Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

no limit on child detention, no protection from modern slavery, prison ships for people charged with no crime in the UK

140 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 07:19

How the government treat asylum seekers, most of whom will be proven to be genuine refugees, fleeing persecution.

This is not how to treat people fleeing war, torture, threats, persecution

All because THEY ( the government) have messed up the application system, and now have such a back log they cant cope, and don't know where to house the people who are waiting.

How about investing in extra staff to clear the back log of people waiting? Rather than abusing the people waiting?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/07/2023 09:04

MissyB1 · 18/07/2023 07:57

Yes the fact that so many people will be happy with all of this dog whistle shit makes me feel sick. Isn’t it obvious it’s just a way for the Government to yet again distract from their failure to run anything properly? Let’s blame refugees for all our problems eh? Instead of telling the bloody truth!

I know there a saying along the lines of "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity" and there's no doubting many in this government are stupid but, it's really hard to malice in the way they handle this.

I actually heard a tory mp attempt to lay the blame on Labour's door yesterday, and worse, shortly after read similar comments online. Quite how anyone can claim the issue lies with a party who've not been in power for over a decade and not with the party with a 50+ seat majority is beyond me, but facts and truth come second to feelings and bias when it comes to this sort of topic.

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 09:03

People here have very little idea of what happens to refugees once they have refugee status.

I have volunteered for several refugee charities.

You would be surprised at how many refugees sleep rough, considering the views on here - that includes children, even babies and toddlers.

Typical example, parents in their 20s, refugees from Iran, escaped in the clothes they were standing up in when a sympathiser in the police contacted them and warned they were about to be arrested. Their crime was being suspected of Christianity.

Sleeping rough in London with their two year old daughter. Their choice was to keep her on the street with them, or give her up to the care system and possibly never see her again

OP posts:
3dogsandarabbit · 18/07/2023 09:02

Orangeleaves - Of course nobody wants their husband, brother etc to fight during a war, but sometimes you have to stand up and fight for your country. If it wasn't for our men fighting during WW2 this country would be under a German dictatorship.

Hecate01 · 18/07/2023 08:58

I have 2 friends who've just lost their jobs at Stradey Park Hotel in Llanelli due to it closing to house migrants/immigrants/refugees. Go tell them how fortunate they are, especially the one who's a single parent with two children and has now been forced out of her job.

Then there's the problem with the impact on local services, hospitals are already overstretched (Welsh Labour run no matter how you dress it up), schools are full and the area isn't exactly affluent. Seems like everyone wants them but not in their back yard.

I don't know what the answer is but forcing people into poverty to take people from other countries isn't the answer.

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:58

loislovesstewie · 18/07/2023 08:49

Asylum seekers have the right to present as homeless and be dealt with under that legislation.

asylum seekers have a right to housing, refugees dont

OP posts:
Iamclearlyamug · 18/07/2023 08:58

gogomoto · 18/07/2023 08:07

You use the term children, these are unaccompanied minors who have made their way across Europe alone, legally (they claim) to be under 18 but as most don't have birth certificates or passports this has been a tricky area with some "children" ending up being in their 20's but the smugglers tell them to claim to be 16 for better treatment.

We all want genuine refugees to be treated well and granted refuge but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees. Our politicians need to devise a better system of temporary work visas applied for before entering the country, for asylum applications to be started before arriving in all but the most exceptional circumstances, then zero tolerance for illegal arrivals

I agree with this

loislovesstewie · 18/07/2023 08:55

A person who is given leave to remain for any reason, can apply for social housing, so they can join the housing register and can present as homeless. If you don't believe me Shelter provide exactly that information.

Baconisdelicious · 18/07/2023 08:53

Of course we all have sympathy for genuine refugees, but there are an awful lot of people abusing our sympathy and posing as refugees.With regard to genuine refugees, with the best will in the world, we can't take them all in

The vast majority of refugees in the world are taken in by neighbouring countries. We don't seem to take many genuine refugees fleeing persecution in France or Ireland Confused

What they need to do is make the UK less appealing. In Spain you don't get any benefits, healthcare, social housing

Well, you clearly know sod all about benefits for asylum seekers....but if you put that aside and think critically about economic migration. How do you think that works? Do you think people living in poor economic conditions wake up one morning and go oh I know, I'll travel.half way round the world on a crowded van, dodging immigration and other legalities all for £80 a week? Or do you think that people in other countries look at a place like the UK, with long, long history of stable democracy, where healthcare and education are free and everyone is able to be someone with hard work, and wish they could have some of that to help support their families? Do you think poor, vulnerable families might club together and send one of their young, strong members with what we know as people traffickers but who present as people offering opportunity, jobs, a passport and visa and a legal means by which to enter the UK? Do you honestly think that every young male economic migrant is here because 'benefits' or because somewhere in their home country is a family hopeful that person will improve their quality of life? Do you think they realised when their family clubbed together to send them that they would be having to risk their lives crossing water in an overloaded dinghy or do you think they might have been a bit naive in believing the streets were paved with gold?

loislovesstewie · 18/07/2023 08:52

Sorry I will clarify, once given leave to reamain anyone can present as homeless. I meant to put successful at the beginning[ trying to do two things at once doesn't help!]Those refused may become over stayers and can't be housed.

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:51

WTFAreYouForReal · 18/07/2023 08:25

Exactly.

What they need to do is make the UK less appealing. In Spain you don't get any benefits, healthcare, social housing - if there is any, there isn't where I am - unless you've paid in to the system for at least a year, and then you only get it for a certain amount of time based on how long you've paid in for, I believe. They must have a refugee system, but it's not abused because once processed it's not a free ride, I assume.

Ukrainians were brought here recently but all help was from the community, not the government.

If the UK brought that in, the problem would most likely cure itself.

you seem to have a very strange idea of what happens once someone gets refugee status. They dont get any housing, for example

OP posts:
grannysmithspips · 18/07/2023 08:50

Whatames · 18/07/2023 08:47

They tried to set up an asylum camp for 2000 men in my village of 700. Essentially an open prison as the only place they would be able to go would be the village. I started learning about asylum refugee policy in order to fight it. The problem is the backlog. If they processed applications quickly and actually sent back those not genuine then the tax payer wouldn’t be paying for anyone. Those whose cases were agreed would be supporting themselves by working and becoming integrated in society. Instead they keep people for around 2 years at the tax payers expense. It’s all
optics and they have created the problem in order to appear ‘harsh’ to asylum seekers. Living in a village where this was proposed was honestly awful…it would have changed our lives beyond recognition and the government were very slyly changing the planning laws so they could do what they liked. Although I think we need a practical solution for immigration these large scale camps in all their forms are not the answer either for the poor people inside or the communities they are based in

Good to hear from somebody who actually looked in to this.

loislovesstewie · 18/07/2023 08:49

Asylum seekers have the right to present as homeless and be dealt with under that legislation.

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:47

WandaWonder · 18/07/2023 08:31

Op I am sure it will ease some pressure if you have some come and live with you, unless you do already?

I have already, but the people who can be housed by volunteers often already have refugee status - contrary to common belief, refugees get no housing, only asylum seekers. Once the claim has been processed, the individual is often homeless.

OP posts:
Whatames · 18/07/2023 08:47

They tried to set up an asylum camp for 2000 men in my village of 700. Essentially an open prison as the only place they would be able to go would be the village. I started learning about asylum refugee policy in order to fight it. The problem is the backlog. If they processed applications quickly and actually sent back those not genuine then the tax payer wouldn’t be paying for anyone. Those whose cases were agreed would be supporting themselves by working and becoming integrated in society. Instead they keep people for around 2 years at the tax payers expense. It’s all
optics and they have created the problem in order to appear ‘harsh’ to asylum seekers. Living in a village where this was proposed was honestly awful…it would have changed our lives beyond recognition and the government were very slyly changing the planning laws so they could do what they liked. Although I think we need a practical solution for immigration these large scale camps in all their forms are not the answer either for the poor people inside or the communities they are based in

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:45

3dogsandarabbit · 18/07/2023 08:22

Orangeleaves - It needs to be done fairly though depending on geographical size of country and existing population. Our population, although less than France or Germany has increased more percentage wise than those 2 countries in the last 30 years.

the trouble is, if refugees are fairly allocated, buy any measure, UK should be taking far more than we are, by some measures, up to 10x more. However, this is not what this thread is about, This is about the government "celebrating" their "victory" in passing laws allowing them to get out of their humane responsibilities to these people sitting waiting in detention in the UK.

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 18/07/2023 08:44

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:35

are you seriously implying that soldiers in the army are so stupid they could not do your job within 5 years of training?

You realise this has been building up for 5 years, right, and that the first calls to use the army were 5 years ago?

I am sure one or tow of them would have been bright enough to have got the hang of it by now

Oh come of it! It seems that you expect the army to deal with everything. You think, along with others , that they can be up to date on regulations/laws about this and countless other things. It's as ridiculous as thinking that I could be an army officer, and a plumber, and a social worker, and countless other specialist jobs. The answer is that people learn ho to do a job and do that job, not get pulled in to another job, often quite badly. It's along the lines of people criticising social workers, because after all that just takes a bit of common sense doesn't it? No need to have any knowledge of legislation.
Generally speaking, most people have no idea what has to be considered, what the legislation actually says, what caselaw says, what challenges might be brought, how to deal with that, and lots more. If it's so simple then I suggest people who think that should apply to do the job.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/07/2023 08:43

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:18

but the vast majority trying to enter the country are economic migrants not refugees

This is soooo untrue - it is what the govt wants you to think

What I don't understand is that often the same people who rant on and on about the government control, the WEF, big pharma, MSM, etc, will do a 180, swallow any old propaganda and become the government's biggest supporter the moment it suits one of their biases.

Is it too much to ask for just a little bit of consistency from the right?

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:42

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:22

Why exclude Albania,they make up
most
of the economical tourists. As for Aganistan,Iran and Iraq- no western conflicts there either, Afganistan is getting rid of us and uk poppy plantations, they have now reduced them by 90 percent where they used to be in kabul area and replaced them with wheat fields. Iran and Iraq are becoming trade partners Which US of course dosent like.

Funny how these refugees are 97 percent males in their prime who should be at home fighting for their county if there is a conflict, who leaves their kids,wife,mum and grandma behind?

1 - what is the relevance of whether there are western conflicts in a particular country or not?

2 - I seriously question your information on agriculture in Afghanistan - global warming has destroyed the fruit crops, which traditionally Afghans have relied on economically, and for food - and guess who has contributed more to global warming between you personally, and the average refugee from Afghanistan. You realise the collapse of crops is a major contributor to political instability all over the world. So if you own a car, take flights for leisure, use central heating, waste plastic, etc etc etc you are directly implicated

3- 97 % of refugees are not young men- that is a media lie designed to erode sympathy

4- why should young men stay in their country and fight anyway? How about your son, your brother, your partner - would you think they should stay and die for one dictator or another? or attempt to reach safety, as any human has the right to, male or female, young or old.

OP posts:
lieselotte · 18/07/2023 08:39

Our politicians need to devise a better system of temporary work visas applied for before entering the country, for asylum applications to be started before arriving in all but the most exceptional circumstances, then zero tolerance for illegal arrivals

yes I agree we need legal routes for people to claim asylum or apply to come here to work if they have family here already.

And those who are already here should not be shut up in hotels or prison ships, but taught English, their skills audited, and found paid work. There are plenty of jobs, both skilled and unskilled, that they could be doing. What's the point of them sitting around doing nothing?

cakeorwine · 18/07/2023 08:38

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:22

Why exclude Albania,they make up
most
of the economical tourists. As for Aganistan,Iran and Iraq- no western conflicts there either, Afganistan is getting rid of us and uk poppy plantations, they have now reduced them by 90 percent where they used to be in kabul area and replaced them with wheat fields. Iran and Iraq are becoming trade partners Which US of course dosent like.

Funny how these refugees are 97 percent males in their prime who should be at home fighting for their county if there is a conflict, who leaves their kids,wife,mum and grandma behind?

You seem to be making stats up on the spot.
Have to go to work but I am sure someone will be telling you the actual stats during this thread.

Bliss1221 · 18/07/2023 08:37

Baconisdelicious · 18/07/2023 08:35

What they need to do is make the UK less appealing. In Spain you don't get any benefits, healthcare, social housing - if there is any, there isn't where I am - unless you've paid in to the system for at least a year, and then you only get it for a certain amount of time based on how long you've paid in for, I believe. They must have a refugee system, but it's not abused because once processed it's not a free ride, I assume

So...you believe and you assume....but you don't actually know

As an european citizen if refugees can claim child benefit they are better off than europeans with uk residency, i cant claim child benefit for my children born in the uk because of my nationality lol,my husband has volunteered to give it up twice and they have turned it down

Baconisdelicious · 18/07/2023 08:35

What they need to do is make the UK less appealing. In Spain you don't get any benefits, healthcare, social housing - if there is any, there isn't where I am - unless you've paid in to the system for at least a year, and then you only get it for a certain amount of time based on how long you've paid in for, I believe. They must have a refugee system, but it's not abused because once processed it's not a free ride, I assume

So...you believe and you assume....but you don't actually know

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:35

loislovesstewie · 18/07/2023 08:18

I'm a retired public sector worker. I am so sick and tired with the idea that;
a] we did nothing, when in reality we worked hard all day.
b] anyone could do the job, when in actual fact I had to know a huge amount about the bit of law I dealt with and quite a lot about other related legislation.
c] another person with no knowledge of the legislation, or who had managed to read through it,knew more than me. I'm talking about your army comment here.
d] it was sooo easy to recruit. It wasn't, if I told you want I actualy did in the day , how much I had to know, that I was up against barristers if challenged, and what I was paid, you would be shocked.
If you want to improve the country then do something about the successive appalling governments we have inflicted on ourselves.
Also realise that people are not truthful, don't be taken in by either side of any argument . The first lesson I learnt was that emotions and emotional responses don't improve situations.

are you seriously implying that soldiers in the army are so stupid they could not do your job within 5 years of training?

You realise this has been building up for 5 years, right, and that the first calls to use the army were 5 years ago?

I am sure one or tow of them would have been bright enough to have got the hang of it by now

OP posts:
3dogsandarabbit · 18/07/2023 08:33

endoftheline - What decent man would leave their wife and children in a country at war to find a safer country to take them to. If that was my husband he would make sure that me and the children were taken to safety first. Imagine if that had happened here during World War 2. None of us would be here typing on MN.

orangeleavesinautumn · 18/07/2023 08:32

dontchaknow · 18/07/2023 08:21

Of course we all have sympathy for genuine refugees, but there are an awful lot of people abusing our sympathy and posing as refugees.
With regard to genuine refugees, with the best will in the world, we can't take them all in. For example, under current rules, anyone fleeing sexual persecution who can prove it will (eventually) be allowed residency. So that means that the entire female and non straight population of, for example, Afghanistan is eligible.

OMG, do you really beehive the regurgitated platitudes dribbling out of your mouth!

The vast majority of people applying for asylum in the UK are found to be genuine refugees when their cases are examined

We are not talking about taking them all, We are not even talking about taking our fair share, on this thread,

We are talking about processing the people who are here and waiting, and looking after them in a humane way while they are waiting

ie, protection from human trafficker, and a legal limit to the time a child can be detained! Both of which the government has rejected

OP posts: