Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance one night stand

508 replies

Roses121 · 18/07/2023 13:48

I got pregnant from a one night stand 2 years ago. I was 19 at the time and he was 35. Wasn’t really thinking straight and although we used contraception I ended up pregnant.

I made the decision to keep my baby and knew full well I would be raising him on my own. I didn’t want a relationship with him.
I didn’t have any expectations for his father although he said he wanted to be in his life and has been.

My son has never stayed overnight with him as he’s breastfed (16 months now), so we’ve only ever met at public places as I would feel a bit weird having him at my place and vice versa.
When we met I was aware that he had kids (2) and he told me he had split from his ex 3 years prior. Looking back now, it’s possible he lied about the last part just to get me in to bed.
I have not met her or their kids or anyone from his family and vice versa. Contact is not that often, maybe once or twice a month.

I am starting uni in September and will have less money since I’ll have to take on less hours at work. Up until this point I have never asked him for money nor has he offered but after looking at the child maintenance calculator I think my son is entitled to 300-400 monthly.

I know that legally a man is obliged to pay this but morally speaking, would it be wrong to put in a claim since we didn’t plan the baby? Also I will add that although he was shocked when I told him I was pregnant, as was I, he never said ‘I don’t want it.’ I think it’s likely that he pays for his other kids, whether he is in a relationship with her or not, so I think it’s unfair on my son to get nothing but I’m also aware if I do claim it then he’ll have less money for his other kids so I feel a bit bad about that.
I don’t know his salary but Googling average incomes for his job are between 30-50k hence why it estimates 300-400, he is also currently building a house in another country so I know he’s not broke if you get me.

Hope this all make sense x

OP posts:
PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 12:37

Sorry, B!

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 12:36

CakeyBakeyHeart · 20/07/2023 12:09

Okay so I’m intrigued as to whether you genuinely disagree with what I’m asserting or simply don’t understand it. Here we are in the format of an equation:

My assertion is that if -

Decision on whether to keep an unplanned baby = A (does man want baby) + B (does woman want baby) + C (adjustment for all factors relating to ethics) + D (adjustment for all factors relating to biological difference e.g. medical risks of abortion, emotional and physical costs/risks of carrying a baby to term)

and you then remove C and D from the equation you should have a choice where A and B are given equal weight.

Refute at your leisure! (noting that things like do I have financial means, does my existing child want a sibling etc. all fit in to A or B category)

Eh?
You think that if someone has the temerity to disagree with you, then they haven't understood your point?

This situation is not a formal proof of logic, and doesn't boil down to being mechanically verifiable. I don't agree with your axioms in any case.

Decision on whether or not to keep an unplanned baby ≠ A+B . A&B should not be given equal weight.

Decision on whether or not to keep an unplanned baby = A.

sunglassesonthetable · 20/07/2023 12:30

and you then remove C and D from the equation you should have a choice where A and B are given equal weight.

But why do you remove these? They are crucial to decision making.

CakeyBakeyHeart · 20/07/2023 12:09

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 10:28

Yet you think this is how it should be for men (who have made their choice by using contraception)

Yes, that's exactly what I think. Women and men have different, but equal choices to make, because they play different but equal roles in reproduction. Men have autonomy over their own bodies, and women theirs, and so must act accordingly if they wish to avoid unplanned parenthood, not encroach on the others choices (in the case of a difference of choice, I mean).

then you are morally in the wrong

No, they're not. You're asserting your opinion/moral position as fact. It's not.

Okay so I’m intrigued as to whether you genuinely disagree with what I’m asserting or simply don’t understand it. Here we are in the format of an equation:

My assertion is that if -

Decision on whether to keep an unplanned baby = A (does man want baby) + B (does woman want baby) + C (adjustment for all factors relating to ethics) + D (adjustment for all factors relating to biological difference e.g. medical risks of abortion, emotional and physical costs/risks of carrying a baby to term)

and you then remove C and D from the equation you should have a choice where A and B are given equal weight.

Refute at your leisure! (noting that things like do I have financial means, does my existing child want a sibling etc. all fit in to A or B category)

PearlClutzsche · 20/07/2023 11:43

I know a million posters will say that’s not okay but really why is choice only one way!

If you realise that your opinion is probably that of a only small minority, could it be that it's, ya know, wrong?

FootieMama · 20/07/2023 11:28

@Roses121 ,

I am not concerned for your son per se. I am concerned about you.

GabriellaMontez · 20/07/2023 10:46

Nofurme · 20/07/2023 08:32

I’m sorry why should two adults not have equal choices! Two adults using contraception find woman is pregnant - woman has choices relating to her body and baby at birth. Why should man have no choice at all. It’s not anti woman - it’s more anti men to say the man has to live with choice coz they had sex. Woman can always choose. He chose contraception too. Then together they choose. If a woman choses to abort he has no choice. So why can’t a man say no we used contraception - now there’s a pregnancy im not ready for a child my choice is not to be part of it.
I know a million posters will say that’s not okay but really why is choice only one way!

Ps in general terms not this post

Why should two adults not have equal choices?

His equal choices only extend to his body.

His choice is to have sex. Knowing there is always a risk if pregnancy. Also knowing that he doesn't get to decide if a woman continues or ends a pregnancy.

Nor does he get to attend the birth or decide what sort of pain relief is used.

You sound like some kind of incel.

Do you think men should be able to force women to continue a pregnancy? Or that they can withdraw consent for the pregnancy at some stage?

monsteramunch · 20/07/2023 10:41

@CakeyBakeyHeart

Two scenarios for you...

What about a man who says he wants a baby, is fully on board during pregnancy then decides when it's born that he wants nothing to do with it? Should he be allowed to make the choice to walk away with no financial obligation to his child? Is it 'morally wrong' of the mother to pursue child maintenance payments from that man even though they both decided to have the baby? How can the legal system prove or disprove that the man was a willing participant up to a certain point?

What about a man who says he wants a baby, is fully on board until 8 months into the pregnancy then decides he wants nothing to do with the child? Should he be allowed to make the choice to walk away with no financial obligation to his child? Is it 'morally wrong' of the mother to pursue child maintenance payments from that man even though they both decided to have the baby? How can the legal system prove or disprove that the man was a willing participant up to a certain point?

How would your moral standpoint on this work in reality?

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 10:28

CakeyBakeyHeart · 20/07/2023 10:03

How would you like it if for example you wanted an abortion and every health care provider told you you had made your choice ‘at the point of sex’. Yet you think this is how it should be for men (who have made their choice by using contraception) to the point that anyone thinking otherwise is a misogynist.

Ultimately the situation is different for the man and the woman in an unplanned pregnancy and the woman is entitled to autonomy over her body. From a moral viewpoint though, if you chose to continue the pregnancy simply because you want a baby, despite the father not wanting it, rather than because you are opposed to the ethics/mental burden/or medical risks of abortion then you are morally in the wrong (it is noted in the OP’s case the father did not voice that he did not want it).

Yet you think this is how it should be for men (who have made their choice by using contraception)

Yes, that's exactly what I think. Women and men have different, but equal choices to make, because they play different but equal roles in reproduction. Men have autonomy over their own bodies, and women theirs, and so must act accordingly if they wish to avoid unplanned parenthood, not encroach on the others choices (in the case of a difference of choice, I mean).

then you are morally in the wrong

No, they're not. You're asserting your opinion/moral position as fact. It's not.

moderndaywitch · 20/07/2023 10:25

How would you like it if for example you wanted an abortion and every health care provider told you you had made your choice ‘at the point of sex’. Yet you think this is how it should be for men (who have made their choice by using contraception) to the point that anyone thinking otherwise is a misogynist.

Well it's not really the same is it. Pregnancy, childbirth and abortion does not affect a man's body at all.

Women and men make their choice at the point of sex on whether they will risk pregnancy. If a pregnancy occurs it is only affecting the woman's body, so it is her choice on what to do next. Abortion is not always an easy choice you know.

I'm not sure what you are saying the solution is here? If the law made it so men could get women pregnant and then 'opt out' of paying for it there would be a lot of men doing just that. Unfortunately it is instinct for men to spread their seed as far and wide as possible (whereas women are programmed to be more selective), so making this an option would be pretty catastrophic.

CakeyBakeyHeart · 20/07/2023 10:03

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 07:55

Can’t believe this misogynistic nonsense is still coming up.

So how does this “both parents choosing” work?
Should a male stranger (if ONS) get to decide whether a woman has an abortion or not? Can force her if she doesn’t want to, or stop her if she does? That’s horrific.
Men do have a choice which comes earlier than that: at the point of sex.
As a PP said, they know how their dicks work.

How would you like it if for example you wanted an abortion and every health care provider told you you had made your choice ‘at the point of sex’. Yet you think this is how it should be for men (who have made their choice by using contraception) to the point that anyone thinking otherwise is a misogynist.

Ultimately the situation is different for the man and the woman in an unplanned pregnancy and the woman is entitled to autonomy over her body. From a moral viewpoint though, if you chose to continue the pregnancy simply because you want a baby, despite the father not wanting it, rather than because you are opposed to the ethics/mental burden/or medical risks of abortion then you are morally in the wrong (it is noted in the OP’s case the father did not voice that he did not want it).

sunglassesonthetable · 20/07/2023 09:50

I hear you and obviously I have my concerns about him. At the same time tho nothing dangerous or horrible has happened to the point where it would be my duty as a mother to protect my son from him.
I don’t want my son to blame me for not having a relationship with his dad if I cut him out.
We had actually planned to meet today 😬before all this. I haven’t heard from him since the DNA request so I’m not sure he wants to. Plus I think it’s unfair on my son to be around someone questioning his paternity. So I don’t think I’m gonna meet until thats done.

Such a level decision. That babe is lucky to have you.

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 09:42

*derail

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 09:42

@Roses121 sorry for the detail. You’ve done the right thing. Questioning his paternity certainly means he shouldn’t be meeting with your son.

I hope this goes well for you, and you enjoy uni.

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 09:40

Nofurme · 20/07/2023 08:32

I’m sorry why should two adults not have equal choices! Two adults using contraception find woman is pregnant - woman has choices relating to her body and baby at birth. Why should man have no choice at all. It’s not anti woman - it’s more anti men to say the man has to live with choice coz they had sex. Woman can always choose. He chose contraception too. Then together they choose. If a woman choses to abort he has no choice. So why can’t a man say no we used contraception - now there’s a pregnancy im not ready for a child my choice is not to be part of it.
I know a million posters will say that’s not okay but really why is choice only one way!

Ps in general terms not this post

It’s as simple as this: women have choices over their own bodies, and men have choices over theirs.

I’m sorry why should two adults not have equal choices

Their choices are equal but different. Both can choose to avoid unplanned parenthood. They play different roles in reproduction, so make choices on their own involvement. For men that’s not having sex. Or using some sort of belt and braces method of contraception. Or being in a committed relationship where both partners agree about what will happen should an unplanned pregnancy arise.

Apart from the MRAs on this thread, pretty much no one thinks that men should be able to have unlimited, inconsequential casual sex with strangers without a backward glance; nor, worse still, that a woman he impregnates should be required to seek his permission on whether to abort or birth her child.

Roses121 · 20/07/2023 09:27

@FootieMama I hear you and obviously I have my concerns about him. At the same time tho nothing dangerous or horrible has happened to the point where it would be my duty as a mother to protect my son from him.
I don’t want my son to blame me for not having a relationship with his dad if I cut him out.
We had actually planned to meet today 😬before all this. I haven’t heard from him since the DNA request so I’m not sure he wants to. Plus I think it’s unfair on my son to be around someone questioning his paternity. So I don’t think I’m gonna meet until thats done.

OP posts:
OnGoldenPond · 20/07/2023 09:21

Mikimoto · 18/07/2023 15:56

If the alleged father is not on the birth certificate, OP would first need a DNA test from him before making any financial claims.

No not true. The mother names the father and applies to the CSA for maintenance. They contact the father. If he disputes paternity he must do a DNA test to prove the child isn't his. If the test proves he is the father he has to pay for the test and he is assessed for maintenance. If he doesn't reply he is presumed to be the father and is assessed for maintenance.

moderndaywitch · 20/07/2023 09:19

Yeah, it's pretty staggering there are people on this thread feeling sorry for a man in his 30s who pursued a girl in her teens, and who was quite possibly married and lying just to get that teenager into bed. It makes me wonder what kind of crap they tolerate from the men in their own lives.

I agree, the internal misogyny on this thread is quite something.

moderndaywitch · 20/07/2023 09:16

Nofurme · 20/07/2023 08:32

I’m sorry why should two adults not have equal choices! Two adults using contraception find woman is pregnant - woman has choices relating to her body and baby at birth. Why should man have no choice at all. It’s not anti woman - it’s more anti men to say the man has to live with choice coz they had sex. Woman can always choose. He chose contraception too. Then together they choose. If a woman choses to abort he has no choice. So why can’t a man say no we used contraception - now there’s a pregnancy im not ready for a child my choice is not to be part of it.
I know a million posters will say that’s not okay but really why is choice only one way!

Ps in general terms not this post

Men have to ejaculate to make a baby. That's after he has penetrated a woman. It doesn't just happen, he has had time to change his mind, he knows how it works!

Plus men are fertile 24/7, women only for a couple of days. The POOR MENZ need to take responsibility.

And many men do opt out and have nothing to do with the child throughout pregnancy and then birth and then for the rest of their lives. We all know someone who had an absent father who was nowhere to be seen.

I mean god, this is already very much a man's world. Almost everything is orchestrated to be for the convenience of men, and they don't even have to go through the pain of childbearing and everything else a woman has to go through (periods, menopause etc etc).

If he is so worried about making an unwanted baby he shouldn't cum. I know men who use condoms and still pull out before ejaculation to avoid an accident.

And let's not forget he's a disgusting married man in his mid-30s, with kids already, who pursued a teenager. And then when she was pregnant he failed to do the decent thing and provide financially, taking advantage of her youth and naivety. He is disgusting!

Roses121 · 20/07/2023 09:15

Gingerboy22 · 20/07/2023 08:35

This is the first of you looking at her and your child's potential half siblings? You must be one very restrained person.

Yes, I didn’t look for her until I thought about claiming the day before I posted this.
I’m not ‘in her business’ or stalking like someone suggested 😂
& I know what her kids looks like as my sons dad has sent me multiples photos (without me asking shall I add.)

OP posts:
SpiralHecate · 20/07/2023 09:01

Rachie1973 · 20/07/2023 08:38

Morally he shouldn’t have taken a chance.

Your post is one of the worst I’ve seen on here, and that’s saying a lot.

The poor menz. Just wanted to make his Willy sticky and now he’s stuck.

Yeah, it's pretty staggering there are people on this thread feeling sorry for a man in his 30s who pursued a girl in her teens, and who was quite possibly married and lying just to get that teenager into bed. It makes me wonder what kind of crap they tolerate from the men in their own lives.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 20/07/2023 08:56

Can't believe how many seem to think abortion or adoption have no effect on the woman or her body. The effect of those decisions on a man or a woman are not equal.

Men have a choice whether to ejaculate inside someone since that affects their body anything beyond that is outside their control because it doesn't affect their body.

FloydPepper · 20/07/2023 08:51

Nofurme · 20/07/2023 08:32

I’m sorry why should two adults not have equal choices! Two adults using contraception find woman is pregnant - woman has choices relating to her body and baby at birth. Why should man have no choice at all. It’s not anti woman - it’s more anti men to say the man has to live with choice coz they had sex. Woman can always choose. He chose contraception too. Then together they choose. If a woman choses to abort he has no choice. So why can’t a man say no we used contraception - now there’s a pregnancy im not ready for a child my choice is not to be part of it.
I know a million posters will say that’s not okay but really why is choice only one way!

Ps in general terms not this post

I think you need to define what that “choice” looks like for him

Rachie1973 · 20/07/2023 08:38

ElizaAgainn · 19/07/2023 19:34

He didn't have the option of having an abortion - you did and you chose not to. Or the alternative option of getting the child adopted as soon as it was born - again...you did have that option and you chose not to. Why should he be held "accountable" for 2 choices you had/but he didn't? So - I think you know the answer in your heart of hearts, ie that it would not be reasonable to tell him to pay you maintenance money on the one hand and, if you try to do so, well you said "He's building a house in another country" and I expect you'd soon find he'd moved to that other country (even if he wasn't going to in the first place). He cannot be held accountable morally for choices he wasn't able to have any part in and I think it would be best all round to leave him alone.

Morally he shouldn’t have taken a chance.

Your post is one of the worst I’ve seen on here, and that’s saying a lot.

The poor menz. Just wanted to make his Willy sticky and now he’s stuck.

villamariavintrapp · 20/07/2023 08:38

@Nofurme the two adults don't get an equal choice because only one of them is pregnant. The man does have the choice not to be involved with a child he didn't want, but regardless of how involved he is the child still needs financial support. Why should that all fall to the mother, or the state?