Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don’t think opportunity is out there and so they remain in a lower standard of living?

218 replies

upugotep · 18/07/2023 09:35

Sort of inspired by the post about what makes a high earner, it reminded me of a friend who has gone through her life literally never thinking she can earn more.

We had massively different backgrounds and it was expected of me that I should go into a professional job and progress etc. Around ten years into our friendship in our very early 30s, my friend was talking about her ‘wealthy’ family friends, whose dad at 50 had just been promoted and was now earning 52k. She followed this up with ‘I can’t even imagine it, I will never be on anything near 50k.’ At this point I was on 58k and hopeful that my pay would increase a lot in future.

I didn’t say anything other than she might be surprised if she put herself out there that more could be earned.

What I found odd about it is that she is highly intelligent, very employable, personable, just brilliant really. It’s purely her lack of belief in another sort of life and her expectations of herself that hold her back. I am slightly better educated than her but only because of my background and she would absolutely be a competitor to me in an interview and probably get the job over me. I actually think it’s a dirty secret that those ‘at the top’ like to make out they are something special and it’s unattainable when actually it’s not. Why on earth should my friend think 50k is unattainable when she was only 31?!

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 19/07/2023 07:55

@Baconisdelicious

I do not believe that earning well is something to be congratulated on. It's not a measure of a person's value to friends, family or wider society. You're not ' better' than someone who earns less than you or who doesn't feel the need to climb the greasy career pole. Money is important in life, but lots of it doesn't automatically mean everything else will fall into place.

It doesn't, but not having it pretty much guarantees everything in your life will be much harder.

Of course money isn't a measure of anyone's worth. But dismissing its importance is naive. The ability to be financially self-sufficient and provide for yourself is very central to your ability to have agency over your own life.

I understand why people don't want their children to become overly focused on money and I think it needs to be instilled that certain types of jobs don't make anyone better than others, but I think signalling that money doesn't matter is also quite a dangerous message: particularly to female children.

I see quite a lot of people on here talking about "climbing the greasy career pole" as though it was something negative and slightly dubious which people only do for selfish reasons. In fact for women and girls the ability to maximise their own income is what stands between them and dependence on a man or the state. So it worries me a bit that there are so many threads on here which present work and careers in such essentially negative terms.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/07/2023 07:46

@LaMaG

I was the same in reverse @Coffeetree, groomed from a very young age to be a university graduate. I don't think anyone stopped to consider my preferences. I was always good with my hands and at about 15 I knew I was good with hair and said maybe I could be a hairdresser. There was a silence then everyone burst out laughing. It became a joke, if we saw someone with bad hair on TV or whatever they would be like maybe LaMaG will sort her / him out ha ha. Even heard my mum telling her family the hilarious anecdote. Yes i had opportunity but we are all trapped in our family expectation, esp when decisions about career are made while under their care.

This is interesting as my family was exactly like this. We were pushed really hard into white collar/professional work as children. It never occurred to anyone that we would do anything else.

This turned out to be OK for me as it played to my natural strengths but my DSis, having shoehorned herself into a white collar profession she clearly hated for years, is now retraining as a carpenter in her mid 40s and feels she's clearly found herself.

My parents were very preoccupied with the way they were perceived socially and they would have considered blue collar work as a sign of failure.

Those sorts of professional/social prejudices can work the other way around too. On balance I'd rather be pushed hard into a high-achieving, high earning profession than be told I can't ever achieve anything but there are downsides to this approach too.

BlibBlobBloo · 19/07/2023 07:14

ReleasetheCrackHen · 18/07/2023 09:59

That’s how the class system works in Britain. It teaches working class children their place in society from an early age. And their accents and background always flag up their roots- so she may be qualified to be a contender in an interview but she is also right that she is highly unlikely to get the job too.

The failing isn’t on her, it’s on the class system.

Bollocks. I came from a working class family my parents instilled a work ethic in me from a young age, they wanted me to live a better life than the one they had.

Baconisdelicious · 19/07/2023 07:08

Qbish · 18/07/2023 18:16

You seem to imply that anyone earning a lot can't do all those things too?

Not at all. But I do not believe that earning well is something to be congratulated on. It's not a measure of a person's value to friends, family or wider society. You're not ' better' than someone who earns less than you or who doesn't feel the need to climb the greasy career pole. Money is important in life, but lots of it doesn't automatically mean everything else will fall into place.

FrivolousTreeDuck · 19/07/2023 07:07

bonfirebash · 18/07/2023 18:48

Here's a job example near me, I would like to earn 30k and this is 31k

It's 40hrs a week, including weekends, anything between 8am - 10pm and they want all of this (which I know from seeing what managers do will be a nightmare Grin and I don't have the experience they want)

I see people on here earning 100k, I looked up a job that was paying that out of interest
For 100k they want

Tertiary qualified in a relevant discipline (social sciences, community development, civil engineering, project management).
• Minimum of 15-20 years' experience managing mutlimillion dollar social and/or infrastructure projects
Oh and for you to speak Swahili or another local language

£31k is below average for a call centre manager (which that obviously is) in my experience. It's an underpaid role generally.

RhubarbFairy · 19/07/2023 06:58

AwkwardPaws27 · 18/07/2023 10:34

^ also this.

I wanted to be a vet, I was predicted As/A*s at GCSE but our careers advisor said "oh its very hard to be a vet. How about veterinary nursing".
In hindsight I'd love veterinary nursing, but the salaries were far lower than for a veterinary surgeon, & there was no encouragement to consider the impact of earnings, just "this route is too hard".

Couldn't agree more with this. Plus, the background factor is huge.

I was told by a careers advisor at 14 (that met me that one time for 15 minutes) that I wasn't clever enough to go to university to train to be a teacher. She suggested that I go into nursery nursing instead.

I come from a background where only my uncle has a degree across my whole wider family. So there was no one at home to tell me that that careers advisor was talking rubbish and that I could do so much more.

I did go into nursery nursing, which I enjoyed, but it was never what I wanted to do. It's notoriously low paid, so I nannied for a long time instead. Better wages, but not many options for progression long term, unless you give up all other elements of your life.

I met DH at 18, and he was my biggest cheerleader from that point. He would send me brochures for different unis so that I could go for it, but what had been said to me, and my background were ingrained, and it took me many years to listen.

I'm 40 now. Yesterday, I got my degree results, a 2:1 in Education Studies. I work as a TA, regularly cover my class teacher, and I start my QTS training through work in the new year.

It's only by being around DH that I began to believe that I am worth more.

He comes from a similar background to me. But he never received that dreadful advice, so he never doubted himself. He went to uni and is a high earner. Careers' advisors should not be allowed to discourage anyone from following their dreams.

MRex · 19/07/2023 06:51

At 10 years of experience and on £58k, I doubt very much that your friend who doesn't have those work experiences and is at a low level would compete with you at interview. Perhaps you have a streak of inadequacy yourself if you can't see that you have gained certain skills and knowledge over 10 years plus however many more have passed. Confidence can be an important skill within jobs too; sales pitching, presentations, training, strategy, analysis and any manager level needing to review budget all require a level of confidence to be done successfully.

There are certainly some structural issues. I've argued with only some success to hire non-graduates for roles that really don't need that high an education level, yet still offer the same type of career paths as graduate schemes. A useful career shortcut is that when companies grow quickly, the growth itself pushes people upwards because of natural demand that those who have been there longer fill responsibility gaps. Again there is a confidence issue though; people have to be willing to take risks and believe in themselves enough that they'll pick something else up if it fails.

Timing of starting work and early luck also matter more than it logically should, because getting into the first "real" job quickly is what creates confidence that it's possible to move between jobs. Some age groups take more career risk than others; those joining the workforce 90s-07 are good, but even so many years later the caution of those who joined the workforce 08-12 is noticeable. I pity graduates of the last couple of years with covid then this year having degrees withheld, and sadly think it will knock confidence for many of them.

AwkwardPaws27 · 19/07/2023 06:38

ChocChipHandbag · 19/07/2023 00:02

What did you become in the end?

@ChocChipHandbag I fell out with my mum & was kicked out at 16, & didn't finish A Levels.
I worked various admin jobs (including veterinary receptionist/reception manager), did an access course and then went to uni in the evenings around full-time work.
Now training as an accountant - the degree was unrelated but enabled me to get onto a grad scheme.

daisychain01 · 19/07/2023 06:26

You come across as "if only you worked harder, you'd get further" like "you know you can fly, jump out of the window, you just need to flap your arms a bit harder, you know you can do it". Yeah right, as if life was that simple.

maybe your friend is happy as they are. Just get on and live your best life and let your friend do the same.

Don't whatever you do, give your friend unrequested advice on their life chances or you could soon be minus a friend!

ChiPawPrint · 19/07/2023 06:19

Some people just truly aren't bothered about striving for more money and a career and are content with what they have. I personally couldn't be bothered with the stress and time involved to have a big career.

Kalodin · 19/07/2023 06:13

I absolutely love the legal side of stuff @Delphigirl But never knew that was a job! Thank you. I currently very much enjoy pouring over Case Law in planning. Always wondered if I'd end up becoming an Inspector

Kalodin · 19/07/2023 06:09

Thank you @GarlicGrace . I'm aware of the project manager roles, I applied for a couple but was told i needed Engineering or Site Manager experience and currently arent getting exposed to that at work enough. I am intending on purpusing the Engineering route more, just need to strategise how. The MD role is my aspiration and something i could get to in my workplace now, but I would definitely need to take on a dual role. Urban Planners don't typically end up in MD positions, it seems anyone from any other department can end up there but there's never been a Planner... mind you, maybe I could be the first!

Coffeetree · 19/07/2023 05:11

LaMaG · 18/07/2023 21:34

I was the same in reverse @Coffeetree , groomed from a very young age to be a university graduate. I don't think anyone stopped to consider my preferences. I was always good with my hands and at about 15 I knew I was good with hair and said maybe I could be a hairdresser. There was a silence then everyone burst out laughing. It became a joke, if we saw someone with bad hair on TV or whatever they would be like maybe LaMaG will sort her / him out ha ha. Even heard my mum telling her family the hilarious anecdote. Yes i had opportunity but we are all trapped in our family expectation, esp when decisions about career are made while under their care.

Oh isn't that interesting. I never thought of the reverse scenario.

coxesorangepippin · 19/07/2023 03:01

See, I read this and still don’t have a clue what you are talking about. No offence. It’s just not my world.

^

Ok....so stay where you are. Or maybe Google the words you don't understand??? Get an idea??

coxesorangepippin · 19/07/2023 02:56

When I got to uni people were taking Economics.

I had no idea what Economics was!

That's how different backgrounds can be

Hellokittymania · 19/07/2023 02:20

I have a couple of thoughts on this one, I am visually impaired, just bought my first home in Greece, set up an organization when I was 23 years old, and moved to Vietnam, or I lived for several years, and have done my best to do as well as I can, even though I have had to create a lot of opportunities for myself.

it has not been an easy road. I am quite resourceful, and always have an eye out for things that are free, free classes, if I can speak to someone, for example, a tradesmen, for a couple of minutes and just learn how to do some DIY from my home, I will. but many people don’t expect anything out of people with disabilities, if I were to sit at home, all my life, nobody would bought an eyelash.

I know quite a few people with a visual impairment, some of whom can see much more than I can, and have university degrees, and have had more experience than I have, I am almost totally blind from birth, but many of them just get jealous of me or they say I should be grateful for what I have. They don’t take into account how much I have struggled throughout my life. I have had to rent privately, live with mice, I was evicted a few months before I bought my home, after being taken advantage of by the landlord, who just was using me because I was visually impaired, and it made her look like a better person than she was. So why shouldn’t I buy my own home? Yes, it has been a challenge, but I’m learning every day and I enjoy living here.

not only this, but when people with a disability want chains, and change happens, because somebody works very hard to make it happen, they complain and get jealous of the person who makes the change. I have always tried to break glass ceilings, and I don’t think I will ever be able to stop. but I do pay a price, and I much rather have the few good friends that I know I can trust, for this reason.

interestingly, enough, in Greece, I have met some real estate agents who have assisted rather high-end clients, and getting mortgages and getting their properties, and she is always asking me what I am going to do with mine, and Innoway, it’s a challenge for me because somebody actually has high expectations for what I could do with my home.

GarlicGrace · 19/07/2023 02:20

@Kalodin, according to this you can progress to Project Director and Construction Director (up to £100k).

I'm quite surprised by the salary rages for urban planners & civil engineers - as incredibly responsible roles with lasting impact, I'd have thought they paid more!

If you're more into the planning than the construction aspect of your job - it looks like you have wizard project management & logistics skills. Both those areas have tons of scope. (I enjoyed logistics, and nearly moved sideways that way myself. Big earning potential.)

Construction Planner Job Description, Salary & Skills

Fill a vital role during the construction process by creating a plan that leads to project completion. View a full construction planner job description here.

https://www.goconstruct.org/construction-careers/what-jobs-are-right-for-me/planner/#progression-opportunities-section

Delphigirl · 19/07/2023 02:06

Kalodin · 18/07/2023 15:23

If anyone here can give me some solid career advice on what I cam switch to, to attain a salary of £75k+ I'd be grateful!

As a PP said on 1st page "you don't know it unless you see it" and I think that's particularly true.

I'm happy in my career (as a Planner in Construction) but I'm aware that I'm coming close to the top of my pay now for my career (having spoken to my friends in the same sector) unless I make a jump to a Consultant for a massive firm and become CEO.

What careers are out there that are high earning? I honestly haven't a clue on what it would be and how to get into it.

I suppose the other issue for a lot of people is that risk of starting again! I'd be worried about having to take a potential pay decrease to start my career again, especially as I'm the higher earner in the household.

Do a masters in construction law at kings college London and become an expert witness in construction-related disputes?

Symphony830 · 19/07/2023 01:43

In my home we were actively encouraged to go out there and do things - a very positive and can-do environment. No one laughed when we had big dreams - they wanted to hear them.

Then in school we are told we are the brightest and have good futures ahead of us. This constant praise leads to good self esteem and a strong belief in your capabilities. This puts you on a very good course for life.

It took me a long time to realise that not everyone has this experience and that I am fortunate to have had this shape me.

As a parent I know the most important thing that I can help my child with is to develop and instil in them a good sense of self-esteem. I value it above everything.

I agree with the posters that say it is the UK class system in operation. This is exactly where it comes from! The working class are kept down not only by those above but also by their own contemporaries who mock them for having ideas above their station. Sigh

ikno · 19/07/2023 01:23

I think careers advice should include a bit on what the prospective earnings would be. Not just what jobs you are suited too.

They already do. I went to school less than 10 years ago and then studied a levels at a college. Both school and college gave prospective earnings on degree courses. No one thought studying drama or travel and tourism would get you the same salary as law or medicine. There’s the benefit of the internet now as well, so many websites such as the government’s or the national careers service will indicate prospective earnings

WimbledonHasselhoff · 19/07/2023 01:14

Lifechangesalot · 18/07/2023 23:57

Also surely this means you have to put loads of effort into feigning interest into random this you don't care about, if you're just going for the money. How do you keep that up?

Not in the slightest. If you're good at what you enjoy doing and what comes naturally you can find the career that works for you. If you're a money chaser you can head in that direction, if you're after a job well done you can go in that direction if you just want a job to keep you busy you can go in that direction.

Social work degrees open a lot of doors in a lot of sectors. Why did you do a social work degree? Think like a 6 year old "when I grow up I want to be a...." Brain storm how to get there/turn it into a reality.

I don't have a social work degree, I have a psychology degree. I studied it as an adult because I was interested, but I don't have what it takes to be an academic/research which is what I'd do with it if I was just pursuing interest!

I don't think the things I enjoy doing are things you can make money from. I have some skills/interests that could be the basis for a job but only ultra competitive, low wage type stuff.

I honestly don't know what I want to do. That's part of what I mean about jobs you don't see in daily life - I don't know what jobs exist! I will give it more thought though, as I have been feeling recently that an actual career and job that engages my brain would be really good.

Sugarfree23 · 19/07/2023 00:51

I think careers advice should include a bit on what the prospective earnings would be. Not just what jobs you are suited too.

But I do remember hearing a radio program along time ago about the influences refugee children had on local inner city kids. The refugee kids saw education as their way out of poverty. The local kids were down beat, they'd lost hope, had mindset of their was no jobs, they'd end up in a NMW job with top up benefits. Like the rest of their families.

In Scotland Nicola Sturgeon has bumped her gums about closing the attainment gap but really she's pulled the top kids down not pushed bottom kids up.

But a huge chunk of it has to come from kids by give them the belief that yes they can go to Uni and become a lawyer earn decent money, not just stack shelves.

ChocChipHandbag · 19/07/2023 00:02

AwkwardPaws27 · 18/07/2023 10:34

^ also this.

I wanted to be a vet, I was predicted As/A*s at GCSE but our careers advisor said "oh its very hard to be a vet. How about veterinary nursing".
In hindsight I'd love veterinary nursing, but the salaries were far lower than for a veterinary surgeon, & there was no encouragement to consider the impact of earnings, just "this route is too hard".

What did you become in the end?

Lifechangesalot · 18/07/2023 23:57

Also surely this means you have to put loads of effort into feigning interest into random this you don't care about, if you're just going for the money. How do you keep that up?

Not in the slightest. If you're good at what you enjoy doing and what comes naturally you can find the career that works for you. If you're a money chaser you can head in that direction, if you're after a job well done you can go in that direction if you just want a job to keep you busy you can go in that direction.

Social work degrees open a lot of doors in a lot of sectors. Why did you do a social work degree? Think like a 6 year old "when I grow up I want to be a...." Brain storm how to get there/turn it into a reality.

GarlicGrace · 18/07/2023 23:28

Fairislefandango · 18/07/2023 18:42

Isn't it strange how easy it is to suggest that people with a different background from your own should be able to just shake off the deeply-ingrained views and attitudes created by their upbringing, while happily clinging to your own because they happen to be ones that serve you well?

Yes, indeed.

I really appreciate that OP is "checking her privilege" but there's a heck of a lot of replies from posters implying that people who aren't like them should be like them Confused Well said!