Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think scrapping inheritance tax would not be popular with voters

620 replies

Lanadelday · 17/07/2023 12:44

I'd say I can't believe the conservatives are considering it, but nothing surprises me any more that they do. But AIBU to think most people wouldn't back this anyway- I can't see it being a big vote winner and don't think they really get that voters are sick of all the inequality and so many people including kids and elderly, living in poverty, not wanting to make it worse.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
plasticwallet · 18/07/2023 15:49

Inheritance tax should be scrapped now more than ever. The generations below are coming up poorer and poorer than previous generations and will need every bit of help from dead family that they can get just to buy a house and secure a roof over their head being as the council can’t even house all our homeless either!

And what about those who don't have much to inherit?

plasticwallet · 18/07/2023 15:45

I would far rather reduce whatever inheritance I stand to get in the future & pay less income tax now as I do think they should raise the bands.

GasPanic · 18/07/2023 15:43

MrsDoylesTea · 18/07/2023 15:28

I think if people can see past the politics of envy, they realise that it's a terrible tax - and as such I think even if you wouldn't have to pay it, many would agree that scrapping it would be popular.

I can't fathom how anyone can think it's fair or a good idea that after working hard to accumulate property and savings all their life that the government should be entitled to swoop in and take it. And they DEFINITELY can't spend the money well.

I think this is a left/right issue with the left basically believing that all wealth belongs to the state, you are allowed to play with it whilst you're alive, but after you die it's theirs to do what they wish with. Not on, and I'll be doing all I can to make sure I avoid it when I'm gone.

Presumably you can't fathom tax full stop then because every year the government "swoops in" and takes the money I have worked hard for all year.

What's more I actually need that money now and can spend it now, whereas when I am dead I don't/can't.

MrsDoylesTea · 18/07/2023 15:28

I think if people can see past the politics of envy, they realise that it's a terrible tax - and as such I think even if you wouldn't have to pay it, many would agree that scrapping it would be popular.

I can't fathom how anyone can think it's fair or a good idea that after working hard to accumulate property and savings all their life that the government should be entitled to swoop in and take it. And they DEFINITELY can't spend the money well.

I think this is a left/right issue with the left basically believing that all wealth belongs to the state, you are allowed to play with it whilst you're alive, but after you die it's theirs to do what they wish with. Not on, and I'll be doing all I can to make sure I avoid it when I'm gone.

Whattodowithit88 · 18/07/2023 15:17

Inheritance tax should be scrapped now more than ever. The generations below are coming up poorer and poorer than previous generations and will need every bit of help from dead family that they can get just to buy a house and secure a roof over their head being as the council can’t even house all our homeless either!

GasPanic · 18/07/2023 14:21

Dragonfly909 · 18/07/2023 14:15

@Blossomtoes Yes I did start thinking along these lines, e.g. if a better system would be to offer tax relief on donations from inheritance but that would probably be very complicated!

My relative did donate to charity in her Will but it was not a huge percentage of her estate. She had saved a lot of money to pay for care in her old age but sadly died before that was needed.

I don't know the ins and outs. But I suspect you could have used a deed of variation to donate some of your share to charity and ensure it was IHT free.

Dragonfly909 · 18/07/2023 14:15

@Blossomtoes Yes I did start thinking along these lines, e.g. if a better system would be to offer tax relief on donations from inheritance but that would probably be very complicated!

My relative did donate to charity in her Will but it was not a huge percentage of her estate. She had saved a lot of money to pay for care in her old age but sadly died before that was needed.

SerendipityJane · 18/07/2023 14:05

verdantverdure · 18/07/2023 13:54

96% of estates never attract any inheritance tax so honestly I don’t see that it’s a pressing issue for most of us.

It's not.

But it is a pressing issue for the people trying to decide who will Britain, which is why it's been trawled through the fish tank of social discourse.

Blossomtoes · 18/07/2023 14:00

Dragonfly909 · 18/07/2023 13:43

Our family have just paid a lot of IT and my feeling was I would be happy for a huge chunk of my relative's money to go to the government if it went to help people, but it seems extremely likely it will just be wasted. That's what I resent. I would prefer to get the the money and then I choose how much and where to donate it (which i am doing with what I did get).

Or your relative could have saved you a job - charity donations are exempt of inheritance tax.

verdantverdure · 18/07/2023 13:54

96% of estates never attract any inheritance tax so honestly I don’t see that it’s a pressing issue for most of us.

Dragonfly909 · 18/07/2023 13:43

Our family have just paid a lot of IT and my feeling was I would be happy for a huge chunk of my relative's money to go to the government if it went to help people, but it seems extremely likely it will just be wasted. That's what I resent. I would prefer to get the the money and then I choose how much and where to donate it (which i am doing with what I did get).

SunnyEgg · 18/07/2023 13:38

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 13:37

Inheritance tax revenue is a drop on the ocean compared to what the NHS costs. Personally I would look at what works in other countries, and see whether those things could be implemented in the UK. For example, would the Bismarck model work better than the NHS/Beveridge model?

I would also look at what is likely to attract wealth and investment to the UK, and encourage growth.

Agree

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 13:37

Changes17 · 18/07/2023 12:57

So, for those that don't like inheritance tax but do like having a functioning health service and would like to have a care service that worked, on the off chance they might need to use it, what tax would they like to see brought in in order to finance that? Or are they happy to take their chances/go private?

Inheritance tax revenue is a drop on the ocean compared to what the NHS costs. Personally I would look at what works in other countries, and see whether those things could be implemented in the UK. For example, would the Bismarck model work better than the NHS/Beveridge model?

I would also look at what is likely to attract wealth and investment to the UK, and encourage growth.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 18/07/2023 13:35

It isn't a popular tax. Death duties have been around forever and have never been popular. However, it is deeply misunderstood by many people who say they don't like it without understanding it.

Currently, a married couple (on the death of the 2nd person) could leave an estate of up to £650k before any IHT is due. A single person could leave £325k. Pension funds are exempt, as are any life insurances written in trust.

But homeowners whose children are beneficiaries can leave up to £1m (married couple) or £500k (single person).

So elderly dad with £400k house, £500k in pensions, some life assurance (written in trust) and £100k in savings/investments - not a penny to pay.

Wealthy widow with £750k house, a £800k pension fund and an investment portfolio of £300k - the estate would pay £20k inheritance tax. The pension fund is excluded and, of the rest, only £50k is subject to tax, if the kids inherit.

The vast majority of estates do not pay inheritance tax. It is a tax on the wealthy.

And yes, my kids will likely have to pay it when we die and no, we don't care to put mitigation measures in place - they'll inherit £500k each and only be taxed on anything above that, so they'll still be far better off than most.

Verv · 18/07/2023 13:34

@Changes17 Possibly but I started paying health insurance in my early 30s so my only pre-existing was asthma.
I already pay tax to fund a health service, and despite a nation paying tax into the service its still crippled, so what good is an additional 7 billion going to do?
Nowt.

Changes17 · 18/07/2023 13:26

@Badbadbunny I have no skin in the IHT game, since I'm not likely to inherit anything. I don't mind if it would be IHT or something else that I'm more likely to pay.

What would your something else be? VAT? I guess that affects everyone who buys anything, including the lower paid. But maybe we could have a higher rate of VAT on luxury goods and zero rate essentials, as we do for children's clothes and some types of food? The tax on a designer handbag could be what - 50%? 100%? (I mean, it already is but currently the brand that makes it gets a lot of that). SUVs could be taxed more heavily, since they are essentially unnecessary.

I'd have a really hefty carbon tax affecting flights past the first return journey in each tax year. Maybe it would rise more slowly for the second return flight but be eyewatering beyond three. I'd tax school fees. The money could all go into improving the 'essential' versions of these things - from a low carbon economy to investment in state schools. I could quite get into this. Tax lottery wins over a certain amount? Meals out costing £xx or more per head (£100? £200?) could attract an extra level of tax?

DdraigGoch · 18/07/2023 13:22

Badbadbunny · 18/07/2023 12:25

Actually that's not a bad idea. At the moment, "gains" are ignored upon death with IHT charged instead. Perhaps we should scrap IHT and also scrap the CGT exemption on death, so that assets that have risen in value over someone's life get taxed at CGT rates, with the usual exemptions for CGT. So no CGT on the gain in someone's home, but full CGT on, say, investments such as stocks & shares or a holiday let or a BTL, etc.

If the inherited home becomes the beneficiary's second property then it wouldn't get the main home exemption, but they're not being charged anything until they liquidate the asset (if they choose to do so).

This is how Australia does it:
https://www.ato.gov.au/Individuals/Capital-gains-tax/Inherited-assets-and-capital-gains-tax/How-CGT-applies-to-inherited-assets/

How CGT applies to inherited assets

How CGT applies when you sell an inherited asset, or it passes to a foreign resident, charity or super fund.

https://www.ato.gov.au/Individuals/Capital-gains-tax/Inherited-assets-and-capital-gains-tax/How-CGT-applies-to-inherited-assets

Changes17 · 18/07/2023 13:15

@Verv That's fine until it gets really expensive, isn't it? Even with private medical insurance you get into not covering pre-existing conditions. I guess you could hope for the best - but paying tax to fund a working health service/care service pools the risk to you as an individual of those expensive things happening.

One of my DC had a form of childhood cancer – completely unpredictable, but it would have wiped us out if we'd had to go private - or been in the States. And that could happen to anyone, at any age. Instead, it was promptly dealt with by the NHS and we were able to continue working from a stable home – and paying a good level of tax.

Badbadbunny · 18/07/2023 13:15

Changes17 · 18/07/2023 12:57

So, for those that don't like inheritance tax but do like having a functioning health service and would like to have a care service that worked, on the off chance they might need to use it, what tax would they like to see brought in in order to finance that? Or are they happy to take their chances/go private?

NHS cost £180 billion
IHT raises £7billion
So chickenfeed really, just 3.9%.

Costs of administration of IHT is the highest of all taxes as a proportion of the amount raised due to the complexity, expensive tax disputes, court cases, etc., Because the figures are large on a case by case basis, disputes often end up in court as you could be talking millions in dispute on a single case.

Far better to raise other taxes which are simpler, such as VAT which basically administers itself because the admin burden is on business!

sleepyscientist · 18/07/2023 13:08

GasPanic · 17/07/2023 13:00

It is a popular policy, despite the fact only a very small amount of estates actually pay IHT.

You always get stuff like "taxing the dead" and "being taxed twice" rolled out, whereas in fact the value gain in a lot of estates (house price increases) has never been taxed at all.

As far as I think, I think it is a reasonable way of recovering both the massive spend on services that older people have benefited from that has been funded by borrowing and also funding elderly healthcare and triple lock pension plans.

It honestly really surprised me that people in general seen to react so negatively to it. I think it should come in at a much lower threshold and be structured so it is unavoidable.

I would rather lose the triple lock and get rid of inheritance tax. I work to give DS the best life possible and we should be able to pass that onto him and his kids on the future without spending a fortune on an accountant. The problem with this country is we don't reward hardwork enough

Blossomtoes · 18/07/2023 13:05

plasticwallet · 18/07/2023 12:41

The simplest way to avoid IHT is to get your estate under the threshold!

This.

Verv · 18/07/2023 13:00

@Changes17 Private.

Changes17 · 18/07/2023 12:57

So, for those that don't like inheritance tax but do like having a functioning health service and would like to have a care service that worked, on the off chance they might need to use it, what tax would they like to see brought in in order to finance that? Or are they happy to take their chances/go private?

Pinkprescription · 18/07/2023 12:56

Changing rules around inheritance tax would make for pretty small fry when compared to changing the rules around the big taxes - income tax, NICs, VAT and corporation tax.
The 2023/24 forecast IHT tax raised is £7.2 billion. This represents 0.7% of all tax receipts and is equivalent to 0.3 per cent of national income.
One thing to remember is that taxes cost money to administer - HMRC employees time, IT systems, cost of court cases etc.
Personally I'd not scrap IHT but wonder if the CGT uplift on death will go. At the very minimum you'd get a base cost rollover so first disposal by whoever inherits will be a gain based on market value at disposal less the giftee's original cost.

NoNonsensePotato · 18/07/2023 12:49

And to be cynical, I'm not even sure it's possible to achieve a situation where everybody is catered for. The population is far too large and growing rapidly with immigration and ever increasing lifespans. Most people just try and look after themselves and their family and it's hard to blame them tbh.

I also feel like there's maybe less of a sense of community nowadays than there once was. If I were someone from the older generation reading derisive diatribes about 'boomers' I'd probs think 'OK, fuck em' tbh.

Whether the issue is race reparations, men in womens toilets, the patriarchy, etc, it does sometimes feel like all sections of society are locked in ideological conflict with each other. The media no doubt exacerbates this but all considered it doesn't really make for a society where people feel empathy and kinship with their fellow occupants or feel particularly inclined to want to help them, especially not if it's at the expense of their own offspring.

Swipe left for the next trending thread