Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make new mum life easier?

814 replies

Animallover87 · 17/07/2023 16:08

Due my first baby next month.

I know it'll be a huge life change and I'm keen to try and protect my mental health as far as possible by taking steps to make life a bit easier.

For example, I'm not going to try and breastfeed. I've bought a prep machine and was considering just using ready made formula for out and about to avoid faff.

Having a planned c section which most people seem to recover fairly quickly from and allows me to feel a bit more in control of what's going to happen.

Next 2 me on my DHs side of the bed so he can do the lifting baby etc during the night if I'm struggling with movement after c section at the beginning.

Any other tips, even if unpopular, to make life easier for myself as a first time mum?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Confusion101 · 23/07/2023 09:30

@Muthaofcats apologising yet you still continue to insult... Nobody on this thread wants to have the breast v formula debate, because the OP didn't want any info on it, and it's the reason she has since left the thread too! It is horrible to tell somebody they are setting their child up to be disadvantaged because you don't agree with one of their parenting techniques!

At the end of the day, through my own research (of which there was a lot), I am happy with the decision I made to not breastfeed. She has maintained her centile weight, she has reached every milestone, and any minor illness that she picked up her breastfed cousin also picked up. The only reason I doubt my decision is because I have to put up with rude, obnoxious comments from people like you! Think before you speak!!

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 09:16

Emotionalmama · 23/07/2023 09:02

I’m not trolling my own family - what I said is fact. Did they reach their milestones later than me? Yes. Are they less intelligent? Yes. Has it got to do with being FF or BF? Well for the sake of your argument I hope not because the correlation isn’t what you’re arguing.

You literally told an expectant mother to be that she’s putting her baby at a disadvantage. What works for one doesn’t work for someone else. I really don’t care if people breast fed, bottle feed, elective section, natural birth etc. there is no ‘best’ way; every mother and baby is different so just do what works for you! honestly who cares what anyone else is doing but don’t come on like so many other posters here being a sanctimonious so and so and try to tell women what they’re doing is wrong. Motherhood is hard and every mother should be encouraged to do whatever is easier. Provide perfect NHS data all you want but do not come on and tell someone they’re putting their baby at a disadvantage because of a perfectly legitimate choice for her baby. Ps you might want to look at maternal mental health on the NHS website whilst you’re at it.

yes sorry if the disadvantage point didn’t seem considerate. I can see that pointing at the objective data alone isn’t considering the fuller picture about how such a statement might land so apols for that.

I was concerned about the number of incorrect comments circulating and the statements that formula is just as good. That doesn’t meant I’m a troll or trying to upset the OP. Which I was at pains to reiterate.

mumsnet makes its money off of the breast v formula debate and people get extremely upset whenever anyone tries to correct misinformation. I just find it curious that we are in a world where people saying what you don’t want to hear is bullying or trolling.

Our future generations are all screwed and it won’t be because of how they got their milk!!

Emotionalmama · 23/07/2023 09:02

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 08:44

I’m not suggesting it, the data is? I’m not trying to be unpleasant or cause any feelings of shame. I’m saying that statistically formula fed and summer born babies are shown to be at a disadvantage. That’s just objective.

Does it mean ALL formula fed babies are screwed. Of course not. There are so many factors at play, but to say formula is equivalent and just as good as breast milk is incorrect if you base your approach on data rather than opinion, and that’s the only point I was addressing. Whilst being clear to state there are lots of reasons one may not breast feed and that I explicitly wasn’t judging the decision, rather the reinforcement of false statements like ‘fed is best’.

Youre the one trolling your own family online saying your cousins kids aren’t intelligent. Yet someone literally just referring to the data published on the NHS is a troll? Why do my comments engender such a strong emotional reaction if you’re so happy with your choices ?

I’m not trolling my own family - what I said is fact. Did they reach their milestones later than me? Yes. Are they less intelligent? Yes. Has it got to do with being FF or BF? Well for the sake of your argument I hope not because the correlation isn’t what you’re arguing.

You literally told an expectant mother to be that she’s putting her baby at a disadvantage. What works for one doesn’t work for someone else. I really don’t care if people breast fed, bottle feed, elective section, natural birth etc. there is no ‘best’ way; every mother and baby is different so just do what works for you! honestly who cares what anyone else is doing but don’t come on like so many other posters here being a sanctimonious so and so and try to tell women what they’re doing is wrong. Motherhood is hard and every mother should be encouraged to do whatever is easier. Provide perfect NHS data all you want but do not come on and tell someone they’re putting their baby at a disadvantage because of a perfectly legitimate choice for her baby. Ps you might want to look at maternal mental health on the NHS website whilst you’re at it.

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 08:58

Fingerscrossedfor2021HK · 23/07/2023 08:50

Oh and @Muthaofcats I was a summer, formula fed baby and I can assure you that I suffered zero disadvantages from that. I’m 5’11” and spent a decade working as a city lawyer after obtaining a first from one of the uk’s best universities. I also learned a little something called compassion and about not writing horrible messages to strangers on the internet. Does putting other people down make you happy?

Sorry you found what I wrote upsetting. Wasn’t my intention.

I appreciate it’s a highly emotive subject.

glad to see you’ve done so well, that’s brilliant !

Fingerscrossedfor2021HK · 23/07/2023 08:50

Oh and @Muthaofcats I was a summer, formula fed baby and I can assure you that I suffered zero disadvantages from that. I’m 5’11” and spent a decade working as a city lawyer after obtaining a first from one of the uk’s best universities. I also learned a little something called compassion and about not writing horrible messages to strangers on the internet. Does putting other people down make you happy?

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 08:48

Confusion101 · 23/07/2023 08:34

@Muthaofcats I'm not in the UK. I already know what age she will be starting school at. I don't need your unsolicited advice, thanks!

the whole point of mumsnet is unsolicited advice :) we’d all be better off reading scientific papers….

If your child isn’t in the U.K. then they’re highly likely to be starting school much older than just turned 4 so the issue isn’t likely to affect them anyway

Fingerscrossedfor2021HK · 23/07/2023 08:47

OP - please ignore the boob mafia. My son couldn’t breastfeed and I spent 3 months expressing for him, severely damaging my mental and physical health in the process. It was NOT worth it and when I have my second I will likely formula feed after the first few weeks. Formula is a godsend. Try HiPP Combiotic - the baby’s poop is indistinguishable from a breastfed baby (for all those who say formula makes them constipated etc) and he is thriving. It also comes in ready to drink newborn size bottles which will make your life so much easier in hospital! The stage 2 is also available in ready to drink which is great for out and about / travelling.

And btw, my son was a c section summer baby. He is ahead on every milestone, tall for his age and I expect he will end up clever and healthy just like my husband and me. The studies on the benefits of breastfeeding are not actually that conclusive (see the work by Emily Oster in this topic, as already mentioned by others). Genetics and the home in which a child is raised okay a vastly more important role than breast milk.

I am sick of women tearing other women down for their perfectly rational choices. OP is not asking whether she should drink or smoke while pregnant, formula is perfectly safe and healthy. And so are c sections.

To all of those shaming the OP - it’s not your body and it’s not your baby. If you don’t want to formula feed then don’t formula feed! If you don’t want a section then don’t (plan to) have one! Her choices are rational and perfectly understandable.

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 08:44

Emotionalmama · 23/07/2023 08:32

Aye because my post screams ashamed. You’re literally suggesting kids are at a disadvantage being FF as opposed to BF. Wise up. It’s hard enough becoming a new mum without trolls like you trying to stir unneeded self doubt.

I’m not suggesting it, the data is? I’m not trying to be unpleasant or cause any feelings of shame. I’m saying that statistically formula fed and summer born babies are shown to be at a disadvantage. That’s just objective.

Does it mean ALL formula fed babies are screwed. Of course not. There are so many factors at play, but to say formula is equivalent and just as good as breast milk is incorrect if you base your approach on data rather than opinion, and that’s the only point I was addressing. Whilst being clear to state there are lots of reasons one may not breast feed and that I explicitly wasn’t judging the decision, rather the reinforcement of false statements like ‘fed is best’.

Youre the one trolling your own family online saying your cousins kids aren’t intelligent. Yet someone literally just referring to the data published on the NHS is a troll? Why do my comments engender such a strong emotional reaction if you’re so happy with your choices ?

Confusion101 · 23/07/2023 08:34

@Muthaofcats I'm not in the UK. I already know what age she will be starting school at. I don't need your unsolicited advice, thanks!

Emotionalmama · 23/07/2023 08:32

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 08:29

No one is shaming anyone.

Sharing information to correct ignorant assertions is not shaming.

If you feel ashamed at your choice that’s on you.

Aye because my post screams ashamed. You’re literally suggesting kids are at a disadvantage being FF as opposed to BF. Wise up. It’s hard enough becoming a new mum without trolls like you trying to stir unneeded self doubt.

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 08:29

Emotionalmama · 23/07/2023 08:26

Oh seriously stop talking balls. Formula fed baby here with great health, great development milestone wise (walking at 10 months, talking before I should have), amazing grades (only referencing because that seemed to be thrown into the mix) and high end finance job in my mid 20s and also FF my own 6 weeks old baby. Cousins who have been breastfed have health issues, not as intelligent, reached milestones faaaar later etc etc.

PS If you’re reading this thinking the difference between myself and cousins has nothing to do with breastfed or formula fed well then well done; you’ve got the exact point of the post - it makes no bloody difference so stop shaming formula mums.

No one is shaming anyone.

Sharing information to correct ignorant assertions is not shaming.

If you feel ashamed at your choice that’s on you.

AliTheMinx · 23/07/2023 08:26

Forgot to add that a good baby monitor was always helpful - we had one with the sensor mat - and I had a little speaker so that during feeds I could play soothing music (I think Baby Einstein!) :-)

Emotionalmama · 23/07/2023 08:26

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:15

Not screwed but certainly already at a disadvantage.

Oh seriously stop talking balls. Formula fed baby here with great health, great development milestone wise (walking at 10 months, talking before I should have), amazing grades (only referencing because that seemed to be thrown into the mix) and high end finance job in my mid 20s and also FF my own 6 weeks old baby. Cousins who have been breastfed have health issues, not as intelligent, reached milestones faaaar later etc etc.

PS If you’re reading this thinking the difference between myself and cousins has nothing to do with breastfed or formula fed well then well done; you’ve got the exact point of the post - it makes no bloody difference so stop shaming formula mums.

AliTheMinx · 23/07/2023 08:22

God - this is a nasty thread. OP - ignore the horrid comments and do what is right for you. I admire you for wanting to be prepared. I also chose not to breastfeed and, despite the hatred from others, it was a good decision for our family. My DH absolutely loved sharing the feeds, and bonded closely with DS from the outset, as did I. Despite not breastfeeding, there was lots of skin to skin contact and endless cuddles. DS could not have been more loved. We found DS liked milk at room temperature, so to make things easier, we used the Aptamil ready-made cartons, so we just kept sterilised bottles and cartons nearby and were good to go. This was a godsend in the middle of the night, especially, and easy when out and about. Healthwise, DS has always been very fit and healthy, with a strong immune system. He's now 11, has only ever missed school due to Covid and chicken pox, and has just won an academic scholarship to senior school. This isn't meant as brag, but merely as reassurance that choosing not to breastfeed has no impact on the outcome of your child. Despite what the Breastapo might want you to believe, bottle fed children can thrive and still be happy. The stigmatisation around bottle feeding is absolutely abhorrent. A happy mum is a happy child in my book.

Other advice would be to keep your change bag well stocked (replenish as soon as you get home, so it's ready to go next time) - and similarly, have everything close by your changing mat for any sudden emergencies!

I would also recommend lots of muslin cloths.

DS also used to like being swaddled and enjoyed bath time, so this was an important part of our evening routine and meant he was calm and happy before being put down for the evening.

Good luck, OP. It sounds as though you will be an amazing mum!

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 08:15

Confusion101 · 23/07/2023 08:09

@Muthaofcats I would suggest you read the full thread, or at least all of the OPs posts before commenting, as she as answered your question explaining multiple reasons she has chosen not to breastfeed, that it is a decision she is happy with, and doesn't need further information on it!

Hope my disadvantaged summer born baby is OK with the disappointment of a mother she got in me as I chose not to breastfeed too! 🙄

You know you can delay your child’s reception start if they’re summer born?

Again a topic that is worth reading around if you’re feeling self conscious / defensive about it.

Another example of something that isn’t as ‘easy’ for the parent but long term better for the child.

Confusion101 · 23/07/2023 08:09

@Muthaofcats I would suggest you read the full thread, or at least all of the OPs posts before commenting, as she as answered your question explaining multiple reasons she has chosen not to breastfeed, that it is a decision she is happy with, and doesn't need further information on it!

Hope my disadvantaged summer born baby is OK with the disappointment of a mother she got in me as I chose not to breastfeed too! 🙄

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:58

MariaVT65 · 23/07/2023 07:51

OP’s original post is not asking for any advice on breastfeeding, she is asking for advice on other ways to make mum life easier. She has also clearly stated several times in her thread that she does not want to breastfeed. So any replies focusing on the disasvantages of FF are not what OP is looking for.

‘Other ways to make life easier’ begs the question of whether the choices she made are easier, hence why people are querying it.

if she’s not looking for opinion then why post on mumsnet? Or do you believe it’s only opinions you want to hear that should be listened to…. Otherwise known as an echo chamber.

being kind or caring doesn’t mean blindly agreeing with people who may be misinformed. Gentle challenge and reassurance and support may be long term better for this person and their child; the ‘mum knows best’ doesn’t really help her either and if query how kind it truly is.

its Not just OP who will read this; many other vulnerable women too so those correcting incorrect statements aren’t Just banging their own drum

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:54

MariaVT65 · 23/07/2023 07:31

Public health guidance is for a population and not always appropriate for an individual. It’s a FACT that the NHS gives out some out-of-date advice in some areas, not to mention the indiviual idiots who work there.

Listening to advice of friends and anecdotes of others is perfectly reasonable.

Let’s hope none of those ‘idiots’ in the nhs are on shift for OPs c section or any other needs your children have next time you take them in for help….

MariaVT65 · 23/07/2023 07:51

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:45

Of course she does not need to justify herself to me, or to anyone else.

nor should the data be used to stress out and frighten women.

As I said in my post, there are lots of reasons why one might not choose or be able to breast feed.

I was correcting those who said bottle is just as good. It plainly is not.

That does not mean OP should be shamed for choosing not to because she thinks it will be easier. But she may be basing her decision that it will be ‘easy’ on misunderstanding or anecdotal evidence alone and not aware of the potential implications. It’s not easy to be in and out of a&e with a baby with respiratory issues or suffering with diabetes etc. it doesn’t mean if you formula feed your baby will definitely have issues but statistically this is more likely so you may want to factor that in to any decision that is focused on ‘ease’ alone.

I was asking as Op is clearly looking for guidance and reassurance by posting here so it may be she could be offered support or signposting if her reason for not wanting to, depending on what that reason is.

OP’s original post is not asking for any advice on breastfeeding, she is asking for advice on other ways to make mum life easier. She has also clearly stated several times in her thread that she does not want to breastfeed. So any replies focusing on the disasvantages of FF are not what OP is looking for.

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:45

MariaVT65 · 23/07/2023 07:28

You seem to be missing out the importance of the mother’s physical health, not just mental health. You are also presuming that a mother and baby cannot bond if they are not breastfed, which is utter rubbish. Heard of skin to skin or this thing called ‘a cuddle’?

OP doesn’t have to justify to you why she doesn’t want to breastfeed. I’m sure she has done her research, has probably heard from experiences of her friends and family. There was also a thread on here a while ago asking why women chose not to breastfeed and there were many different answers, including sexual abuse.

Of course she does not need to justify herself to me, or to anyone else.

nor should the data be used to stress out and frighten women.

As I said in my post, there are lots of reasons why one might not choose or be able to breast feed.

I was correcting those who said bottle is just as good. It plainly is not.

That does not mean OP should be shamed for choosing not to because she thinks it will be easier. But she may be basing her decision that it will be ‘easy’ on misunderstanding or anecdotal evidence alone and not aware of the potential implications. It’s not easy to be in and out of a&e with a baby with respiratory issues or suffering with diabetes etc. it doesn’t mean if you formula feed your baby will definitely have issues but statistically this is more likely so you may want to factor that in to any decision that is focused on ‘ease’ alone.

I was asking as Op is clearly looking for guidance and reassurance by posting here so it may be she could be offered support or signposting if her reason for not wanting to, depending on what that reason is.

MariaVT65 · 23/07/2023 07:31

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:20

The disadvantage for summer babies is accepted though and the law therefore accommodates for this by allowing parents to start them at compulsory school age, and anyone who read the data would seriously consider doing this given the long term outcomes for the child. In the same way if you read the data around breast feeding you would accept that this was preferable and only not do it as a plan B if for any reason the option wasn’t available. As a parent responsible for a child you are required to make decisions for them, and consulting public health guidance, and data is likely to lead to a better outcome than anecdote and opinion on mums net 😂

Public health guidance is for a population and not always appropriate for an individual. It’s a FACT that the NHS gives out some out-of-date advice in some areas, not to mention the indiviual idiots who work there.

Listening to advice of friends and anecdotes of others is perfectly reasonable.

MariaVT65 · 23/07/2023 07:28

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:09

OP may I ask why you don’t want to breast feed?

people are telling you it makes no difference to the baby to bottle feed and your bodily integrity is paramount. Of course the latter is important, but the former is not true. Bottle feeding is not the equivalent option, look at the Heath outcomes for breast fed versus bottle fed babies. Lots of people cannot breast feed and shouldn’t be stigmatised if they are unable to. But By choosing something for ‘ease’ alone you are accepting that you’re putting ease above your child’s long term health and safety.

I don’t think it’s judgemental for people to query whether you’re aware of that.

Maybe you’re not aware and the reduced risk of Sids or obesity or reduced impact of childhood illnesses, asthma, type 1 diabetes for your child might be a consideration you’d have been pleased to know about. Short term, your breast milk can give them immunity from infection, and adjust based on the weather to ensure they’re getting exactly what they need. This is without even considering the psychological impact for your child of being placed in a cot away from their mother and without that closeness and connection that breast feeding gives them. And many people have already talked about the practical side - that bottles are likely to be more work, not easier, and certainly much much more expensive. Look into the health benefits for you too (reduced breast cancer risk amongst others).

sharing public health information is not being judgemental. It’s just important to correct ignorance which is often peddled as ‘mum knows best’ ‘happy mum happy baby’.

If you’re on medication that means you are unable to breast feed or have other circumstances that mean it can’t happen for you, then formula is the next best alternative, but that’s a very different consideration to just choosing it ‘to make life easier’. Life for whom? Certainly not your baby.

of course maternal mental health is important but it just feels like a recipe for disaster to see childcare as a threat to one’s own mental health. This is a very short time that is all about closeness and bond and nurturing your child. The truth is your needs do take a back seat, at least for a while anyway but arguably it shouldn’t feel like that. My child’s needs ARE my needs because that’s what’s important to me now; happy baby happy mum!

You seem to be missing out the importance of the mother’s physical health, not just mental health. You are also presuming that a mother and baby cannot bond if they are not breastfed, which is utter rubbish. Heard of skin to skin or this thing called ‘a cuddle’?

OP doesn’t have to justify to you why she doesn’t want to breastfeed. I’m sure she has done her research, has probably heard from experiences of her friends and family. There was also a thread on here a while ago asking why women chose not to breastfeed and there were many different answers, including sexual abuse.

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:20

Babyboomtastic · 22/07/2023 09:40

Its funny how women get judged for not breastfeeding, but not judged for having summer babies, even though the link with exam results/attainment is far stronger.

Should we judge women for TTC in the autumn because they are disadvantaging their future offspring? No being the obvious answer here. Maybe we just let women deicide how they want to feed their babies!

The disadvantage for summer babies is accepted though and the law therefore accommodates for this by allowing parents to start them at compulsory school age, and anyone who read the data would seriously consider doing this given the long term outcomes for the child. In the same way if you read the data around breast feeding you would accept that this was preferable and only not do it as a plan B if for any reason the option wasn’t available. As a parent responsible for a child you are required to make decisions for them, and consulting public health guidance, and data is likely to lead to a better outcome than anecdote and opinion on mums net 😂

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:15

Animallover87 · 22/07/2023 11:03

@Babyboomtastic I know, according to people on this thread my baby is screwed 🤦‍♀️

Not screwed but certainly already at a disadvantage.

Muthaofcats · 23/07/2023 07:14

Please share this study