Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Farm inheritance - ILs should give farm to DH now

206 replies

farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 14:44

I'll start by saying I know inheritance is never guaranteed not an entitlement etc and that we are very very lucky with what we do have now and what my DH will inherit.

I will also state I am not from a farming background and my mum rents so inheritance isn't something I have ever considered. I have always stayed out of what is said in DHs family as it didn't seem like my business.

We met with a solicitor recently to get our wills drawn up, mainly in order to have guardianship set out for DC.

We rent our house from ILs at a very reasonable rate. Both ILs are in their late 70s, they live in the main farm house, we live in a smaller older one.

DH works a lot on their farm. Thankfully FIL is still very fit/ active but understandably is slowing down. DH does not get a wage for this, but as I said we have lower rent.

I originally wanted to buy our own house. But this would have an impact on DH's inheritance tax, there is a farm relief scheme, we are in Ireland. So we didn't buy a house. DH also said there is no point as we will eventually inherit the whole farm and will need to live in the main farm house.

Now the solicitor brought it up when we went in and said about it being better for them to sign it over to DH now in case they end up in nursing homes a lot of the land could end up going in fees.

My DH went with my ILs about a year ago to see an accountant who advised that they sign it all over to DH now. They agreed. But then MIL when to a solicitor who advised against it so they didn't.

I'm a little worried about our financial future now. 1st and foremost I do not want ILs to end up in nursing homes. I genuinely do love them and want them around for as long as possible. DH says "they wouldn't go to one ever" but my uncle is currently in one suffering with Alzheimer's I don't think he thought he would go for one.

I mostly just wanted to vent my frustration.

AIBU to want my ILs to give the farm to DH now? They would still live in the main farm house and receive the farm income btw.

OP posts:
ThanksItHasPockets · 17/07/2023 18:00

Thosepeskyseagulls · 17/07/2023 17:26

How is this not her business?!

It’s the knee-jerk response from a certain kind of MNer to absolutely any thread about inheritance, no matter how nuanced. They are by default greedy, grabby, and entitled.

OhComeOnFFS · 17/07/2023 17:56

I can't believe you've been so naive, OP. Why is your husband working for nothing when he's only getting a small discount on rent? Why are you assuming his siblings will just accept him inheriting the farm? What will you do in the future if you each get 1/3 of the farm?

PlasticSheetingRTÉNews · 17/07/2023 17:46

Nanny0gg · 17/07/2023 16:43

'Mind your own business'?

It is her business. Her family, her future.

The farm that her in-laws own is none of her business.

If they leave it to the local cat shelter, it’s none of her business.

BeachBlondey · 17/07/2023 17:37

Also MIL asked after we got married, that when her or FIL dies can they live with us so unless they are in very bad health and I can't cope with it they are very unlikely to go to a nursing home

I'm sorry, but this is such a naive comment. I can see why you would say it, because until my own parents got old, I would have said the exact same! It's so easy to say "Oh, I'd never put my Dad in a home", as if it's only neglectful children that would do so, but the reality can be very different than what you imagine. My Dad is in one, he has no mobility at all, needs a hospital bed, wears a nappy, and he weighs 22 stone, so can only be moved with hoists and slip sheets. Reckon you can take that on? And work full time? And have any kind of life? I would never have imagined that this would have happened to us, but here we are.

ILuvJam · 17/07/2023 17:36

Radyward · 17/07/2023 17:27

In no way should your in laws sign all over. you will then be in charge over the roof over their heads when they are still fit and healthy and puts them in a weak position going forward. what if theres a row/ disagreement etc down the line. if your DH has siblings they need to be included in any discussions too as all need to be in agreement.inheritance tax is your and your DH problem. The very same thing happened in our family all was signed over and my DB and his wife took over. bossed my poor parents around.changed their home with no by your leave . its a nightmare-my poor parents are depressed!! Their rationale in signing over was to avoid tax for my DB and provide him and his wife with a house ( the rest of us sorted our own homes) by all means sign the landover but not the house they currently live in. im in ireland by the way . you are already benefitting by cheap rent.whats the rush?????

What's the rush? The rush is they only have a limited amount of time where they can get a mortgage to buy a house of their own. If they leave it another 10 years then that option will not be on the table to the same degree.

Buy your own house. If it needs a bit of work you and your husband need to put your spare time into doing it up instead of working for free for you in-laws. 200 quid a month of the market rent is pittance for what you're providing.

Then move into the house and let your in-laws deal with the hassle of renegade tennants that cannot be legally evicted from the house they so graciously let you pay to do up the bathrooms in 😂

AvanGelist · 17/07/2023 17:34

Radyward · 17/07/2023 17:27

In no way should your in laws sign all over. you will then be in charge over the roof over their heads when they are still fit and healthy and puts them in a weak position going forward. what if theres a row/ disagreement etc down the line. if your DH has siblings they need to be included in any discussions too as all need to be in agreement.inheritance tax is your and your DH problem. The very same thing happened in our family all was signed over and my DB and his wife took over. bossed my poor parents around.changed their home with no by your leave . its a nightmare-my poor parents are depressed!! Their rationale in signing over was to avoid tax for my DB and provide him and his wife with a house ( the rest of us sorted our own homes) by all means sign the landover but not the house they currently live in. im in ireland by the way . you are already benefitting by cheap rent.whats the rush?????

It's house built on farming land - highly likely that the two cannot be separated. As a PP have said the law around it and property rights are archaic

Radyward · 17/07/2023 17:34

Sorry read some more replies and its true myself and my siblings are fuming over what happened in secret between my brother and his wife and our elderly parents.not a word said all signed over.i can hardly stay in my parents house freeely as its owned by DB. Zero consideration for us as siblings .my parents are in poor health and felt pressured by DB . im sickened by their greed and it has affected is 4 siblings and DB relationship. so in our view its completely up to Db and wife to cover the care home costs going forward as they have got the best part of 650k

Radyward · 17/07/2023 17:27

In no way should your in laws sign all over. you will then be in charge over the roof over their heads when they are still fit and healthy and puts them in a weak position going forward. what if theres a row/ disagreement etc down the line. if your DH has siblings they need to be included in any discussions too as all need to be in agreement.inheritance tax is your and your DH problem. The very same thing happened in our family all was signed over and my DB and his wife took over. bossed my poor parents around.changed their home with no by your leave . its a nightmare-my poor parents are depressed!! Their rationale in signing over was to avoid tax for my DB and provide him and his wife with a house ( the rest of us sorted our own homes) by all means sign the landover but not the house they currently live in. im in ireland by the way . you are already benefitting by cheap rent.whats the rush?????

Thosepeskyseagulls · 17/07/2023 17:26

PlasticSheetingRTÉNews · 17/07/2023 14:46

You can “want” them to do things all you like, but it’s not your decision.

Mind your own business and be very thankful that you’re benefiting from reduced accommodation cost.

How is this not her business?!

Chatillon · 17/07/2023 17:24

MistyMountainTop · 17/07/2023 17:08

Incredible foresight by the uncle then, seeing into the future that the DH was going into the farm when he was only a teenager! More likely that he wrote the will before DH was born and never updated it.

In farming families these things are often set out well in advance. It really is not that uncommon for money over wider family members to be used to equalise. Especially if the uncle was independently wealthy or had no heirs. I know this from many professional dealings in this area directly.

mushti · 17/07/2023 17:22

If you were in the UK then you might be able to use a little-known corner of English law called "proprietary estoppel". (I know you're not, but it might help someone else to hear of it.)

If someone promises you'll inherit some property (a farm is the usual case) and you rely on that promise to your detriment (by not buying your own house) then the courts can order the farm be given to you.

PuntoEBasta · 17/07/2023 17:18

PlasticSheetingRTÉNews · 17/07/2023 14:46

You can “want” them to do things all you like, but it’s not your decision.

Mind your own business and be very thankful that you’re benefiting from reduced accommodation cost.

It is quite literally her business. Farming inheritances are ridiculously archaic and not at all comparable to most people's experience of inheriting.

Stillcantbebothered · 17/07/2023 17:18

PlasticSheetingRTÉNews · 17/07/2023 14:46

You can “want” them to do things all you like, but it’s not your decision.

Mind your own business and be very thankful that you’re benefiting from reduced accommodation cost.

Reduced rent in lieu of income still puts them as disadvantage so she has every right to be concerned.

Scenarios where you’re working on a farm with the goal of inheriting the farm to keep it in the family is very different from normal situations where you’re just inheriting a house form your parent. If they don’t get the farm they have literally wages their lives with nothing to show for it.

Keeping farms in the family happens a lot as it involves family members starting to work on farm from young through to adulthood and invert and repeat.

itsmylife7 · 17/07/2023 17:14

Trust no-one but yourself in life OP.

You need to look out for YOU so do what you need to do.

And remember ' a promise is a comfort to a fool ' so don't be no ones fool. 😉

Aquamarine1029 · 17/07/2023 17:10

The more you write the worse it gets. Did you not ask why you couldn't build your own home? If your husband will be taking over the farm, what's the issue?

They have pulled a massive bait and switch on you. If I were you, I would go alone and get legal advice for you. Ask them what happens to you if this all blows up in your face and what you need to do to protect yourself.

MistyMountainTop · 17/07/2023 17:08

Chatillon · 17/07/2023 16:20

The farm is going to DH. SIL + BIL are 'looked after' they also both received approx €400k each when an uncle died who left DH out of the will, we don't know why.

They got €400k because your DH is going to be given a farm. This type of arrangement is not uncommon. Equalisation across the wider family.

Incredible foresight by the uncle then, seeing into the future that the DH was going into the farm when he was only a teenager! More likely that he wrote the will before DH was born and never updated it.

farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 17:05

@AIBUIthinkNot FIL, is that you 😂

OP posts:
Crinkle77 · 17/07/2023 17:04

Outdamnspot23 · 17/07/2023 15:42

I can't believe your husband isn't getting a wage at all. Even self-employed people (and I think co-running a family farm is a type of that) often pay themselves a salary. Does that mean all the rent money is coming from your pay packet?

Yes this! They are massively taking advantage of your husband despite the reduced rent.

farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 17:04

@JusthereforXmas no it's ok tax wise to sign it over. In fact here the gov try to encourage it. Get more young blood back into farming.

OP posts:
farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 17:02

@HarridanHarvestingHeldaBeans they were also against us building our own house. This was the dream/ stream/ cloud whatever you'd like to say I was lured here on. Shown a fantastic part of the farm where we could build our house. When this was not materialising I wanted to buy one. I think I would be converting the large garage which is fully detached into a self contained annex.

@anabundanceofjars I can well see them living until their 90s and I really hope they do. But they, esp MIL will still think she is the boss. She controls everything with a fine toothcomb. Altho DH is getting her to release things slowly and she has had me over a few times to show me where certain things are.

@weekfour it'd sicken you to see what we could have bought 10 years ago when we first moved here. But should of could have. I think I need to talk to DH about seriously looking at buying somewhere now. I am feeling very insecure with DC and yes what if something were to happen to DH we would be left with nothing.

OP posts:
JusthereforXmas · 17/07/2023 16:59

Surely 'signing it over' is like a big red flashing flag sign to the tax man.

I'm no expert and know quite little about this but if your trying to be sly wouldn't the best thing to do be to be added onto their property deeds so your DH has a legitimate 1/3rd interest in and be added as a business partner. Rather than have it passed over to you which is obviously just trying to get around inheritance.

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/07/2023 16:56

@AIBUIthinkNot Oh god - so much this.

My dad does not own his farm but has a inheritable life time tenancy that is worth money to my brother and me. He is still farming as well.

He would not make a will or sort out a POA when in hospital last year with heart trouble - his refrain was "oh I'll be fine" - our uncle, his older brother, had to literally go in to the hospital and bully him in to doing it.

I am very very glad I am not dependent on the farm for income or a home - I got out and went my own way at 18.

weekfour · 17/07/2023 16:47

I think I'd be saying that if they don't want to sign it over then you want to buy your own house. They could live another 20 years. Or is that not possible now with house prices sky rocketting?

empties · 17/07/2023 16:46

I would check out succession planning - accountancy firms like IFAC do this and I think Teagasc or IFA have produced a book - worth you both looking at it and husband deciding maybe to raise it with parents. Most farm families really dont like the idea of having to sell the farm, break up the farm to pay for care or otherwise. I think there is now a cap on this under Fair Deal but it still may add up - and this could still be a possiblility - it would be worth you or at least husband and parents attending a meeting to explore succession planning to avoid this - husband can raise it in terms of wanting to avoid paying excessive tax...

anabundanceofjars · 17/07/2023 16:46

I'm in a similar situation but my PILS are in their 90s and still think they are the managers. DH and I have worked the farm (managing it) for decades with no recognition.
Farming is a whole different ball game, you have my sympathies

Swipe left for the next trending thread