Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance one night stand

508 replies

Roses121 · 18/07/2023 13:48

I got pregnant from a one night stand 2 years ago. I was 19 at the time and he was 35. Wasn’t really thinking straight and although we used contraception I ended up pregnant.

I made the decision to keep my baby and knew full well I would be raising him on my own. I didn’t want a relationship with him.
I didn’t have any expectations for his father although he said he wanted to be in his life and has been.

My son has never stayed overnight with him as he’s breastfed (16 months now), so we’ve only ever met at public places as I would feel a bit weird having him at my place and vice versa.
When we met I was aware that he had kids (2) and he told me he had split from his ex 3 years prior. Looking back now, it’s possible he lied about the last part just to get me in to bed.
I have not met her or their kids or anyone from his family and vice versa. Contact is not that often, maybe once or twice a month.

I am starting uni in September and will have less money since I’ll have to take on less hours at work. Up until this point I have never asked him for money nor has he offered but after looking at the child maintenance calculator I think my son is entitled to 300-400 monthly.

I know that legally a man is obliged to pay this but morally speaking, would it be wrong to put in a claim since we didn’t plan the baby? Also I will add that although he was shocked when I told him I was pregnant, as was I, he never said ‘I don’t want it.’ I think it’s likely that he pays for his other kids, whether he is in a relationship with her or not, so I think it’s unfair on my son to get nothing but I’m also aware if I do claim it then he’ll have less money for his other kids so I feel a bit bad about that.
I don’t know his salary but Googling average incomes for his job are between 30-50k hence why it estimates 300-400, he is also currently building a house in another country so I know he’s not broke if you get me.

Hope this all make sense x

OP posts:
contrary13 · 20/07/2023 19:30

Teapot13 · 20/07/2023 13:45

Posters arguing that a man should have no responsibility if he took precautions and the woman refused an abortion are making a categorical mistake. A child isn’t a contract that’s negotiated between the parents. It’s a human being with its own rights. In our society, a child has a right to support from both parents, regardless of how it was conceived or what medical procedures the father wanted the mother to have.

It’s really not for the mother to refuse maintenance—the child has a right to it.

Sheesh.

Fair enough - and I do actually agree with you, regarding the fact that it's the child with the rights, and the biological parents with the responsibilities (to ensure it's adequately supported)...

But it's not always so simple. My oldest was born 9 months after I walked away from an abusive relationship (both aged 19), and 7 months after I found out that I was pregnant. Contraception had been used on my part and - well, I think he was removing the condoms during sex without my knowledge, to be honest. I was given the wrong information by the locum GP I ended up seeing, who told me that I was further along and therefore it was too late to terminate. This was back in the '90s, so I don't know if the time limit has changed since then, or not. I was suddenly trapped, with everyone trying to convince me to go back to him because he was my child's "father"... I knew, if he did, that he'd hurt my baby -to hurt me. Because I'd had the temerity to leave him. I refused any potential claim from him. To this day, he hasn't paid a penny towards my child. I put myself through uni, like @Roses121 is about to do, and I built a career so that my child(ren) could have a better future than everyone expected her (them) to have. Yes, in the early days, the state did step in, but not for long. It's there as a short-term support system for those who need it. I would still have had to rely on it, even if I had put a claim in which the CMS, though - because at that time uni students were exempt (not earning) and then he (thankfully) fucked off abroad. I am by no means the only mother who goes without additional finance from the "other parent"... because we're terrified of them getting anywhere near those children who would end up abused one way or another, just so that they can... I don't even know... wear designer labels from birth?

OP, what I will say to you is this... even if you do find a nice man and start a family with him, be aware that your choice to have your son may cause others to suggest to your future partner about a DNA test, or you trying to trap him by getting pregnant (yes; even if the pregnancy is actively planned...). When my oldest was a baby - I think 11 or 12 months old - my friendship with a man I'd known since senior school became a relationship. We actively planned our now 18 year old... but his mother tried to convince him that I was trying to trap him (I was earning more than he was and had my own place, whilst he (at 28) still lived with his parents. She also insinuated that our son wasn't/isn't his (which he is... they're literally the spit of each other). When we separated, our son was 4 - and his father tried to humiliate me by saying that they needed a DNA test before any maintenance was forthcoming. Because my ex's name wasn't on the birth certificate. He missed the appointment, wouldn't answer his phone and then having his name added was always on his list of things to do, but he never quite got around to, you know...? He knows, and always has done, that he is our 18 year old's father. But the rest of his family...?! It really damaged the way that I looked upon them, from the time that I was 6 months pregnant (which was the first they knew because... my ex knew what they were like and was trying to put the situation off for as long as possible, I think). I have never forgiven them, or my ex, for the way that it was me who was humiliated - whereas he was the one who spent 2 years talking me round to the idea of actually trying for our son...

Poor men with their inability to think long-term like we women have to. For the sake of the children they create, then refuse to accept responsibility for. Hmm

MumGMT · 20/07/2023 19:03

Meadowflower2023 · 20/07/2023 17:43

That’s just about the most judgemental remark I’ve seen for a while! I’m sure the intelligent, sensible OP is well able to make her own decisions about any relationships she may have in the future.

Judgemental... well of course it's judgemental, I do judge people that have children as a result of one night stands. As do many others. It's hardly bloody commendable. Im not quite sure intelligent and sensible were the first characteristics that came to my mind though it's nice to hear she's off to uni.

Not just judgemental, incredibly patronising.

And many will judge you for your nasty post to the OP.

SpainToday · 20/07/2023 19:03

Teapot13 · 20/07/2023 13:45

Posters arguing that a man should have no responsibility if he took precautions and the woman refused an abortion are making a categorical mistake. A child isn’t a contract that’s negotiated between the parents. It’s a human being with its own rights. In our society, a child has a right to support from both parents, regardless of how it was conceived or what medical procedures the father wanted the mother to have.

It’s really not for the mother to refuse maintenance—the child has a right to it.

Sheesh.

@Teapot13 you are totally correct with all your points. However if a man and woman take precautions and an accidental pregnancy occurs, the man definitely has less choices than the woman. None of this means he should get away without paying maintenance, but I do have a small amount of sympathy for a man who takes precautions and still ends up fathering a child when he didn’t choose to.

sunglassesonthetable · 20/07/2023 17:59

Judgemental... well of course it's judgemental, I do judge people that have children as a result of one night stands. As do many others. It's hardly bloody commendable. Im not quite sure intelligent and sensible were the first characteristics that came to my mind though it's nice to hear she's off to uni.

So you know she's reading this?

And how did you think you would 'help ' this OP or her situation?

Or did you just want to get that 'judgement' out there?

For the record lots of intelligent people have one night stands. Though I'd agree it's not that sensible. But it's hardly defining, as much as you sneer.

Meadowflower2023 · 20/07/2023 17:43

That’s just about the most judgemental remark I’ve seen for a while! I’m sure the intelligent, sensible OP is well able to make her own decisions about any relationships she may have in the future.

Judgemental... well of course it's judgemental, I do judge people that have children as a result of one night stands. As do many others. It's hardly bloody commendable. Im not quite sure intelligent and sensible were the first characteristics that came to my mind though it's nice to hear she's off to uni.

5128gap · 20/07/2023 17:32

Yes of course he should pay. The law clearly says so.
Morally, yes again. A 35 year old father of two should be fully aware that unprotected sex can lead to him becoming a father of three. If he regrets his choice to have unprotected with a drunk 19 year old once it starts costing him £300 per month, that's too bad, and not your responsibility.

Tandora · 20/07/2023 17:00

Nofurme · 20/07/2023 08:32

I’m sorry why should two adults not have equal choices! Two adults using contraception find woman is pregnant - woman has choices relating to her body and baby at birth. Why should man have no choice at all. It’s not anti woman - it’s more anti men to say the man has to live with choice coz they had sex. Woman can always choose. He chose contraception too. Then together they choose. If a woman choses to abort he has no choice. So why can’t a man say no we used contraception - now there’s a pregnancy im not ready for a child my choice is not to be part of it.
I know a million posters will say that’s not okay but really why is choice only one way!

Ps in general terms not this post

When men can get pregnant they can have an equal say about abortion 👍🏻.

Otherwise, once a baby is born it’s not about what’s fair or not between individual men and women, it’s about the fact that a child needs financial support. Both parents are responsible for this so that financial security for children is maximised and the burden doesn’t fall entirely to the state. End of.

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/07/2023 16:42

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 20/07/2023 12:53

CakeyBakey can be as 'intrigued' as they like as they wilfully miss the point: a man can't order a woman to have a medical procedure (terminate a pregnancy), end of. Just as they can't order a woman to continue a pregnancy (up to the point where abortions are legally allowed); women aren't property.

Men do have choices; they are exercised up to the point of conception where they have a myriad of options to prevent pregnancy. And yes, they have to accept that sometimes those prevention techniques don't work. So yes, they have to accept that at that point, should a pregnancy occur, the woman gets to make the final choice in the long line of choices they both had.

Absolutely

Louder for those (misogynists) at the back.

sunglassesonthetable · 20/07/2023 16:03

That’s just about the most judgemental remark I’ve seen for a while! I’m sure the intelligent, sensible OP is well able to make her own decisions about any relationships she may have in the future.

Yep I'm sure this intelligent young woman bringing up her child as a single parent needs telling that. 🙄

greenbeansnspinach · 20/07/2023 15:58

Meadowflower2023 · 20/07/2023 12:54

You have a lot of support on here OP.
I just hope you have realised that even with all the support, sleeping with men almost double your age that you've admitted you do not even know is not the responsible thing to do at 19, 29 or any age. One can only hope you have learned from this experience and will think more wisely when choosing who will potentially father your children in the future. Obviously he's not looking like he's going to be the best dad or role model to your child and you've said you decided to keep the baby but didn't want to be romantically involved even though he said he would support you (most probably just with a relationship from you I guess!) He used protection that we are led to believe is approximately 97/98% effective, topped with the Ella morning after pill which they claim to be 98% effective which failed for you too. It's obvious, though I'm sure you wouldn't change your son for the world that making a baby wasn't in the forefront of either of your minds that night. I think you need to be a little more cautious when choosing your one night stands and possible fathers for your children.

Well done on Uni! 👏🏼

That’s just about the most judgemental remark I’ve seen for a while! I’m sure the intelligent, sensible OP is well able to make her own decisions about any relationships she may have in the future.

Ponderingwindow · 20/07/2023 15:47

why men don’t get as much control over their dna

Both have choice to have sex or not. Man chooses to release his dna into woman or not.

both have choice to use contraception or not. Women gets full decision making on any hormonal birth control because it is her body. Man can take steps to prevent dna from entering woman’s body.

if a pregnancy occurs, while that pregnancy is inside a woman’s body she is the only one who can make any decisions. Man has no control over his dna.

if a baby is born, baby now has rights and control of own dna. Neither man nor woman has any control over dna anymore.

the man doesn’t get as much control over his dna because it is either inside the woman or it built a baby unless he decides to release it elsewhere.

sunglassesonthetable · 20/07/2023 15:18

I* wasn't critiquing your equation; I was dismissing it entirely as pointless and wrong.

Human situations can't be reduced to such terms.*

100% 👍🏻

PearlClutzsche · 20/07/2023 15:15

This thread! 😂😂

<plays sad song on world's smallest violin for the poor menz>

You're doing everything right, OP, hold your nerve. If this man isn't playing ball then don't meet up with him and pursue your claim through the CSA channels.
He's so cheeky to try to be some sort of paternal presence, but contribute nothing to his son's upkeep. And then question if he is indeed, the father.

Good luck with your uni course.

monsteramunch · 20/07/2023 15:04

@ElizaAgainn

I would guess a lot more people would agree that the man is entitled to have a DNA test - to check whether the child is (technically speaking) "his". OP and he don't know each other well enough for him to know whether he can trust her enough to take her word for it that the child is his.

I think it's fine for anyone to want a DNA test.

The fact is that this particular man was happy to take her word for it that the child was his without a test, happy to start and build a relationship with the child without a test... then immediately demanded a test when asked to actually make a contribution towards the child he previously believed was his and had started and build a relationship with.

I personally think he's a wanker for only being bothered about whether the child is his when he's asked to put his hand in his pocket. The thought of the emotional effects on a child of thinking the wrong person was their dad etc didn't weigh on him before. He just doesn't want to have to pay towards the child.

With that in mind, plus the fact he was shagging teenagers in his mid thirties, he's hardly a victim in all this is he?

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 14:16

CakeyBakeyHeart · 20/07/2023 13:14

Going to make this my last post on this thread as it’s probably getting a bit boring for everyone. If as stated you were to remove C and D they need to go on the left side of the equation, not disappear to give an assertion I’ve not made. I don’t believe an temerity was used on my part in suggesting you didn’t understand 🙂

I think you need to reread what we both wrote.
I wasn't critiquing your equation; I was dismissing it entirely as pointless and wrong.

Human situations can't be reduced to such terms.

Teapot13 · 20/07/2023 13:45

Posters arguing that a man should have no responsibility if he took precautions and the woman refused an abortion are making a categorical mistake. A child isn’t a contract that’s negotiated between the parents. It’s a human being with its own rights. In our society, a child has a right to support from both parents, regardless of how it was conceived or what medical procedures the father wanted the mother to have.

It’s really not for the mother to refuse maintenance—the child has a right to it.

Sheesh.

sunglassesonthetable · 20/07/2023 13:20

Going to make this my last post on this thread as it’s probably getting a bit boring for everyone. If as stated you were to remove C and D they need to go on the left side of the equation, not disappear to give an assertion I’ve not made. I don’t believe an temerity was used on my part in suggesting you didn’t understand 🙂

" The Left Side " ? What does that imply?

You get that people who are not maths fluent have sex and get pregnant?

DrSbaitso · 20/07/2023 13:16

ElizaAgainn · 20/07/2023 13:03

I would guess a lot more people would agree that the man is entitled to have a DNA test - to check whether the child is (technically speaking) "his". OP and he don't know each other well enough for him to know whether he can trust her enough to take her word for it that the child is his. I've certainly got a male friend that told me one time that he'd been going out with a woman for some weeks and she came to him and told him she was pregnant and he must support her decision to have/keep the child. At which point he turned round to her and, perfectly truthfully, told her it was literally impossible for it to be his child - as he'd been sterilised some time before (in case of precisely this scenario coming up). At that point she had to admit it was another man she'd been seeing on the side that was the father and that was the end of that as far as my friend was concerned and he was not at all happy she'd tried that on with him (as he knew a bit about the other man, I gather, and she seemed to have chosen to try and pin the "fatherhood" on him because he was the better financial bet out of the two of the men).

I've certainly got a male friend

I bet you have, Eliza.

But ok. DNA tests are usually demanded to insult the mother and hinder the process rather than because there's serious doubt, but ok. Sometimes women are dishonest and a man has a right to be sure.

Having established that it's yours, why should a man be exempt from all responsibility for his own child just because he couldn't force a woman to have an abortion? If you want to be 100% certain of not having a child, you do what a woman who is 100% certain of not having a child or an abortion does, and you abstain.

Once she's pregnant, nothing will be consequence free, whatever she chooses. Why does the mother and the state owe men risk and consequence free sex?

CakeyBakeyHeart · 20/07/2023 13:14

PrudenceDictates · 20/07/2023 12:36

Eh?
You think that if someone has the temerity to disagree with you, then they haven't understood your point?

This situation is not a formal proof of logic, and doesn't boil down to being mechanically verifiable. I don't agree with your axioms in any case.

Decision on whether or not to keep an unplanned baby ≠ A+B . A&B should not be given equal weight.

Decision on whether or not to keep an unplanned baby = A.

Going to make this my last post on this thread as it’s probably getting a bit boring for everyone. If as stated you were to remove C and D they need to go on the left side of the equation, not disappear to give an assertion I’ve not made. I don’t believe an temerity was used on my part in suggesting you didn’t understand 🙂

GodspeedJune · 20/07/2023 13:04

It’s astounding that he hasn’t once put his hands in his pocket for his son! Well done for making the claim, absolutely the right thing to do.

Wishing you all the best for your time at uni.

ElizaAgainn · 20/07/2023 13:03

I would guess a lot more people would agree that the man is entitled to have a DNA test - to check whether the child is (technically speaking) "his". OP and he don't know each other well enough for him to know whether he can trust her enough to take her word for it that the child is his. I've certainly got a male friend that told me one time that he'd been going out with a woman for some weeks and she came to him and told him she was pregnant and he must support her decision to have/keep the child. At which point he turned round to her and, perfectly truthfully, told her it was literally impossible for it to be his child - as he'd been sterilised some time before (in case of precisely this scenario coming up). At that point she had to admit it was another man she'd been seeing on the side that was the father and that was the end of that as far as my friend was concerned and he was not at all happy she'd tried that on with him (as he knew a bit about the other man, I gather, and she seemed to have chosen to try and pin the "fatherhood" on him because he was the better financial bet out of the two of the men).

Meadowflower2023 · 20/07/2023 12:54

You have a lot of support on here OP.
I just hope you have realised that even with all the support, sleeping with men almost double your age that you've admitted you do not even know is not the responsible thing to do at 19, 29 or any age. One can only hope you have learned from this experience and will think more wisely when choosing who will potentially father your children in the future. Obviously he's not looking like he's going to be the best dad or role model to your child and you've said you decided to keep the baby but didn't want to be romantically involved even though he said he would support you (most probably just with a relationship from you I guess!) He used protection that we are led to believe is approximately 97/98% effective, topped with the Ella morning after pill which they claim to be 98% effective which failed for you too. It's obvious, though I'm sure you wouldn't change your son for the world that making a baby wasn't in the forefront of either of your minds that night. I think you need to be a little more cautious when choosing your one night stands and possible fathers for your children.

Well done on Uni! 👏🏼

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 20/07/2023 12:53

CakeyBakey can be as 'intrigued' as they like as they wilfully miss the point: a man can't order a woman to have a medical procedure (terminate a pregnancy), end of. Just as they can't order a woman to continue a pregnancy (up to the point where abortions are legally allowed); women aren't property.

Men do have choices; they are exercised up to the point of conception where they have a myriad of options to prevent pregnancy. And yes, they have to accept that sometimes those prevention techniques don't work. So yes, they have to accept that at that point, should a pregnancy occur, the woman gets to make the final choice in the long line of choices they both had.

RachaelN · 20/07/2023 12:43

I would just go to CSA and apply tbh. He will soon show his true colours. He is a grown man and knows he can't have his cake and eat it.

sunglassesonthetable · 20/07/2023 12:41

@CakeyBakeyHeart

Do you always make decisions like this?