Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don’t think opportunity is out there and so they remain in a lower standard of living?

218 replies

upugotep · 18/07/2023 09:35

Sort of inspired by the post about what makes a high earner, it reminded me of a friend who has gone through her life literally never thinking she can earn more.

We had massively different backgrounds and it was expected of me that I should go into a professional job and progress etc. Around ten years into our friendship in our very early 30s, my friend was talking about her ‘wealthy’ family friends, whose dad at 50 had just been promoted and was now earning 52k. She followed this up with ‘I can’t even imagine it, I will never be on anything near 50k.’ At this point I was on 58k and hopeful that my pay would increase a lot in future.

I didn’t say anything other than she might be surprised if she put herself out there that more could be earned.

What I found odd about it is that she is highly intelligent, very employable, personable, just brilliant really. It’s purely her lack of belief in another sort of life and her expectations of herself that hold her back. I am slightly better educated than her but only because of my background and she would absolutely be a competitor to me in an interview and probably get the job over me. I actually think it’s a dirty secret that those ‘at the top’ like to make out they are something special and it’s unattainable when actually it’s not. Why on earth should my friend think 50k is unattainable when she was only 31?!

OP posts:
Lifechangesalot · 18/07/2023 15:28

Kalodin · 18/07/2023 15:23

If anyone here can give me some solid career advice on what I cam switch to, to attain a salary of £75k+ I'd be grateful!

As a PP said on 1st page "you don't know it unless you see it" and I think that's particularly true.

I'm happy in my career (as a Planner in Construction) but I'm aware that I'm coming close to the top of my pay now for my career (having spoken to my friends in the same sector) unless I make a jump to a Consultant for a massive firm and become CEO.

What careers are out there that are high earning? I honestly haven't a clue on what it would be and how to get into it.

I suppose the other issue for a lot of people is that risk of starting again! I'd be worried about having to take a potential pay decrease to start my career again, especially as I'm the higher earner in the household.

Look out for new areas of work that are either up and coming or there are brand new jobs being developed. Are there training opportunities your current employer can fund that would help you move sideways into another industry with more growth potential? Make your own fortune - get onto Google and search out where your field of work is heading, find the research papers, look into the start ups, look at local colleges and universities and distance learning schemes.

Is there a professional body attached to your employer or current area of work? Look on their websites for training programmes.

Look at where you can specialise and become a subject matter expert and push yourself forward into being that SME, get the reputation as THE person for that area of knowledge and don't sell yourself short!

Kalodin · 18/07/2023 15:23

If anyone here can give me some solid career advice on what I cam switch to, to attain a salary of £75k+ I'd be grateful!

As a PP said on 1st page "you don't know it unless you see it" and I think that's particularly true.

I'm happy in my career (as a Planner in Construction) but I'm aware that I'm coming close to the top of my pay now for my career (having spoken to my friends in the same sector) unless I make a jump to a Consultant for a massive firm and become CEO.

What careers are out there that are high earning? I honestly haven't a clue on what it would be and how to get into it.

I suppose the other issue for a lot of people is that risk of starting again! I'd be worried about having to take a potential pay decrease to start my career again, especially as I'm the higher earner in the household.

Callmesleepy · 18/07/2023 15:16

I remember negotiating for a salary and my working class husband thought I was mad to even suggest what I asked for. He just hadn't known people earn that much before somit was a massive shock when they paid it right away. I can imagine having everyone around you have that attitude would hold you back.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 18/07/2023 15:14

JessicaWasFIrst · 18/07/2023 10:27

No actually I get this. Dh and his sibling raised in the same household with the same parents. Dh went to uni and got a graduate job in his field. Rose through the ranks through hard work and gaining more skills. Earns over the £65k quoted on the other thread.

My SIL did A levels and seems to just do office admin jobs, she has said her current role is worth between £23-£25k. She has been in this latest role almost a year, incredible praise and feedback from the manager. She is smart, organised but never pushes herself. Recently her manager was off sick, she took on loads of the responsibility to keep stuff going (small business) and I told her when she has her year end review she should go in armed with the above and beyond things she has done over the year and ask for a pay rise. She was all well no I don't think they would give me a pay rise. I said why not ask? She will not negotiate her salary and so she will just remain an employee who does more than her job title and never ask for the pay increase.

She is mid 40s so this isn't something new, she has always done this. Done above and beyond even taken on some supervisory stuff at every company she has worked at but seems stuck working for relatively small companies rather than national ones where there would be more scope to progress. There is a lot of opportunity jobs wise too. She cannot afford a holiday, even UK breaks, gave up her car a couple of years ago after it was written off just couldn't afford a new one and complains about having no money but never does anything about it. I don't know why.

Its obvious to me, she was a girl, and her brother was a boy. Very few households socialise boys the same as girls.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 18/07/2023 15:11

upugotep · 18/07/2023 10:05

@ReleasetheCrackHen she doesn’t have an accent though. As I said, in an interview she would likely get it over me but she just doesn’t think she’s capable. It is baffling to me!

But she has the background….that’s enough by itself.

mewkins · 18/07/2023 14:57

Thelnebriati · 18/07/2023 11:25

Disadvantages work to actively prevent people getting better positions. Even when you push yourself forwards, you still don't get picked as often as people from the other group.

This is a thing too. I hope it's getting better but I have been in interviews when younger and the interviewer sneered at the school I went to (yes it really happened!) and was surprised I'd got a degree etc. It was clear he didn't see me as fitting into the organisation. I think (hope) it happens less now and large organisations have focused on a more inclusive way of recruiting staff although I'm sure this kind of thing still happens. I'm really conscious of encouraging my children to do well and find out about all sorts of careers available to them. And to not sell themselves short as I have done in the past. The encouragement and positivity you grow up with as a kid really does impact you in your working life.

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/07/2023 14:56

See, the thing I always thought is that if you are from a poor background surely there is an even bigger incentive to be more career orientated and earn more money.

But it’s all relative, I remember feeling very well paid on £18k because I had grown up with nothing so that £18k felt like riches to me - I felt I had achieved. Many years (couple of decades) on I’m better educated and have used the opportunities open to me and am significantly better paid, but at that time I was very proud of what I had done. It would have been an easy thing to stay in that line of work and not seen my salary increase much over my career knowing I was still much better off than my parents were.

squeezedinthemiddlewithyou · 18/07/2023 14:56

LadyDanburysHat · 18/07/2023 11:05

I agree with the PP who mentioned that you need to know the jobs exist to aim for them.

I have a degree, not a great one, went into admin roles after uni. Followed by having my DC and working part time in admin type roles for a long time. At 40 I got yet another admin role, but full time, hoping I could get somewhere in earning more money. I really hoped one day I might earn £30k as an EA. That was it, I didn't see how I could possibly earn more than that. However, the admin role I had stumbled into was in a small pharma company and I got the opportunity to learn other skills. I changed to a more technical role, left for a new company on a 35% pay rise, and have had 2 promotions here. I now earn £45k which would have been mindblowing to me 5 years ago. I do expect to earn more now. It is easier to aim for it once you are up there.

I am like you.I have a degree and lots of experience in lots of different fields. (Have recently self diagnosed with adhd which explains a lot) but have never earned more than £33k pro rata when I did a term time only job for a bit
I am nearly 46 with twenty years experience and only took 9 month mat leave for each dc

FirstTimeNameChanger · 18/07/2023 14:53

Cross posted with @rosetintedmemories2023 really interesting post. I'm not from a rich background, but I had help with my house deposit and have always known that there is help available to me in a crisis. Maybe that impacts career choices as well, without a safety net I may well have had to become a hedge fund manager 🙈

FirstTimeNameChanger · 18/07/2023 14:51

Thehonestybox · 18/07/2023 14:32

I'm working class and we are definitely taught that blowing your own trumpet and is actively bad. Telling people about your achievements, even your superiors at work, is actively frowned upon.

I think Gen Z working class people will be different and have more confidence, but anyone older, I think it's been instilled in us far too deeply to think that high salaries are for already rich people and not for us

Some fields that people go into won't ever make them high earning though, and that's okay too. I'm not particularly shy about blowing my own trumpet and have more qualifications and degrees than most people. I'm really good at my very specialist job. I earn FTE £34K per year, but don't work full time. At some point I may move into a managerial role and earn £45 ish. I till probably top out there.

Its not all to do with class and confidence, some people choose to work in lower paying fields. They tend to be roles that are crucial to society (teaching, nursing, etc) but will never be big bucks. We shouldn't discourage that either

rosetintedmemories2023 · 18/07/2023 14:49

See, the thing I always thought is that if you are from a poor background surely there is an even bigger incentive to be more career orientated and earn more money. If you are from a wealthy family, you don't actually need to try as hard as you will need less money esp if your family pays for your university education, gives you a deposit or even gifts you a house. You can have a really great lifestyle on an ordinary wage.

I have rich parents so while I often tell myself to forget that, I know that I will probably get a big inheritance (though I don't want to rely on it). But I know. Dh on the other hand knows he can only rely on himself. And his regular call to his sister often involves the question 'do you need any money, can i send you some?' So a person from a poor background not only has to support himself or herself in a country where 50% of FTBs get help but also has to help out poorer family members. If you ask me, they probably need to earn 20% more than the middle class person just to bridge the gap.

DrCoconut · 18/07/2023 14:43

I see quite a few people coming into higher education in later life having left school at 16 and got a job in a factory, supermarket etc. It's cultural and usually they have some kind of revaluation of their life after a significant event (illness, birth of child, loss of parent who told them they couldn't do it etc). I've got one graduating this year with a good job already lined up and I'm really proud of him even though I'm only his lecturer.

gonetogreece · 18/07/2023 14:36

I think it's a lot to do with upbringing. I was literally dragged up my outlook on the world when I left school was to work In retail and try to get a council flat. That was what I'd been born into and just thought they were my options.
My son has been brought up in a completely different environment, not rich but comfortable due mainly to DH job. (Im still stuck in retail) He is 21 now and talks about his future in a way that didn't occur to me as possible, and at 21 having completed an apprenticeship now earns 45k a year.
Was your friend also brought up with low expectations?

Qbish · 18/07/2023 14:34

TimeForTeaAndG · 18/07/2023 10:05

If you're surrounded by folk telling you to know your place, don't blow your own trumpet etc it's really difficult to see why you should try and achieve anything. Folk commenting on those who try as having ideas above their station. It's all part of the ground in idea that working class people should be happy with what they've got.

Yes, I suspect a lot of it is down to parental attitudes. She has never been taught to aim higher.

Thehonestybox · 18/07/2023 14:32

I'm working class and we are definitely taught that blowing your own trumpet and is actively bad. Telling people about your achievements, even your superiors at work, is actively frowned upon.

I think Gen Z working class people will be different and have more confidence, but anyone older, I think it's been instilled in us far too deeply to think that high salaries are for already rich people and not for us

CrustyWingshield · 18/07/2023 14:32

Supernova23 · 18/07/2023 09:58

You sound like a Tory.

Don't insult the poor woman!

OP, it is clearly about class. My workplace is full of people in top positions who either present themselves as having had a paid education or have. There is definitely a class ceiling and I work in the public sector.

My parents worked in roles that did not require education beyond senior school. As much as I have tried to get beyond that by getting a degree (and doing very well and getting a 1st and an additional award) my own self belief has held me back. I can't talk in public and constantly question myself and my ability. This is because of class, it isn't something I can snap out of as it has been ingrained in me that I am somehow beneath people who have been more fortunate.

My mum asked me if I regretted not staying in education beyond undergraduate level, and in a way yes, I do regret it, but I could no longer afford to do a masters or the funded studentship I was told to apply for. I couldn't live on fuck all because I had no help from family or a partner that was doing well in his career.

Money and privilege have a lot to do with whether someone has self belief to do well in a career, or logistically can put in the extra hours or take a low paid traineeship to get into a high paid role. This is why we have shortages in some professional careers. Educational psychologists are in short supply, but the route in means years of study and low pay, which many can't afford.

Notanotherhousepost · 18/07/2023 14:28

I'm very much working class - just recently change jobs and now on 6 figures. Age 47.

Its not down to class, its about the drive and ambition of the person in the class

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 18/07/2023 14:25

There are so many factors in play but if we want to become a more productive and wealthy nation we need to tackle them. Off the top of my head I can think of people in my life affected by the following:

  • lack of knowledge of available careers
  • lack of careers advice after leaving full time education and especially for career changers
  • lack of funding for adult education
  • inadequate diagnosis or support for low level neuro diversity
  • Gendered expectations
  • Not knowing how to negotiate salary or understanding worth
  • changing employment/labour landscape and the difficulty of breaking away from traditional local industry
  • lack of education on basic business skills so people feel empowered to be self employed
  • no examples or mentors available
  • family expectations
  • family or local prejudices
  • Salary secrecy
TashieWoo · 18/07/2023 14:23

My in laws are terrible reverse snobs and also anti education, they don’t seem to want their DC and DGC to do better than them which I find baffling. DP is a bit that way too but I am convincing him otherwise. I’d be lying if I said it wasn’t a massive stumbling block in our relationship at the moment.

ssd · 18/07/2023 14:19

Its all about confidence and self belief. Its about knowing how people look at you or react to you in certain situations and adjusting your behaviour accordingly. Its about being expected to be looked down on. Or its about expecting to look down on others.

It is the invisible class system.
digitalsynopsis.com/inspiration/privileged-kids-on-a-plate-pencilsword-toby-morris/

electriclight · 18/07/2023 14:09

I guess it will be, like most other things, a combination of nature and nurture.

Some people are naturally cautious, risk-averse, worrying types who find their comfort zone and never move, or do so only when they're out of other options.

And then nurture serves to minimise or exacerbate this as many pp have said - family attitudes to ambition, awareness of and exposure to opportunities, self belief and so on.

DSis and I had the same upbringing and experiences. I am ambitious and she says she wants only to earn the bare minimum to live a comfortable life, prioritising home life and hobbies. I don't think either one of us is necessarily better. I'm richer in money but she's richer in time.

EmpressSoleil · 18/07/2023 14:07

I grew up rurally and there was a milk factory down the road. On the day I turned 16 my dad said "get yourself down the milk factory and get a job"! It was an area of the country with very low aspirations. We weren't encouraged to carry on at school or go to Uni. I was always told Uni was for "rich" people. And that was back in the days when it was free! But I didn't know that.

Long story short, I moved away and did get a decent career. Yet many of my relatives still live in that area and go from one minimum wage job to the next. Even if they wanted to, there just aren't the opportunities there to make decent money. Even with an education, the jobs aren't available and they are happy living where they are and wouldn't want to move.

giraffesinscarfes · 18/07/2023 13:56

Confidence is a huge barrier for lots of people. I used to work in care for a few years when I was younger (so MW, hard work) and one of my colleagues told me she wouldn't have the confidence to go for interviews because of her teeth (I'd genuinely never once noticed her teeth).

Another lady had worked there for 20 years and was absolutely brilliant at her job, we encouraged her to apply for a management position. She said she could never be a manager as she was too thick. Eventually our area manager gave her a bit of a pep talk, asked her to apply and she got the job. She never would have applied if she hadn't been encouraged to.

feenac · 18/07/2023 13:49

Professional jobs just weren't for people like me. I grew up around family friends who all had working class jobs and left school by 16. They paid the bills but nobody aspired to be a high earner because it wasn't the norm. I think there's an ingrained fear of going for something and failing so nobody ever tried. It's easier to pretend it's your choice. Growing up, anyone who aspired for more was mocked and accused of getting ideas above their station.

Thankfully I've been able to shake off the embarrassment and although I'm not a high earner, I earn 28k which is more than most of my family. My dad is a supermarket delivery driver, my mum is the manager of a betting shop (barely pays above nmw), my older sister works in a call centre and my younger sister works in a supermarket. They're the kind of jobs that would induce pearly clutching here but nobody gives it a second thought where I grew up. In the meantime, my office job with a bit of responsibility is called posh.

DandelionBurdockAndGin · 18/07/2023 13:33

gloov · 18/07/2023 09:48

"We had massively different backgrounds"

This might be slightly blinding you here to the likelihood of this second part "she would absolutely be a competitor to me in an interview and probably get the job over me"

I used to work mentoring brilliant people from poor or socially disadvantaged backgrounds and they all experienced, multiple times, being overlooked for roles they were the most qualified for, and overlooked in the job for promotions too. It happened too widely and too regularly for me to believe it was just bad luck, or just their own attitude.

Few years ago there was a lot in media about how women didn't put themselves forward for promotion and pay rises - DH female college had been acting up in a higher role went for it was told she needed more experience they then employed a man with less qualified and considerably less experience - employer were shocked when she left.

DH a lecturer had regular arguments with colleges who look down on their more first generation university students insisting DH expectation are too high - he points out he was once one them - first in entire extended family to get to university and they need to skills to get into their industry.

We had to fight against the kids schools low expectations - it is drip drip drip.

One of our kids is off on an extended access course but he only had confidence to apply because as parents we encouraged it to point sat down and helped him apply - about only one at the school who did so - it's why DH and I did well our parents believing and encouraging us even if our schools wrote us off or though our aspiration should be lower.