Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance one night stand

508 replies

Roses121 · 18/07/2023 13:48

I got pregnant from a one night stand 2 years ago. I was 19 at the time and he was 35. Wasn’t really thinking straight and although we used contraception I ended up pregnant.

I made the decision to keep my baby and knew full well I would be raising him on my own. I didn’t want a relationship with him.
I didn’t have any expectations for his father although he said he wanted to be in his life and has been.

My son has never stayed overnight with him as he’s breastfed (16 months now), so we’ve only ever met at public places as I would feel a bit weird having him at my place and vice versa.
When we met I was aware that he had kids (2) and he told me he had split from his ex 3 years prior. Looking back now, it’s possible he lied about the last part just to get me in to bed.
I have not met her or their kids or anyone from his family and vice versa. Contact is not that often, maybe once or twice a month.

I am starting uni in September and will have less money since I’ll have to take on less hours at work. Up until this point I have never asked him for money nor has he offered but after looking at the child maintenance calculator I think my son is entitled to 300-400 monthly.

I know that legally a man is obliged to pay this but morally speaking, would it be wrong to put in a claim since we didn’t plan the baby? Also I will add that although he was shocked when I told him I was pregnant, as was I, he never said ‘I don’t want it.’ I think it’s likely that he pays for his other kids, whether he is in a relationship with her or not, so I think it’s unfair on my son to get nothing but I’m also aware if I do claim it then he’ll have less money for his other kids so I feel a bit bad about that.
I don’t know his salary but Googling average incomes for his job are between 30-50k hence why it estimates 300-400, he is also currently building a house in another country so I know he’s not broke if you get me.

Hope this all make sense x

OP posts:
Taz234 · 12/11/2023 19:41

I had a one night stand with a woman, used contraception.
She told me she was pregnant but I didn't want to be a parent and couldn't afford to be one. We don't sleep with random people to be parents unless you are planning to be one, right.
She decided to keep the baby and invited me to be in my daughter's life. She assured me she didn't want maintenance as she did not need the money. I paid her a monthly amount and had regular contact with my daughter. Fast forward 3 years and I met someone I'm very happy with, this is when the problems started.
She said that my daughter couldn't mix with my partner and if my mother invited my partner over to dinner, I'd ask if I could have my daughter over too and I'd get accused of putting my partner before my daughter.
Now she has stopped me seeing my daughter altogether and has went to the CMS. She states that as long as I see my partner or in a relationship with anyone, I'm a crap dad and I need to see my daughter everyday. I was abused mentally every day.
The amount the CMS is taking from me leaves me with hardly anything. I have a mortgage and debt.
I am not on the birth certificate or have any parental rights. I did a home DNA which confirms my daughter
I feel absolutely let down and gutted that someone can do this and weaponize the CMS against you and financially I'm ruined.
How someone can have this financial coercive control over you is not right
I'm gutted Im not allowed to see my daughter now and do not have the money to go to court.

Taz234 · 12/11/2023 19:38

This happened to me. I had a one night stand with a woman, used contraception.
She told me she was pregnant but I didn't want to be a parent and couldn't afford to be one. We don't sleep with random people to be parents unless you are planning to be one, right.
She decided to keep the baby and invited me to be in my daughter's life. She assured me she didn't want maintenance as she did not need the money. I paid her a monthly amount and had regular contact with my daughter. Fast forward 3 years and I met someone I'm very happy with, this is when the problems started.
She said that my daughter couldn't mix with my partner and if my mother invited my partner over to dinner, I'd ask if I could have my daughter over too and I'd get accused of putting my partner before my daughter.
Now she has stopped me seeing my daughter altogether and has gone to the CMS. She states that as long as I see my partner or in a relationship with anyone, I'm a crap dad and I need to see my daughter everyday. I waa abused mentally every day.
The amount the CMS is taking from me leaves me with hardly anything. I have a mortgage and debt.
I am not on the birth certificate or have any parental rights. I did a home DNA which confirms my daughter
I feel absolutely let down and gutted that someone can do this and weaponize the CMS against you and financially I'm ruined.
How someone can have this financial coercive control over you is not right

whynotwhatknot · 31/07/2023 13:57

they havent really tried have they

is there anyway you can find out his address

popgoesthecat2 · 30/07/2023 16:34

In some cultures their legal registered name is different to the name they use in day to day life. It used to be more common in the UK too. Could this be the case with him?

Mayhem3 · 29/07/2023 21:38

I didn’t know my exes address with I went to CMS.

I told them his name and where I thought he’d lived and they found his address. He also lied to me about his age and parents age so I had literally nothing to go on.

He did have a unique surname though which must have helped.

SpiralHecate · 29/07/2023 21:17

Sorry to hear this OP.

He's probably older than he said he was. Can you def not trace him by going to where he worked?

Still, while it's rough right now, it probably for the best he's shown his true colours before your son got old enough to know who he was. Chances are he'd have abandoned you both at some point regardless of whether or not you asked for child support.

Roses121 · 29/07/2023 21:05

Thank you for your support. It means a lot. Harsh to know that money is more important than a child. But I guess that’s the world we live in 🤷🏻‍♀️.
I don’t think he lied about his name, as it’s on his Facebook. Although he did initially, when we first met, he told me his name was something else and causally mentioned his real name after the birth of our son.
Age, he could’ve lied about.
Obviously address I don’t have, but would’ve been pretty easy for me to get if I played along with his wishes of me coming over to his 😂kinda wish I would’ve done that now but I wasn’t thinking this far ahead.

OP posts:
TheoTheopolis23 · 29/07/2023 18:18

He should have been paying all along.

He owes you thousands.

Planned or not, it doesn't matter. It's a possibility when you have sex.

greenbeansnspinach · 29/07/2023 18:13

Child support are really good at not finding people when all the correct details have been given. They also sometimes triumphantly send the parent with care (the claimant) a letter announcing that the other parent is going to pay up ten years backlog of payments that they owe, when there’s a cats chance in hell they’ll ever pay a penny of it, something both parents and Child support are all perfectly well aware of.

sunglassesonthetable · 28/07/2023 09:05

Sorry to hear that OP.

I have no experience of CMS so can offer no help on this other than I think the father of your child should be contributing.

I hope the new dob throws something up.

BibbleandSqwauk · 28/07/2023 07:39

I'm sorry OP. Yours is a perfect example of how the idea of fatherhood appeals (asking you to keep the baby, being somewhat present for the look of things) but then running a mile from the reality. Please don't give up..it's the principle as much as anything else. From what you've written he had long standing hopes that you'd rekindle the relationship ...given the age gap no doubt imagined you'd "need" him but you've shown you are a capable and intelligent person who can stand on her own feet. But your child is entitled to support from their father. If any further communication is forthcoming all you can do is be calm and clear.

AndyMcFlurry · 27/07/2023 23:25

I’m sorry to hear this, it’s very disappointing. Both about the CMS and also that he cares so little for his child.

Do you think it’s possible that he’s deliberately given you the wrong information about himself?

Roses121 · 27/07/2023 20:21

They called me today to say they couldn’t trace him. 🙄
Kinda expected this based on my lack of info on him.
Turns out I may have given the wrong year of birth so updated that and they said they will look again. No mention of his previous employment, for some reason they aren’t interested in contacting them.
I really don’t want any drama especially since I’m going on holiday next week so refraining from messaging his so called ex.
Also haven’t heard a peep from him since all this. Not even messaged to ask how our son is doing or for photos. Nothing.

OP posts:
FootieMama · 22/07/2023 14:01

Twentytwothousand · 22/07/2023 06:58

This is the best response to this question I have ever seen and I will quote it widely. It is not an equal situation at all, ever.

Yes, so we'll put!!!
@ aloris.
I've seen so many young women traumatised for having to an abortion. The decision process, the instinctive need to protect an unborn child even if everything in your life tells you that you can't have the baby. And then other completely different trauma if you decide to carry to term and put the up baby for adoption. Watching Long Lost Family you see story after story of mums who gave up their baby and spend all their life wondering if it was the right decision. It is never easy for women specially at the young age of the OP.

DrSbaitso · 22/07/2023 13:02

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 22/07/2023 12:35

That some men see it as hatethat they should be made to pay a nominal amount towards their own children, that women and the state do not owe them risk and consequence free sex, that women and the state should not be more responsible for their children and themselves than they are, is a sign of how deep the entitlement runs in these particular people.

Chillingly accurate about a significant percentage of men and their handmaiden supporters, sadly.

If it helps (it might not), then bear in mind that not everyone presenting as a woman on MN really is one.

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 22/07/2023 12:35

That some men see it as hatethat they should be made to pay a nominal amount towards their own children, that women and the state do not owe them risk and consequence free sex, that women and the state should not be more responsible for their children and themselves than they are, is a sign of how deep the entitlement runs in these particular people.

Chillingly accurate about a significant percentage of men and their handmaiden supporters, sadly.

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 22/07/2023 12:32

DamnUserName21 · 21/07/2023 22:47

Unless a couple are married, the father has to be present at birth registration in order to go on birth certificate. Men are not present for many reasons and it, usually, is not down to 'mums choice'. In OP's case, her child's father was out of the country.
A father not being on birth certificate is still required to pay child maintenance unless he contests the child is not his and then he will have to get DNA test to prove otherwise.

Exactly

Stop trying to punish children for grown ups' issues. Children are entitled to the support of both parents.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/07/2023 11:31

as an absent dad whilst missing out on the aspects that are a burden (loss of time/finance/freedom) is also missing out on all the special moments that make it worthwhile which you are having as a result of the choice made. After all why would you have a child (pro life aspects aside) if you anticipate it being a net burden.

You do wonder don't you?

Yet it happens so often ( and I'm basing that on people I know ) not what you so often read on here.

AnSolas · 22/07/2023 11:06

CakeyBakeyHeart · 22/07/2023 00:31

When you say that if the law does not force a man to financially support his child ‘what you are proposing is essentially a situation where BOTH parties used contraception, but ONLY the woman ever bears the burden of contraception failure’ you’re suggesting that to men the burden of contraception failure is only financial. I imagine that if you don’t want a child the mental burden of having a child you didn’t want out there in the world is quite significant.

‘If she aborts the baby, all he sees is that the baby is gone. La la la, he goes back to his normal life, hardly even noticed someone was pregnant’ - whilst this may be the case for some men, many may be very torn on whether they want the pregnancy to go ahead, some may have pro-life views that they only realise after the news and suffer greatly by an abortion of their future child being carried out against their will.

‘Let's take situation A. If she has the baby, yes he has to pay a small amount of child maintenance, but as we've seen from so many threads here, it's she who gives up her freedom, pays most of the costs of raising the child, etc. His burden is far less than hers.’ - when you talk about loss of freedom and loss of finances as a burden I think you should really be looking at net burden, as an absent dad whilst missing out on the aspects that are a burden (loss of time/finance/freedom) is also missing out on all the special moments that make it worthwhile which you are having as a result of the choice made. After all why would you have a child (pro life aspects aside) if you anticipate it being a net burden.

Sigh..

Then none of these men should engage in baby making activity, the same idea as not becoming a crash test dummy.

Flyingskunk · 22/07/2023 08:48

Maybe he doesn’t pay because he is still in a relationship potentially with the mother of his children and is going to have some serious explaining to do.
Definitely talk to him first. Once you put a claim in things could turn unpleasant and you could be throwing a grenade into some other poor woman and children’s lives.
To add I’m not saying he shouldn’t pay just don’t jump straight to the CMS.
I know a guy who this happened to and he spent the next 18 years doing voluntary work abroad just so that he never had to pay a penny for that child. He’s married with a child now and I often wonder if he regrets it.

DonnaBanana · 22/07/2023 08:44

the only 100% effective method is abstinence

And yet whenever someone gets the bright idea of teaching this in school people get all upset. People need to stop having casual sex because casual sex does not exist when a baby can occur from it! Full stop.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/07/2023 07:36

This is the best response to this question I have ever seen and I will quote it widely. It is not an equal situation at all, ever.

👏🏼

Twentytwothousand · 22/07/2023 06:58

aloris · 21/07/2023 20:35

If you think about this in terms of public policy, it gets awkward. A man wears a condom to have sex and says he doesn't want a baby. The condom breaks. If the law does not require him to support the child he fathered, then essentially the woman is forced to choose either (a) to support the child alone or (b) abort the child. So what you are proposing is essentially a situation where BOTH parties used contraception, but ONLY the woman ever bears the burden of contraception failure, and a situation that highly encourages, maybe even coercively encourages, women to get abortions if the pregnancy was unplanned (and let's remember, before contraception, most pregnancies were unplanned. Unplanned was the historical default, not the exception). That is very unequal.

So essentially, you are contorting the nature of the situation so as to ignore pertinent facts, in other words you're very selectively looking at a tiny part of the situation so you can whine that it's unequal for the poor men. But in reality, it's the woman who is more burdened, no matter what happens: whether she (A) has the baby, (B) aborts the baby, or (C) gives up the baby for adoption. In each of those situations, the man suffers less. Let's take situation A. If she has the baby, yes he has to pay a small amount of child maintenance, but as we've seen from so many threads here, it's she who gives up her freedom, pays most of the costs of raising the child, etc. His burden is far less than hers. Let's take situation B. If she aborts the baby, all he sees is that the baby is gone. La la la, he goes back to his normal life, hardly even noticed someone was pregnant. She has to make the wrenching decision, has to endure an abortion, maybe it's against her conscience, maybe her social group will judge her, maybe she will have medical secondary issues from the abortion, etc. Totally unequal, her burden is greater. Let's take situation C. She gives up the baby for adoption. She still undergoes an entire pregnancy. She probably bonds with her baby in utero. She has to separate from her baby, which may be emotionally wrenching. Many women who gave up babies for adoption never quite got over it. What does the man do: oh it's taken care of, he never meets the baby, never thinks of it again, may not even remember he once got a woman pregnant. Again, totally unequal, his burden is far less.

So as you can see, in all those situations, the burden on the woman is greater than on the man no matter which option she chooses. But you are narrowing down the field of view so that all you can see is the effect on the man, and pretending that's the only important part of the picture and the rest of it doesn't exist or doesn't matter.

Look, it's very simple. All contraception has a failure rate. Anyone who uses contraception, accepts by default that there is a chance his partner will become pregnant. All the contraception accomplishes is to REDUCE that rate. If he wishes to 100% avoid that, the only 100% effective method is abstinence. if he doesn't want to pay for any baby that results from sex, saying "But I wore a condom" is not a valid defense. It's not the woman's obligation to indemnify him from the failure rate of contraception. It's not a woman's obligation to take the unfair nature of pregnancy and endure that the resulting burdens always fall on herself so that an unplanned pregnancy never makes a man sad.

This is the best response to this question I have ever seen and I will quote it widely. It is not an equal situation at all, ever.

CakeyBakeyHeart · 22/07/2023 00:31

aloris · 21/07/2023 20:35

If you think about this in terms of public policy, it gets awkward. A man wears a condom to have sex and says he doesn't want a baby. The condom breaks. If the law does not require him to support the child he fathered, then essentially the woman is forced to choose either (a) to support the child alone or (b) abort the child. So what you are proposing is essentially a situation where BOTH parties used contraception, but ONLY the woman ever bears the burden of contraception failure, and a situation that highly encourages, maybe even coercively encourages, women to get abortions if the pregnancy was unplanned (and let's remember, before contraception, most pregnancies were unplanned. Unplanned was the historical default, not the exception). That is very unequal.

So essentially, you are contorting the nature of the situation so as to ignore pertinent facts, in other words you're very selectively looking at a tiny part of the situation so you can whine that it's unequal for the poor men. But in reality, it's the woman who is more burdened, no matter what happens: whether she (A) has the baby, (B) aborts the baby, or (C) gives up the baby for adoption. In each of those situations, the man suffers less. Let's take situation A. If she has the baby, yes he has to pay a small amount of child maintenance, but as we've seen from so many threads here, it's she who gives up her freedom, pays most of the costs of raising the child, etc. His burden is far less than hers. Let's take situation B. If she aborts the baby, all he sees is that the baby is gone. La la la, he goes back to his normal life, hardly even noticed someone was pregnant. She has to make the wrenching decision, has to endure an abortion, maybe it's against her conscience, maybe her social group will judge her, maybe she will have medical secondary issues from the abortion, etc. Totally unequal, her burden is greater. Let's take situation C. She gives up the baby for adoption. She still undergoes an entire pregnancy. She probably bonds with her baby in utero. She has to separate from her baby, which may be emotionally wrenching. Many women who gave up babies for adoption never quite got over it. What does the man do: oh it's taken care of, he never meets the baby, never thinks of it again, may not even remember he once got a woman pregnant. Again, totally unequal, his burden is far less.

So as you can see, in all those situations, the burden on the woman is greater than on the man no matter which option she chooses. But you are narrowing down the field of view so that all you can see is the effect on the man, and pretending that's the only important part of the picture and the rest of it doesn't exist or doesn't matter.

Look, it's very simple. All contraception has a failure rate. Anyone who uses contraception, accepts by default that there is a chance his partner will become pregnant. All the contraception accomplishes is to REDUCE that rate. If he wishes to 100% avoid that, the only 100% effective method is abstinence. if he doesn't want to pay for any baby that results from sex, saying "But I wore a condom" is not a valid defense. It's not the woman's obligation to indemnify him from the failure rate of contraception. It's not a woman's obligation to take the unfair nature of pregnancy and endure that the resulting burdens always fall on herself so that an unplanned pregnancy never makes a man sad.

When you say that if the law does not force a man to financially support his child ‘what you are proposing is essentially a situation where BOTH parties used contraception, but ONLY the woman ever bears the burden of contraception failure’ you’re suggesting that to men the burden of contraception failure is only financial. I imagine that if you don’t want a child the mental burden of having a child you didn’t want out there in the world is quite significant.

‘If she aborts the baby, all he sees is that the baby is gone. La la la, he goes back to his normal life, hardly even noticed someone was pregnant’ - whilst this may be the case for some men, many may be very torn on whether they want the pregnancy to go ahead, some may have pro-life views that they only realise after the news and suffer greatly by an abortion of their future child being carried out against their will.

‘Let's take situation A. If she has the baby, yes he has to pay a small amount of child maintenance, but as we've seen from so many threads here, it's she who gives up her freedom, pays most of the costs of raising the child, etc. His burden is far less than hers.’ - when you talk about loss of freedom and loss of finances as a burden I think you should really be looking at net burden, as an absent dad whilst missing out on the aspects that are a burden (loss of time/finance/freedom) is also missing out on all the special moments that make it worthwhile which you are having as a result of the choice made. After all why would you have a child (pro life aspects aside) if you anticipate it being a net burden.

JenniferBooth · 21/07/2023 23:52

Im sure i heard a snippet on the news yesterday that they are about to get stricter with parents who try to avoid paying

Swipe left for the next trending thread