Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think scrapping inheritance tax would not be popular with voters

620 replies

Lanadelday · 17/07/2023 12:44

I'd say I can't believe the conservatives are considering it, but nothing surprises me any more that they do. But AIBU to think most people wouldn't back this anyway- I can't see it being a big vote winner and don't think they really get that voters are sick of all the inequality and so many people including kids and elderly, living in poverty, not wanting to make it worse.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 22:35

I know. I saw a map the other day showing the number of estates liable for inheritance tax by location. In the county where I live - 60 miles north of London - it was 30 estates last year.

Kendodd · 19/07/2023 22:30

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 22:19

https://www.trusselltrust.org/news-and-blog/latest-stats/end-year-stats/#:~:text=Between%201%20April%202022%20and,the%20same%20period%20last%20year.

HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) has reported that 41,000 people were liable to paying inheritance tax (IHT) in the 2022/23 financial year.

So, I was right. 760,000 first time food bank users last year and 3 million food bank parcels distributed. With only 41,000 people liable for inheritance tax, you're nearly 20 times more likely to need to use a food bank in the UK than pay inheritance tax.
Wow!
And its inheritance taxpeople are up in arms about!

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 22:19

Kendodd · 19/07/2023 22:11

I wouldn't be surprised at all if more people use food banks in the UK each week than are affected by inheritance tax. It seems bizarre to me that it's the richest 4% that we're prioritising.

https://www.trusselltrust.org/news-and-blog/latest-stats/end-year-stats/#:~:text=Between%201%20April%202022%20and,the%20same%20period%20last%20year.

HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) has reported that 41,000 people were liable to paying inheritance tax (IHT) in the 2022/23 financial year.

End of Year Stats - The Trussell Trust

Food banks in the Trussell Trust network distributed almost 3 million food parcels in the past 12 months — read our latest stats

https://www.trusselltrust.org/news-and-blog/latest-stats/end-year-stats/#:~:text=Between%201%20April%202022%20and,the%20same%20period%20last%20year.

Kendodd · 19/07/2023 22:11

I wouldn't be surprised at all if more people use food banks in the UK each week than are affected by inheritance tax. It seems bizarre to me that it's the richest 4% that we're prioritising.

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 21:10

SgtPercyTwentyman · 19/07/2023 20:01

Labour would be fools if they didn't. Sadly the left wing of the Labour Party has form for putting what it calls "principle" before electoral advantage - as the past 13 years (especially 2017 and 2019) have shown.

We’ll wait and see what happens next year, shall we?🙂

SgtPercyTwentyman · 19/07/2023 20:01

GasPanic · 19/07/2023 10:48

That's why it's such a great policy for the Tories.

It appeals to the champagne socialist/floating voter.

In fact it is so vote winning and little cost that I am pretty much 100% confident that if the Tories offer it Labour will steal the policy and be forced to offer the same, or at least something similar.

Labour would be fools if they didn't. Sadly the left wing of the Labour Party has form for putting what it calls "principle" before electoral advantage - as the past 13 years (especially 2017 and 2019) have shown.

Chatillon · 19/07/2023 17:35

Suchab · 19/07/2023 16:07

To be honest it’s not something I have ever needed to worry about and I don’t know anyone else that does either. I’m sure people in the South will get more excited by it than people in the North.

They have already rewarded wealthy people by scrapping the lifetime allowance and increasing the annual allowance for pension investment and this just seems like another attempt to make wealthy people more wealthy.

The divide between those that have and those that don’t is certainly getting bigger.

That is 100% the case.

There is an argument for increasing the IHT exemptions, perhaps even having a larger Residential Nil Rate Band for Greater London homes. But the wholesale scrapping of IHT will drop £7 billion of tax revenue a year out of collection.

The rich 4% of who pay IHT will get away, but it will be the middle-earners that pick up the tab. In case it has not sunk in yet I will say it again very loudly:

THE INTEREST WE PAY ON UK GOVERNMENT DEBT IS GOING TO BE £115 BILLION THIS FINANCIAL YEAR ALONE.

25 YEARS OF QUANTATIVE EASING IS OVER. HIGHER INTEREST RATES ARE HERE TO STAY.

UK NATIONAL DEBT AVERAGES £90,000 PER HOUSEHOLD.

THERE IS NO MONEY LEFT TO GIVE TAX CUTS TO THE RICHEST.

There is certainly no case to abolish IHT completely and give a £2m estate a £400k uplift.

But sheep will believe anything they are told that is written in the Daily Mail or the side of a red bus.

A303 · 19/07/2023 17:11

This calculator is a bit misleading though. Most couples would enter joint assets but it only allocates one SNRB and one MRNRB. The actual tax it calculates is £200k too high for estates between £500k and £2m.

https://www.which.co.uk/money/tax/tax-calculators/inheritance-tax-calculator-aLtwm6T5zOu0

Inheritance tax calculator - Which?

Estimate the value of your estate and how much inheritance tax may be due when you die

https://www.which.co.uk/money/tax/tax-calculators/inheritance-tax-calculator-aLtwm6T5zOu0

Twiglets1 · 19/07/2023 16:56

Apologies @Wildandwonderful they may have to pay some IHT but not much as they would effectively get a 500k exemption so only have to pay 40% on what is left after that. You can use online calculators to get a rough idea.

https://www.which.co.uk/money/tax/tax-calculators/inheritance-tax-calculator-aLtwm6T5zOu0

Inheritance tax calculator - Which?

Estimate the value of your estate and how much inheritance tax may be due when you die

https://www.which.co.uk/money/tax/tax-calculators/inheritance-tax-calculator-aLtwm6T5zOu0

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 16:45

Twiglets1 · 19/07/2023 16:41

They wouldn't have to pay any IHT on it because assuming you leave the house to them equally in your will, they would each gain about 250k from the sale and they would get at least the 325k exemption each.

No they wouldn’t. The exemption is per estate, not per heir. They’d still get £250k each + 60% of the residue though which isn’t insignificant.

Twiglets1 · 19/07/2023 16:41

Wildandwonderful · 19/07/2023 13:19

I agree with a PP upthread who suggested CGT on the sale of a deceased's assets would be preferable to IHT. I am a single parent with two adult children still living at home. If I went under a bus, I would love them to be able to inherit the house tax free so they could stay in it. The IHT would force them to sell as despite being a very modest house, it is worth more than £500,000 and they don't yet have the income to cover the tax.

They wouldn't have to pay any IHT on it because assuming you leave the house to them equally in your will, they would each gain about 250k from the sale and they would get at least the 325k exemption each.

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 16:27

The divide between those that have and those that don’t is certainly getting bigger.

Truest words on the thread.

usernother · 19/07/2023 16:15

I'd like it and it wouldn't affect me in the slightest. I think it's a very unfair tax.

Suchab · 19/07/2023 16:07

To be honest it’s not something I have ever needed to worry about and I don’t know anyone else that does either. I’m sure people in the South will get more excited by it than people in the North.

They have already rewarded wealthy people by scrapping the lifetime allowance and increasing the annual allowance for pension investment and this just seems like another attempt to make wealthy people more wealthy.

The divide between those that have and those that don’t is certainly getting bigger.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 15:54

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/07/2023 15:51

I'm not sure if you are willfully misunderstanding me or genuinely incapable of reading comprehension.

For the last time, I have not told you that you should be contented with anything. Frankly, I couldn't care less whether you are contented or not.

And yes, actually, the state does decide the level at which to tax individuals - it isn't just a voluntary arrangement, though of course there are loopholes that can be exploited by those with no scruples. The sooner those are closed off, the better.

If you don't like the current inheritance tax policy, you are of course free to campaign against it. Just as others are free to question your motivations for doing so.

I am not going to keep going round in circles with this. I do think your motivations are selfish. I understand that you disagree. Your personal circumstances are irrelevant to this conversation.

I'm sure you'll come back wanting to have the last word. I have nothing more to say to you on the issue.

Of course the state decides the level at which to tax individuals. It doesn’t do that on the basis of “it’s reasonable for you to have this much and we’ll take the rest.” It just feels like that sometimes.
I’m not sure the one struggling with comprehension here is me …

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/07/2023 15:51

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 15:15

you say “I give up” and yet you don’t. Your opinions on what I ought to be contented with are uninformed, intrusive and irrelevant to the policy debate.
our tax system, thankfully, doesn’t work on the basis that the state decides what’s reasonable for an individual to have at their disposal and takes the rest (however much you might like it to). your opinions on this question are entirely beside the point.

I'm not sure if you are willfully misunderstanding me or genuinely incapable of reading comprehension.

For the last time, I have not told you that you should be contented with anything. Frankly, I couldn't care less whether you are contented or not.

And yes, actually, the state does decide the level at which to tax individuals - it isn't just a voluntary arrangement, though of course there are loopholes that can be exploited by those with no scruples. The sooner those are closed off, the better.

If you don't like the current inheritance tax policy, you are of course free to campaign against it. Just as others are free to question your motivations for doing so.

I am not going to keep going round in circles with this. I do think your motivations are selfish. I understand that you disagree. Your personal circumstances are irrelevant to this conversation.

I'm sure you'll come back wanting to have the last word. I have nothing more to say to you on the issue.

whumpthereitis · 19/07/2023 15:18

The thing is that despite those in favour of inheritance tax calling those opposed to it selfish, greedy etc…those people are still going to be against it, they’re still going to vote in favour of parties pledging to scrap it, and they’re still going to avoid it if at all possible. Thinking people should be okay with it, and have a more moderate definition of ‘enough’ doesn’t mean they will be. Okay, you think I’m selfish…and? What impact does that have on my life exactly? Please do go ahead and think I’m selfish, that isn’t something that worries me tbh.

btw, estate planning is not just for the super wealthy. Anyone worried about iht should look at what their options are, because they do exist.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 15:15

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/07/2023 15:08

Oh, I give up.

I haven't said that you should shut your trap and be content with what you have got. I simply believe that some redistribution of wealth is just and fair.

You're right that I don't know your exact personal circumstances but to be honest, these are irrelevant. We are not talking about you as an individual, we are talking about policy.

The fact is, if you're worrying about inheritance tax, you stand to pass down a vast amount of wealth to your dc. I don't begrudge that in the slightest, I just think it's perfectly reasonable for a modest percentage of that to be taken by the state in tax to help support those who are less fortunate, regardless of your personal circumstances.

you say “I give up” and yet you don’t. Your opinions on what I ought to be contented with are uninformed, intrusive and irrelevant to the policy debate.
our tax system, thankfully, doesn’t work on the basis that the state decides what’s reasonable for an individual to have at their disposal and takes the rest (however much you might like it to). your opinions on this question are entirely beside the point.

Newbutoldfather · 19/07/2023 15:13

@Abitofalark ,

How does inheritance tax ‘catch’ anyone? You are dead! You can’t take your money with you and it was never your children’s money to start with.

I am also opposed to stamp duty. It penalises those forced to move and those getting divorced. A better solution would be taxing property wealth. Foreign buyers and those buying through corporations couldn’t avoid this. The CGT exemption on people’s primary residence is very questionable. It encourages people to buy far bigger houses than they need and penalises those trying to buy an affordable property (via price inflation).

In a civilised country, we have to pay taxes, unless we want even more inequality than we are currently seeing. A lot query the unfairness of taxes but few query the nepotism and London-centric ability of socially questionable businesses who can pay huge wages to a number of very average people.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/07/2023 15:08

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 14:03

The clear implication of saying that I have more than other people in comparable situations is that I should shut my trap and be jolly well content with that. Given your total ignorance of my circumstances this is both stupid and extremely rude. Give over.

Oh, I give up.

I haven't said that you should shut your trap and be content with what you have got. I simply believe that some redistribution of wealth is just and fair.

You're right that I don't know your exact personal circumstances but to be honest, these are irrelevant. We are not talking about you as an individual, we are talking about policy.

The fact is, if you're worrying about inheritance tax, you stand to pass down a vast amount of wealth to your dc. I don't begrudge that in the slightest, I just think it's perfectly reasonable for a modest percentage of that to be taken by the state in tax to help support those who are less fortunate, regardless of your personal circumstances.

Abitofalark · 19/07/2023 14:36

It has become a stealth tax which catches people of modest means but with an asset of a house*, and the rich for whom it was intended may largely avoid it. When a tax departs from the purpose for which it was intended or becomes so far out of kilter, it should be abolished or reformed or replaced. There's a case for saying stealth taxing should be illegal.

VAT is another example of stealth taxing. The rate was put up to 20% to deal with the financial crisis of 2008 and it has been kept at that for all these years. 15 years. Is it now permanent? Looks like it. It brings in a lot of money.

Stamp duty is another questionable tax. Thresholds and rates have been tinkered with at times of panic about the housing market but why should anyone pay a tax in the first place just for buying a house? It brings in money but is it the right way to raise money?

*other types of asset may be exempt.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 14:04

SunnyEgg · 19/07/2023 13:35

Yep. Nuts

Nasty, too.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 14:03

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/07/2023 13:38

You seem to have a problem with reading comprehension?

There is a difference between having "enough" and having a lot more than other people in comparable situations. If you are unable to understand this simple difference, I don't know how to explain it to you.

The clear implication of saying that I have more than other people in comparable situations is that I should shut my trap and be jolly well content with that. Given your total ignorance of my circumstances this is both stupid and extremely rude. Give over.

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 13:53

if you drop IHT from 40% to 10% people are less incentivised to avoid it and the overall tax take rises.

If you did that the amount raised would barely be worth collecting. There might be a tiny fraction of the tiny fraction of people whose estates are likely to be liable for inheritance tax taking steps to avoid it but it almost certainly isn’t the majority. There are plenty of couples who think a tax free share of £1 million, plus 60% of everything over that is enough for their kids.

Sunnyespania · 19/07/2023 13:45

SgtPercyTwentyman · 19/07/2023 10:26

It's a voluntary tax. Anyone with serious wealth is clued up enough to have made arrangements to avoid it.

If you (well, your estate) pay it, it's because you just tripped over the limit.

Given that the limit will catch every homeowner in London and the SE and a large number elsewhere, I would say that abolishing it would be amazingly popular.

Frankly, if the Tories offer it, I would have to think VERY carefully how I voted in the next general election.

The problem with IHT is that it is a voluntary tax to those who are so rich they don’t need to use the assets they gave on their day to day living. If you have a £800k house that you want to live in and some savings to see you though but die relatively early at say 70 then your estate could incur IHT. If you have £10m in the bank and a nice pension then you could set £1m aside for a luxurious retirement and give the other £9m away without IHT. It’s the upper middle class who pay, not the massively wealthy.

Studies show that if you drop IHT from 40% to 10% people are less incentivised to avoid it and the overall tax take rises.