Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

no limit on child detention, no protection from modern slavery, prison ships for people charged with no crime in the UK

140 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 07:19

How the government treat asylum seekers, most of whom will be proven to be genuine refugees, fleeing persecution.

This is not how to treat people fleeing war, torture, threats, persecution

All because THEY ( the government) have messed up the application system, and now have such a back log they cant cope, and don't know where to house the people who are waiting.

How about investing in extra staff to clear the back log of people waiting? Rather than abusing the people waiting?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
WandaWonder · 18/07/2023 08:31

Op I am sure it will ease some pressure if you have some come and live with you, unless you do already?

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:31

endofthelinefinally · 18/07/2023 08:25

Culturally I think the idea is that the fittest men go ahead to establish a safe place to bring their wives and family. Sadly it doesn't often work out. Few people would have money to send a whole family.

Nonsense, any loving and caring man would sent their wife, kids and mum to the nearest safe country- my homeland has been repeatedly occupied and its the first 50 years of freedom,in our family if our country was at war again my brother and dad would stay at home to look after our home and send female
family members to a safe country,in fact my mum said she wouldnt leave my dad because she has no young children and if her grandchildren would get out of the country she would be happy with that.

now you see hordes of men coming off the boats where they have passed 6 or 7 safe countries,many with similar culture like theirs. No this is being an economic migrant

Blackbyrd · 18/07/2023 08:30

All the time there is this typical and ridiculous over reaction to this topic, as illustrated here with the hyperbole, nothing will be achieved as it is impossible to have a reasonable debate.
Firstly, they are not "prison ships", inhabitants will be free to come and go as they are anywhere . They're not "proven to be genuine refugees" generally, the useless Home Office can't prove they're not. Which is why many asylum seekers destroy their papers and pretend to be from elsewhere. If you destroy your ID and lie then why would the UK want you?
We do not need to add to our existing population, which is many millions more than the official Government figures. At what point would all of you defending population increases of over half a million a year say enough is enough. I'll wager it's not your communities suffering due to lack of resources, overcrowding etc
Are you actually aware of what's happening in other European countries before slagging off the UK? Walls being built, genuinely right wing politics on the rise (not just "Fuck the Tories"), shanty towns and squalid immigration camps. Go protest outside their embassies

endofthelinefinally · 18/07/2023 08:25

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:22

Why exclude Albania,they make up
most
of the economical tourists. As for Aganistan,Iran and Iraq- no western conflicts there either, Afganistan is getting rid of us and uk poppy plantations, they have now reduced them by 90 percent where they used to be in kabul area and replaced them with wheat fields. Iran and Iraq are becoming trade partners Which US of course dosent like.

Funny how these refugees are 97 percent males in their prime who should be at home fighting for their county if there is a conflict, who leaves their kids,wife,mum and grandma behind?

Culturally I think the idea is that the fittest men go ahead to establish a safe place to bring their wives and family. Sadly it doesn't often work out. Few people would have money to send a whole family.

WTFAreYouForReal · 18/07/2023 08:25

gogomoto · 18/07/2023 08:07

You use the term children, these are unaccompanied minors who have made their way across Europe alone, legally (they claim) to be under 18 but as most don't have birth certificates or passports this has been a tricky area with some "children" ending up being in their 20's but the smugglers tell them to claim to be 16 for better treatment.

We all want genuine refugees to be treated well and granted refuge but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees. Our politicians need to devise a better system of temporary work visas applied for before entering the country, for asylum applications to be started before arriving in all but the most exceptional circumstances, then zero tolerance for illegal arrivals

Exactly.

What they need to do is make the UK less appealing. In Spain you don't get any benefits, healthcare, social housing - if there is any, there isn't where I am - unless you've paid in to the system for at least a year, and then you only get it for a certain amount of time based on how long you've paid in for, I believe. They must have a refugee system, but it's not abused because once processed it's not a free ride, I assume.

Ukrainians were brought here recently but all help was from the community, not the government.

If the UK brought that in, the problem would most likely cure itself.

Eyesopenwideawake · 18/07/2023 08:24

We all want genuine refugees to be treated well and granted refuge but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees.

You keep telling yourself what the Govt and RW press what you to think. Alternatively look at the facts.

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01403/

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:23

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:20

This isnt true, as I said, I personally have met children under 10 caught up in this. Babies and toddlers even

Then take the children and the mum,males need to go back to sort their home out so wife and kids can return one day

3dogsandarabbit · 18/07/2023 08:22

Orangeleaves - It needs to be done fairly though depending on geographical size of country and existing population. Our population, although less than France or Germany has increased more percentage wise than those 2 countries in the last 30 years.

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:22

cakeorwine · 18/07/2023 08:15

If you exclude Alabania. then you have many people from Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran and Sudan.

I guess you have heard of the situation in those countries?

Why exclude Albania,they make up
most
of the economical tourists. As for Aganistan,Iran and Iraq- no western conflicts there either, Afganistan is getting rid of us and uk poppy plantations, they have now reduced them by 90 percent where they used to be in kabul area and replaced them with wheat fields. Iran and Iraq are becoming trade partners Which US of course dosent like.

Funny how these refugees are 97 percent males in their prime who should be at home fighting for their county if there is a conflict, who leaves their kids,wife,mum and grandma behind?

AllMyExesWearRolexes · 18/07/2023 08:22

Use the Army for what? Armies are for defence, not some kind of camouflaged miracle workers running around trying to solve the latest governmental fuckup.
The current situation is untenable, fully open doors are not desirable and the answer is hidden somewhere between the two.
The UK is not bound to absorb everyone who wants to come here, genuine cases with a verifiable connection of course, the rest require screening - that's the problem. The screening process is hopelessly inefficient because it's staffed by people who don't really want to do it & given half arsed funding by a government who don't want to do it at all.
There are 3 options - open borders, no screening = chaos,
Closed borders, possibly excepting genuine cases verified abroad before travel - some would say this is too harsh.
Holding all arrivals while they are processed. This is where we are now but if it's going to work it has to be adequately funded and staffed.
You can't have these people running around the country unscreened, potential terrorists or criminals might be among them, as might carriers of diseases we don't have here. There might be other categories of undesirable so we must have screening but it must be fair, timely and done in acceptable conditions.
It must also be enforceable, there needs to be a mechanism for removal of the ones that are not accepted.

dontchaknow · 18/07/2023 08:21

Of course we all have sympathy for genuine refugees, but there are an awful lot of people abusing our sympathy and posing as refugees.
With regard to genuine refugees, with the best will in the world, we can't take them all in. For example, under current rules, anyone fleeing sexual persecution who can prove it will (eventually) be allowed residency. So that means that the entire female and non straight population of, for example, Afghanistan is eligible.

cakeorwine · 18/07/2023 08:20

For context:

There are 108,000,000 displaced people in the world of which 35,000,000 are refugees.

UNHCR - Refugee Statistics

We take a tiny tiny tiny fraction compared to the numbers.
Most stay in refugee camps near their home country.

UNHCR - Refugee Statistics

UNHCR's Refugee Statistics is a database containing information about forcibly displaced populations, spanning across almost 70 years of statistical activities. It covers displaced populations such as refugees, asylum-seekers and internally displaced p...

https://www.unhcr.org/refugee-statistics/

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:20

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:13

Most are from Albania,not even in any conflict. The children you are talkig about are young adult males.

UK has big enough problems on its own without taking on rest of the undeveloped worlds problems on

This isnt true, as I said, I personally have met children under 10 caught up in this. Babies and toddlers even

OP posts:
orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:18

but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees

This is soooo untrue - it is what the govt wants you to think

OP posts:
AIBot · 18/07/2023 08:18

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:13

Most are from Albania,not even in any conflict. The children you are talkig about are young adult males.

UK has big enough problems on its own without taking on rest of the undeveloped worlds problems on

Does the general public really believe this? Pig ignorant.

loislovesstewie · 18/07/2023 08:18

I'm a retired public sector worker. I am so sick and tired with the idea that;
a] we did nothing, when in reality we worked hard all day.
b] anyone could do the job, when in actual fact I had to know a huge amount about the bit of law I dealt with and quite a lot about other related legislation.
c] another person with no knowledge of the legislation, or who had managed to read through it,knew more than me. I'm talking about your army comment here.
d] it was sooo easy to recruit. It wasn't, if I told you want I actualy did in the day , how much I had to know, that I was up against barristers if challenged, and what I was paid, you would be shocked.
If you want to improve the country then do something about the successive appalling governments we have inflicted on ourselves.
Also realise that people are not truthful, don't be taken in by either side of any argument . The first lesson I learnt was that emotions and emotional responses don't improve situations.

cakeorwine · 18/07/2023 08:18

gogomoto · 18/07/2023 08:07

You use the term children, these are unaccompanied minors who have made their way across Europe alone, legally (they claim) to be under 18 but as most don't have birth certificates or passports this has been a tricky area with some "children" ending up being in their 20's but the smugglers tell them to claim to be 16 for better treatment.

We all want genuine refugees to be treated well and granted refuge but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees. Our politicians need to devise a better system of temporary work visas applied for before entering the country, for asylum applications to be started before arriving in all but the most exceptional circumstances, then zero tolerance for illegal arrivals

And yet a lot of people successfully claim asylum.

How many people cross the Channel in small boats and how many claim asylum? - BBC News

So maybe your claim about most being economic migrants might not be true

Migrants in a dinghy sail in the Channel toward the south coast of England

How many people cross the Channel in small boats and how many claim asylum?

Rishi Sunak has said that "stopping the boats" bringing migrants to the UK is a political priority.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-53699511

OprahWinfery · 18/07/2023 08:17

It’s a liberal view to pay for and protect arseholes like Nawaz Shariff - who are wanted for crimes in their country but it’s the British taxpayers who pay for their protection over here.

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:16

Yes, there needs to be a system whereby asylum seekers anywhere in the world can apply to the UN and have their cases assessed, and then be allocated to a country once they have got refugee status. However, if refugees were allocated fairly across the world, obviously the UK would be expected to take far more, so a vote loser for the Tories,

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 18/07/2023 08:15

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:13

Most are from Albania,not even in any conflict. The children you are talkig about are young adult males.

UK has big enough problems on its own without taking on rest of the undeveloped worlds problems on

If you exclude Alabania. then you have many people from Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran and Sudan.

I guess you have heard of the situation in those countries?

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:14

gogomoto · 18/07/2023 08:07

You use the term children, these are unaccompanied minors who have made their way across Europe alone, legally (they claim) to be under 18 but as most don't have birth certificates or passports this has been a tricky area with some "children" ending up being in their 20's but the smugglers tell them to claim to be 16 for better treatment.

We all want genuine refugees to be treated well and granted refuge but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees. Our politicians need to devise a better system of temporary work visas applied for before entering the country, for asylum applications to be started before arriving in all but the most exceptional circumstances, then zero tolerance for illegal arrivals

There are adults pretending to be children, sure, but this is a tiny number. There are children with parents, and their are young children alone. I've known children under 10 caught up in this

OP posts:
mambojambodothetango · 18/07/2023 08:14

but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees.

This is just not true. Where do you get your 'facts' from?

cakeorwine · 18/07/2023 08:13

If you exclude Albanians, most people who come here on boats come from countries such as Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran and Syria.

Most refugees are in countries that are near to them. We take very few refugees in comparison to the numbers and we offer very few safe routes.

I can imagine the outcry if we start to refuse asylum for people who have served this country as Afghan translaters, or have suffered terrible abuse in countries such as Iran for standing up for their rights.

We condemn Afghanistan and Iran for their actions in the country but condemn people who try to leave and settle here to escape these actions. We say they should go elsewhere despite the fact that most do go elsewhere.

But people don't here that.

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:13

Most are from Albania,not even in any conflict. The children you are talkig about are young adult males.

UK has big enough problems on its own without taking on rest of the undeveloped worlds problems on

OprahWinfery · 18/07/2023 08:11

Why are they fleeing persecution?