Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you ever had a thread removed when you weren’t actually a troll?

145 replies

Yoghurtpit · 18/07/2023 07:40

I always wonder this. Sometimes I comment on a thread then it’s gone as it’s ‘not genuine’ etc. But I wonder if sometimes the facts are changed a little to protect confidentiality and really the essence of the story is true? This happened to me many years ago now and I still remember feeling like I was at my lowest then that happened! Everything I had put was actually accurate but the situation must have seemed so awful it was unbelievable to some posters.

OP posts:
Ds16dv · 18/07/2023 18:21

I have had threads removed ( not by choice ) I often get attacked on my own threads. Mostly I don't want the thread removed I also don't want nasty comments removed . I want them to stay so genuine posters /readers can see how that poster is rolling and it kind of shames them. Where if it's all deleted it kind of covers their shit up.

startingover202 · 18/07/2023 17:52

Did about 3 reverse threads. Not good.
But thought if anyone recognised the details or it ended up somewhere else they would think it was the other person not me.
Not the best idea but did get some advice that helped.

startingover202 · 18/07/2023 17:43

Yes I've been banned.
Old account. Posting various scenarios from different perspectives but labelled a troll.
Probably not the best way to seek advice but desperate at the time.
Changed details as didn't want to be recognised. Outed or in the daily fail.

justasking111 · 18/07/2023 17:40

Always be aware that posts can wind up on social media and others may recognise the author IRL

TimesRwo · 18/07/2023 17:24

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 17:04

I think that’s actually disgusting.

And of course people change small details – it’s a simple (and completely inconsequential) way of making yourself less identifiable.

For the purposes of a post or thread it likely won’t matter if it’s a brother or a sister you’re talking about or if you’re married or cohabiting, etc.

I know. What makes it worse is I only started changing details after a thread of mine went viral, including appearing on the Daily Mail, which resulted in a couple of people in real life knowing something very personal about me (I had posted about an incident, and then as the thread developed, explained why I had acted the way I did).

So I even explained to them that I had to protect myself after they didn’t protect me, so I change details, but nope, it’s not allowed apparently and can get you banned - even though most people on MN do it.

It’s made me super careful about what I post now.

catsgoldfishandtoomanypets · 18/07/2023 17:21

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 17:04

I think that’s actually disgusting.

And of course people change small details – it’s a simple (and completely inconsequential) way of making yourself less identifiable.

For the purposes of a post or thread it likely won’t matter if it’s a brother or a sister you’re talking about or if you’re married or cohabiting, etc.

Totally agree

catsgoldfishandtoomanypets · 18/07/2023 17:20

I've been outted on MN, I now change some things in my posts - DD/DC or DH/partner, age (by a few years) , number of DC and some events of the story behind my post eg location, event eg "I went to the theatre with my girlfriends and we all fell out coz J lost her bag" This might become "we went to a show, the group fell out coz K lost her coat/purse/phone" The theme of the post still stays the same, just the detail may change to protect me being outted

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 17:04

TimesRwo · 18/07/2023 16:33

Yes! I had a thread removed with the message claiming I was a previously banned poster and then I was banned from MN because my posts were inconsistent and I wasn’t a genuine poster.

What really happened is I had a thread where some people didn’t like the terminology I used. MN removed it and claimed I was previously banned.

I had never been banned - I had another account beforehand for an email address I forgot the password for, so MN closed that account so I can open a new one.

My inconsistent posts were because I change my personal info when I post to avoid being outing. MN actually set me a list of everything I had written to show I was fake, yet they didn’t see the common theme - I had been married for less than 5 years and had one young toddler. I had simply changed how long I had been married, or the age and sex of my child, but nothing else was made up. I explained everyone on MN does it, but they didn’t accept that.

The not being a genuine poster was then because they blamed other offensive posts on me. I had reported racist posts and they then claimed those posts were mine!

It was complete nonsense, which is why I know don’t assume every deleted post is a troll.

I think that’s actually disgusting.

And of course people change small details – it’s a simple (and completely inconsequential) way of making yourself less identifiable.

For the purposes of a post or thread it likely won’t matter if it’s a brother or a sister you’re talking about or if you’re married or cohabiting, etc.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 16:57

I remember a few years ago someone asking for advice about a very sensitive situation which involved another person. She had changed various details to preserve anonymity, but people picked away so much at the 'inconsistencies' that in the end it became clear which details had been changed.

I hate it when people do that. Even when people say that they've been coy about the details, so as not to be outing, but that they do know what they're talking about, some others really are like a dog with a bone.

There was one only the other week where the OP (teacher) was obviously really upset at several young children independently asking her if she was a boy, wondering if everybody really secretly thought she looked like a man. The number of posters who were insisting on their theory that the kids had made it up together as a silly game in the playground or passed a rumour through the school.

OP eventually felt forced to declare that she was a supply teacher - which obviously narrows it down somewhat if anybody knows her - and this had happened at several completely different schools. It completely derailed the thread and very obviously made her feel worse when she'd originally just come on seeking some genuine support. No need for it whatsoever.

Mysterian · 18/07/2023 16:50

I think I remember having one taken down. No idea why. I'd had a nice evening and maybe a teenie weenie drink, then posted a thoughtful, witty and intelligent thread opening post which people may have wrongly mistaken for incomprehensible slurred gibberish. Maybe I had an 'off' bag of crisps between drinks.

TimesRwo · 18/07/2023 16:33

Yes! I had a thread removed with the message claiming I was a previously banned poster and then I was banned from MN because my posts were inconsistent and I wasn’t a genuine poster.

What really happened is I had a thread where some people didn’t like the terminology I used. MN removed it and claimed I was previously banned.

I had never been banned - I had another account beforehand for an email address I forgot the password for, so MN closed that account so I can open a new one.

My inconsistent posts were because I change my personal info when I post to avoid being outing. MN actually set me a list of everything I had written to show I was fake, yet they didn’t see the common theme - I had been married for less than 5 years and had one young toddler. I had simply changed how long I had been married, or the age and sex of my child, but nothing else was made up. I explained everyone on MN does it, but they didn’t accept that.

The not being a genuine poster was then because they blamed other offensive posts on me. I had reported racist posts and they then claimed those posts were mine!

It was complete nonsense, which is why I know don’t assume every deleted post is a troll.

Keepyournoseoutthanks · 18/07/2023 16:19

Yes. Many years ago I had a thread deleted and got banned.

I was actually in a really bad place at the time in my relationship and my partner had thrown something and something had got broken. I got absolutely ripped to pieces by a lot of people who said that it could never happen and I was making it up.

I honestly can't understand it, it wasn't a particularly far fetched story. A household item has been thrown and bounced and broken something.

Got torn apart, reported and banned. So yeah, thanks for that mumsnet.

I think this forum is vile on the whole but I've learnt to stick mainly to the lighter topics which can be nice and friendly.

BodegaSushi · 18/07/2023 16:19

Fightyouforthatpie · 18/07/2023 12:42

I don't believe a word of it 😂

Tbh the twins thing isn't just in isolation. The twins are usually 2 of mutiple children, severe disabilties tend to be involved, also add an absent father and no one, not a single soul around who can help. The OP usually cannot drive, lives in a totally isolated area, and buses only come once every full moon. Extra points if they're about to be made homeless as well, their beloved animals cannot be rehomed no way, but they can't get help from the council because they've no internet connection.

While of course each of these situations can exist, them occuring altogether does make me raise an eyebrow. But the people lap it all up.

Caravanvirgin · 18/07/2023 16:08

FromNowOn23 · 18/07/2023 08:15

Exh posted a thread once and I recognised him and joined in and it went on for pages but it was deleted in the end!

Was the thread about you?

Greensleeves · 18/07/2023 16:01

x2boys · 18/07/2023 08:18

Why would you post about it on here though?
I often wonder that when people start a,thread talking about something grim their partner has done in relation to.personsl.care
I wonder why their first thought is too post it on a public forum🤔

Because in a social set-up where people, especially mothers, can feel isolated and separate, MN functions as a sort of watering-hole where women can find a peer group to talk to about anything that's on their minds? I think that's why it's so successful.

Boatshoes · 18/07/2023 16:00

SpainToday · 18/07/2023 08:05

Yes! It was years ago now, I was posting about training cats to use a cat flap. Heaven knows who I offended and why?

Then a couple of years ago a post of mine was deleted in a fairly benign conversation about noisy children disturbing the peace of their neighbours garden.

Haha! Maybe some folk thought you were training cats as part of a nationwide burglary scheme?!

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 15:57

LanaDeIRabies · 18/07/2023 15:43

This was evidently a troll, though. They posted about ghostly wotsit fingerprints and pissing themselves at 'DH's' funeral, among other things. By the end the posts were veering into a sort of surreal sick comedy. It was horrible.

It was really in response to this comment:

They do get it right often though. Stuff pops up there and ends up deleted here all the time.

ColinRobinsonsFart · 18/07/2023 15:53

@HonoriaLucastaDelagardie
@SpainToday

He survived. We are still coming to terms with the surgery. He is working part time but more importantly we are still together and love each other.

Thank you

JobMatch3000 · 18/07/2023 15:51

Someone decided to ask that their post was deleted for privacy reasons after I suggested they needed to find emergency childcare not take a sicky from work, when their attendance was already under management review, when their DC was ill.

OhNoOhNo · 18/07/2023 15:46

Not remover but I did have loads of people disbelieving me and troll
hinting (typo but hinting is quite apt actually) and saying things like ‘No way can this be real’ etc.

Some people can only view and understand things through their own experience (or inexperience might be more apt).

LanaDeIRabies · 18/07/2023 15:43

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 15:34

Just because something was deleted, doesn’t mean it was actually a troll.

As mentioned in this thread, many threads are taken down on a hunch from MN and nothing more. A thread being deleted doesn’t serve as proof that it was actually a troll.

(As many posters have mentioned, threads are frequently deleted without contacting the OP or any sort of behind-the-scenes investigation)

This was evidently a troll, though. They posted about ghostly wotsit fingerprints and pissing themselves at 'DH's' funeral, among other things. By the end the posts were veering into a sort of surreal sick comedy. It was horrible.

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 15:38

Spreadbed · 18/07/2023 15:35

Years ago a friend of mine started a thread about John Lennon and the controversy around him. We were together having drinks at the time. People went absolutely crazy defending him and it was deleted due to ‘concerns about the poster’! We were stumped.

If it makes you feel any better I can’t bear John Lennon 😆

BadNomad · 18/07/2023 15:36

Look

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4852052-to-think-this-is-weird

Real or troll? So much shite ('scuse the pun) gets posted that it just spoils it for genuine posters. The trolls are the people to blame. Not the cynical people fed up with it all.

Spreadbed · 18/07/2023 15:35

Years ago a friend of mine started a thread about John Lennon and the controversy around him. We were together having drinks at the time. People went absolutely crazy defending him and it was deleted due to ‘concerns about the poster’! We were stumped.

FrugalKisses · 18/07/2023 15:34

LanaDeIRabies · 18/07/2023 13:14

They do get it right often though. Stuff pops up there and ends up deleted here all the time.

They're particularly good at spotting begging threads and bereavement trolls. The latter are the lowest of the imo. Genuinely bereaved posters relive the worst times of their lives in solidarity with them. There was one a while back, a dead pilot (his 'widow' claimed to sleep with a pillow shaped like her dead DH with a phone playing a video of snoring sounds under it) - MN Trolls spotted it immediately but it took days to be taken down. The sickest thing about it was it was based on a true story the poster had clearly read in a newspaper. I hope the poor man's actual widow never saw it.

Just because something was deleted, doesn’t mean it was actually a troll.

As mentioned in this thread, many threads are taken down on a hunch from MN and nothing more. A thread being deleted doesn’t serve as proof that it was actually a troll.

(As many posters have mentioned, threads are frequently deleted without contacting the OP or any sort of behind-the-scenes investigation)