Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Honest or cruel?

102 replies

MoMuM7 · 18/07/2023 10:06

My mother prides herself on being honest and forthcoming. She says what I consider, very offensive things, and concludes with an 'I'm just being honest'. We were raised in a household where you were encouraged to voice your feelings not matter who you hurt. I always found that brutal and was considered the 'sensitive' one. We have a civil, not close, relationship so I just got on with it. My mum said something that deeply hurt and I called her out and yet again, I was labeled as too sensitive.

Apparently i was a very difficult baby. Born with a birth defect, needed multiple surgeries before I was one etc. This plunged mum into PND. It was the worst year of her life as she's often told me. She neglected my older siblings, lost herself etc..Hard stuff I understand. But yesterday she told me that she would have aborted me had she known what my first year of life would be...

Am I being sensitive or is it incredibly hurtful to tell your child that you would aborted them if you could go back in time?

OP posts:
ididntwanttodoit · 18/07/2023 12:02

"Being honest" rarely involves telling people something nice - funny that, isn't it? Putting a positive spin on what your mum said to you, perhaps she meant that she had been upset at what you had to go though? I wouldn't automatically assume that she meant she wished you weren't there - simply that both you and the family would have been spared an ordeal at the time. I do think that she is lacking self-awareness rather than being deliberately cruel, but I also think that you have a negative mindset towards her that you should be trying to turn around for your own mental wellbeing.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 18/07/2023 12:02

I think I’m in the minority with not finding it particularly offensive.

there are many posters on here who push that it’s a woman’s right to choose abortion for any reason right up to delivery (not me, I’m happy with 24 weeks). So many many women knowing that they would have a very difficult first year would probably have chosen to abort. It doesn’t change her love for you now, but if she’d have known how tough things would have been she probably wouldn’t have been alone in choosing not to go ahead.

ok, she didn’t need to tell you, but it probably wasn’t said intentionally to upset you. She was probably just thinking of things practically. This is from someone who’s own mother told them regularly growing up that they were a mistake and would never have chosen to have another baby so soon after her first and that I made things incredibly difficult and ruined her mental health. She’s right, I did. F all I can do about it though and I don’t hold it against my mum. It was a hellish time for her and I was a very difficult baby.

ManchesterLu · 18/07/2023 11:59

Honesty is only good to an extent. Then it becomes cruelty.

GetYourHandsOffMyCake · 18/07/2023 11:56

It's one thing to be honest, another to be a completely insensitive and uncaring twat - your mother (I use that term loosely) is the latter. Sorry, OP.

FatArse123 · 18/07/2023 11:53

Your mother should be thoroughly ashamed of her "honesty". You are not unreasonable for feeling very hurt by what she said.

SunnySummerPlease · 18/07/2023 11:53

My son was born with a life limiting condition, the first year of his life was pure hell, I suffered from PTSD & if I’d know what it was going to be like, I would have had an abortion…. I would never say any of this to him, it’s my parental struggle that I own.

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 18/07/2023 11:44

That's a disgusting thing for your mum to say. She's not a good person, she couldn't say that if she was. She's one of those people that think 'truth' can excuse anything no matter how racist or nasty or bigoted. She's wrong. You're not too sensitive, it's perfectly normal to find things like that unnecessary nastiness.

ButterflyOil · 18/07/2023 11:43

Jesus. Agreed - this is cruelty dressed up as honesty. Sounds like your mother resents being a mum and takes it out in her kids under this ‘honesty’ guise to me.

You’re not too sensitive. You’re a normal amount of sensitive.

CamCola · 18/07/2023 11:38

That is shocking.

My son has a severe disability and I would never ever say anything like that.

BorneoBound · 18/07/2023 11:33

Absolutely NBU. There is a time for harsh honesty e.g. telling someone they smell (it's not nice to tell them, but it's for the best that they know) but what your mother said is downright wrong. What kind of person says that to their child?! I would have to tell her that she is an awful human being who doesn't deserve the kids she has with a 'just being honest' thrown in at the end

ThomasHardyPerennial · 18/07/2023 11:28

What exactly are you supposed to do with this information? What was the point of your mother telling you that? It was cruel and selfish of her, and beyond careless of her to share it with you.

itsmyp4rty · 18/07/2023 11:26

Exasperatednow · 18/07/2023 11:20

You need to tell your mother thst she uses 'honesty' as an excuse for cruelty. She lacks empathy and sounds like she has a personality disorder

This is exactly right.

ThomasHardyPerennial · 18/07/2023 11:22

Fucking hell, that is awful. I'm so sorry she said that to you.

Exasperatednow · 18/07/2023 11:20

You need to tell your mother thst she uses 'honesty' as an excuse for cruelty. She lacks empathy and sounds like she has a personality disorder

HarridanHarvestingHeldaBeans · 18/07/2023 11:17

My mother and grandfather are/were like this (one of definitely dead and I don't know about the other one). The only truth that matters is their interpretation of it, and it is always worded to hurt- no effort is ever made to soften a blow. They enjoy the hurting part, it's the whole point.

However, when someone else expresses their version of the truth (often that their words are unnecessarily hurtful/spiteful and possible not even objectively true), this is interpreted as a personal attack or extreme sensitivity.

My mother told me often that she didn't love me when I was first born, and it took her a while to get used to me. That is almost certainly true. It is also a very damaging thing for a child to hear.

TheBlinkOfAnEye · 18/07/2023 11:16

Maddy70 · 18/07/2023 11:11

I think she was just being honest about her parenting difficulties

She doesn't mean she didn't want you but she wa unprepared for the ons struggles she faced

She said she would have aborted her just yesterday. That's just cruel.

Mrsjayy · 18/07/2023 11:16

Maddy70 · 18/07/2023 11:11

I think she was just being honest about her parenting difficulties

She doesn't mean she didn't want you but she wa unprepared for the ons struggles she faced

A disabled adult knows the difficulties of childhood and how it's not a walk in the park they don't need their mother to tell then that "it causerd pnd) and if she knew she would consider termination, there Is sharing experiences then there is cruelty and emotionally dumping on your adult child!

Maddy70 · 18/07/2023 11:11

MoMuM7 · 18/07/2023 10:06

My mother prides herself on being honest and forthcoming. She says what I consider, very offensive things, and concludes with an 'I'm just being honest'. We were raised in a household where you were encouraged to voice your feelings not matter who you hurt. I always found that brutal and was considered the 'sensitive' one. We have a civil, not close, relationship so I just got on with it. My mum said something that deeply hurt and I called her out and yet again, I was labeled as too sensitive.

Apparently i was a very difficult baby. Born with a birth defect, needed multiple surgeries before I was one etc. This plunged mum into PND. It was the worst year of her life as she's often told me. She neglected my older siblings, lost herself etc..Hard stuff I understand. But yesterday she told me that she would have aborted me had she known what my first year of life would be...

Am I being sensitive or is it incredibly hurtful to tell your child that you would aborted them if you could go back in time?

I think she was just being honest about her parenting difficulties

She doesn't mean she didn't want you but she wa unprepared for the ons struggles she faced

airforsharon · 18/07/2023 11:11

I've a relative like that, says she "calls a spade a spade" 🙄 It's just arrogance really, the belief that her view is the right view, and everyone wants to hear it. It's not always, and we don't.

People who are deliberately cruel in the name of 'honesty' don't deserve your time or respect OP, even if that person is your Mum.

TheBlinkOfAnEye · 18/07/2023 11:10

Cruel, definitely. I'm sure you were worth the stress of the hard start, that is really a short time compared to all the time after.

Commentsonly · 18/07/2023 11:08

Cruel

Missingmyusername · 18/07/2023 11:07

Jesus.
Some things you keep to yourself, I can understand it may have been dark days for her, depression, worry etc, but you don’t tell your child that!

Perhaps you should also be honest and tell her she’s a ! (I’ll let you come to your own conclusions!) Despicable thing to say. Sorry op.

Aria2015 · 18/07/2023 11:07

You're not being sensitive. Being honest implies it's dishonest not to have said something, but it's not dishonest to keep certain views or feelings to yourself if you know voicing them serves no real purpose and will hurt someone.

Your mother has achieved nothing other than to upset you with her 'honestly' and so it's serves no purpose. It's just cruel. I'm sorry that you've had to hear her say cruel things to you. Remember your worth as a person doesn't hang on the opinion of any one person. Surround yourself with people who want to protect your heart, not hurt it.

medianewbie · 18/07/2023 11:06

thistimelastweek · 18/07/2023 10:21

It's a a nasty manipulative double whammy.

The cruelty is passed off as honesty and it's somehow your fault when it hurts. Even when it's meant to hurt.

Perfectly put!
It's deliberately cruel. She knows it. Then gaslights your (appropriate hurt)
OP, limit your exposure to her. She will probably get (even!) worse as she ages

Chocolatesandroses · 18/07/2023 11:05

I feel you op , my mother is the same. I hear comments like this all the time . You’re not too sensitive and she was out of order with her comments . My children have asd and my mum will say well least they don’t look disabled . I asked her what do u mean she basically said she wouldn’t have a children who looks disabled and she would have had us adopted or aborted if we was . It’s got nothing to do with not being able to cope or anything like this , it’s the way we look that would bother her . Life with her was incredibly hard , when she says that I just say I would have probably had a better childhood if u had