.

Maybe she should, but that doesn't stop her being an adult.

Rosecoffeecup · 18/07/2023 19:09

Does she actually want a baby? It certainly doesn't sound like she's ready for one. I would remind her of her options.

In terms of her grades scheme offer, can she defer or transfer? There's a number of CS offices in the NW I think? She may be able to attach to a different location to London.

Mikimoto · 18/07/2023 19:06

thedancingbear · 18/07/2023 19:04

What misogynistic shite. You never made a mistake?

Which mistake are you referring to - the first affair, the second affair, the cocaine, the binge drinking or the pregnancy?

FatCatBum · 18/07/2023 19:05

So if the other guy beat her to it in telling her boyfriend she cheated with him in Greece, because they were all out drinking together it was clearly someone they both knew and not some random holiday encounter

Was it the same bloke she woke up with in February? If so, based on her other behaviour and the 'what would you do if I was pregnant' message, I think the ex is quite right not to trust a single word she says

Totaly · 18/07/2023 19:05

I’m not sure why everyone is turning detective!

She’s young, single and pregnant - the rest is irrelevant.

Deal with the facts and stop judging her.

What you should be doing as a parent is supporting her choices and at the moment you are being judgmental.

She needs facts about her future choices - help her with those and stop messaging people (just for a second how would you feel is someone you thought you could trust went behind your back and messaged your DH?) Terrible behaviour -
Wonder where DD she got it from?

PowerBMI · 18/07/2023 19:05

Takeitonthechin · 18/07/2023 18:56

If she gives her job up, she won't get maternity leave pay.
No disrespect but she doesn't seem mature enough to have a baby if she's cheating on her boyfriend, does she really want a baby, because if she's thinking this is a way of him coming back to her, when she's already ruined the trust she had, plus, did she really love him to cheat on him.
She's either going to have to make up her own mind, sounds like you're going to have your hands full with a baby if she goes ahead and has this.
I'm afraid she's got herself into this mess

She doesn’t start the job until September. She won’t get mat pay

thedancingbear · 18/07/2023 19:04

Mikimoto · 18/07/2023 19:01

Whoever ends up with her will be a lucky, lucky guy.

What misogynistic shite. You never made a mistake?

Blossomtoes · 18/07/2023 19:03

Clymene · 18/07/2023 18:57

If my summary is correct, then she doesn't want this baby but she's just hoping it all goes away in a very childish way. But unfortunately pregnancy doesn't work like that. Support her in having a termination. She doesn't have much time and it will be much more difficult the longer she leaves it

This. If she terminates she can draw a line under all this and start again. It’s the best thing for all concerned.

Strawberryfieldsforever12345 · 18/07/2023 19:03

Not ok.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 18/07/2023 19:03

Mikimoto · 18/07/2023 19:01

Whoever ends up with her will be a lucky, lucky guy.

People make stupid mistakes especially when they’re young. There’s no need to be nasty.

Gilmorehill · 18/07/2023 19:02

After reading about the drinking and taking cocaine, I’d be really concerned about damage to the baby 😕.

Mikimoto · 18/07/2023 19:01

Whoever ends up with her will be a lucky, lucky guy.

Katey83 · 18/07/2023 19:01

This all sounds quite implausible as others have pointed out. Something isn’t right - either she knew before last week and had the scan yesterday, or the whole thing is a manipulative ruse to get you to reach out to her ex. I imagine the timings of the cheating are also a lie. I would be very clear with DD that if she isn’t totally honest with you from now forward it’s not going to be possible for you to support her. Certainly, she can’t expect her ex to do anything other than wait until baby is born and request a DNA test. If the baby is his, he will legally need to provide for it. He owes her nothing right now however, as he can’t trust a word that she says and given the details you posted here, nor should you!

Clymene · 18/07/2023 18:57

If my summary is correct, then she doesn't want this baby but she's just hoping it all goes away in a very childish way. But unfortunately pregnancy doesn't work like that. Support her in having a termination. She doesn't have much time and it will be much more difficult the longer she leaves it

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 18/07/2023 18:57

Damnedidont · 18/07/2023 18:47

If she keeps the child is she prepared to deal with fetal alcohol syndrome?? This is almost a certainty.Any drinking can cause it and if she binges ....

Alcohol doesn’t cross the placenta until 10-12 weeks. So fingers crossed so long as stops now it should be ok. I certainly drank loads before I knew I was pregnant and dd18 is fine.

Takeitonthechin · 18/07/2023 18:56

If she gives her job up, she won't get maternity leave pay.
No disrespect but she doesn't seem mature enough to have a baby if she's cheating on her boyfriend, does she really want a baby, because if she's thinking this is a way of him coming back to her, when she's already ruined the trust she had, plus, did she really love him to cheat on him.
She's either going to have to make up her own mind, sounds like you're going to have your hands full with a baby if she goes ahead and has this.
I'm afraid she's got herself into this mess

thedancingbear · 18/07/2023 18:56

OP, I think your DD is getting a hard time of it here. Whatever her behaviour outside the relationship, her ex had unprotected sex, with predictable consequences. He’s 50% responsible for her situation, and needs to take responsibility. ‘Blocking and moving on’ is not an option for him.

honeylulu · 18/07/2023 18:55

Her latest update makes a lot more sense. Though I suspect there is more info to come and there has been more cheating between Feb and June (Greece) than she's letting on for now. I don't really believe she isn't sure if she cheated or not in Feb. Was it the same bloke both times? As that would be more indicative of an ongoing "affair" over a six month period that the boyfriend mentioned rather than two separate one night stands. Despite her protestations she may not know who the father is though desperately wants it to be the boyfriend. What a mess. I do feel quite sorry for her, she's made lots of poor decisions and they probably escalated while she was in denial. As a very rough calculation she likely got pregnant early-mid May which may or may not clarify the paternity issue.

Strawberryfieldsforever12345 · 18/07/2023 18:55

As in could they ever track him down, meet him, have a relationship with him, know their heritage