Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What happens if the scapegoat child becomes successful in life and has a happy marriage?

107 replies

AliceMay55 · 17/07/2023 19:14

Would a Narc parent want the scapegoat to have an unhappy marriage?
asking because my husband routinely tells them sad stories and makes it appear as though we are quite miserable together. It’s absolutely not the case in reality. He says they assume things, but why would they?

OP posts:
Catcatcatcatcat · 18/07/2023 07:36

Honestly, tell them to fuck off. Nothing you ever do will be good enough anyway.

How dare they be dismissive of you in your own home? Going NC was the best thing I ever did for myself.

Oh, and being golden child isn’t all that either. My poor brothers MH is shot to pieces and he’s alcoholic on the back of her manipulating and pressure. I love him to bits and don’t blame him at all. It’s affected him too, just differently. Harder for him to go NC and escape the bitch.

Curseofthenation · 18/07/2023 06:59

Off topic, but why are you running round making them teas and coffees?! Meals I get but they can bloody well get up and make their own drinks if they can't be arsed to talk to you.

In terms of being in equal positions now, I would just keep saying how proud you are that your DH has managed to work his way up to the same level.

As a bonus, I might even be really annoying and do things like give DH a high five after doing a chore together in front of ILs and saying 'team work makes the dream work' just to really piss them off. I am a petty creature though. Negative people like your ILs find happiness and optimism unbearable.

AliceMay55 · 18/07/2023 06:51

Also, there is some weird assumption set in stone. some how, DH is way brighter than me, I am lucky to have him. Despite my multiple promotions, earning more than DH, one level above him professionally for years until yesterday (equal level now). Yet, they talk like SIL and me are at the same level. Wtf 🤬

OP posts:
AliceMay55 · 18/07/2023 06:48

I am NC with the golden child SIL. DH is VLC with her and all her one-way “gifting” from us has stopped. She called and had a go at DH a few months ago - saying “you never helped me”. Wtf ! Why does she need helping out?

This has been grating inlaws. FIL wants us to speak to her. Why? She is happy, we are happy - so what’s the problem?

There is something really weird about SIL. Her DH has a great job. She never worked a day in her life. They never bought a house because they always wanted a 5 bed detached house within 10mins from central London. Like from day 1! They don’t have that kind of money. We bought a flat in Croydon, then traded to a 3 bed semi in Tunbridge Wells, now in a 5 bed detached in TW. SIL now constantly moans they don’t have a house. Inlaws feel really sorry for her. This, with DHs pay hike, set the bomb off.

I really wish I could pack them off, if they don’t start to behave. The nerve of giving me silent treatment in my own house, while I still do their teas, coffees, meals etc.

OP posts:
GreyCarpet · 18/07/2023 06:40

I could quote so much from these responses! I recognise so much from my own life but the main one is the following.

I bet your in laws feel so smug every time your DH makes our your marriage is rubbish. He needs to stop.

This is so important. Four months after I went NC with my mum, my dad died and my marriage broke down. Not having my mother in my life to enjoy it was the only thing that got me through. Your husband needs to understand what is happening. And stop feeding it.

ConnieTucker · 18/07/2023 06:38

Kingsparkle · 18/07/2023 00:23

Mine threw a tantrum they’d not been given a big enough role in the wedding. Came up with a written list of 5 ways I’d slighted them on my wedding day. Then threw themselves a second wedding a few months later complete with white lace dress and a big party.

They also think my DH is either too good for me and I boss him around and make him miserable or he is weird and weak because he is isn’t “alpha male”. It’s weird, they are weird. There is no logic to it.

My mum ignored me on my wedding day. She gave me old new borrowed blue things on the thurs before and i asked if the 6 pence was old or borrowed and she hit the roof screaming i was ungrateful. She didnt attend the rehearsal on the friday. Showed up at my house for photos and to go in the car with the bridesmaids but ignores me all morning. Posed smiling. Ignored me. When she left for the church, still ignoring me, the photographers mouth was on the floor.

her behaviour was so bad my sister cancelled her wedding saying she couldnt deal with her. She never bother to get married and has been ‘engaged’ now for 20 years.

if it isnt about my mum she will make everyone else miserable.

Kingsparkle · 18/07/2023 00:23

Mine threw a tantrum they’d not been given a big enough role in the wedding. Came up with a written list of 5 ways I’d slighted them on my wedding day. Then threw themselves a second wedding a few months later complete with white lace dress and a big party.

They also think my DH is either too good for me and I boss him around and make him miserable or he is weird and weak because he is isn’t “alpha male”. It’s weird, they are weird. There is no logic to it.

GarlicGrace · 18/07/2023 00:17

I think DH is playing them right. I'd recommend taking your lead from him. Perhaps it's appropriate to remind you you are not dealing with sane & rational human beings. You can throw logic & reason at them all day long, it will not alter their perspective one whit. Or it might, but only to your detriment - mentally disordered people are extremely threatened by attacks on their constructed world view, and will retaliate in fury.

Do you know about the "grey rock" approach? Look it up. DH has got it down to a fine art, by the sound of things.

Brokendaughter · 18/07/2023 00:01

If you are the designated failure/black sheep in your family, in my experience nothing you ever do that doesn't play into that is good enough, or deserved, or something to be proud of.
If you do better than siblings who weren't meant to be the failure you can never make it right & somehow their failure to exceed you will be your fault too.

Those kind of parents expect you to stay in your lane & will insist on doing their utmost to put you back there if you let them.

Leave them to their delusions & get on with being happy.

You can't reason with that sort of toxic & if you engage it will only ever make you feel worse than if you ignore it.

babysharkdoodoodedoodedoo · 18/07/2023 00:00

I was the scapegoat child, I am now NC with my parents. My mum, before I went NC, would continue to try to manipulate and control me and if I stood for myself, would try to get my husband on her side by acting as though I was so horrible and unreasonable and that she and him ought to stick together and wait for me to stop being awful. Once I left her home and she tried to convince DH to stay there overnight to teach me some kind of weird lesson! (Her husband was there too, nothing weird going on! Just wanted me to feel isolated I guess.) in my experience, they might like it if they feel your marriage is crap and YOU might also end up being insulted and criticised - my mum used to be awful about my DH and act as though he were useless and that poor old her had to pick up the pieces and help us both! Not that anyone wanted her help, and there wasn’t even anything to help with. But it made her feel extra superior. I bet your in laws feel so smug every time your DH makes our your marriage is rubbish. He needs to stop.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 17/07/2023 23:56

Ffs OP! Tell them if they can't be civil to you in your own house, while you're doing them a massive favour, then they can get out. Now.

Dump their stuff in the garden, and tell them to call SIL.

Then don't bother with them ever again.

honeylulu · 17/07/2023 23:46

Yes it's interesting. My sister is golden child and I am scapegoat. All my childhood and youth I got told I'd never make anything of my life, wouldn't be able to hold down a job, would never marry. It made me determined to do those things but then when I did I got the feeling my parents were annoyed I had proved them wrong. Conversely my sister hasn't had much of a career and has even said that I've "got the life everyone thinks she should have had". I'm happy with my life but none of them are happy for me, silly arses.

AIBUNoNoNo · 17/07/2023 23:09

I suspect it's because it highlights you are a team - supporting each other, encouraging confidence being happy in each other's success.
My narc Mum prefers divide & rule & moan, tis not enough to succeed others must fail/bitch/be disappointed. Try having a moan about your DHs success, she be able to tear the pair of you apart and report to others that'll that career success hasn't made you happy, golden child would of course handle a prize so much better.

GreyCarpet · 17/07/2023 23:06

My mother would have revelled in the thought that I was unhappy. She deliberately sabotaged me on many occasions.

She was spiteful/dismissive about my siccesses and positively overjoyed about my 'failures'.

She used to call my then husband when she knew I was out to bitch about me and try and get him onside. Tbf, he handled her brilliantly.

If she perceived me to have done better than my brother in some way (eg I got a better class of degree than he did) she was hugely critical of me. She saw me doing well as a personal affront. Almost as thought I'd done it deliberately to get one over on my brother and she had to defend him as a result. My brother was always really proud of me and didn't see it that way it has to be said.

AliceMay55 · 17/07/2023 22:58

I’m struggling to understand todays drama though.

How is DHs payrise my fault exactly? Why am I getting the silent treatment while they are talking as normal to DH ?

OP posts:
AliceMay55 · 17/07/2023 22:57

AIBUNoNoNo · 17/07/2023 22:51

I'm the scapegoat, my brother is golden balls. Just after my dad died, my mum & brother were sat at lunch with extended family talking about how they could take me down a peg or two with embarrassing stories. My brother was sacked for gross misconduct and is an unemployed alcoholic. I & DH work in interesting fields - never asked.
DH & I have been together 29 years, they cropped photos to remove him, never mentioned at the funeral...Golden balls partner was named in the will, especially thanked by my mum. My mum can't say enough great stuff about the pair of them even though DH & I did a lot of heavy lifting & logistics. DH is never named or acknowledged. They'd be so pleased if we split.
Golden balls is seperating but still their partnership only this evening was been praised to the heavens. My narc Mum has recently overplayed her hand and has been a bit too obvious in her dislike for us. It has made life easier to push it all into a 'its her not me' box.

That’s exactly how I get treated ! (Scapegoat’s spouse)

OP posts:
AIBUNoNoNo · 17/07/2023 22:51

I'm the scapegoat, my brother is golden balls. Just after my dad died, my mum & brother were sat at lunch with extended family talking about how they could take me down a peg or two with embarrassing stories. My brother was sacked for gross misconduct and is an unemployed alcoholic. I & DH work in interesting fields - never asked.
DH & I have been together 29 years, they cropped photos to remove him, never mentioned at the funeral...Golden balls partner was named in the will, especially thanked by my mum. My mum can't say enough great stuff about the pair of them even though DH & I did a lot of heavy lifting & logistics. DH is never named or acknowledged. They'd be so pleased if we split.
Golden balls is seperating but still their partnership only this evening was been praised to the heavens. My narc Mum has recently overplayed her hand and has been a bit too obvious in her dislike for us. It has made life easier to push it all into a 'its her not me' box.

AliceMay55 · 17/07/2023 21:57

thanks all for sharing your thoughts and experiences. Right now they are living with us for a couple of
months while their house gets refurbished.

SIL is the golden child. She is a housewife, yet can’t be bothered to have them as she is busy managing 2 kids. I work full time and we have 3 kids, yet I’m not!

Right now they are talking to DH, but I’m getting silent treatment. FIL told me I’m lucky because DH got a hike but SIL’s DH doesn’t get paid as much. Wtf? How is that even relevant? As though DH should be turning down the money as he will now be making more than SILs husband!! Also, I didn’t get a pay rise - DH got. Why am I lucky because of money? DH was never “Lucky” when I made more than him for years. Fed up of all the drama !

OP posts:
Elsiebear90 · 17/07/2023 19:57

My MIL is a narc and my wife is the scapegoat, in their case my MIL is intensely jealous of my wife and will often say how she is so surprised my wife has done well for herself as she always thought her brother was smarter. She tries to sabotage happy moments, completely ignores them or makes them about herself by having some kind of health crisis, starting drama so the attention is on her or trying to play the victim, whereas she heaps praise upon my BIL and is intensely proud of him.

My BIL works as a HCA and gets heaps and heaps of praise for this and how clever he is and how important he is and all the things he does at work, whereas my wife is a band 8 and she couldn’t be less interested.

She was a complete nightmare during our wedding planning because she cannot get over her divorce from my father in law. She tries to convince my wife I’m cheating on her with one of my friends, didn’t acknowledge our engagement was making digs about it and then stormed off in tears because we weren’t giving her enough attention about her holiday, told my wife she doesn’t deserve a diamond that big on her engagement ring, threatened repeatedly not to come to her hen do, cancelled on my wife’s dress fitting, refused to see her on Mother’s Day because we refused to drive her three hours to the venue and back the day before and day after our wedding because she wanted to stay in a different hotel, told us her hotel room we booked for her wasn’t good enough, started so much drama at the wedding to make the whole thing about how hard it was for her to see her ex with his new wife.

We are going in for fertility treatment and she has made a number of comments trying to make my wife feel insecure about not carrying the baby by saying things like the baby won’t be anything to do with her and her family and insinuating that because I’m not using my wife’s egg (because it’s too bloody expensive) that it’s because I don’t want a child that’s my wife’s.

So yeah she’s an absolute nightmare any time my wife has a success or happy occasion and tries to spoil it for her.

Tooyoungtofeelthisold · 17/07/2023 19:45

They dont want happiness that they could never conceive of for themselves.

If the scapegoat child has a successful and happy life, they won't be around to see it. I'm a great believer that if you have the ability to break free of all of the misconceptions you'd known growing up with narcs, that you'd drop tge narcs as part of your happier life.

YesSirMam · 17/07/2023 19:43

Still trying to break mine free. Watching with interest

Catcatcatcatcat · 17/07/2023 19:36

Treacletoots · 17/07/2023 19:23

@ConnieTucker this totally. Mine said she gave me the drive to succeed by kicking me out on the streets aged 15. Sure. Neglect/drive to succeed, very similar 🤔

Me too, although I was 16. But I was dressed only in my nightie!

OP, they will be FURIOUS. They will do everything they can to fuck things up either directly or indirectly by undermining the scapegoat. They will remind him how shit he really is, cos they really know him and the people supporting him right now just haven’t realised what a loser he is.

Is there a reason why he’s still in contact with them?

Nowitstarts · 17/07/2023 19:32

OMG we've been NC with DH parents for 20 years and everything described here is absolutely the way they are. For years blamed myself for not being able to smooth things over. It all came to a head the day we bought a bigger house than theirs!

My parents were just thrilled for us and I really didn't understand what was going on.

RecklessBlackberries · 17/07/2023 19:28

Scapegoat isn't really the word I'd use to describe myself but my mum definitely has narcissistic tendencies and I am the less favoured child.

I have a very happy marriage and we're getting on fine with our child. My mum is just contrary about everything. If I'm happy about something, she'll find a way to downplay it or burst my bubble. If I'm sad about something, that thing is actually great and I'm unappreciative. My husband can do no wrong, so I'm always in the wrong if we disagree on something. I'm sure it will be the same with my children when they get older.

Michiru · 17/07/2023 19:26

I can't comment on the happy relationship part as ime scapegoat children are generally emotionally quite screwed up and need a LOT of work to not fall back into old patterns - something I haven't achieved yet.

When I told my mother I was getting married she looked like thunder, only perked up once she was able to talk about my golden child sister again (who had finally managed to learn to cook at the grand old age of 33).

I am successful in my job and everyday life other than social interactions. Every success I had, she managed to sour somehow.

Be it getting great A-levels (she criticised me for the one A despite me being top of my entire year, getting more A-levels and more at A* than anyone else).

She refused to speak to me for 4 whole weeks while I made plans to move abroad, getting accepted at any university I applied to.

She was so happy when me getting pregnant and then left meant my degree was at risk, but miserable when I did it anyway, despite doing the whole thing as a lone parent.

She was even more miserable when I bought my first house, knowing my sister would never have the money (no doubt by now she has been gifted enough for her own deposit; I had to work for every penny).

She loved it when I got divorced and has conspired with my ex ever since. She has alienated me from the entire family after my last grandparent died.

I severed contact completely many years ago now and I am happier for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread