Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you ever had a thread removed when you weren’t actually a troll?

145 replies

Yoghurtpit · 18/07/2023 07:40

I always wonder this. Sometimes I comment on a thread then it’s gone as it’s ‘not genuine’ etc. But I wonder if sometimes the facts are changed a little to protect confidentiality and really the essence of the story is true? This happened to me many years ago now and I still remember feeling like I was at my lowest then that happened! Everything I had put was actually accurate but the situation must have seemed so awful it was unbelievable to some posters.

OP posts:
Fightyouforthatpie · 18/07/2023 12:49

I have been troll hunted -someone trawled all my previous posts and did a "ha gotcha" - which wasn't, that posted a huge and very hateful pile-on, that then appeared in MNtrolls on Reddit with more self-congratulatory backslapping and hatred of me.
In the end it was a bit silly and as it was over a trivial post I didn't take it to heart. It does show how daft MN and the internet can be though. I think the thread still exists but I had to stop reading it (I didn't start the thread but it turned into we all hate Fightyou).

changeyerheadworzel · 18/07/2023 12:47

I did once when I asked did anyone think adult kids kissing their parents on the mouth was weird.

PyjamasToMyLeft · 18/07/2023 12:46

longtompot · 18/07/2023 10:21

I haven't, but I do remember one when I was first starting to come on here. The op was in very premature labour and was asking for help and she was accused of being a troll and had her post pulled. It turned out she was in fact a real person and this was happening to her, and she was even later on One Born Every Minute! Poor thing was so scared and needed help.

Yes I came on to say that. When they took down the post as a troll I felt betrayed as I’d been concerned and thinking about the young woman a lot (I probably hadn’t posted anything).

And then horrified when she was on One Born Every Minute. Her baby died.

MN came back and said they were sorry it looked like they’d made a mistake.

Fightyouforthatpie · 18/07/2023 12:42

Minfilia · 18/07/2023 09:20

This.

One of the signs apparently being that a poster has twins. I have twins but can’t post about them because it makes me a troll Hmm

I don't believe a word of it 😂

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 12:39

PrudenceDictates · 18/07/2023 12:35

Ha, yes, and let's not forget the "interesting first post, OP" comment which is so annoying.
When someone has a problem and starts a thread, it's not unlikely that they'll name change.
What an absolute saddo someone must be to go looking up others' posting history so they can catch them out.

I know, right!

I assume most people on mn change their name frequently as a matter of course now, and yes, particularly when starting a thread about something personal or sensitive!

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 12:37

Warrensrabbit · 18/07/2023 10:24

yes I have. I regularly change my username, but changed my email address to because I was talking about something financial and didn’t want it tied back to anything I’d previously written. I was deleted as a troll.
Im in the process of leaving a really nasty relationship and it was incredibly upsetting for Mumsnet to essentially invalidate something that I was going through

Yes exactly this. Horrible feeling and often on absolutely no basis – which I think people don’t realise when there’s a statement saying a thread has been deleted. People have the impression it must have been removed on the basis of some evidence – nope.

But if none of these hunches are ever verified, it’s just kind of a self-perpetuating confirmation bias. Even the sense that there are ‘lots of trolls’ is probably very skewed by all the genuine threads that get incorrectly removed and a little notice put up.

Bobbleballbags · 18/07/2023 12:35

About two years ago I had a thread under a different name that must have been reported by a few people who seemingly thought I was a troll trying to scam money judging by a few of the replies and a comment on the thread from mn. I was in a very low place at the time, having just left my ex and starting out as a single mum with no home and no job. My thread was a mixture of venting and asking for advice on various things - including financial related because I was in a very insecure position but certainly not asking for money from anyone! I don't think the thread got removed but the reaction to it made me feel awful and I stayed away from mn for a while after that!

PrudenceDictates · 18/07/2023 12:35

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 12:28

Oh yeah totally. Or not replying to the thread every 5 minutes.

’OP seems to have done a disappearing act, what a surprise’

In my case I’d been on the thread all morning (I’d woken up in the small hours to something happening and started the thread), then went out to go and treat myself to lunch and clear my head. By the time I came back apparently I was obviously a troll as I’d been away from the thread for several hours 🙄

Know exactly what you mean by the gleeful detailing of ‘the signs’ 🙄😆 It’s soo weird, and yes, the pride they take in it 😂😂😆

Ha, yes, and let's not forget the "interesting first post, OP" comment which is so annoying.
When someone has a problem and starts a thread, it's not unlikely that they'll name change.
What an absolute saddo someone must be to go looking up others' posting history so they can catch them out.

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 12:28

Lastlegsbuckledunder · 18/07/2023 09:18

I suspect this. That ithere are a sub-group of Mnetters who proudly look for trolls and spend their days gleefully reporting them. From posts on here they proudly list their ‘signs’ a post is a troll. Their ‘signs’ include totally normal stuff normal posters do. Like giving details of what happened..🙄

Oh yeah totally. Or not replying to the thread every 5 minutes.

’OP seems to have done a disappearing act, what a surprise’

In my case I’d been on the thread all morning (I’d woken up in the small hours to something happening and started the thread), then went out to go and treat myself to lunch and clear my head. By the time I came back apparently I was obviously a troll as I’d been away from the thread for several hours 🙄

Know exactly what you mean by the gleeful detailing of ‘the signs’ 🙄😆 It’s soo weird, and yes, the pride they take in it 😂😂😆

empatheticpretzel · 18/07/2023 12:19

Lots of people reported me for being a troll because I posted about the same thing multiple times

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 12:12

FromNowOn23 · 18/07/2023 08:15

Exh posted a thread once and I recognised him and joined in and it went on for pages but it was deleted in the end!

Ha that is funny!

LaughterTitsoff · 18/07/2023 12:12

With regards to some of the things mentioned here, I do think MNetters themselves need to take a bit of responsibility and stop sharing stories about piss, shit and periods.

Absolutely fine to advise anyone with a problem regarding the above, but it's the "Please share your stories" trolls that are so bloody obvious and yet you can guarantee some will trot along and dutifully oblige, without giving any actual advice at all.

It's not just MNHQ at fault in these cases, it's anyone who shares that stuff without giving it any thought as to why they're being asked to do so.

potniatheron · 18/07/2023 12:05

TeaKitten · 18/07/2023 11:30

I haven’t but I remember a poster once did, her waters broke at 18 weeks and she didn’t no if the baby would survive, she got lots of support and great advice, and then after weeks mumsnet pulled it and said it was a troll. About a year later she appeared on One born every minute and the story had indeed been true! Mumsnet apologised but it’s horrible that she got called a troll and has all that support and advice deleted when she was indeed telling the truth.

This is so sad. Imagine going thru such a traumatic event and then having the biggest website for mothers telling you outright you are lying.

LanaDeIRabies · 18/07/2023 11:55

HelterSkelter123 · 18/07/2023 11:52

I saw a thread on MN once where an OP had posted about their DP getting drunk at a family event and drawing a flower around the toddler DCs belly button with a sharpie as they thought it was 'cute'.

Not okay to be drunk and drawing on a child obviously and that was the OPs complaint. But the thread went absolutely deranged with some posters saying if she didn't LTB immediately she was enabling child abuse, and a couple of posters claiming it was 'well known' that drawing on DC was something CSA rings producing CSAI do, and threatening the poster that they'd report the thread to social services and the Police so MNHQ would have to disclose their email and IP address.

I think the thread was deleted, I can't remember, but whether it was or not, I'm sure the OP was terrified and very distressed by the pile-on and frankly batshit accusations she received.

Both of these are absolutely shocking.

LanaDeIRabies · 18/07/2023 11:53

I was accused of trolling once on a thread I started and also had a thread started about be on MN Trolls Reddit. It was at a seriously low point in my life and everything I wrote was the truth. It wasn't a very nice experience if I'm honest, it definitely knocked me when I was already down. The thread didn't get removed but it was reported. It was about a close family member having a MH crisis. Not a begging thread or anything outlandish, just looking for support/to vent. I de-regged for a while after that.

A while ago a Facebook friend messaged me to say they'd recognised me here after I posted something about a band I'm into. Now I NC regularly and change identifying stuff eg sex/age/number of DCs, my own age etc to keep things extra private. I do worry that if I'm ever reported again MN will take that as 'inconsistencies' and therefore proof I'm a troll, but it's better than being outed.

HelterSkelter123 · 18/07/2023 11:52

Dobbyatemysocks · 18/07/2023 11:39

About five/six years ago there was a thread from an OP about how her teenage kids where driving her mad with housework/hygiene etc.

I commented that I had "survived' my fives teenage years with a good sense of humour and a water pistol. It was ment to be a jokey comment, one that I have used many times and my now grown up children use it.

FOR THE RECORD I HAVE ONLY EVER HAD WATER PLAY FIGHTS WITH MY KIDS.
I HAVE NEVER USED A WATER PISTOL AS A PUNISHMENT.

HOWEVER,

Several users on here decided that a was a child abuser, unsafe to be around children and the pile on after my comment were really nasty. I received several nasty messages and threats of involving social services. I reported all to Mumsnet and no action was taken!!
The next time I went to log into my account it was locked and I had been removed.

It had a big impact on me and I doubted my abilities as a parent and now a very much involved grandparent.

Recently, after receiving a diagnosis of autism and ADHD I joined in on a thread for other members like myself to explain how this affects/effects us, our family and other people around us. I found this a great help - being able to talk, chat and even laugh about our day to day struggles. It was a big help, realising that I wasn't alone.

But then another thread who was aimed at people who live with people like me decided that they would use our thread as a 'look, see how funny they think it is at how they cause us heartache' and 'educational'.

I and many others on the thread disappeared and left because of this.

Mumsnet admins sat back and did nothing.

I have no doubt in my mind that this will probably get deleted and my account will be blocked again but I'm a lot stronger now and I really don't care.

I saw a thread on MN once where an OP had posted about their DP getting drunk at a family event and drawing a flower around the toddler DCs belly button with a sharpie as they thought it was 'cute'.

Not okay to be drunk and drawing on a child obviously and that was the OPs complaint. But the thread went absolutely deranged with some posters saying if she didn't LTB immediately she was enabling child abuse, and a couple of posters claiming it was 'well known' that drawing on DC was something CSA rings producing CSAI do, and threatening the poster that they'd report the thread to social services and the Police so MNHQ would have to disclose their email and IP address.

I think the thread was deleted, I can't remember, but whether it was or not, I'm sure the OP was terrified and very distressed by the pile-on and frankly batshit accusations she received.

unicornhair · 18/07/2023 11:42

Yes on an old account. Was worried about DDs friend who was basically gorging herself on food all the time (encouraged by her mother). Was told it couldn’t possibly be true and no child would eat like that. It was, she’s a morbidly obese teenager now.

Dobbyatemysocks · 18/07/2023 11:39

About five/six years ago there was a thread from an OP about how her teenage kids where driving her mad with housework/hygiene etc.

I commented that I had "survived' my fives teenage years with a good sense of humour and a water pistol. It was ment to be a jokey comment, one that I have used many times and my now grown up children use it.

FOR THE RECORD I HAVE ONLY EVER HAD WATER PLAY FIGHTS WITH MY KIDS.
I HAVE NEVER USED A WATER PISTOL AS A PUNISHMENT.

HOWEVER,

Several users on here decided that a was a child abuser, unsafe to be around children and the pile on after my comment were really nasty. I received several nasty messages and threats of involving social services. I reported all to Mumsnet and no action was taken!!
The next time I went to log into my account it was locked and I had been removed.

It had a big impact on me and I doubted my abilities as a parent and now a very much involved grandparent.

Recently, after receiving a diagnosis of autism and ADHD I joined in on a thread for other members like myself to explain how this affects/effects us, our family and other people around us. I found this a great help - being able to talk, chat and even laugh about our day to day struggles. It was a big help, realising that I wasn't alone.

But then another thread who was aimed at people who live with people like me decided that they would use our thread as a 'look, see how funny they think it is at how they cause us heartache' and 'educational'.

I and many others on the thread disappeared and left because of this.

Mumsnet admins sat back and did nothing.

I have no doubt in my mind that this will probably get deleted and my account will be blocked again but I'm a lot stronger now and I really don't care.

HelterSkelter123 · 18/07/2023 11:37

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/07/2023 10:16

Yeah, these are the ones I think are grim and should be deleted. I don't want to hear about your husband leaving shit stains on the bed ta, it's foul and grim, and does make me wonder about the mindset of these people posting this kind of thread. Are they trying to make others share their similar stories. Makes me wonder who's behind the threads, and I would never post on them.

Also, I could post a few things from my life that have happened/that I have experienced, and some people would probably call 'troll.' As they would just not believe them. As a pp said, some people can't see past their own life, and just because someone has not experienced something, that doesn't mean it has never happened to someone else.

And long-term MNetters know there are (in)famous piss, shit and school uniform trolls. "OMG I just shat myself at work, please share your stories of when you've shat yourself in public so I don’t feel so embarrassed" 🙄

I doubt anyone posting about their DP leaving shit stains on the bed or wiping bogies on the sofa really don't know it's disgusting and need other posters to confirm they are NBU.

TeaKitten · 18/07/2023 11:30

I haven’t but I remember a poster once did, her waters broke at 18 weeks and she didn’t no if the baby would survive, she got lots of support and great advice, and then after weeks mumsnet pulled it and said it was a troll. About a year later she appeared on One born every minute and the story had indeed been true! Mumsnet apologised but it’s horrible that she got called a troll and has all that support and advice deleted when she was indeed telling the truth.

potniatheron · 18/07/2023 11:25

No but I've had posts removed for misgendering people, and some other stuff.

MN relies v heavily on advertising so I think that drives some of the moderation decisions they make.

I personally think it's dreadful when posters pile on a person who seems to be going through a difficult time, telling them there's a troll, when there are zero tells that they might be.

But I appreciate it's a difficult decision. I used to volunteer for a crisis helpline and the number of men who'd call up to get their rocks off was surprising to say the least. There were a couple of repeat callers who I was taught how to identify straight away but there was one guy that I absolutely thought was genuine for about 4 minutes I'd say.

It's mad what some men get turned on by.

Plennury · 18/07/2023 11:21

Personally I couldn't care less about troll threads, I think people who sit there reporting them have too much time on their hands.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/07/2023 11:19

@Ivyy That's quite sad that you were banned like that when you were only asking about girls clothes/girls underwear ... It's quite normal for mums of young children to be asking about clothes and things for them...

Unfortunately you do sometimes get trolls on here that will try and get the mums on here talking about their little girls underwear, (bras and underpants etc,) So you were very likely reported because people thought that's what you were ( little girls underwear troll.) But at least mumsnet sorted it out and reinstated you. Flowers Even THEY make mistakes sometimes. Grin

Ivyy · 18/07/2023 11:16

catsgoldfishandtoomanypets · 18/07/2023 07:57

I've also been banned before due to a few posts/ threads being reported. Again, nothing illegal, trolling, goading, racist or discriminating in any way. Except you don't get told you've been banned, you try to log on and your account is locked. But the Message suggests your email address and/or password is wrong. Leaving you thinking you're typing either one of these wrong.

Exactly the same happened to me, I emailed Mumsnet to ask why I couldn't log in or reset my password, and was pretty shocked to read the reply saying they'd suspended my account. Apparently someone had reported me as a troll or that I had a fetish or something because I'd posted asking for girls underwear recommendations! I remember asking due to my daughter (who was probably about 8 at the time, this was a few years ago) having really bad sensory issues and struggling to find any underwear she found comfortable. She's autistic so it might even have been posted in the children with special needs section. I had some good recommendations in reply, but apparently someone reported the post and me as a user being suspicious or something ConfusedApparently I was always posting or replying about girls underwear! It was bizarre, apart from that one post, I may have replied on another thread at some point with a question or something, I can't remember now, but it would have been something very minor like where did you buy them / cost et! Whoever thought I was a troll for that and reported me must have been very bored and not very aware of ND children having sensory issues with clothes, yes including underwear!

MN did respond quickly and reactivated my account once they'd looked at all the info, I was actually a bit upset that it hadn't been looked into until I contacted them. If I hadn't, I may well have just been left suspended or banned forever! MN did apologise, hopefully now they review these types of reports faster and don't automatically suspend an account without looking at any evidence.

BlueThursday · 18/07/2023 11:09

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/07/2023 11:06

I have honestly never ever shaved my legs ... I'm quite blonde, and I've actually never needed to ... But is that unusual to shave your legs above the knee(s) then?

Not for me it isn’t but apparently the troll hunter thought it impossible

Swipe left for the next trending thread