Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think scrapping inheritance tax would not be popular with voters

620 replies

Lanadelday · 17/07/2023 12:44

I'd say I can't believe the conservatives are considering it, but nothing surprises me any more that they do. But AIBU to think most people wouldn't back this anyway- I can't see it being a big vote winner and don't think they really get that voters are sick of all the inequality and so many people including kids and elderly, living in poverty, not wanting to make it worse.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
GasPanic · 17/07/2023 13:29

DancingLedgend · 17/07/2023 13:27

It's not really a question of whether you would prefer you/ your parents to not have to pay IHT. (Which of us wants to pay more tax?)

It's a question of what kind of country we will be living in, if essential services are massively slashed?
This would be a far bigger hit to spending on essential services than Liz Truss's failed tax slash, which crashed the economy so quickly that she had to reverse it.

After years of austerity, many councils and Gov departments have no funding for anything but the minimum.
What do you want to see savage cuts to? Education? NHS? Carers? Police?

Where you've got it wrong is that Liz Truss's tax slash was giving money to rich Tories, whereas removing inheritance tax would be giving money to rich Tories.

Badbadbunny · 17/07/2023 13:27

It's pointless anyway because it's so easy to avoid with all the reliefs/exemptions etc. The punitive 40% rate also encourages people to plan to avoid it.

If it's to stay, the rate needs to fall dramatically to discourage avoidance planning, and the reliefs/exemptions need removing so it's harder to avoid.

More people paying, say, 10%, would bring in a lot more money and would be fairer, than a tiny number of people who didn't plan paying 40%!

DancingLedgend · 17/07/2023 13:27

It's not really a question of whether you would prefer you/ your parents to not have to pay IHT. (Which of us wants to pay more tax?)

It's a question of what kind of country we will be living in, if essential services are massively slashed?
This would be a far bigger hit to spending on essential services than Liz Truss's failed tax slash, which crashed the economy so quickly that she had to reverse it.

After years of austerity, many councils and Gov departments have no funding for anything but the minimum.
What do you want to see savage cuts to? Education? NHS? Carers? Police?

drpet49 · 17/07/2023 13:25

lljkk · 17/07/2023 13:07

I think it would be very popular. 2/3 of people own home, of which majority have no mortgage. They don't want any of that asset taxed for their heirs.

Definitely more supported than not.

So much for fighting inflation if this is the plan, though.

This.

ditalini · 17/07/2023 13:25

Onlyonedog · 17/07/2023 13:17

I thought Inheritance tax kicked in on anything over £325k? (I may be wrong) which is more or less the average house price in UK so majority of people will pay some? Have I misunderstood? I'm hoping that I have.

If you're inheriting your parents' house then that's £500,000 and remember that's half a mil per parent, so potentially a million pound property tax free.

As was mentioned above, you'd think that the country was swimming in estates affected by inheritance tax but it's actually a very, very tiny minority that benefit from that kind of money in their family and have it to pass on.

krustykittens · 17/07/2023 13:25

I couldn't care less about inheritance tax. What I would like is to see everyone paying their fair share, from high net worth individuals to large corporations.

Anyotherdude · 17/07/2023 13:24

Inheritance Tax was introduced after WWI - mainly to strip the Aristocracy of unfair amounts of inherited and un-earned wealth.
Because of where I live, houses with 3 bedrooms, but really only 2 double bedrooms plus a box-room, semi, are going on the market at over £875k. This means that my DC, once they have paid IHT on £525k, may not be able to purchase anything in the area in which they grew up.
Given that the average house price in the UK is £285k (figures from February 2023), Why is it fair that a DC of someone in an average price house could easily afford to get on the housing ladder, or go from a 3-bed to a 4 or even 5-bed, when those living in areas like mine can’t?
We have also already paid tax on the money we used to pay the mortgage, so why should it be taxed again, just because of where we live? There was an outcry when Tebbit suggested that people “got on their bikes” to find a job in a different area of the Country, and another one when the residents of Grenfell Tower were offered alternative accommodation miles away from Kensington, so why should homeowners’ families be similarly punished?
It would be much fairer if everyone selling a house was charged a sliding scale of %age of the sale price - that way, your “average” house might be charged 2.5%, double that at 5%, 3 times at 7.5% Etc. That would far more fairly distribute the Tax Burden to those that could afford it.

Bluebellbike · 17/07/2023 13:24

I do not believe IHT should be scrapped.

I am currently making a new will.
My estate will fall below the IHT threshold so none will be due when I die.
One company I spoke to regarding my will said that as no IHT will be due I could choose to create an "Asset Protection Trust", which would mean my estate could be administered without probate and would protect my property from Care Home fees.
There is no way I would do that. Apart from the moral issue of such a thing; if I need care in the future I wod prefer to have a choice as to what that would be, rather than what the council could/would provide.

PineappleRumble · 17/07/2023 13:23

I'd be delighted they were scrapping it, it's a vile stealth tax.

Fortunately, there are legal ways around it (if you have a very good financial advisor) so regardless of whether they do or don't scrap it, I do not intend to pay a penny of it.

LauraNicolaides · 17/07/2023 13:22

Onlyonedog · 17/07/2023 13:17

I thought Inheritance tax kicked in on anything over £325k? (I may be wrong) which is more or less the average house price in UK so majority of people will pay some? Have I misunderstood? I'm hoping that I have.

If you own your home (or a share in it) your tax-free threshold can increase to £500,000 if:

- you leave it to your children (including adopted, foster or stepchildren) or grandchildren
^^
-your estate is worth less than £2 million
^^
www.gov.uk/inheritance-tax/passing-on-home
^^

Overthebow · 17/07/2023 13:22

RebelR · 17/07/2023 13:19

There's no IT between spouses and the 2nd death benefits from both allowances, plus where property is left to children the allowance is higher, so most estates won't pay until they're worth £1m

Not if relative had a spouse and the house was passed to the spouse. The threshold can be up to £1m, as was the case for my family member and why we paid no IHT on £800k.

GasPanic · 17/07/2023 13:22

LauraNicolaides · 17/07/2023 13:11

That was a huge estate, council kid or not!

About £1.4 million at the minimum would be my guess.

If you expect the "rich Tories" to pay for everything like Labour supporters seem to, does £1.4 million qualify you as a "rich Tory" or not ?

And if not then what does ?

Hugasauras · 17/07/2023 13:20

Onlyonedog · 17/07/2023 13:17

I thought Inheritance tax kicked in on anything over £325k? (I may be wrong) which is more or less the average house price in UK so majority of people will pay some? Have I misunderstood? I'm hoping that I have.

Additional £175k if property is being passed down. Also spouses have exemption and you can use unused IHT from spouse to reduce your IHT liability.

My mum has just died and left around £550k in her estate but we only need to pay IHT on the £50k because £500k is covered as some of that money is her share of the house.

Flickersy · 17/07/2023 13:19

It isn't inheritance being passed down that's fuelling inequality, it's the wide-scale artificial inflation of housing costs and the fact that pay has not kept up with inflation for decades now.

Inheritance tax (or lack thereof) would be a drop in the ocean when it comes to fighting inequality. Those who would benefit massively from its removal will already be very wealthy and therefore clued up enough to be as tax efficient as possible. Those that aren't wouldn't gain that much from its removal.

The inheritance tax take for the UK is miniscule compared to the income and corporate tax takes, so from the Tories perspective it's an easy win that honestly doesn't lose them very much money.

There are then ideological / moral questions either way about whether inheritance tax is right or fair, but they can be argued til the cows come home and there's no one right answer.

ComtesseDeSpair · 17/07/2023 13:19

I think it would be fairly popular - even though it would be one of those things which nobody actually ever admits voting for even though it’s obvious a vast proportion of people did, like Brexit. You only have to read an MN thread full of posters who think it’s a travesty that their elderly parent might need to use their own savings and sell their house to pay for their residential care, and trying to get around it, believing that other taxpayers - including those on the lowest incomes who don’t have savings or a house - should instead pay for the care, to realise that many people firmly believe they’re due an inheritance and want that protected.

RebelR · 17/07/2023 13:19

Onlyonedog · 17/07/2023 13:17

I thought Inheritance tax kicked in on anything over £325k? (I may be wrong) which is more or less the average house price in UK so majority of people will pay some? Have I misunderstood? I'm hoping that I have.

There's no IT between spouses and the 2nd death benefits from both allowances, plus where property is left to children the allowance is higher, so most estates won't pay until they're worth £1m

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 13:17

@LauraNicolaides he saved and invested all his life despite living like a pauper. Never married so the full whack was payable on his estate.

Ap24 · 17/07/2023 13:17

I wonder what percentage of the population understands the current rules? I often hear the "taxed twice" narrative and worries from those whose relatives are far below the threshold.

Ultimately I don't care anymore. I used to get quite angry about inequality but I've grown despondent. I just make the rules work for me in the best way possible.

Onlyonedog · 17/07/2023 13:17

cafecreme · 17/07/2023 13:06

It needs reforming not scrapping. IHT is only paid in 5% of deaths and most of those are concentrated in the SE/London.

I thought Inheritance tax kicked in on anything over £325k? (I may be wrong) which is more or less the average house price in UK so majority of people will pay some? Have I misunderstood? I'm hoping that I have.

RebelR · 17/07/2023 13:16

Starsandrain · 17/07/2023 13:15

We pay tax over and over. That inheritance tax people pay on the sale of their parent house is wrong when their parents have paid tax over and over. Stamp duty, etc etc. if I could leave my kids half a house each when im
gone why should they pay a large chunk of that to the tax man. Why shouldn’t they have access to that house to help their futures.

Oh come on. Almost all of that is capital gain on which no tax whatsoever has been paid.

Namechange2625 · 17/07/2023 13:15

It's definitely a vote winner, especially in the South East where simply owning a home would tip you into paying it.

Starsandrain · 17/07/2023 13:15

We pay tax over and over. That inheritance tax people pay on the sale of their parent house is wrong when their parents have paid tax over and over. Stamp duty, etc etc. if I could leave my kids half a house each when im
gone why should they pay a large chunk of that to the tax man. Why shouldn’t they have access to that house to help their futures.

ResisterRex · 17/07/2023 13:14

It would be popular! You go to work, pay tax on your wages. Save those wages (again, possibly taxed in so doing) to buy a house, pay stamp duty. Die, pay more tax on the house you've already paid tax on. People would definitely welcome not being taxed again after death on all the things you've already paid tax on.

But it's been talked about for so long that if it's changed, people might feel more like "well yeah, finally". Can't tell if it would be a deal breaker and for what kind of proportion.

Overthebow · 17/07/2023 13:13

Lanadelday · 17/07/2023 12:59

I really believe most people are not that selfish. It's going to just make inequality so much worse and whether or not people can get a house will depend on their parents. I think people who've 'made money' just through luck via house price rises mainly would think inheritance tax on that unearned wealth is fair.

I don’t think actually make that much difference to inequality between those who really don’t have anything and those who own houses and have some money. The inheritance tax threshold is pretty high at the moment so won’t affect many households inheritance. For example, my family inherited £800k from my grandads estate and no inheritance tax was due on it. I got a decent chunk of that.

LauraNicolaides · 17/07/2023 13:13

RebelR · 17/07/2023 13:06

You're wrong, unfortunately. The UK has long history of saying they want better public services but never, ever voting for a party which says it will increase taxes to pay for them.

Exactly!

Delusional "cakeism" did not start with Johnson. He just told the deluded what they wanted to hear and pretended it was available!

Swipe left for the next trending thread