Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to move into a house?

84 replies

SnotRag81 · 18/07/2023 12:45

I’ve always lived in flats. DH and I currently live in a 2 bed flat with DS and we’re now in the position to move to somewhere bigger. I’ve looked at a few flats and when I showed DH he rolled his eyes and said “will you stop looking at flats, we want a house”. I don’t!! I’ve always lived in flats and I have no desire to change that.
DH says a house will give us outdoor space but neither of us are gardeners so what’s the point? There is always a park nearby for fresh air.

DH is refusing to discuss it further saying he isn’t moving into another flat. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Serrina · 24/08/2023 10:54

Or you could compromise and look at maisonettes? Then you get the best of both worlds.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/07/2023 21:12

PurpleButterflyWings · 18/07/2023 19:58

Of COURSE YABU. Who the hell would choose to live in (and BUY) a flat when you have the option of a house? Confused No brainer. Of course a house is better.

Surely it depends. When we moved we could either afford a maisonette in a nice area or a house in a shit area. For us it was a no brainer to live in the nice area and I've never regretted it.

Simonjt · 18/07/2023 20:58

I prefer flats too, we’re moving into a house as my husband already owns it, I would much much rather we sold it or rented it out and lived in a flat instead.

FluffyFlower · 18/07/2023 20:44

Depends on a flat! Definitely would prefer a nice spacious newbuild flat with noise insulation and lots of storage and a terrace/balcony to your average house on 2-3-4 levels with multiple stairs, and zero noise insulation and energy efficiently. Cities like London - definitely a flat. A small family with one dc - nothing wrong with a flat. A house makes sense for a bigger family and suburban living.

derite · 18/07/2023 20:08

We lived in a 2 bed flat until our DC1 was 4, then we moved to a house. But lots of relatives are raising families in flats and it's fine. Personally I think apartment living was much more convenient - stairs are a real pain with young dc and it was lovely to wheel a sleeping baby into a lift and leave them in the hall to nap (we still do that now but have to bump the buggy up a few steps). We didn't have a garden with our old flat but I know lots of families with garden flats so not sure why people automatically assume you wouldn't have a garden in a flat. Neighbour noise is worse in our current Victorian house than it was in our modern flat

The main reason we got a house was because we wanted freehold and to have more freedom to modify, e.g change room layout which is harder in a flat (but not impossible), and also for future gains as houses increase in value more than flats. I also feel like the property is "ours" properly as it's a freehold.

Generally flats are cheaper than houses, and location is more important for me. If living in a flat was the only way to live in a nice location then I'd opt for location every time. But if you can afford a house in the same quality of location it seems a bit short-sighted financially to opt for a flat over a house.

Davros · 18/07/2023 20:06

Living in a freehold property is worth it. We looked at both last year and really wanted freehold if possible, not a share of freehold

DWTKQHG · 18/07/2023 20:04

Flats are much more common in Scotland. Beautiful, large tenements flats (not just in the cities, but in the older established towns eg Stirling) with large rooms and (in many cases) original features. Also, often with a real sense of community:- families, older people, younger adults all living separately but in community (chats on the stairs) and available for each other. I much prefer that to a small modern house on a "family" estate, often well out of town (need a car) and quite isolating unless you are in the that age demographic Most people could never afford to buy (or upkeep) an older house which offers the type of spacious accommodation which a traditional Scottish tenement flat offers.

tillyandmilly · 18/07/2023 20:00

I would love to move from our flat but financially we can’t afford a house - I would love a garden as we would love to adopt a dog 🥲

PurpleButterflyWings · 18/07/2023 19:58

Of COURSE YABU. Who the hell would choose to live in (and BUY) a flat when you have the option of a house? Confused No brainer. Of course a house is better.

Cucucucu · 18/07/2023 19:57

midsomermurderess · 18/07/2023 15:44

I disagree.

I don’t even know anyone in my kids schools who live in apartments and I’m in Scotland

Yellowlegobrick · 18/07/2023 19:46

How old is your DS? Mine spend loads of time in the garden that couldn’t be replaced by going to the park

This. A park, even on your doorstep, does not come close to the benefits of having a garden for DC.

ChildrenOfRuin · 18/07/2023 19:41

I don’t think either you or your DH are being unreasonable about what sort of property you want, there’s advantages and disadvantages to both sorts of property.

The unreasonable bit here is the problem you and your DH are having with discussing it and listening to each other.

sweepleall · 18/07/2023 17:49

I am sure we somehow just do gardens wrong but despite having a mud kitchen, a sandpit, paddling pool and all sorts out there, ours have always much preferred the park.

We hate gardening and don't get much out of having a garden. British people are obsessed with gardens though, as this thread shows.

The big thing I like about a house is being in control of the maintenance and not having to pay a management charge

Babsexxx · 18/07/2023 17:38

yabu screw what you want here! think of your dc?!! Hardly have to be a Gardener to throw a lawnmower over a patch of grass!

Dotcheck · 18/07/2023 17:37

Well now I’m curious to see why you like flats so much.
Is it because they’re warmer?
Or feel safer?
Don't’ have to worry about fences or external maintenance?

Trickedbyadoughnut · 18/07/2023 17:28

Well, there are advantages and disadvantages to both and realistically, I think you both need to view some of both in your budget and location.

A garden wouldn't necessarily offset having to move further out of a town centre for example, if your DC's activities were walking distance and you love going to museums. (We had a garden as a child, neither of us kids spent much time in it,)

Yes, there can be noise issues in flats, but there can also be noise issues in terraces/semis, especially because of people being out in their gardens (enough threads on here about it).

Maintenance costs are non-negligible when you move to a house.

The wider problem is the refusal to discuss it.

TiaraBoo · 18/07/2023 17:17

I think you’re both being unreasonable not to discuss it properly.

PupInAPram · 18/07/2023 16:56

Peachy2005 · 18/07/2023 13:50

We had a lovely new-build 2-bed apartment where both kids were born, communal gardens, tennis court, short walk to buses and trains. If we had only chosen the 3-bed option (we bought off plans) we wouldn’t have needed to move.

I hate being home-owners, the garden is only of use when kids are little, plenty of parks with playgrounds nearby which they preferred anyway. The garden is a massive chore if you don’t like gardening or sitting/eating outdoors - and it’s a never-ending chore. I think the worst bit is all the upkeep in a house is your responsibility and if you’re not handy and don’t have family who are, that’s a huge thing. I’d much rather pay mgmt fees and have someone else sorting out any structural/roofing issues, gutters, exterior painting etc.

I can’t wait till we can get back to apartment-living again!

I'm so glad you said this. I plan to move from a house to a flat when I retire for this very reason.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/07/2023 16:37

Maybe he wants a garden? Telling somebody they can't try something because they've never done it before is unfair - nobody should be forced to stay in a box because they've never had the opportunity to step outside it before. 'Oh, no, stick with what you know' is the refrain used to keep people in their place in so many ways.

Or he just doesn't want to listen to people's bums squeaking in their baths and conversations above and/or below anymore.

Twilight7777 · 18/07/2023 16:27

I don’t understand why you wouldn’t want your own outdoor space that your child can enjoy. Gardens can be as low or high maintenance as you’d like, can have a fully paved garden if you wanted then the only job is to keep weeds away.

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 18/07/2023 16:25

Flat lover here too.
I live in a house now, because 3+ bedroom flats around my way are few and far between, but I hate the garden upkeep, I hate hoovering the stairs, whenever you want something it’s always on the wrong floor. If I could get a 4bed flat I would move in a heartbeat.
I would insist on having a balcony though, for the 2 weeks or so that we have summer in the UK.

mkpka · 18/07/2023 16:22

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 18/07/2023 12:53

I understand it from a location perspective - our choice was flat in the city or house in the suburbs. We chose the flat and I have no regrets.

Same here. Everything's on the doorstep, great public transport links and a park behind the shared garden. Flats are the norm in my city, and aren't necessarily smaller than houses (our 3-bed flat is bigger than the 3-bed house we used to live in, last time we lived in a house).

Mumsnet seems to be a bit anti-flat in general, though! We don't have kids, so perhaps we'd feel differently about moving to the suburbs if we did.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/07/2023 16:21

I live in a maisonette so have the best of both worlds. I have the front garden and my own back garden and can walk straight out into it. I hate gardening and if I didn't have DH to do it I'd pay a gardner! I will hold my hands up to having artificial grass though!

LaughterTitsoff · 18/07/2023 16:18

What does giving your child an outdoor space to play in have to do with gardening?

NumberTheory · 18/07/2023 16:16

I’ve lived in both, OP, and I’d prefer a flat if it was just me and DH, too. Maintenance is easier, they tend to be more compact and more available in city centres - all things I value. I also like living higher providing there’s a reliable elevator.

But I do find a house is better with kids. In general you get more outdoor space which is great as they get older and can go outside without you having to schlep them to the park, noise is less of a concern and they tend to be larger and have more storage space.

But choosing housing is a matter of weighing up the pros and cons of each one. You’re both wrong to dismiss the other’s suggestions out of hand.