Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you ever had a thread removed when you weren’t actually a troll?

145 replies

Yoghurtpit · 18/07/2023 07:40

I always wonder this. Sometimes I comment on a thread then it’s gone as it’s ‘not genuine’ etc. But I wonder if sometimes the facts are changed a little to protect confidentiality and really the essence of the story is true? This happened to me many years ago now and I still remember feeling like I was at my lowest then that happened! Everything I had put was actually accurate but the situation must have seemed so awful it was unbelievable to some posters.

OP posts:
FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/07/2023 11:06

BlueThursday · 18/07/2023 11:03

Not a deletion but being called a troll and a liar once for saying I shave my legs above the knee

i was both 🤔and😂

still not over it

I have honestly never ever shaved my legs ... I'm quite blonde, and I've actually never needed to ... But is that unusual to shave your legs above the knee(s) then?

tidalway · 18/07/2023 11:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BlueThursday · 18/07/2023 11:03

Not a deletion but being called a troll and a liar once for saying I shave my legs above the knee

i was both 🤔and😂

still not over it

Blondey2023 · 18/07/2023 10:53

Yes about vaping weirdly! Wanted advice on how to quit and the very innocent thread got deleted for being a suspected troll. Go figure!

LaughterTitsoff · 18/07/2023 10:50

MNHQ will always make mistakes but I think that's something we have to accept, in return for being able to post on a forum that allows name changing.

Name changing or having more than one account isn't allowed on most other forums, and that cuts down on the amount of lies and bullshit, because their own posting history would literally out them.

HelterSkelter123 · 18/07/2023 10:35

AbacusAvocado · 18/07/2023 08:41

I had one deleted - asked for advice as my young child had said odd things that might have indicated abuse.

Was told by MNHQ that they were deleting it because those threads attract unsavoury types to the site.

But it was a genuine concern and I needed advice - ended up talking to a children’s protection charity who talked me through how to question my son without leading him, got more info and thank god all was fine.

He was using some of his words incorrectly and sort of half describing a cartoon and half a situation that reminded him of the cartoon, so it sounded very dodgy but was actually innocent.

Always felt that one should have been allowed to stand even if they wanted to edit out specifics of what was said.

That's very similar to some of the 'satanic panic' scandals in the 90s where some of the very strange things some children were saying during an investigation into organised/ritual CSA turned out to be related to a character in teenage mutant hero turtles.

Sorry, off-topic for the thread!

Warrensrabbit · 18/07/2023 10:24

yes I have. I regularly change my username, but changed my email address to because I was talking about something financial and didn’t want it tied back to anything I’d previously written. I was deleted as a troll.
Im in the process of leaving a really nasty relationship and it was incredibly upsetting for Mumsnet to essentially invalidate something that I was going through

longtompot · 18/07/2023 10:21

I haven't, but I do remember one when I was first starting to come on here. The op was in very premature labour and was asking for help and she was accused of being a troll and had her post pulled. It turned out she was in fact a real person and this was happening to her, and she was even later on One Born Every Minute! Poor thing was so scared and needed help.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/07/2023 10:20

WarmSausageTea · 18/07/2023 10:10

I think this is unfair. People might need support or an outside view for whatever reason - sometimes you can’t see the wood for the trees.

Also, where does that poster say her first thought was to post about it here? That’s pure projection, and quite likely not the case at all.

LOL, how is @x2boys 'projecting?' What a weird comment. 😆 She SO is not.

Also, it IS every shade of weird to run straight onto mumsnet to post about your partner's disgusting and vile personal habits/personal hygiene. Who DOES that? Why would ANYone want to tell ANYone about that?! Weird. And as I said, makes me wonder about the motives behind it.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/07/2023 10:16

x2boys · 18/07/2023 08:18

Why would you post about it on here though?
I often wonder that when people start a,thread talking about something grim their partner has done in relation to.personsl.care
I wonder why their first thought is too post it on a public forum🤔

Yeah, these are the ones I think are grim and should be deleted. I don't want to hear about your husband leaving shit stains on the bed ta, it's foul and grim, and does make me wonder about the mindset of these people posting this kind of thread. Are they trying to make others share their similar stories. Makes me wonder who's behind the threads, and I would never post on them.

Also, I could post a few things from my life that have happened/that I have experienced, and some people would probably call 'troll.' As they would just not believe them. As a pp said, some people can't see past their own life, and just because someone has not experienced something, that doesn't mean it has never happened to someone else.

WarmSausageTea · 18/07/2023 10:10

x2boys · 18/07/2023 08:18

Why would you post about it on here though?
I often wonder that when people start a,thread talking about something grim their partner has done in relation to.personsl.care
I wonder why their first thought is too post it on a public forum🤔

I think this is unfair. People might need support or an outside view for whatever reason - sometimes you can’t see the wood for the trees.

Also, where does that poster say her first thought was to post about it here? That’s pure projection, and quite likely not the case at all.

ShakeYourFeathers · 18/07/2023 09:49

Yeah my first post . Broke guidelines and I needed to ask permission first or something

britneyisfree · 18/07/2023 09:48

Yeah. Two I think. One where I said I love MN and you're all hero's. Woke up and it was gone.

Another where I was like where has Bluntness100 gone!!!! She's still not back lol

Mygrandadwasmywingman · 18/07/2023 09:44

Yes,I once posted about my sd who'd moved in with us and I needed help about her shitty and entitled attitude

I posted,got a few responses (which where bloody helpful) and fell asleep

Woke up to my thread had been deleted and I was blocked from my account

No communication from mumsnet to say why-i was just blocked and deleted

Still pissed off about it as I was being 100% genuine-I would never start a thread again

ALLiDOisWIN · 18/07/2023 09:35

Happened to me years ago when I posted under a different username. I described an actual situation that has happened to me asking for an advice. I was called a troll, a liar and many other things. Thread got deleted although every single thing I wrote was true and all I wanted was an impartial opinion from people.

namechange1986 · 18/07/2023 09:28

My thread wasn't removed, but people were accusing me of being a troll. It was about my ex H and his behaviour.

The fact people assumed I was making it up definitely convinced me how bad he was...

Minfilia · 18/07/2023 09:20

Lastlegsbuckledunder · 18/07/2023 09:18

I suspect this. That ithere are a sub-group of Mnetters who proudly look for trolls and spend their days gleefully reporting them. From posts on here they proudly list their ‘signs’ a post is a troll. Their ‘signs’ include totally normal stuff normal posters do. Like giving details of what happened..🙄

This.

One of the signs apparently being that a poster has twins. I have twins but can’t post about them because it makes me a troll Hmm

Lastlegsbuckledunder · 18/07/2023 09:18

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 09:03

I think that thread got reinstated and the OP was relieved to have the support back.

You always seem to get loads of troll hunters who decide that they think something’s fake and start making sneery comments – I wonder if those people send multiple reports, which ends up seeing genuine threads removed.

I suspect this. That ithere are a sub-group of Mnetters who proudly look for trolls and spend their days gleefully reporting them. From posts on here they proudly list their ‘signs’ a post is a troll. Their ‘signs’ include totally normal stuff normal posters do. Like giving details of what happened..🙄

PrudenceDictates · 18/07/2023 09:17

The troll hunters get on my wick. They gleefully post that they think a post is fake, or make hilarious jokes about bridges and hairy hands 🙄. Or the one word gotcha that is "Reported!"
But troll hunting is just as much against the rules as trolling, so they're no better! Just report quietly FGS.

I haven't had a thread pulled, but have had a couple of posts deleted. One I've no idea why, the other was a personal attack. There was a misogynist wind up merchant posting, just to rile people up. Called him a cunt 🤷‍♀️

Yoghurtpit · 18/07/2023 09:10

bruffin · 18/07/2023 08:42

No necessarily because they give a skewed view of the world and i suspect most responders are there for the juicy updates rather than to give advice

@bruffin yes but coming to an Internet forum for advice must surely be with the knowledge that it’s not the same or as genuine at all as seeking professional support? You have no idea who the posters are really. So whilst I think MN is a HUGE source of support for many, it cannot be the only place people turn when in crisis. It’s best for mundane questions or tricky relationship scenarios but not things like sexual abuse etc where obviously you need a safe and genuine place for support. Even with relationship advice I think you have to take it with a pinch of salt and it’s usually a venting exercise than anything else (which is fine of course).

OP posts:
LaMaG · 18/07/2023 09:06

I was following one with interest recently, it was a really worrying one about a distraught mum whose teenage son was making awful sexual remarks at his sister, she sounded genuine and it was such a worrying situation I thought it was very unfair to pull it.

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 09:03

Tiredmummaoftwo · 18/07/2023 08:23

I've been wanting to ask about this! I'm fairly new to MN - someone was posting about their DH cheating the other day with a full blow by blow account and the thread got deleted.. why would they do that? It sounded so genuine and like this person was really going through it. Loads of people had taken ages to comment and it was removed?

So many threads get removed I don't understand it? Are the OP is literally making up the thread and it's all BS?

I think that thread got reinstated and the OP was relieved to have the support back.

You always seem to get loads of troll hunters who decide that they think something’s fake and start making sneery comments – I wonder if those people send multiple reports, which ends up seeing genuine threads removed.

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 08:58

Yes this happened to me. I posted a genuine thread and had been finding it a massive support.

MN didn’t so much as contact me, they just removed the thread and said ‘looks like all is not as it seems with this thread’.

So it was just 100% pure speculation on their part.

Found it really shitty to be honest.

rainbowstardrops · 18/07/2023 08:50

I haven't had a thread deleted but I had a post deleted once. Someone was describing the DD's awful behaviour and I said the daughter was acting like a brat. That's it! I've read far worse on here than BRAT 🤣

bruffin · 18/07/2023 08:42

TimeIhadaNameChange · 18/07/2023 08:33

I think troll threads have their merit and should stay, as the advice will be genuine and might help someone in the future. Reminds me of a problem page in a teen paper years ago: an apology was printed in which a lass said her letter that had been printed a week previously had been a work of fiction. But as the agony aunt said, it might have helped someone else so she was not to worry unduly.

As this thread shows, among the genuine threads are those where details are changed but the reactions are valid. They should be allowed to stand.

No necessarily because they give a skewed view of the world and i suspect most responders are there for the juicy updates rather than to give advice

Swipe left for the next trending thread