Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance one night stand

508 replies

Roses121 · 18/07/2023 13:48

I got pregnant from a one night stand 2 years ago. I was 19 at the time and he was 35. Wasn’t really thinking straight and although we used contraception I ended up pregnant.

I made the decision to keep my baby and knew full well I would be raising him on my own. I didn’t want a relationship with him.
I didn’t have any expectations for his father although he said he wanted to be in his life and has been.

My son has never stayed overnight with him as he’s breastfed (16 months now), so we’ve only ever met at public places as I would feel a bit weird having him at my place and vice versa.
When we met I was aware that he had kids (2) and he told me he had split from his ex 3 years prior. Looking back now, it’s possible he lied about the last part just to get me in to bed.
I have not met her or their kids or anyone from his family and vice versa. Contact is not that often, maybe once or twice a month.

I am starting uni in September and will have less money since I’ll have to take on less hours at work. Up until this point I have never asked him for money nor has he offered but after looking at the child maintenance calculator I think my son is entitled to 300-400 monthly.

I know that legally a man is obliged to pay this but morally speaking, would it be wrong to put in a claim since we didn’t plan the baby? Also I will add that although he was shocked when I told him I was pregnant, as was I, he never said ‘I don’t want it.’ I think it’s likely that he pays for his other kids, whether he is in a relationship with her or not, so I think it’s unfair on my son to get nothing but I’m also aware if I do claim it then he’ll have less money for his other kids so I feel a bit bad about that.
I don’t know his salary but Googling average incomes for his job are between 30-50k hence why it estimates 300-400, he is also currently building a house in another country so I know he’s not broke if you get me.

Hope this all make sense x

OP posts:
MumGMT · 21/07/2023 22:55

Excellent post @aloris

DamnUserName21 · 21/07/2023 22:47

Whatthefuck3456 · 18/07/2023 15:30

men who are not on the birth cert should not have to pay maintenance. It’s the mums choice to not give the father legal rights so he should not have to pay as is not on the birth cert

Unless a couple are married, the father has to be present at birth registration in order to go on birth certificate. Men are not present for many reasons and it, usually, is not down to 'mums choice'. In OP's case, her child's father was out of the country.
A father not being on birth certificate is still required to pay child maintenance unless he contests the child is not his and then he will have to get DNA test to prove otherwise.

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 21/07/2023 22:26

aloris · 21/07/2023 20:35

If you think about this in terms of public policy, it gets awkward. A man wears a condom to have sex and says he doesn't want a baby. The condom breaks. If the law does not require him to support the child he fathered, then essentially the woman is forced to choose either (a) to support the child alone or (b) abort the child. So what you are proposing is essentially a situation where BOTH parties used contraception, but ONLY the woman ever bears the burden of contraception failure, and a situation that highly encourages, maybe even coercively encourages, women to get abortions if the pregnancy was unplanned (and let's remember, before contraception, most pregnancies were unplanned. Unplanned was the historical default, not the exception). That is very unequal.

So essentially, you are contorting the nature of the situation so as to ignore pertinent facts, in other words you're very selectively looking at a tiny part of the situation so you can whine that it's unequal for the poor men. But in reality, it's the woman who is more burdened, no matter what happens: whether she (A) has the baby, (B) aborts the baby, or (C) gives up the baby for adoption. In each of those situations, the man suffers less. Let's take situation A. If she has the baby, yes he has to pay a small amount of child maintenance, but as we've seen from so many threads here, it's she who gives up her freedom, pays most of the costs of raising the child, etc. His burden is far less than hers. Let's take situation B. If she aborts the baby, all he sees is that the baby is gone. La la la, he goes back to his normal life, hardly even noticed someone was pregnant. She has to make the wrenching decision, has to endure an abortion, maybe it's against her conscience, maybe her social group will judge her, maybe she will have medical secondary issues from the abortion, etc. Totally unequal, her burden is greater. Let's take situation C. She gives up the baby for adoption. She still undergoes an entire pregnancy. She probably bonds with her baby in utero. She has to separate from her baby, which may be emotionally wrenching. Many women who gave up babies for adoption never quite got over it. What does the man do: oh it's taken care of, he never meets the baby, never thinks of it again, may not even remember he once got a woman pregnant. Again, totally unequal, his burden is far less.

So as you can see, in all those situations, the burden on the woman is greater than on the man no matter which option she chooses. But you are narrowing down the field of view so that all you can see is the effect on the man, and pretending that's the only important part of the picture and the rest of it doesn't exist or doesn't matter.

Look, it's very simple. All contraception has a failure rate. Anyone who uses contraception, accepts by default that there is a chance his partner will become pregnant. All the contraception accomplishes is to REDUCE that rate. If he wishes to 100% avoid that, the only 100% effective method is abstinence. if he doesn't want to pay for any baby that results from sex, saying "But I wore a condom" is not a valid defense. It's not the woman's obligation to indemnify him from the failure rate of contraception. It's not a woman's obligation to take the unfair nature of pregnancy and endure that the resulting burdens always fall on herself so that an unplanned pregnancy never makes a man sad.

Spot on, @Aloris, spot on.

DrSbaitso · 21/07/2023 21:42

Of course it's unfair that men don't get a choice about abortion, but it's the kind of unfair we can't do anything about. It's also unfair that women have a window on their fertility in a way men haven't, but we aren't demanding that men have vasectomies in their 40s to right this injustice. Some things we can even out, some things we can't, so we take the interests of the person most affected, or the child, and we prioritise that. Because while it's not "fair" that a man can't choose an abortion, it's way better than the alternative - men being able to force pregnancy and childbirth, or abortions, on unwilling women, and fathers being able to abdicate all responsibility for their own children, with the taxpayer more liable than they are.

That some men see it as hate that they should be made to pay a nominal amount towards their own children, that women and the state do not owe them risk and consequence free sex, that women and the state should not be more responsible for their children and themselves than they are, is a sign of how deep the entitlement runs in these particular people.

gemstoneju · 21/07/2023 20:49

'It's not a woman's obligation to take the unfair nature of pregnancy and endure that the resulting burdens always fall on herself so that an unplanned pregnancy never makes a man sad.'

Exactly, and this thread has made me more convinced than ever that there needs to be a more urgent and concerted push for a decent form of male birth control, and for them to willingly use it, because they are infinitely more fertile than us. Even the language is so passive and reflects the societal view that diminishes the agency of men - women 'get' pregnant, women 'fall' pregnant. No, women are impregnated. The moral and physical burdens forced on women are unjust.

aloris · 21/07/2023 20:35

Nofurme · 20/07/2023 08:32

I’m sorry why should two adults not have equal choices! Two adults using contraception find woman is pregnant - woman has choices relating to her body and baby at birth. Why should man have no choice at all. It’s not anti woman - it’s more anti men to say the man has to live with choice coz they had sex. Woman can always choose. He chose contraception too. Then together they choose. If a woman choses to abort he has no choice. So why can’t a man say no we used contraception - now there’s a pregnancy im not ready for a child my choice is not to be part of it.
I know a million posters will say that’s not okay but really why is choice only one way!

Ps in general terms not this post

If you think about this in terms of public policy, it gets awkward. A man wears a condom to have sex and says he doesn't want a baby. The condom breaks. If the law does not require him to support the child he fathered, then essentially the woman is forced to choose either (a) to support the child alone or (b) abort the child. So what you are proposing is essentially a situation where BOTH parties used contraception, but ONLY the woman ever bears the burden of contraception failure, and a situation that highly encourages, maybe even coercively encourages, women to get abortions if the pregnancy was unplanned (and let's remember, before contraception, most pregnancies were unplanned. Unplanned was the historical default, not the exception). That is very unequal.

So essentially, you are contorting the nature of the situation so as to ignore pertinent facts, in other words you're very selectively looking at a tiny part of the situation so you can whine that it's unequal for the poor men. But in reality, it's the woman who is more burdened, no matter what happens: whether she (A) has the baby, (B) aborts the baby, or (C) gives up the baby for adoption. In each of those situations, the man suffers less. Let's take situation A. If she has the baby, yes he has to pay a small amount of child maintenance, but as we've seen from so many threads here, it's she who gives up her freedom, pays most of the costs of raising the child, etc. His burden is far less than hers. Let's take situation B. If she aborts the baby, all he sees is that the baby is gone. La la la, he goes back to his normal life, hardly even noticed someone was pregnant. She has to make the wrenching decision, has to endure an abortion, maybe it's against her conscience, maybe her social group will judge her, maybe she will have medical secondary issues from the abortion, etc. Totally unequal, her burden is greater. Let's take situation C. She gives up the baby for adoption. She still undergoes an entire pregnancy. She probably bonds with her baby in utero. She has to separate from her baby, which may be emotionally wrenching. Many women who gave up babies for adoption never quite got over it. What does the man do: oh it's taken care of, he never meets the baby, never thinks of it again, may not even remember he once got a woman pregnant. Again, totally unequal, his burden is far less.

So as you can see, in all those situations, the burden on the woman is greater than on the man no matter which option she chooses. But you are narrowing down the field of view so that all you can see is the effect on the man, and pretending that's the only important part of the picture and the rest of it doesn't exist or doesn't matter.

Look, it's very simple. All contraception has a failure rate. Anyone who uses contraception, accepts by default that there is a chance his partner will become pregnant. All the contraception accomplishes is to REDUCE that rate. If he wishes to 100% avoid that, the only 100% effective method is abstinence. if he doesn't want to pay for any baby that results from sex, saying "But I wore a condom" is not a valid defense. It's not the woman's obligation to indemnify him from the failure rate of contraception. It's not a woman's obligation to take the unfair nature of pregnancy and endure that the resulting burdens always fall on herself so that an unplanned pregnancy never makes a man sad.

SpiralHecate · 21/07/2023 19:39

@Roses121 Ah okay, I understand now. Well of course you had your child for yourself, is he so vain he thinks a girl he barely knew would keep the baby for his sake?

I'm getting a better picture of this guy and he really doesn't sound very nice at all. If he met you at the venue where he works chances are this wasn't the only time he's done something like that. The only reason I asked was more to assure you that you've behaved far more honourably throughout all this than he has.

If you do decide to pursue him for the child support you're entitled to, best of luck with it. It sounds like you're best off going through the proper channels than trying to reason with him. Don't let him pressure you into anything you don't want.

Remember in the long term that children need stability and security more than they need two parents, and I think you can give your son all that on your own. No father is better than a bad one.

Willyoujustbequiet · 21/07/2023 14:32

He has to pay up and as you have his previous employer the HMRC will track him from his insurance number. Its.a done deal.

Well done OP. Not only uni but also standing up for your child who will be proud of you in years to come for doing it.

Ignore the tiny minority of handmaidens.

tolerable · 21/07/2023 14:27

@Roses121 your threads being turned into a bitchfest and encouraging your drama.Theres no real mileage in that for you.
yuve asked him for money-i still think his dna response was reasonable. i still think claim if want
now you wont speak to him and therefore any sort of"daddy"game is up.you are making a rod for your own back.
the literal ins and outs how it got to this dont matter.your focus needs to be baby and you. IF for whatever reasn dm doesnt go your way-you still need a plan

CakeyBakeyHeart · 21/07/2023 14:25

I think anyone who describes a man having sex with a condom as ‘making his choice to be a parent’ is about as ridiculous as telling someone crippled in a car crash whilst wearing a seatbelt that they ‘made their choice to be in a wheelchair’ when they got in the car, as there was a known risk.

Perfectly fine with men being told they need to understand/accept there is a risk even with protection, and that ultimately they won’t and shouldn’t have final say in what happens next. If their partner (whether a wife, an ONS, or anything in between) is fair and decent they will at a minimum listen to and consider the effect the final choice will have on them.

AnSolas · 21/07/2023 11:34

ElizaAgainn · 21/07/2023 05:53

Zelda - I hadnt thought of it like that - but I agree with you. Basically it is correct that if someone is going to have casual sex (ie outside a "relationship" per se) then they do need to be prepared to deal with it. That being by taking their own contraceptive precautions in advance (ie the Pill or being sterilised - dependant on whether they ever intend to have children or no and can manage to get sterilised if they don't) and also prepared to have an abortion if need be. It's actually taking responsibility for oneself to ensure one has done one's own precautions/though this through.

Yep....there is one heck of a lot of man-hating going on on this thread - anyone would think men are a different species!

@ElizaAgainn which is it
a)you beleive that a man who made the choice of sexual reproduction should have the right to force an abortion on a woman, or
b) in the context of your paragraph your words "someone" and "oneself" etc actuallly only means women?

Willyoujustbequiet · 21/07/2023 11:07

DrSbaitso · 21/07/2023 08:13

They're used to a world where men's best interests are usually prioritised and it blows their minds that this is more or less the only time women's interests come first. If they can't march a woman to an invasive and potentially traumatising medical procedure, nor offload sole responsibility for their own child and choices on to the mother and state, they see it as hate. They feel that entitled to risk and consequence free sex that if they don't want to support their own child, literally anyone but them should have to do it.

They think women and taxpayers have more responsibility for their lives than they have. And it's man hate to believe otherwise.

This is indeed what it boils down to.

AnSolas · 21/07/2023 11:01

SpainToday · 21/07/2023 08:05

Sweetie, the OP took 100% responsibility for her reproductive choice. She did not leave her baby behind in the hospital.

The man in this situation has failed to take responsibilty for his reproductive choice.

@AnSolas but it wasn’t his choice, was it?

@SpainToday

Yes is was his choice.

He is male.

His "social" choice it to engage in an act of sexual reproduction or not.

Once he puts his sperm in her vagina, his spem have a chance to make him a baby.
That is basic human sexual reproduction.

He can use methods to reduce the risk but not 100% remove the risk.

So his option is no sex at all, until and unless he wants to make a baby or have sex and risk making a baby.

He can be very anti-social and harm the pregnant mother or kill a birthed baby. But we as a society tend to want to lock that type of man out of society.

Thats it.

This has been true since humans started engaging in acts of sexual reproduction and babies being born.

It is still is true today.

Boo hoo for men, but science has moved on and DNA testing can prove a genitic link between a man and his baby.

Before DNA testing woman were taught that men can be anti-social assholes and some will call the woman he decided to risk getting pregnant a slut etc. and claim that the baby was not his. That when asked to judge society would blame the woman for "having recreational sex and getting pregnant" and not hold the man to the same standard, therefore "good" women should not have recreational sex. Men were taught it was ok to have recreational sex but not to "get caught" by a "good" woman because that could result in marrige and/or a beating from her family; but the get out of marrige/a beating clause was to call the woman a slut etc.

Any social context did not and do not alter his sexual reproductive options.

Society is having a delayed reaction in teaching men to adjusting to the new normal of DNA testing.

sunglassesonthetable · 21/07/2023 10:54

You should arrange a time to speak with him
With a friend with you for support.
Also don't be bullied into making any quick decisions while on phone you can say I'll think abiut that's

This

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/07/2023 10:53

Roses121 · 21/07/2023 09:43

@SpiralHecate Say for example my sons called Jack. He said ‘you had Jack for yourself and not me.’

I don’t think he did try to get me pregnant. The night we met I was a bit intoxicated and he wasn’t, as he was working at the venue we met. I’m not even sure why I slept with him. I rejected his advances at first because believe it or not I’d only had one ONS before him😅. He was persistent and I think deep down this satisfied my feeling of ‘wanted to be wanted’ so I didn’t respect my own boundaries.
Definitely wasn’t the ‘r’ word but I do acknowledge I was in a vulnerable place emotionally. Obviously don’t know what was going through his head at the time so he may have also had his own issues that led to it.

These comments about your character and what you did any why, I can see why you want to defend yourself but don't bother. Keep us business like with him. Don't engage in those sort of conversations with him Trying to prove you're morally good etc, his opinion doesn't matter you know your own heart and he's not your friend , just someone who is your child's parent and should be a provider too.

You know you didn't get pregnant to trap him you got pregnant accidentally because you were drunk and you kept the baby because once you found out he was growing inside you you loved and wanted him. Hold onto that and dont bother trying to explain yourself to that prick trying to trigger you

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/07/2023 10:50

Roses121 · 21/07/2023 08:49

He called me twice last night. I aired his calls then he messaged saying, ‘It’s important that why I’m calling you.’ I said, ‘About what?’ He responded, ‘to talk about everything.’
At this point I was kinda pissed off that he had the audacity to skip over asking for a DNA test so I told him ‘we have nothing to talk about until that’s done & why are you even entertaining a conversation with me if you think he’s not yours?’

Then he said ‘U just want my money.’ He also said he’s heading to the country he’s building his house in next month or September. So idk if he’s saying that to try make me think he will escape paying. We’d spoke a bit about his house and he always reiterated he was never leaving London. But maybe he’s changed his mind 🤷🏻‍♀️.

He told me ‘you had sons name for yourself not for me.’ I’m not even sure what he meant by that. I want to block him tbh cus he’s so annoying but I’m scared he will try go to the courts for shared custody or something just to spite me. I’ve muted him now anyways and will check again if he’s said anything when I have the strength to 😅.
Maybe I should’ve just answered and we could’ve spoke amicably but it’s hard not to be emotional about this. I was also naive in thinking when I first asked him for a financial contribution he would be embarrassed and pay up. 🙈

You should arrange a time to speak with him
With a friend with you for support.
Also don't be bullied into making any quick decisions while on phone you can say I'll think abiut that's

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/07/2023 10:46

Roses121 · 20/07/2023 09:27

@FootieMama I hear you and obviously I have my concerns about him. At the same time tho nothing dangerous or horrible has happened to the point where it would be my duty as a mother to protect my son from him.
I don’t want my son to blame me for not having a relationship with his dad if I cut him out.
We had actually planned to meet today 😬before all this. I haven’t heard from him since the DNA request so I’m not sure he wants to. Plus I think it’s unfair on my son to be around someone questioning his paternity. So I don’t think I’m gonna meet until thats done.

You are doing so well honestly you are a lot more mature than many women on this website twice your age what a great mum

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/07/2023 10:44

Roses121 · 19/07/2023 20:09

@SpiralHecate Thank you yes, I have considered this.
I don’t think it would be possible for him to want shared or full custody.
With regards to the other stuff he has mentioned a few times he wants our son to be circumcised. But I didn’t want that for my son so haven’t.
i hope this isn’t something he can do if he has rights. :(

He can't without parental responsibility so well done !

Roses121 · 21/07/2023 09:43

@SpiralHecate Say for example my sons called Jack. He said ‘you had Jack for yourself and not me.’

I don’t think he did try to get me pregnant. The night we met I was a bit intoxicated and he wasn’t, as he was working at the venue we met. I’m not even sure why I slept with him. I rejected his advances at first because believe it or not I’d only had one ONS before him😅. He was persistent and I think deep down this satisfied my feeling of ‘wanted to be wanted’ so I didn’t respect my own boundaries.
Definitely wasn’t the ‘r’ word but I do acknowledge I was in a vulnerable place emotionally. Obviously don’t know what was going through his head at the time so he may have also had his own issues that led to it.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 21/07/2023 09:14

SpainToday · 21/07/2023 08:45

So anyone who has sex with precautions is an idiot?

If they don't realise there is still a risk, albeit very small, yes. And if they did it by simply handballing the precautions to the other person, very much yes.

BibbleandSqwauk · 21/07/2023 09:03

@TheBlinkOfAnEye no he can't asked for back pay since the child's birth..only from when the oP opens the claim.

OP please please do not give up this claim out if fear of a residency (no custody in this country) order. He would never do it and it would never be granted in your situation given his lack of involvement. It sounds to me from everything you've said that he still harbours some hope of a relationship with you and is peeved that you've made it clear that won't happen. He's being nasty re the money as a lash out. Just proceed calmly with claim and DNA test if he insists on it and keep communication minimal. If he does go overseas it's trickier but it depends where he goes.

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 21/07/2023 09:00

At the end of the day, he has a child he should be helping to support. Does he not think his child needs housing, food, clothing, transport, heat/water, etc.

He wanted you to have the baby; he's rewriting history.

Remind him of this and tell CMS every single piece of identifying information you can about him. Your child is entitled to his support.

SpiralHecate · 21/07/2023 08:58

Red flags everywhere with this guy. Be careful.

By 'his name' did he mean that your son has your surname and not his?

I'm more inclined to think he intentionally got you pregnant. Society has this stereotype where women get pregnant in order to trap men, but in reality it happens the other way too, a lot of men make women pregnant in order to hang onto them. The fact you've never wanted a relationship with him makes me wonder if you really wanted the ONS either? I'm not using the 'r' word, but he does sound coercive.

TheBlinkOfAnEye · 21/07/2023 08:55

Roses121 · 21/07/2023 08:53

@TheBlinkOfAnEye Seems a bit irrational to do that yes. But then again I don’t know him well enough to say if he would make that decision.
Maybe he thinks it will delay it as he won’t be here to receive any potential letters/mails and can use that as an excuse.

He can be up for back pay for the years he hasn't paid already, so that's no guarantee he'll escape anything. It does seem drastic fo run away from everything he's established in life, including well established relationships with his earlier two two children, just to avoid one CS payment. It would say a lot about him if he chose that. It seems unlikely, but you never know.

Roses121 · 21/07/2023 08:53

@TheBlinkOfAnEye Seems a bit irrational to do that yes. But then again I don’t know him well enough to say if he would make that decision.
Maybe he thinks it will delay it as he won’t be here to receive any potential letters/mails and can use that as an excuse.

OP posts: