Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don’t think opportunity is out there and so they remain in a lower standard of living?

218 replies

upugotep · 18/07/2023 09:35

Sort of inspired by the post about what makes a high earner, it reminded me of a friend who has gone through her life literally never thinking she can earn more.

We had massively different backgrounds and it was expected of me that I should go into a professional job and progress etc. Around ten years into our friendship in our very early 30s, my friend was talking about her ‘wealthy’ family friends, whose dad at 50 had just been promoted and was now earning 52k. She followed this up with ‘I can’t even imagine it, I will never be on anything near 50k.’ At this point I was on 58k and hopeful that my pay would increase a lot in future.

I didn’t say anything other than she might be surprised if she put herself out there that more could be earned.

What I found odd about it is that she is highly intelligent, very employable, personable, just brilliant really. It’s purely her lack of belief in another sort of life and her expectations of herself that hold her back. I am slightly better educated than her but only because of my background and she would absolutely be a competitor to me in an interview and probably get the job over me. I actually think it’s a dirty secret that those ‘at the top’ like to make out they are something special and it’s unattainable when actually it’s not. Why on earth should my friend think 50k is unattainable when she was only 31?!

OP posts:
MammaTo · 18/07/2023 11:34

I think it’s got a lot to do with self esteem and self confidence.

My friend and I are the same age and very similar backgrounds - she never finished uni but I did - she had the balls to go for an interview for a job 3 grades above her existing role and got it.

I would never dream of this because I see myself as not being competent to jump that much but in reality I’m constantly being praised in work for running rings around managers- if I just put myself out there more i could probably have the same opportunities.

Jigslaw · 18/07/2023 11:30

I think schools, universities and employers do quite a good job of providing opportunity but they can’t physically make young people accept it.

It does warm my soul a bit to know those at my school who were bullied for being studious and mocked for taking school seriously all earn significantly more than their bullies. Ahhhh.

Jigslaw · 18/07/2023 11:29

I do agree to an extent. I grew up in poverty and it hasn't been easy to get into a career. Lots of personal sacrifice, the majority of people I went to school with went straight into work after school and now complain they're stuck in dead end jobs and that I'm so lucky; it wasn't luck it was active choices. Whilst they were spending money on enjoying themselves when younger I was saving, working multiple jobs and studying even if this meant working overnight. I took out huge loans, and whilst they work hard in their jobs that doesn't detract from the fact I lifted myself out of the poverty cycle and didn't have a helping hand. Also agree many people are more than capable of taking on different roles but don't even go for them let alone get them.

This isn't to say people are poor through their own choices and that it isn't complex, but it's that some make choices at great sacrifice to further their opportunities and this is nothing to do with luck.

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 11:26

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/07/2023 11:08

I see it all the time on here, people citing fairly weak reasons why they ‘can’t’ work more hours, or move to find a better paid job, or go back to work now their youngest is in school. It seems that any issue no matter how small is an acceptable reason not to take responsibility for your life and instead blame others.

It's quite difficult to see a different future and the possibilities when you feel you're just about managing as you are. All change involves risk, sometimes to financial security and to living circumstances, if you've been raised to be risk averse, or have taken risks that haven't worked out as you hoped sometimes it feels very safe to just keep on the same track. It's no accident that many successful people come from a privileged background and have family support to back them up while they get established/if it all goes wrong.

This discussion is very pertinent to me at the moment as I consider what my next steps are career wise. I could stay in my very secure, comfortable job which fits my family (but isn't particularly inspiring), or expand my small business which could bring a lot of financial benefit, and is challenging and inspiring, but brings no small amount of risk. When you have other people to consider, and no financial safety net other than that you provide for yourself it's not as simply as "just go for it". I can understand people feeling quite stuck, while also feeling constrained by circumstance and wishing for better.

I wasn’t really referring to people who are weighing up future business plans, more posters who work 8 hours a week and insist they can’t do more for a completely fixable reason. And if you suggest they fix it they just mutter the incantation about ‘you don’t know what’s going on in my life’ and that’s it, they won’t be questioned any more.

I saw a poster say a while ago that the past wealth of the U.K. has acclimatised the public to a certain standard of living that they now feel entitled to whether they work or not, even though we aren’t as affluent as we once were and our public resources are thin on the ground.

I want to see this country move into the future and become a wealthy and vibrant place to live again, but the public need to accept the government can only work with what they’re given by us. If half the workforce are part time and happy to be topped up by UC, or signed off, then we simply don’t have the productivity required to make this a wealthy country with excellent services.

I think schools, universities and employers do quite a good job of providing opportunity but they can’t physically make young people accept it. The good news is it’s quite possible to change your circumstances as an adult if you want to enough.

rosetintedmemories2023 · 18/07/2023 11:26

PaperNests · 18/07/2023 11:13

I think you're also underestimating the impact this has on people's wider family not just what their family life was as a child but what it's like now. I'm at a level in my job now where I could carry on going up and start earning a lot of money. No-one else in my family can, they all do odd jobs in between claiming benefits. If I earned a lot more than them my life would be radically different to theirs, or I'd hide it and feel awful when they were struggling for money. My relationship with my siblings and relatives would never be the same. I would rather stay at my current level and keep the family dynamic.

yes same is true for my DH.

He was on free school meals, his mums is a bohemian type who has never earned more than 16k (but had help with deposits so managed to buy in London even with 4 kids which would have been hard without family help even in the 1990s). His sisters all studied art or music or dropped out of school so have much lower earning potential. Dh studied law and works for a bank so his salary expectations are very different. In fact when he first met me at uni, he told me he had to earn a lot of money as his grandfather had always told him he needed to earn lots to support his mother and 3 sisters. But he is the only son so was the only one raised to be like that. So these expectations can be very gendered.

I remember the younger sister lost her job as a kindergarten teacher and needed a job pronto to pay her rent. I suggested that i saw some remote jobs (from the USA) that paid the USD equivalent of £35k and would be suitable for graduates like herself (she has a masters from a red brick university). She could do it while doing music on the side. She looked at me like I was bonkers and said ' £35k ! I wish. That is a princely salary'. my MIL then kinda laughed and said, 'this is why *insert DH's name and her are yuppies!' Erm.

Thelnebriati · 18/07/2023 11:25

Disadvantages work to actively prevent people getting better positions. Even when you push yourself forwards, you still don't get picked as often as people from the other group.

upugotep · 18/07/2023 11:15

Thelnebriati · 18/07/2023 11:14

OP; you completely dismissed the first answer. So is this thread about structural disadvantages or is it about you and your friend?

@Thelnebriati I can’t see how the issues are separate? So both, I suppose.

OP posts:
upugotep · 18/07/2023 11:14

declutteringmymind · 18/07/2023 10:58

Have you told her what you think?

@declutteringmymind yes I’ve said she could absolutely do the job I do and that she would likely be much better at it!!

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 18/07/2023 11:14

OP; you completely dismissed the first answer. So is this thread about structural disadvantages or is it about you and your friend?

PaperNests · 18/07/2023 11:13

I think you're also underestimating the impact this has on people's wider family not just what their family life was as a child but what it's like now. I'm at a level in my job now where I could carry on going up and start earning a lot of money. No-one else in my family can, they all do odd jobs in between claiming benefits. If I earned a lot more than them my life would be radically different to theirs, or I'd hide it and feel awful when they were struggling for money. My relationship with my siblings and relatives would never be the same. I would rather stay at my current level and keep the family dynamic.

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/07/2023 11:08

I see it all the time on here, people citing fairly weak reasons why they ‘can’t’ work more hours, or move to find a better paid job, or go back to work now their youngest is in school. It seems that any issue no matter how small is an acceptable reason not to take responsibility for your life and instead blame others.

It's quite difficult to see a different future and the possibilities when you feel you're just about managing as you are. All change involves risk, sometimes to financial security and to living circumstances, if you've been raised to be risk averse, or have taken risks that haven't worked out as you hoped sometimes it feels very safe to just keep on the same track. It's no accident that many successful people come from a privileged background and have family support to back them up while they get established/if it all goes wrong.

This discussion is very pertinent to me at the moment as I consider what my next steps are career wise. I could stay in my very secure, comfortable job which fits my family (but isn't particularly inspiring), or expand my small business which could bring a lot of financial benefit, and is challenging and inspiring, but brings no small amount of risk. When you have other people to consider, and no financial safety net other than that you provide for yourself it's not as simply as "just go for it". I can understand people feeling quite stuck, while also feeling constrained by circumstance and wishing for better.

LadyDanburysHat · 18/07/2023 11:05

I agree with the PP who mentioned that you need to know the jobs exist to aim for them.

I have a degree, not a great one, went into admin roles after uni. Followed by having my DC and working part time in admin type roles for a long time. At 40 I got yet another admin role, but full time, hoping I could get somewhere in earning more money. I really hoped one day I might earn £30k as an EA. That was it, I didn't see how I could possibly earn more than that. However, the admin role I had stumbled into was in a small pharma company and I got the opportunity to learn other skills. I changed to a more technical role, left for a new company on a 35% pay rise, and have had 2 promotions here. I now earn £45k which would have been mindblowing to me 5 years ago. I do expect to earn more now. It is easier to aim for it once you are up there.

declutteringmymind · 18/07/2023 10:58

Have you told her what you think?

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 10:58

Coffeetree · 18/07/2023 10:46

I really think this is true. I had a teacher in secondary school suggest I could be a lawyer and my family teased me about for ages, falling about like "Can you imagine Coffeetree with a briefcase, walking into her law office like ooo I'm a lawyer"! Contrast that with other families, where that would be a perfectly normal life goal.

It definitely had the effect of me being a paralegal for ages until qualifying in my late 40s. I really thought I wasn't clever enough!

I agree but I also think at some point we have to throw off the shackles of what our families have done to us and make the best of our lives (like you did). I say this with no ‘privilege’ at all, my home life was total chaos, social services, family court et cetera

Coffeetree · 18/07/2023 10:57

Checking/investigating privilege I mean.

Coffeetree · 18/07/2023 10:56

Lifechangesalot · 18/07/2023 10:55

Why?

I mean, that's literally what the OP is doing?

Lifechangesalot · 18/07/2023 10:55

Tiredalwaystired · 18/07/2023 10:54

This post just needs one response really.

Check your privilege.

Why?

Tiredalwaystired · 18/07/2023 10:54

This post just needs one response really.

Check your privilege.

KingsHeath53 · 18/07/2023 10:54

You can’t be it unless you can see it.

I grew up in a poor city outside London. The very smartest kids from my area aspired to be teachers or maybe work for the council. At a push they wanted to be doctors. The very very richest people in our town would have been maybe GPs on low six figures.

It was only when I moved to London that I realised kids the same as them (brightest in the class) would aspire to be tech entrepeneurs or film stars or hedge fund managers on millions. Not all of them would make it sure but certainly more than those who never knew these jobs existed.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 18/07/2023 10:49

I’ve been brought up like this

better to not to even try as you’ll only fail anyway

Coffeetree · 18/07/2023 10:46

LovelyQuiche · 18/07/2023 10:28

I think people also underestimate how much people’s own family hold them back

Being told they’re not smart, people like us / them don’t do that, know your place etc. No point in studying.

Your parents / family attitude is probably one of the biggest barriers to social mobility and it starts from childhood

I really think this is true. I had a teacher in secondary school suggest I could be a lawyer and my family teased me about for ages, falling about like "Can you imagine Coffeetree with a briefcase, walking into her law office like ooo I'm a lawyer"! Contrast that with other families, where that would be a perfectly normal life goal.

It definitely had the effect of me being a paralegal for ages until qualifying in my late 40s. I really thought I wasn't clever enough!

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 10:43

YANBU, I was thinking the same this morning. I was casually browsing jobs and the number of companies who seem to be actively seeking out people with less opportunity or disadvantage for entry level jobs was quite high.

To be honest while I think the Tories are a shower of shit, we’ve also got a strong ‘blame the government’ mantra which is standing in the way of personal responsibility and bettering yourself. I see it all the time on here, people citing fairly weak reasons why they ‘can’t’ work more hours, or move to find a better paid job, or go back to work now their youngest is in school. It seems that any issue no matter how small is an acceptable reason not to take responsibility for your life and instead blame others.

It’s also interesting that the British public seem to feel entitled to stay living in the area of their choice no matter how expensive. ‘Just build more social housing’ is the answer apparently, despite the fact we have neither the space nor money to do this on the scale that would be required.

Other cultures are happy to move for work and opportunity - look at Eastern European’s. Poland is a country of hard workers who have made personal sacrifices to better themselves and now their economy is booming and set to overtake ours very shortly. Many have slogged away in the U.K. for years and have now returned home to a much better lifestyle and prospects. Good for them!

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/07/2023 10:35

I think it’s easy to underestimate how hard it can be to see yourself in a different light. If you imagine £50k is a huge salary and the preserve of other better, brighter people it can be very difficult to change your view of yourself. It can also feel very risky to put yourself out there and possibly fail (which reinforces the idea that you can’t do it).

People are comfortable with the familiar, even if the familiar isn’t great it’s a known entity to them.

Swrigh1234 · 18/07/2023 10:35

You are not wrong OP. This country has a problem with low aspirations. Reverse snobbery.

Anyone who has done well or aspires to do well is sneered upon as being privileged unless they are a crack addict or had multiple teenage pregnancies. Coming from an average stable background makes you not worthy of success.

The number of posts on these threads with weird responses accusing high earners of being fantasists makes you release how low the bar in this country is.

If you are successful, earn a lot, then that should be congratulated, not sneered upon.

AwkwardPaws27 · 18/07/2023 10:34

cocksstrideintheevening · 18/07/2023 10:06

I think there is a massive lack of decent careers advice. It shows on the high earners thread, most of the posters on there don't seem to think it's possible to be a high earner or what route that would take after school.

^ also this.

I wanted to be a vet, I was predicted As/A*s at GCSE but our careers advisor said "oh its very hard to be a vet. How about veterinary nursing".
In hindsight I'd love veterinary nursing, but the salaries were far lower than for a veterinary surgeon, & there was no encouragement to consider the impact of earnings, just "this route is too hard".

Swipe left for the next trending thread