Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He is not in love with her 2 weeks before wedding

366 replies

grassverge · 18/07/2023 00:06

Alfie has decided 2 weeks before their wedding that he does not want to get married and doesn’t love Claire. They have a new 10 year mortgage together, a two year old and his 3 kids from a previous marriage. She has paid 300k deposit on house and 20k on wedding. He paid 0 deposit but needs his salary for the mortgage. She is in shock and is willing to go ahead with the marriage if he will agree. Claire has only told me, a friend and is too embarrassed to tell anyone else. She is hoping he will change his mind. I want to say end it no matter if he changes his mind AIBU?

OP posts:
AndyMcFlurry · 18/07/2023 08:44

grassverge · 18/07/2023 00:21

I think Claire is in shock and embarrassed to tell her guests who have booked leave and bought hotel rooms and outfits. She cannot think straight. I have no idea why Alfie is doing this to her.

Yes of course she is shocked , embarrassed and humiliated . Id be worried too about the money that people have spent.

But she needs to call it off today . The usual way of doing this is that the hosts ( people whose name is on the invitation ) contact all the guests with this one line

“ The wedding of Claire and Alfie that was planned for Saturday 26 August will no longer take place “.

Normally that’s done by post but in view of the timescale here, email would be better . Someone else (NOT claire , her parents / bridesmaids etc ) needs to phone anyone for whom you don’t have an email address.

You don’t give anymore explanation in writing that that. People who need to know the detail will phone Claire’s mother / best mates etc . You need to protect Claire from having to deal with a hundred phone calls.

That gives guests time to cancel their hotel booking ( most will give refunds until a few days beforehand ) and return new dresses / outfits. If there is anyone from her side that she knows is in a dire financial situation because of this, Claire can always offer to give then some money towards it .

Id not recommend this but it it might make Claire feel better about it and it will cost less that £150,000. Most people who have a £300k deposit also have friends who can cope with the loss of a hotel room deposit.

Most employers will let staff cancel annual leave with a few weeks notice . Or people can make other plans for the day.

She needs to do this today . Guest will be annoyed if she knew it was off but didn’t let them know asap.

Freinds / bridesmaids / her family also need to hep her notify all wedding suppliers IN WRITING asap and check the contracts to see how much money they can get back . Also notify her wedding insurers ( if she took out insurance ).

Alfie almost certainly is cheating on her . I know two people who were in this situation . The first bride cancelled - all the guests were shocked but understood . None of us wanted her to marry that man.

The second bride didn’t - she persuaded him it was just cold feet and to go ahead . The marriage lasted 4 months and ended in a very tragic way.

I’m very sorry for Claire but better a broken engagement than a divorce. This is going to be a few weeks of work and a few months of humiliation. A bad marriage will be years of pain and hurt for her and her child. let alone the financial consequences which Pp have explained .

JFDIYOLO · 18/07/2023 08:43

I think it's highly possible there's someone else. A Camilla in the mix, and if so, better she is exposed now than discovered too late.

You mention he has children - what happened there? Did he leave? Did she leave? Was C the OW? Basically - does he have form?

Farrowandballbag · 18/07/2023 08:43

My brother had this conversation with his fiancé before the wedding, and was persuaded it was cold feet and normal. One year in he told her his feelings hadn't changed- a further year of counselling, trying to make it work and then they separated. 2 years for the divorce to go through making a total of 4 wasted years and much more heartbreak than if he had been sure in his feelings and wasn't swayed by the embarrassment of cancelling.

Shouldbedoing · 18/07/2023 08:43

Friends, family and guests will respect her bravery.
He's been brave too, actually. Wedding plans tend to take off and grow and grow.
Protect your finances Jane.

From a stranger on the internet Please 🙏

AngelinaFibres · 18/07/2023 08:42

My son and DIL were supposed to be attending a wedding in Italy in September. Its all off because the groom has been appearing on Only Fans with another woman, doing BDSM stuff ( not passively watching in his bedroom but actually 'starring' in the films with this woman). He has also been sexting other women. It has all come out and everything is off. There have been difficulties for guests because it was at a remote venue in Tuscany( flights ,rooms paid for to somewhere you wouldn't go unless you were going to that specific venue)but no one is blaming her for calling it off.
Another friend was jilted the night before her wedding. They shared a flat which he owned and when she got home he wasn't there and there was a letter on the table asking her to move out and telling her it was all off. He was Canadian and all his family and friends had flown in for the wedding ,presents had been delivered etc. It was awful but , years later, she is happily married to someone else. .

ThatFraggle · 18/07/2023 08:41

>He has not paid a penny towards the wedding.

This suggests he was never really invested.

3BSHKATS · 18/07/2023 08:41

grassverge · 18/07/2023 00:21

I think Claire is in shock and embarrassed to tell her guests who have booked leave and bought hotel rooms and outfits. She cannot think straight. I have no idea why Alfie is doing this to her.

I have no idea why Alfie is doing this to her.I have no idea why Alfie is doing this to her.

something to do with the fact that it’s not costing him at Penny to get his hands on over £150,000 of equity I would imagine.

No way in hell, would I marry a man who wasn’t paying half towards the wedding and the house deposit

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 18/07/2023 08:41

grassverge · 18/07/2023 08:37

I should have mentioned her deposit is ring-fenced in a trust? Or something of that nature. However she will have to sell the house as she cannot afford it on her salary alone also the penalties of getting out of the new mortgage will be huge.

I would be expecting him to pay any penalties.

LookItsMeAgain · 18/07/2023 08:40

An old neighbour of mine pulled out of their wedding 2 days before the wedding day.

2 DAYS.

It was the best decision for them at the time.

Claire - don't do it. You will only live to regret it.

Best of luck to you with this decision.

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 18/07/2023 08:39

Claire, it won't feel like it now but Alfie is doing the right thing by you here.

He clearly cares about you and your future relationship otherwise he would just have gone ahead regardless.

It would be very wrong for him to continue knowing he doesn't love you. I hope one day you will see that.

Brace yourself for the appearance of another woman. Not guaranteed of course but unfortunately very common.

I'm so sorry love. Do not try to talk him into it.

greenbeansnspinach · 18/07/2023 08:37

She is distraught, betrayed, confused … disbelieving … my heart goes out to her. She can however carry this off with dignity - either go ahead with a gathering for family and friends, or cancel it. The people who care about her will be absolutely fine with it either way.
agree with everyone else that there is no way she should demean herself to beg a man who doesn’t love her (and whatever we feel about the man, probably it took some courage to tell her at this stage) to go ahead. More and more heartbreak would lie ahead.

grassverge · 18/07/2023 08:37

I should have mentioned her deposit is ring-fenced in a trust? Or something of that nature. However she will have to sell the house as she cannot afford it on her salary alone also the penalties of getting out of the new mortgage will be huge.

OP posts:
GoodChat · 18/07/2023 08:37

YeahIsaidit · 18/07/2023 08:13

Haven't rtft but it's interesting that a lot of the comments I've seen so far have been "he'll take her money" and not poor woman shouldn't marry someone that doesn't love her

And she needs his wages to pay the mortgage on a house she's paid a £300k deposit so it sounds like she got an inheritance or something, and he's pulling out before the wedding, which suggests he's not after her money at all

JFDIYOLO · 18/07/2023 08:37

I'm reminded of the story of Princess Diana telling her sister she was having cold feet about marrying the Prince of Wales and getting the reply you can't back out now, your face is on the tea towels.

So what if people have booked leave, bought the dress etc.

This is her life and future happiness and falling into a legally binding contract with someone who doesn't love her is way worse than tearing it up before it's signed.

'He informed me he doesn't love me and doesn't want to marry me, so the wedding is cancelled. He'll be handling any comments or enquiries.'

If any gifts have already arrived, returning them will of course be his responsibility and expense.

Everyone who matters will understand.

HappyasLarrynot · 18/07/2023 08:36

Please tell her to take some of the advice of the posters on here and just get some of her friends to tell everyone else. My ExH told me a couple of years after we got married that he knew he shouldn’t have married me but he did anyway. I would have been beyond mortified at the time but it would have been better than loving with the crap that followed. He doesn’t want to marry her, it’s so horrible for her but she needs to put her big girl pants on and just call it off.

grassverge · 18/07/2023 08:35

Claire loves him and desperately wants him to change his mind. I agree that to go ahead would be terrible and the sooner she cancels the better. However, I think the hope is killing her. I wish he would man up and start cancelling everything for her sake. He has not paid a penny towards the wedding.

OP posts:
TheSeaDoesntKnowMyName · 18/07/2023 08:34

grassverge · 18/07/2023 08:08

Do you think she has any chance of getting some money back from the venue? They won’t have bought the food yet. Food for 112 people would be a lot of money.

Better she loses a relatively small amount now, than half (or more) of her house

Fuck embarrassment

Ducksinthebath · 18/07/2023 08:33

The first thing Claire needs to do is get some proper legal advice. Assuming in England or Wales, if joint tenants then the £300k might already be subject to sharing on sale unless they can now agree something other than 50/50. Even if Tenants In Common they might still be 50/50 but hopefully not.

Whereas married she might have a claim for maintenance and be able to (part)fund the house for a year or two while she tries to arrange to buy him out or the market hopefully recovers and she can get a better sale price.

Been through all this myself and lost half a deposit despite not being married.

First port of call is her property solicitor then find a family solicitor.

Purplecatshopaholic · 18/07/2023 08:33

Of course Claire doesn’t marry him. It’s an expensive divorce waiting to happen. Better a little embarrassment now than a shit ton of it later!

CaramelMac · 18/07/2023 08:28

It will be far more embarrassing for her if she goes through with the wedding and her guests find out when they (inevitably) separate shortly after, and they’ll all be annoyed with her that they gave gifts and spent money on attending the wedding when if she cancels it now they can return the gifts and outfits and possibly get a refund on their accommodation!

If he was willing to leave the mother of his first three children be in no doubt her will happily dump her to move on to the next woman, whether they’ve had a wedding or not.

ThatFraggle · 18/07/2023 08:26

There was that woman who turned the reception into a family party when the wedding did not go ahead, since they were not going to be able to get money back.

AngelinaFibres · 18/07/2023 08:23

grassverge · 18/07/2023 00:21

I think Claire is in shock and embarrassed to tell her guests who have booked leave and bought hotel rooms and outfits. She cannot think straight. I have no idea why Alfie is doing this to her.

He is doing it to her now because the deadline is looming and he can't put it off any longer. He will have been pushing it to the back of his mind and worrying about it in the early hours for months. He has probably hoped it would be okay and that he would suddenly feel that he did love Claire and it would be okay. He now has to absolutely face the fact that he feels sick to the pit of his stomach and simply can't do it. The thought of the wedding is now worse than the lost money ( if he is actually losing any wedding money) and the momentary 'shame' of calling it off and the complications of untying the joint assets.A wedding is much easier to get out of than a marriage. She will be devastated now but in the long run it will be so much better than being with a man who doesn't want to be there. My exhusband had huge doubts. I think my teenage bridesmaid ( his sister,then aged 15) knew he wasn't okay. She stayed at my house the night before and ,just before we went to sleep she said ' what will you do if he doesn't turn up'. I laughed. I thought it was all a beautiful fairy tale of true luuuuurve. He left me a few years ,and 2 tiny children ,later. The best man knew he had massive doubts. I wish he had told me ,run away, got someone else to tell me. I would have been absolutely devastated but it would have been a lot easier than what finally happened.

Jk987 · 18/07/2023 08:22

summerisontheway · 18/07/2023 00:24

So she has taken on his 3 kids from his previous marriage and he doesn't want to marry her despite this and the fact they have a 2 year old together.
Call me old-fashioned but it really is best to not have kids until the relationship is legally formalised.

1/ Marriage has to be about love.
2/ it's a good job she didn't marry him before having their child. He'd be entitled to her assets inc. her 300k house deposit if they were.

OP - she needs her friends and family to surround her and support her while she exits this relationship. Can some of you go and stay in the hotel that was booked? Make use of some of the money spent.

Catsmere · 18/07/2023 08:21

YeahIsaidit · 18/07/2023 08:20

If you have to persuade someone to marry you, it's doomed

Absolutely!

jdebalt · 18/07/2023 08:20

He will have cheated on her. My ex husband told me a couple of months before we got married that he "loved me but wasn't sure he was in love with me". Thankfully I was doing up a house so only spent £5k on the wedding. We did get married, I discovered late on (after 5 years?) that he had been cheating on me with everyone conceivable - escorts, Ashley Madison, people he worked with...you name it. Limped on for a couple more years and then he cheated on me again and left. Best thing that ever happened to me. So I could have saved 7 years of wasted time, money and an STD that nearly caused me to be infertile. (Thankfully too never wants children with him, must have been instinctive). Now very happily married to a wonderful man who adores me and just had IVF embryo transfer as am 44. If she can bear to hear it, do remind her that cancelling a wedding is much the lesser of two evils as someone said previously. I hope she's ok. She will be in the long run.

Swipe left for the next trending thread