Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Farm inheritance - ILs should give farm to DH now

206 replies

farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 14:44

I'll start by saying I know inheritance is never guaranteed not an entitlement etc and that we are very very lucky with what we do have now and what my DH will inherit.

I will also state I am not from a farming background and my mum rents so inheritance isn't something I have ever considered. I have always stayed out of what is said in DHs family as it didn't seem like my business.

We met with a solicitor recently to get our wills drawn up, mainly in order to have guardianship set out for DC.

We rent our house from ILs at a very reasonable rate. Both ILs are in their late 70s, they live in the main farm house, we live in a smaller older one.

DH works a lot on their farm. Thankfully FIL is still very fit/ active but understandably is slowing down. DH does not get a wage for this, but as I said we have lower rent.

I originally wanted to buy our own house. But this would have an impact on DH's inheritance tax, there is a farm relief scheme, we are in Ireland. So we didn't buy a house. DH also said there is no point as we will eventually inherit the whole farm and will need to live in the main farm house.

Now the solicitor brought it up when we went in and said about it being better for them to sign it over to DH now in case they end up in nursing homes a lot of the land could end up going in fees.

My DH went with my ILs about a year ago to see an accountant who advised that they sign it all over to DH now. They agreed. But then MIL when to a solicitor who advised against it so they didn't.

I'm a little worried about our financial future now. 1st and foremost I do not want ILs to end up in nursing homes. I genuinely do love them and want them around for as long as possible. DH says "they wouldn't go to one ever" but my uncle is currently in one suffering with Alzheimer's I don't think he thought he would go for one.

I mostly just wanted to vent my frustration.

AIBU to want my ILs to give the farm to DH now? They would still live in the main farm house and receive the farm income btw.

OP posts:
Cailin66 · 17/07/2023 21:22

2 I originally wanted to buy our own house. But this would have an impact on DH's inheritance tax, there is a farm relief scheme, we are in Ireland.

Well that was pretty sensible of you. But doesn't suit you farm family does it. It would have given you an asset, instead your money goes to paying rent to your husband's parents, and that money will be used by them to give him/his children/his siblings an inheritance.

The inheritance tax angle is a novel one. And I just love it's tied into the farm relieve scheme. How would you owning a house with your husband affect his inheritance tax. You'd have to die and if you did, leaving everything to you husband, there is zero inheritance tax due in Ireland. If you left you share to the children they have a limit of 300K+ each before tax is due.

Cailin66 · 17/07/2023 21:15
  1. We met with a solicitor recently to get our wills drawn up, mainly in order to have guardianship set out for DC.

So your husband has been careful to make sure the children are taken care of. Presumably it was suggested to you the guardian be his sibling and spouse. Does he know the content of your will? Do you know the content of his? And if you do, who has he left his assets to? Was it the same solicitor for both of you? If yes, did you get an opportunity - alone - to discuss your will.

mushti · 17/07/2023 21:06

@farmerswife7

Read this:

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/07/2023 21:04

I think at minimum you need some answers to a bunch of 'what happens if' questions here.

What happens if they both go into a care home - to your current home, to the land/buildings used for your husbands business - to his investment, time/effort wise into the farm.

What happens if your husband dies before them?

What happens if either of the siblings makes a claim on the farm in the event of their death? This may be one for the solicitor that drew up the will tbh.

I would not settle for 'that will never happen' as thats not an answer and they all know that.

farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 20:52

@bevm72yellow he said DC are in the will, whatever that means. It is all legal in a will right now but I suppose they could change their minds. DH understandably says that won't happen and that he trusts his parents. TBH I trust his parents too.

@WiddlinDiddlin you know I have no idea what happens to this house if they go to a care home. I know this house is willed to one of his siblings. I think BIL but I'm not sure.

@Cailin66 I'll go googling now but could they really dispute a legally binding will? AFAIK everything is in my MILs name (strange for the time). I know she has herd no anyway. We visited a solicitor together we're on the NI boarder but in ROI. I really don't know if there is any point in seeing a solicitor independently. I own nothing neither does DH

OP posts:
bevm72yellow · 17/07/2023 20:34

Do not make decisions based on somebody's "word" or "promise". It must be on paper legally to be effective.

bevm72yellow · 17/07/2023 20:30

You would be allowed to live in the house rent free if something happened to your husband so therefore your children would not get an asset from your husband's years of work it would go to "blood family"? Not acceptable to many.

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/07/2023 20:24

This sounds like a nightmare.

IF they need care home, what then becomes of the property you currently rent and the land/buildings from which your DH runs his contracting business from? Because if they go, renting a suitable site for such a biz is not cheap (I know how much space agri-plant takes up, and how secure it has to be given how rife theft of such kit is), on top of renting something to live in.

Is your DH keen to sort this out? It sounds driven by you, with him being rather reluctant (that could just be the way you've written your posts though).

Thefieldisfallow · 17/07/2023 20:05

I really feel for you @farmerswife7 .

I'm in England but my auntie was also told she'd 'never be left struggling and could live in this house rent free'. They kicked her out after he died in such a brutal way, they had zero interest in her and made her life miserable. She'd trusted them for years, being made homeless and suffering grief and betrayal was so much to cope with.

farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 19:42

BeachBlondey · 17/07/2023 17:37

Also MIL asked after we got married, that when her or FIL dies can they live with us so unless they are in very bad health and I can't cope with it they are very unlikely to go to a nursing home

I'm sorry, but this is such a naive comment. I can see why you would say it, because until my own parents got old, I would have said the exact same! It's so easy to say "Oh, I'd never put my Dad in a home", as if it's only neglectful children that would do so, but the reality can be very different than what you imagine. My Dad is in one, he has no mobility at all, needs a hospital bed, wears a nappy, and he weighs 22 stone, so can only be moved with hoists and slip sheets. Reckon you can take that on? And work full time? And have any kind of life? I would never have imagined that this would have happened to us, but here we are.

Sorry if you thought I was saying/ thinking people that go to nursing homes are only there because they have neglectful children. I don't think that at all, and I've only seen recently the struggle some of my family had with the decision to send my uncle (their dad) and that he 100% needed to go to one.

I mentioned to DH there about not having any assets in my name. He said i knew you'd bring this up after the solicitors. That if something were to happen to him I'd have nothing. He said it has been discussed and I'd never be left struggling and could live in this house rent free.

I can actually see from my ILs POV that it wouldn't be nice their son owning their house.

Other siblings really are OK with this AFAIK. They are not being left out of the will. ILs have other assets..no not worth as much (at least on paper) but far more liquid.

I think I need to seriously look into buying an investment property or something!

OP posts:
Lacucuracha · 17/07/2023 19:18

DMLady · 17/07/2023 18:50

Think we’re at cross purposes, @Lacucuracha. I was trying to reply to (and thought I had!) @PlasticSheetingRTÉNews who said:
‘You can “want” them to do things all you like, but it’s not your decision.
Mind your own business and be very thankful that you’re benefiting from reduced accommodation cost.’

Ah sorry DMLady! 😊

apples24 · 17/07/2023 19:15

OP, some very unhelpful responses in this thread....

I agree with all who suggest that you have been naive and need to work out with your DH how to sort this out so you're not left with nothing. You're not being grabby or entitled.

Cailin66 · 17/07/2023 18:52

DMLady · 17/07/2023 18:31

But it IS their business. Literally and metaphorically. And the OP’s DH works on the family farm for no wage, hence the reduced accommodation costs. Why should they be grateful?

He’s not working for nothing. He’s been promised the farm.

His mother though has seen sense, and is refusing to sign. They will cajole and badger her now. And her age is against her to fight it. So likely they will have to do something legal to get her to sign. Mother probably wants son to inherit, and Jenny to have no rights, but MIL will be afraid of being turfed out by son and Jenny if hubby goes first.

I’d say MIL going to a solicitor put the cat amongst the pigeons. Son will be raging at her, as will her husband who wants to ensure the family farm in the family name and no woman getting a slice, never mind an English woman.

I’m on Jenny’s side in this as I know full well what goes on. Jenny is clearly lovely, and touchingly naive. My in-laws wife lived in horrendous circumstances, had to be grateful ‘he’ put in a new kitchen for her, with one bathroom, accessible only via the kitchen. And I bet he’s disinherited her as much as he can in his will. Already very expensive sites given to the children. Who live in amazing mansions.

DMLady · 17/07/2023 18:50

Think we’re at cross purposes, @Lacucuracha. I was trying to reply to (and thought I had!) @PlasticSheetingRTÉNews who said:
‘You can “want” them to do things all you like, but it’s not your decision.
Mind your own business and be very thankful that you’re benefiting from reduced accommodation cost.’

Cailin66 · 17/07/2023 18:40

OP must go to a solicitor. Not near the town she lives in. She will be seen. Go to one in a city. She can also pose a question on somewhere like boards.ie or askaboutmoney.ie

If she pm’s me her county I can recommend one in Galway. Or Limerick.

She can also google the question as it’s discussed in some of the personal money pages of Irish newpapers.

My BIL and one of my brothers are farmers. BIL’s wife owns zero. House never transferred into her name. But she does have legal rights. Known as the ‘spouse legal right share’. Circumvented by your in-laws and husband currently. And it’s why your MIL is declining to sign. She’d be signing away her rights in favour of her son, being left with him having financial power over her. Jenny is an exact copy of her MIL.

Lacucuracha · 17/07/2023 18:36

DMLady · 17/07/2023 18:31

But it IS their business. Literally and metaphorically. And the OP’s DH works on the family farm for no wage, hence the reduced accommodation costs. Why should they be grateful?

Do you really think £200pm is fair recompense for working 3 or 4 days per week on the farm?

DMLady · 17/07/2023 18:31

But it IS their business. Literally and metaphorically. And the OP’s DH works on the family farm for no wage, hence the reduced accommodation costs. Why should they be grateful?

Cailin66 · 17/07/2023 18:29

There are genuine reasons to put the farm in your husbands name. Totally legit estate planning. Five benefits. No tax, avoids care home fees, ensures succession, keeps the farm in the male name. For your husband and his family, there is the added benefit of giving you no rights. And they are all terrified of that.

The two siblings appear to have been bought off. Generally a site, cash towards a house, an education. BUT they can dispute a will. Section 117. Your hubby and his parents will be keen to do this to avoid that.

Your MIL is not on your phone side. But she’s not stupid, she went to a solicitor and knows she’s signing over all rights, and is fearful of her son dumping her in a nursing home. I imagine nothing is in her name either. BUT she has to sign off on it. Particularly the house she lives in. Due to ‘the family home protection act’ . Google it and why. Brought in to prevent men, particularly farmers from disinheriting their wives.

bevm72yellow · 17/07/2023 18:26

You are not building any asset in your name for your children in the future. You are maybe covering unsustainable things e.g. food/ clothing for children, school uniforms etc. Therefore you may have little say over the bigger asset issues eg a better reliable car. The asset in a way is being held over your head because your husband's elderly parents (as in many farming households) have full say over the asset your husband is working on. You are waiting on the behaviour or expectation of somebody else to secure your lives in the future. You are in a difficult position. It is to do with you as it affects you and the lives of your children (people saying "it is none of your business" don't understand it affects your lives and livelihood/secure future) Plus women in a farming situation who do housework/child care/ jobs connected to the farm eg driving for medications to vet/ collecting a farm related products or cooking for others are seen as "not working". And you are not being "grabby" you are trying to secure the welfare of your children. The expectation is being directed to you to look after the needs of everybody else e.g. if sick/unwell/widowed. And yes your husband and you need to have a discussion with them about the farm/inheritance/ future expectations. But if your in laws need a lot of care you will be left to do the major part of it without minimal help from most. Even if the house you are currently in was secured to you it protects you and the children. It does not have to be the whole farm at this point.

Cailin66 · 17/07/2023 18:21

farmerswife7 · 17/07/2023 15:24

@jennyjones198080 what do you mean by "The wife got ‘her day’ " I wouldn't say I am exactly subbing DH but I suppose I sort of am as well. He ploughs all his money back into building his business and improving the farm.

Jenny you need to wise up very quickly.

You are being taken advantage of and don’t even realise it.

Your low rent is a joke, 200 a month less than market rate is nothing. And it sounds to me to be a house other women would not live in.

I’d be putting my foot down now as regards getting up to a modern standard, that’s if I’d even be willing to live in it. Your home of the future you might never see. You should have insisted that your hubby be gifted a site and then you put it in both your names and build a new house.

If you were doing that you’d be gaining ownership of a house and there is no legal reason this can’t be done. Indeed there is no reason your current house couldn’t be gifted to your husband and him to transfer it freely into both your names.

Google ‘hello divorce bye bye daddy” to understand the Irish patriarchal view of women marrying into the family farm.

The lies, semi truths, you are being told is to prevent you owning anything. Because the aim is to keep the farm in the family, PIL to your husband, not you, and then to your children.

PlasticSheetingRTÉNews · 17/07/2023 18:19

ThanksItHasPockets · 17/07/2023 18:00

It’s the knee-jerk response from a certain kind of MNer to absolutely any thread about inheritance, no matter how nuanced. They are by default greedy, grabby, and entitled.

No, there are people on this thread, me included, who are familiar with such scenarios.

At the end of the day, the farm owners took legal advice and have decided that they do not want to gift their business to their son.

No amount of “I want, I want” from the OP will change that.

DumDeeDoh · 17/07/2023 18:10

This is best sorted 7 years before they pass, so as soon as you can. They could also retire and claim the farmers pension. Go to a specialised solicitor.

BreadInCaptivity · 17/07/2023 18:06

OP I think you are getting some pretty poor posts here from people who don't understand the complexity of farming inheritances.

The farm is a business which ultimately your DH has invested a lot of money in through the contribution of his labour.

Often selling parts of land off to compensate non farming siblings can't be done as it would make the commercial running of the farm non viable (and in this case it sounds like the siblings have already been given sizeable inheritance's your DH did not).

You need to sit down with your DH first and agree a plan because the current situation is not tenable for you.

Ideally get legal advice from a specialist in this area. Options may include a partnership and a right for in laws to remain in the main farmhouse for life. But ultimately you need assurances that your family won't be left with no home after decades of promises and hard work. That's not unreasonable.

This isn't an unusual situation in the farming community and a good solicitor should be able to put forward a number of options to protect everyone's interests.

Agree a plan and then speak to the in laws. If they won't compromise then I'd look to leave the farm, buy your own place and your DH find employment that pays a wage.

primoseyellow · 17/07/2023 18:04

I can definitely see why you thinking about the situation, I would be the same.

To put it bluntly I can't see both your DH siblings saying 'oh no worries you keep hold of a million pound property we don't want anything! '

Even if they were helped out by Pil to build their own houses, surely this was a while ago and in Ireland it wouldn't have been that expensive?
How old will you both be if your Pil live till their late eighties? Will you still be living in their smaller house while they are in the main house?