Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don’t think opportunity is out there and so they remain in a lower standard of living?

218 replies

upugotep · 18/07/2023 09:35

Sort of inspired by the post about what makes a high earner, it reminded me of a friend who has gone through her life literally never thinking she can earn more.

We had massively different backgrounds and it was expected of me that I should go into a professional job and progress etc. Around ten years into our friendship in our very early 30s, my friend was talking about her ‘wealthy’ family friends, whose dad at 50 had just been promoted and was now earning 52k. She followed this up with ‘I can’t even imagine it, I will never be on anything near 50k.’ At this point I was on 58k and hopeful that my pay would increase a lot in future.

I didn’t say anything other than she might be surprised if she put herself out there that more could be earned.

What I found odd about it is that she is highly intelligent, very employable, personable, just brilliant really. It’s purely her lack of belief in another sort of life and her expectations of herself that hold her back. I am slightly better educated than her but only because of my background and she would absolutely be a competitor to me in an interview and probably get the job over me. I actually think it’s a dirty secret that those ‘at the top’ like to make out they are something special and it’s unattainable when actually it’s not. Why on earth should my friend think 50k is unattainable when she was only 31?!

OP posts:
Swrigh1234 · 18/07/2023 20:19

Jigslaw · 18/07/2023 13:11

It is a shame to be fair that we live in a society that values making money over all else and people in jobs such as the arts which enhance a lot of people's lives get paid rubbish (unless very lucky and become successful which is a small percentage). Alas as that's the society we do live in have to chase the corporate hell to make decent money.

Last time we checked, you can’t eat art. Or use it as shelter or medicine. It’s the money makers that pay for the things we NEED.

KingsHeath53 · 18/07/2023 20:13

@bonfirebash you’re right, six figure salaries don’t grow on trees they are only open to a few very qualified and / or very lucky people

bonfirebash · 18/07/2023 18:48

Here's a job example near me, I would like to earn 30k and this is 31k

It's 40hrs a week, including weekends, anything between 8am - 10pm and they want all of this (which I know from seeing what managers do will be a nightmare Grin and I don't have the experience they want)

I see people on here earning 100k, I looked up a job that was paying that out of interest
For 100k they want

Tertiary qualified in a relevant discipline (social sciences, community development, civil engineering, project management).
• Minimum of 15-20 years' experience managing mutlimillion dollar social and/or infrastructure projects
Oh and for you to speak Swahili or another local language

To think some people don’t think opportunity is out there and so they remain in a lower standard of living?
Alibaba87 · 18/07/2023 18:44

Do you do the same jobs? Or same field?

Fairislefandango · 18/07/2023 18:42

Isn't it strange how easy it is to suggest that people with a different background from your own should be able to just shake off the deeply-ingrained views and attitudes created by their upbringing, while happily clinging to your own because they happen to be ones that serve you well?

bonfirebash · 18/07/2023 18:36

Hopelesscynic · 18/07/2023 10:17

I think you are presenting things here a lot more simplified than they are. It so much depends on your education and professional experience - has your friend studied the same subject (to the same level) as you that you think she is capable of doing the same job? What about her actual experience?
Let me give you an example of myself, I am educated to a Master level in the social science field. Like your friend, I am hard working, intelligent and likeable. Guess what, no matter how many opportunities I tried, including changing jobs and "putting myself out there", taking training etc... I am pretty much in the same boat, the maximum I've earned is 26K and I dont foresee this could change. Many of the jobs advertised in my field that are higher pay require extensive experience, which has been a chicken and egg situation as I can't get the experience unless I get hired... My education doesn't seem to have helped in the slightest (I appreciate this is not the same for other lines of work).
If I'm lucky, maybe at some point I'll get towards 30K but I don't ever imagine earning anywhere near 50K. Your post sounds patronizing, as if it's that easy to just look for opportunity and get a highly paid job.

Exactly that
I browse the job websites every so often and I don't have the specific qualifications they ask for let alone the experience
39 now and on min wage plus commission

Motherland2624 · 18/07/2023 18:33

My parents bought me up to believe I would never progress learn to drive and would just about be able to hold a job in a factory
they told everyone around me this it’s kind of hard to break out from that mindset

mathanxiety · 18/07/2023 18:30

WarmButteryCrumpets · 18/07/2023 10:10

I'm sorry but this is bonkers. It's being a Tory to acknowledge that people tend to stick to the same social demographic they grew up in and may not realise it's possible for "someone like them" to enter an entirely different wage bracket?

That tends to be a neo-Liberal narrative - that people hold themselves back, that institutional disadvantage isnt a thing and therefore governmemt efforts to level the playing field are not going to help.

ikno · 18/07/2023 18:29

Qbish · 18/07/2023 18:16

You seem to imply that anyone earning a lot can't do all those things too?

Exactly! It’s a stupid post as most people would need to earn a lot to be able to afford all that anyway. Not everyone can afford a demotion and the hit to their pay to facilitate caring for family for example, let alone doing that whilst simultaneously being a home/car over that can afford all bills, holidays, theatre, eating out etc

ikno · 18/07/2023 18:26

I agree. I earn £40k after a recent promotion within same company. I’m mid-20s. I do plan on getting further promotions, whether that’s in my company or outside of it, so expect my salary to continue to increase as I age. I’m just starting out!

However loads of people in my old role are happy to stay in that role until they retire, been on their £28k salary for 20+ years so think my payrise is shocking! there’s been lots of positive and negative comments about me, I’m a topic for gossip for them just because they didn’t have the same ambition when they were my age. There’s nothing stopping them from progressing in their career, they’re just not interested.

I think socioeconomic status plays into it. One of my parents was a specialist NHS consultant, the other was self employed business owner who brought in even more money. Equally their friends are well paid professionals and that is mirrored in my life. People I went to uni with are on 5 figure salaries now! So I’m not of the mindset that £28k will set me up for life - there isn’t a ceiling there.

Qbish · 18/07/2023 18:16

Baconisdelicious · 18/07/2023 17:43

If you are successful, earn a lot, then that should be congratulated, not sneered upon

Personally, I don’t measure my life success by my earnings alone. I enjoy what I do, I don’t particularly aspire to management, I’m good at my job, I make a difference in people’s lives, I am respected, well-thought of in my workplace, I have good friends, enjoy an active social life, have great kids who have grown into interesting and have opinions and their own aspirations. I own a modest home and car. I can pay my bills. I go to the theatre, eat out, have hobbies and take at least one holiday a year. I helped my old parents when they needed me, including down grading my role at the time to give me some space to care. In my opinion, people who consider themselves successful as a result of their higher than average salary and little else need to have a good look at that bigger life picture.

You seem to imply that anyone earning a lot can't do all those things too?

Sugarfree23 · 18/07/2023 18:15

I have working class background, tradesman dad, admin mum. I have a degree professional job and little confidence.

Even when I started work, I couldn't imagine the bosses ever starting out at the bottom. You know that thing that they just appeared as 50 yo men who never went to school or started their first job 🤣

I do think lots of working class people don't expect their kids to ever be in the top job or get promoted.

But there is also a thing in school, education isn't valued, the way it should be.

Starlightstarbright2 · 18/07/2023 18:13

Basic Sociology tells you the basics, education, class and housing all effects outcomes .

anecdotal examples of people who did well despite going up in poverty are the exception rather than the rule.

I grew up in a family with money but not class - I was a vet unhappy child and figured having a lot of money wasn’t going to make me happy - I have a child with additional needs so limited work options as I have needed to be able to take calls or collect Ds when necessary .

The current challenges to funding to university … many young people who might have gone to university won’t I believe this will leave to university only been available generally to the higher classes.

Baconisdelicious · 18/07/2023 17:43

If you are successful, earn a lot, then that should be congratulated, not sneered upon

Personally, I don’t measure my life success by my earnings alone. I enjoy what I do, I don’t particularly aspire to management, I’m good at my job, I make a difference in people’s lives, I am respected, well-thought of in my workplace, I have good friends, enjoy an active social life, have great kids who have grown into interesting and have opinions and their own aspirations. I own a modest home and car. I can pay my bills. I go to the theatre, eat out, have hobbies and take at least one holiday a year. I helped my old parents when they needed me, including down grading my role at the time to give me some space to care. In my opinion, people who consider themselves successful as a result of their higher than average salary and little else need to have a good look at that bigger life picture.

Gpnever · 18/07/2023 17:42

This usually has lots to do with what kind of family / upbringing you’re from and whether you have any confidence in your own decisions

as you go up the work chain and are given more responsibility, it’s my experience that you have to be confident defending decisions and managing conflicts (in most jobs) this is where I’ve seen people really struggle (including myself). The people I’ve seen generally excel in these areas tend to be confident people who don’t outwardly show that this is difficult for them (although I don’t know how they feel inside) and often are people who have benefited from good self esteem, personal investment from others and good support. It’s almost unthinkable for some people to believe they could handle a really high paid job because they lack these attributes.

I’ve worked for about 7 years with a group of women with varying skills, but all uni educated , professional and initially all of us were on about 50k ish. The women who are now further up the salary scale aren’t necessarily the most intelligent / skilled of the group, but the most confident / least risk averse, most likely to give / stand by ideas. In fact the most hardworking person has probably experienced the least progression.

currahee · 18/07/2023 17:42

@GarlicGrace You've reminded me of my relative's interview experience, where they managed to paper over the cracks in their working-class-done-good history and keep the rapport going with the frightfully frightfully gentleman interviewing... right up until the point at which they were asked what school they went to. Being in their forties at the time and having gone to the local comp it took them a second to even parse the question, which was answer enough in itself really.

ThinkingAgainAndAgain · 18/07/2023 17:36

My parents were extremely unhappy about me getting into a level of debt at all as a young person. They’re financially very risk averse indeed, any savings they had were in cash (no shares or bonds), and whilst they funded my university degrees in the 1990s, they gave a minimum allowance (which I was grateful for, of course) and I worked part time throughout, but it was a very different experience than many of my peers, who had student loans as a minimum. No travelling, far fewer culturally enhancing experiences etc. But i think this view about money and risk made them have a ceiling on their income. They could at one stage have definitely afforded to buy an investment property, with a low mortgage, but that would have been too risky for them to contemplate. They’d have made a large amount (in hindsight!). They could have taken advance of the local government employer pension, but they saved the money they should have contributed instead despite working for the local authority for decades between them. They could have invested in any number of things, but wanted to keep their money in cash accounts.

More risk balanced people would have elevated themselves far more.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/07/2023 17:29

This thread reminds me of a woman I saw on TV pre Brexit referendum who said that she would see it as a bonus if opportunities were more limited overseas as her kids had expressed that they might want to move abroad and she literally wanted them to remain on the doorstep.

I grew up in a midlands mining town and at one point had a very interesting job but it was 12,miles away and caught the bus every day (40 minutes) local people there couldn't understand why on Earth I would do that.

I can honestly say that few people wanted to put themselves out , be it move for better prospects, more life, better qualifications and family often were not supportive of those who 'got on' . On the plus side it did have a better sense of community and people knowing each other years and relatives on hand to help with families.

Lifechangesalot · 18/07/2023 17:25

Kalodin · 18/07/2023 15:39

Thank you @Lifechangesalot I do all the training that becomes available, is suitable and would benefit me. I had recently asked my Director to be exposed more to Engineering as that's where I want to be, that's where the money is here. But I was shot down. Told I'm needed too much in my current role. Currently negotiating a payrise on that basis. But I think I'll end up moving.

Good idea to make me THE person for a particular subject, there are two areas I have a lot of expertise on for my field and am the go-to in my company for that. However, typically everyone outside the company would use a Consultant in those fields as they'd be suitably qualified. Perhaps I need to obtain a couple more degrees to have that dual aspect.

Good luck! Don't be afraid to jump ship to somewhere where career development is valued and they invest in their staff.

TinyTeacher · 18/07/2023 17:22

I absolutely could earn more. I have excellent qualifications from school/university. Many of my university friends earn hugely more than me. The education sector would be totally buggered if all well-qualified people rejected teaching as a career because of the pay. I imagine the health and social care sectors would be equally stuffed.

Getting the most possible money has never been my sole motivator. I have always done voluntary work and tried to support my community. It's not that I "lack confidence" to apply for better paid roles. I just don't want to do a job that I don't feel gives back to society.

AlligatorPsychopath · 18/07/2023 17:18

JazbayGrapes · 18/07/2023 16:04

Higher income comes at a cost. It maybe more money, but also higher responsibily and more stress. Many people are happier with a modest income, but enjoyable work, sociable hours, etc.

Again, this really just isn't true. A lot of fairly low-paid jobs are very stressful. A lot of higher-paid jobs are really not that stressful. The relationship between pay and stress is really fairly weak. Value and scarcity of skills is much more important.

I earn £80k and undoubtedly have a lot less stress than many people on £25k.

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/07/2023 17:13

The thing is if everybody aimed for the high salaries and pushed themselves to earn more, the country would be a different place.
Need to work? no childcare
Kids need to learn? no teachers

Or if more people carried their weight there might be more money in the public purse (through tax and NI) to pay necessary occupations a decent salary. We don’t have an infinite public resource, too many people being topped up by the state when they could reasonably be working. And yes I know corruption, lack of childcare etc but if we want people in essential jobs to be well paid, we need people who generate wealth into the public coffers to pay for it.

The answer isn’t to argue someone needs to do low paid jobs as much as it is how do we generate enough wealth that those jobs don’t need to be low paid.

GarlicGrace · 18/07/2023 17:10

Goldenspearmint · 18/07/2023 17:07

Perhaps some of us have now learned that a job we enjoy will never pay mega bucks. So were in a poor paid industry because its a job we enjoy and we accept it will never pay well.

Which is shit because a lot of very Important jobs get pathetic pay.

That's true as well.

Where socially necessary jobs are concerned, I wish there were a sensible way to improve pay & conditions. The pandemic really showed us who we depend on, and it's despicable that our collective appreciation doesn't extend beyond a pat on the back and a gift voucher.

Goldenspearmint · 18/07/2023 17:07

Perhaps some of us have now learned that a job we enjoy will never pay mega bucks. So were in a poor paid industry because its a job we enjoy and we accept it will never pay well.

Which is shit because a lot of very Important jobs get pathetic pay.

GarlicGrace · 18/07/2023 17:04

Class is a real thing. It's almost taboo to mention it, particularly among the higher middle classes; this perpetuates the problem because it's unseen.

Donkeys years ago, I was headhunted for a fabulous job at an incredibly prestigious brand. I knew I had all the right experience, contacts and enthusiasms. I'd been put forward by more than one important client.

By my fifth minute in reception, I knew I wasn't going to be seen as a match. Everyone working there was way posher than me. Chemistry in the interview was good, but there were also strange holes where assumed shared experiences failed to materialise.

I've just visited that company's current staff register. It's still posh. Somewhat less white but still solidly upper middle class or higher.

I'm from a working-class background, and went to a selective grammar school. That school was the making of me, not only by education but also that oft-derided aim of grammar schools: to endow social mobility. Being very good at my job and reasonably pushy, I did have a great career.

Certain avenues remained closed, however. Grammar school can't give you a family that quotes Greek philosophers in ordinary conversation, has a little place in the Alps and a couple of successful artists at weddings & christenings. School can't fund your year or two volunteering in distant lands, get you a place in the Tall Ships or invite you on country house weekends. The families that do provide such environments tend to favour others like them.

I'm in favour of the growing campaign to make socio-economic class a protected characteristic. I'm also, unsurprisingly, in favour of grammar-school values at least to GCSE level.

Swipe left for the next trending thread