Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don’t think opportunity is out there and so they remain in a lower standard of living?

218 replies

upugotep · 18/07/2023 09:35

Sort of inspired by the post about what makes a high earner, it reminded me of a friend who has gone through her life literally never thinking she can earn more.

We had massively different backgrounds and it was expected of me that I should go into a professional job and progress etc. Around ten years into our friendship in our very early 30s, my friend was talking about her ‘wealthy’ family friends, whose dad at 50 had just been promoted and was now earning 52k. She followed this up with ‘I can’t even imagine it, I will never be on anything near 50k.’ At this point I was on 58k and hopeful that my pay would increase a lot in future.

I didn’t say anything other than she might be surprised if she put herself out there that more could be earned.

What I found odd about it is that she is highly intelligent, very employable, personable, just brilliant really. It’s purely her lack of belief in another sort of life and her expectations of herself that hold her back. I am slightly better educated than her but only because of my background and she would absolutely be a competitor to me in an interview and probably get the job over me. I actually think it’s a dirty secret that those ‘at the top’ like to make out they are something special and it’s unattainable when actually it’s not. Why on earth should my friend think 50k is unattainable when she was only 31?!

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 18/07/2023 13:31

Some of us actively choose to work in jobs that don't pay well but are doing good in society! Not everything is measured in money.

Not everything does come down to money and I think jobs that do social good should be paid enough for a decent standards of living, without needing to resort to benefits to get by. These jobs though are generally funded through the public purse either directly in the public sector or through third sector receiving significant funding through local government. To fund that we need people who are being paid higher salaries and paying tax and we need those who can working full time rather than working part time and relying on benefits to top up part time wages.

AlligatorPsychopath · 18/07/2023 13:22

IceCreamQueen86 · 18/07/2023 13:08

I’m the child of immigrants who was born and brought up in Croydon - a place where joining a gang or becoming a drug dealer were seriously considered career options in the bog standard comp I went to.

My parents had accents from their country of origin and I picked up the local accent of replacing the ‘th’ at the beginning of words with a ‘d’ sound or if in the middle of a word, with a ‘f’ sound and dropping the ‘tt’ in the middle of words entirely - habits I still slip into occasionally.

My parents had manual labour jobs when they first got here and worked all hours under the sun so were hardly ever home and I was a latchkey kid from a very young age who also had the responsibility of younger siblings to look after. I also had other hardships that I won’t get into however my siblings and I all became successful in our own ways, using a variety of different paths, because our parents drummed it into us that we must - it never occurred to us that we wouldn’t and more importantly couldn’t. At every opportunity our parents pushed, supported and took an active interest in our career paths - sometimes with the help of a slipper or a cooking ladle! My dad’s favourite saying was “If one door closes, another door opens or if all doors are shut, then climb through the window, if the window is locked then you break it”. Education, training and bettering ourselves were pushed down our throats from as early as I remember and it was an expectation that we absolutely would do better than our parents.

So I’m a woman who is as working class as it gets with an accent to match and rather than that holding me back as some people here have claimed, it actually helped me as employers recognised that I had to work 10 times harder to get to the same place as my more privileged counterparts and saw the value in that.

I’m in no way unique or special either, a lot of immigrants and children of immigrants will have a similar story.

My partner on the other hand (we went to the same primary and secondary schools) comes from an environment where it was normal to either deliberately have a baby as a career choice or be “on the sick” as it was called and everyone was expected to know their place and not get above their station. My partner was guilted into not bettering himself or going after any sort of career as those things were not for people “like him” apparently.

Despite him being more intelligent / brilliant / gifted / naturally able than me in every way, my partner never progressed into any sort of career whereas I did - the only reason for that is that we are both products of our upbringing.

(Just to be clear, I’m not saying my upbringing is in anyway better or superior by the way, just that it pushed me career wise. In many ways, the one track approach my parents had also took away my childhood).

Very valid point. Many immigrants and children of immigrants are dealing with all the class barriers and lack of cultural capital that white British working class populations, plus the additional burden of ingrained racism. Yet many of those groups achieve very high rates of excellent higher education and skilled professional jobs. What exactly explains the educational attainment gap between them and white working class pupils, if expectations don't play a role?

That is, of course, not saying that class and financial resources play no role. Afua Hirsch writes at some length in her book about how her partner, who grew up on a deprived, majority Black council estate in Tottenham, had to have the asceticism and self-discpline of a monk to achieve the law degree that for her, child of affluent middle class parents in Wimbledon, was the path of least resistance.

Jigslaw · 18/07/2023 13:11

rosetintedmemories2023 · 18/07/2023 12:56

Yes in my DH's family, anything that is artistic and pays little is considered much better than a 'boring' job. DH's sister once told him that it was all very well for him to do all the 'admin excel bureaucratic' work (he does compliance for a bank) but she was made for 'higher' creative pursuits. i get that playing music is a lot more fun than sitting in an office but there was time when she was claiming housing benefit and this is all paid for by higher rate taxpayers like my DH who may not be in such glamorous jobs (but which do pay between £60k-100k depending on level)

Your job is a personal decision, there is no right or wrong, but imho looking down on people who pick careers that earn more and yet expecting a welfare state (they believe that there should always be benefits and free healthcare) is a bit strange. who do they think will pay for a welfare state?

It is a shame to be fair that we live in a society that values making money over all else and people in jobs such as the arts which enhance a lot of people's lives get paid rubbish (unless very lucky and become successful which is a small percentage). Alas as that's the society we do live in have to chase the corporate hell to make decent money.

IceCreamQueen86 · 18/07/2023 13:08

I’m the child of immigrants who was born and brought up in Croydon - a place where joining a gang or becoming a drug dealer were seriously considered career options in the bog standard comp I went to.

My parents had accents from their country of origin and I picked up the local accent of replacing the ‘th’ at the beginning of words with a ‘d’ sound or if in the middle of a word, with a ‘f’ sound and dropping the ‘tt’ in the middle of words entirely - habits I still slip into occasionally.

My parents had manual labour jobs when they first got here and worked all hours under the sun so were hardly ever home and I was a latchkey kid from a very young age who also had the responsibility of younger siblings to look after. I also had other hardships that I won’t get into however my siblings and I all became successful in our own ways, using a variety of different paths, because our parents drummed it into us that we must - it never occurred to us that we wouldn’t and more importantly couldn’t. At every opportunity our parents pushed, supported and took an active interest in our career paths - sometimes with the help of a slipper or a cooking ladle! My dad’s favourite saying was “If one door closes, another door opens or if all doors are shut, then climb through the window, if the window is locked then you break it”. Education, training and bettering ourselves were pushed down our throats from as early as I remember and it was an expectation that we absolutely would do better than our parents.

So I’m a woman who is as working class as it gets with an accent to match and rather than that holding me back as some people here have claimed, it actually helped me as employers recognised that I had to work 10 times harder to get to the same place as my more privileged counterparts and saw the value in that.

I’m in no way unique or special either, a lot of immigrants and children of immigrants will have a similar story.

My partner on the other hand (we went to the same primary and secondary schools) comes from an environment where it was normal to either deliberately have a baby as a career choice or be “on the sick” as it was called and everyone was expected to know their place and not get above their station. My partner was guilted into not bettering himself or going after any sort of career as those things were not for people “like him” apparently.

Despite him being more intelligent / brilliant / gifted / naturally able than me in every way, my partner never progressed into any sort of career whereas I did - the only reason for that is that we are both products of our upbringing.

(Just to be clear, I’m not saying my upbringing is in anyway better or superior by the way, just that it pushed me career wise. In many ways, the one track approach my parents had also took away my childhood).

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 13:01

rosetintedmemories2023 · 18/07/2023 12:56

Yes in my DH's family, anything that is artistic and pays little is considered much better than a 'boring' job. DH's sister once told him that it was all very well for him to do all the 'admin excel bureaucratic' work (he does compliance for a bank) but she was made for 'higher' creative pursuits. i get that playing music is a lot more fun than sitting in an office but there was time when she was claiming housing benefit and this is all paid for by higher rate taxpayers like my DH who may not be in such glamorous jobs (but which do pay between £60k-100k depending on level)

Your job is a personal decision, there is no right or wrong, but imho looking down on people who pick careers that earn more and yet expecting a welfare state (they believe that there should always be benefits and free healthcare) is a bit strange. who do they think will pay for a welfare state?

Ugh she’s already annoying me and I don’t know her!

Spendonsend · 18/07/2023 13:01

gogomoto · 18/07/2023 12:37

Some of us actively choose to work in jobs that don't pay well but are doing good in society! Not everything is measured in money. I'm fortunate to still have a good standard of living but I have found a niche that is purposeful and gets lots of satisfaction from

Yes, some job sectors just dont pay as well as others. You can prioritise jobs that pay more but not everyone has the aptitude for these this things.

Ceebeegee · 18/07/2023 13:00

I think upbringing and family attitudes play a big part in it, from my experience. I feel like I am just like your friend - I don't have a high standard of living, stuck in a mid-rate admin job, stretching money to cover the bills each month.

Growing up, I knew from year 7 that I wouldn't be able to go to uni. It was not about my grades. It was simply We couldn't afford it. Don't even try, because we can't afford uni.
Unfortunatley my family also had a massive chip on their shoulder. Going to uni was something children of the GP and local solicitor did, a kid like me from a stay-at-home-mum and a bus driver did didn't go to uni.

Being brainwashed from a young age, that higher education is "just not what our type of family do" , no wonder I didn't end up with lots of opportunities.

heatherheathe · 18/07/2023 12:59

Hopelesscynic · 18/07/2023 10:17

I think you are presenting things here a lot more simplified than they are. It so much depends on your education and professional experience - has your friend studied the same subject (to the same level) as you that you think she is capable of doing the same job? What about her actual experience?
Let me give you an example of myself, I am educated to a Master level in the social science field. Like your friend, I am hard working, intelligent and likeable. Guess what, no matter how many opportunities I tried, including changing jobs and "putting myself out there", taking training etc... I am pretty much in the same boat, the maximum I've earned is 26K and I dont foresee this could change. Many of the jobs advertised in my field that are higher pay require extensive experience, which has been a chicken and egg situation as I can't get the experience unless I get hired... My education doesn't seem to have helped in the slightest (I appreciate this is not the same for other lines of work).
If I'm lucky, maybe at some point I'll get towards 30K but I don't ever imagine earning anywhere near 50K. Your post sounds patronizing, as if it's that easy to just look for opportunity and get a highly paid job.

This seems to be because you've limited yourself to a specific job/sector though.
I completely understand because I trained and worked for a while in the heritage sector and it was exactly as you say, despite most jobs needing quite specific and high level qualifications jobs were hard to get and paid badly, with very few higher level opportunities (and those were incredibly competitive).

So you're probably completely right in that if you stayed in that sector you'd struggle to earn anywhere near £50k, through no fault of your own.

However that's not the same as saying that it is, (and was from the moment you chose your degree and set your path in stone from the age of 18) impossible for you ever to earn £50k. You could have chosen a different career pathway, and could still retrain now if money was more important to you, which was what I did eventually -I really wanted to own my own house and it would never be possible with my earning in that sector. Quite a few people my age (mid 30s) have done the same.

Obviously it's not fair that people are effectively priced out of careers they love and are good at but that's a different question.

It doesn't have to be linked to academics, either -my bil left school with minimum gcses and worked in customer service type jobs for a few years making £15-£18k. Retrained age 25 as a plumber and by 35 had his own business and was making nearly £100k.

So I can see what op means about having the confidence and knowledge to look for other opportunities even if they are out of your comfort zone (although of course there are other elements like familial support, having some financial fall back to cover you while you're retraining etc.)

rosetintedmemories2023 · 18/07/2023 12:56

hettie · 18/07/2023 12:39

@ThisIsACoolUserName I feel your pain, privileging education and then being a passive aggressive critic is also my mum's trick. I get things like "x (who has by the way a professional qulalication) has taken a few shifts in the pub. They're not afraid to role their sleeves up/work hard." My qualifications and skills and high flying job are almost pitied/sneered at. One side of dh's family just the same, like he was getting ideas above his station. Why can't you just celebrate his success? As others have explained it weirdly separates you from family, like your some kind of black sheep. It's very isolating and lots of people choose not to challenge the status quo....

Yes in my DH's family, anything that is artistic and pays little is considered much better than a 'boring' job. DH's sister once told him that it was all very well for him to do all the 'admin excel bureaucratic' work (he does compliance for a bank) but she was made for 'higher' creative pursuits. i get that playing music is a lot more fun than sitting in an office but there was time when she was claiming housing benefit and this is all paid for by higher rate taxpayers like my DH who may not be in such glamorous jobs (but which do pay between £60k-100k depending on level)

Your job is a personal decision, there is no right or wrong, but imho looking down on people who pick careers that earn more and yet expecting a welfare state (they believe that there should always be benefits and free healthcare) is a bit strange. who do they think will pay for a welfare state?

hettie · 18/07/2023 12:39

@ThisIsACoolUserName I feel your pain, privileging education and then being a passive aggressive critic is also my mum's trick. I get things like "x (who has by the way a professional qulalication) has taken a few shifts in the pub. They're not afraid to role their sleeves up/work hard." My qualifications and skills and high flying job are almost pitied/sneered at. One side of dh's family just the same, like he was getting ideas above his station. Why can't you just celebrate his success? As others have explained it weirdly separates you from family, like your some kind of black sheep. It's very isolating and lots of people choose not to challenge the status quo....

gogomoto · 18/07/2023 12:37

Some of us actively choose to work in jobs that don't pay well but are doing good in society! Not everything is measured in money. I'm fortunate to still have a good standard of living but I have found a niche that is purposeful and gets lots of satisfaction from

AlligatorPsychopath · 18/07/2023 12:32

I know that if I go for a higher paying job, it follows that it will take more from me, otherwise what am I getting paid for?

The thing is, this is really only true for fairly low-skilled jobs. Jobs which depend on skills or experience which are relatively scarce, there is often very little relationship between pay and what the job "takes" from you. Acquire sufficiently valuable skills and you can probably be paid quite highly for a relatively cushy job in terms of hours, pressure, etc.

I'm an individual contributor in a skilled technical field and earn well. I intend to break six figures before I'm done. I have very normal working hours and not that much pressure, certainly less than many people earning much less.

liondreams · 18/07/2023 12:26

Suprise suprise, not everyone aspires to be extremely wealthy! Many people are happy living a basic, simple or frugal life. Also depending on your chosen career path, it may involve working in a big corporation in a soul draining job to get paid the high wages side of thing (not always I admit). I'd much rather earn less doing something I love and live a basic life than be a corporate wage slave.

NoNonsensePotato · 18/07/2023 12:24

I think a lot of people aren't prepared to be flexible, and in many ways 'thinking outside the box' is a similar process to what a lot of entrepreneurs do.

I was talking to a young working class lad at a job today. He was working as a slinger (guiding the crane via walkie talkie) and said he'd started working construction two years ago at 23yo and had just got his crane ticket. Said as soon as he found out how much the crane guy was on he'd started saving as it seemed like the better job sitting in the cab being paid twice what the guys below him in the rain and mud were getting.

Total cost was £3k but he'd immediately been offered a job on £65k which he's starting in a fortnight.

ThisIsACoolUserName · 18/07/2023 12:23

I agree. I think a lot of it comes down to confidence, expectstions and knowledge of what opportunities are out there.

My working class mum sent me to private school (on an 'assisted place') and then a good university. My entire childhood and teenage years were about education and eventually getting a good job (so I thought).

I then left uni and got a temp job and, after a few months, said to mum "I need a better job than this, I didn't go to uni to earn £7.30 an hour", to which mum told me she was ashamed of me and didn't raise me to turn my nose up at minimum wage!

I then got my first permanent role on £15000 a year and she told me I should be very pleased indeed to be bringing home £1000 a month and what more could anyone need!

She's been uncomfortable with my career ever since (Im now in a senior role), which leads me to wonder what she was trying to achieve with all of that education in the first place 🤔

MintJulia · 18/07/2023 12:12

This is why confidence and self-belief are so important. It is why private schools are so keen on extra-curricular activities that build confidence. It is also why having parents who encourage and support their children's achievements is essential.

I had a df who belittled and undermined all his dds. Told us all we were useless and ugly, and nobody would ever want us. Several of us gave up, left school at 15 and didn't reach their potential until their 50s. Others, supported by teachers, were told to ignore him, and we made it to university, and on upwards.

The impact of an unsupported childhood can be lifelong. Your friend needs encouragement, not criticism.

MsCactus · 18/07/2023 12:09

While I agree there's an element of class here, I think it's mainly about confidence.

I've watched terrible co-workers from early in my career - who were very confident - end up progressing quickly and earning a lot, simply because they won't stay in a job otherwise.

Likewise I've known brilliant people who have, for example, been made redundant/list confidence then accepted a much much more junior role elsewhere.

The later person I'm talking about had a "posher" upbringing than me, but was way less self assured. I'm not earning about five times her amount - we were once in the same place, and she was better than me. Probably still is.

It's all about confidence, not class, though they're probably intertwined.

moonlight1705 · 18/07/2023 12:03

Commentsonly · 18/07/2023 11:53

I just want to say that I am eternally grateful to all those who don’t choose a job just based on salary. My best friend is a nursery manager she will not earn over £50k. My sister is a nurse in NICU and again she may never earn over £50k. My mother in law is a community nurse and did her degree whilst working full time and she doesn’t earn £50k.

I hope that we can live in a world where we don’t just judge people on salaries but what they do. Just to think these people on what OP says is ‘not a very good standard of living’ that are making such a great contribution to the society in which we live.

Thank you to them all.

This! I love my job and what I do, I am good at my job and have lots of responsibilities....but I work in the charity sector and will never, never get above £40k. I would have to retrain in something that I do not want to do in the slightest.

Nothing to do with my background, sometimes it's simply about what you are good at or like doing.

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/07/2023 12:02

I agree to an extent. I grew up in poverty and it hasn't been easy to get into a career. Lots of personal sacrifice, the majority of people I went to school with went straight into work after school and now complain they're stuck in dead end jobs and that I'm so lucky; it wasn't luck it was active choices.

I agree with you to an extent. I too did all my studying while also working full time, with no student loans etc - I paid all my uni fees as I went. There was a lot of very hard work and sacrifice to do so. I also have to acknowledge being in the privileged position to do so, having enough money to fund my higher education, having the capacity to give it the time it needed, not having children so no competing priorities.

Im now a single parent with two children who have complex needs, which makes things much harder because I need a degree of flexibility in my work and, as the sole earner, need security in my work. If I had had children in my 30s I’d be in a secure but dead end job because I wouldn’t have been physically able to dedicate the time I did. There are many factors that can limit, or appear to limit, career choices and lifestyle beyond self belief.

FatArse123 · 18/07/2023 12:01

I agree that this sounds like social class rearing its ugly head again. But I have to say, OP, are you sure she wants what you have? I know that if I go for a higher paying job, it follows that it will take more from me, otherwise what am I getting paid for? That is likely to be the things that I actually love, like art and exercise. Not everyone wants to climb the ladder. There seems to be a bit of societal taboo about being unambitious, and maybe she is comfortable where she is?

MySerenity · 18/07/2023 11:59

I come from a free school meal background and my parents had no O levels and did ad hoc working class work.

I'm now a doctor and have struggled with imposter syndrome over the years. The times I realised I wasn't aiming high enough was when I realised people less qualified or intelligent than me were expecting better things from life than I could ever imagine for myself.

Then I had some CBT and other therapy. Then some career coaching. Plus some anxiety meds.

I'm getting there! Now I do put myself forward for things more often and my self esteem is much better than it was.

My mum still looks shocked when I apply for new positions or that I will only take extra shifts at £x/hr. I would also rather outsource work around the house, rather than spend hours to save pennies, and therefore save my time for family/improving my career/paid overtime.

Spreadbed · 18/07/2023 11:57

Your differing backgrounds are the reason. It is very difficult to transcend social class barriers, no matter how educated.

I am from a very working class background, went to an elite university and became involved in a social circle drastically different from anything I’d known before. The things they perceived as completely normal were things I had thought were reserved for an extreme minority - like their parents being able to fund their entire uni experience, having connections get them work experience placements in top companies, which later turned into jobs, having gone to private school and thus having done instrumental lessons, being able to speak other languages, being talented and experienced in sports. The school I went to had a netball club, a football club and a tiny debate team, the teacher of which forgot to book us into competitions.

These individuals have been exposed to their parents experiences, jobs, lifestyles their whole lives and that is normal to them. It’s cultural capital - they have experiences that children in more working class backgrounds often don’t have access to.

In the same way working class children grow up with their parents’ experiences being normal.

Mine and my acquaintances’ attitudes of normal salaries were acres apart. My first job out of uni, a colleague couldn’t believe our boss was ‘only’ on £85k - that to me was millionaire money. The ‘rich’ people I’d went to school with, their parents earned £50k ish and we all thought they were rich!

It’s very difficult to understand if you aren’t from a working class background, which is why it’s a real travesty that most of our PMs are from that tiny percentage at the very top and will never understand the difficulties that so many face.

Commentsonly · 18/07/2023 11:53

I just want to say that I am eternally grateful to all those who don’t choose a job just based on salary. My best friend is a nursery manager she will not earn over £50k. My sister is a nurse in NICU and again she may never earn over £50k. My mother in law is a community nurse and did her degree whilst working full time and she doesn’t earn £50k.

I hope that we can live in a world where we don’t just judge people on salaries but what they do. Just to think these people on what OP says is ‘not a very good standard of living’ that are making such a great contribution to the society in which we live.

Thank you to them all.

chopc · 18/07/2023 11:37

With a lot of high paying jobs comes stress and responsibility. People have different levels of resilience and choose to earn less and have less responsibility and stress.

Background/ upbringing certainly plays a role. This may be why people who attend private schools have a certain air of confidence about them. In a few this may come across as arrogance. However, I think they are taught to be ambitious and to feel good enough to approach anything . Plus they have the skills to do so. In general.

I was also brought up to aim to be in a better position than my parents. I try to emphasise to my kids that having choice in life is invaluable and in order to have choice they need to be well educated and personable and look for opportunities.