Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone have a baby/toddler but no car?

94 replies

Marcos56 · 17/07/2023 12:08

I don't drive and just wondered if anyone's in this situation, and if they manage ok?

OP posts:
Blathermoa · 17/07/2023 14:39

We went with a travel system as it was the type of pram we wanted anyway and that came with a car seat, which we found handy on occasion. I never got on with a sling but friends had them and found them very convenient. Never had much of a problem getting on buses in central Manchester, and the rain never bothered me anyway- sure you'll be used to it anyway, as we seem to be having all the weather the last few weeks!

wingingit1987 · 17/07/2023 14:32

I don’t drive but husband does. Everything is a million times easier when he is here with the car. I feel a lot less restricted when we have the car.

WanderingWitches · 17/07/2023 14:31

I've never driven and I have a 20 year old, a 9 year old and a 7 year old.
I've found it fine but the times a car would have been really handy is when we need to go to the airport or when it's really raining.
I've tried driving but as an autistic I cannot pick it up at all.

meganorks · 17/07/2023 14:30

Surely it massively depends where you live. Where I am would be fine - I could walk to a different stay and play every day; close to parks; close to shops; on several bus routes. I did have a car and mostly used that to getting to in laws (20 min car journey vs at least an hour and a half bus journey and walking)

elliejjtiny · 17/07/2023 14:26

We did for 2.5 years, from a year before dc1 was born until he was 18 months. We stopped using a car because ours failed its MOT and We couldn't afford to replace it. We live in a fairly rural area and dc1 is 17 now so back then supermarket delivery, online shopping and Amazon prime wasn't as popular as they are now. Only 2 takeaways near us delivered. The hardest bit was when I had to go to hospital for bleeding we had to ask someone for a lift at a time when we would rather it was just the 2 of us. Taxi's weren't an option because we couldn't afford them. We got the bus a lot and my in-laws have us a lift to Tesco once a month to buy the bulky stuff. Everything else we had to carry ourselves. It was ok and we managed it but it was very hard.

greebee · 17/07/2023 14:24

We have a 4yo and a 1yo and we live in London. We've never ha a car. We're very central in zone 2, with the tube 5 mins walk and train 10 mins walk, and 20 bus routes in 3-14 mins walk. So can get anywhere really and no hassle of parking or cost of petrol. School and office are walking distance and can go on day trips and holidays easily as it's easy to get to mainline stations and trains to airport or Eurostar. Never need to use taxis as connections are excellent. Except for coming home from hospital, because I couldn't walk the 10 mins to tube after a c-section so we got a taxi. DC1 was in a buggy at the back.

Groceries are delivered. Used a buggy and carrier in early days, then a Phil and Ted's sometimes, or buggy and scooter depending on where we go. Found it better to go for a buggy without a huge basket, as the smaller buggies which are easier to fold tend to have smaller baskets. Plus you don't want to the basket to be full of loose items when you come to fold it, as they all fall out and the buggy doesn't close properly. Better to have everything in a rucksack then you put it on your back and baby in a carrier and the folded buggy on your shoulder, then you can board any transport whenever you want and not wait for a bus that has one of its two buggy spots free.

Marcos56 · 17/07/2023 14:23

Thanks so much for your replies :) my next question is about raising one in a 1 bed flat 😂 (to start with)

OP posts:
yikesanotherbooboo · 17/07/2023 14:18

I lived in a city with first one and then two tiny children. I had a car but had next to no use for it. We could walk to supermarket, bottle bank, parks,toddler group , library etc. I lived in a rural location with my first and it would have found it much harder or at least less I teresti g. I would also have been dependent on DH for food shopping, lift to hair dresser etc

bryceQ · 17/07/2023 14:06

I live in London and hardly any friends have cars, I don't drive. I don't find it a hassle

ShimmyingThroughTheChaos · 17/07/2023 14:03

DS is almost two and we manage fine with no car. We live in a London suburb near shops and amenities. I don't drive for a range of reasons - never got diagnosed formally with dyspraxia but I have big issues with spatial awareness and coordination and major anxiety about driving lessons. Something I am going to revisit next year!
The YoYo pram has been a godsend. It ain't cheap but it is compact and is really good for public transport. Not being able to drive has limited our holiday options a bit but honestly daily life is fine and I had a lovely mat leave.

lanthanum · 17/07/2023 13:21

We didn't get a car until DD was 3, and I didn't learn to drive until she was in school. We live in a village, but there was a bus into town every 20 minutes, so we had relatively good public transport. It's absolutely fine.

Tips:

Choose your pram - we went for one with plenty of luggage space underneath for doing the shopping. The only snag was when we discovered it wouldn't fit in my parents' boot, but we got round that. It wasn't a good pram for anyone who wanted to put it in a car, but it was great for us.

BabiesRUs were fantastic at advising us on the car seat which fits the largest number of cars - it was useful to have one so that we could accept lifts, but of course it was no use if it would fit the car. We were before isofix became common, so I don't know how that will affect things.

Although it's always best to have proper car restraints, there are two exceptions to the law: taxis, and short local journeys in unexpected circumstances. I think the latter boils down to "your friend won't be fined for giving you a lift to A&E". ROSPA advised us that if we had the pram, we should ask for a wheelchair accessible taxi, and put the pushchair facing perpendicular to the direction of motion. The other thing we did was to get me in and belted, and then put her in the sling (when small) or put the long bit of her reins around me, so that she was secured to me.

Reins can be hooked round the back of some bus seats to help keep a toddler anchored.

If you have a longer bus journey, make sure a toddler has been to the playground before you get on the bus home (or go to the library with a crawler) so that they aren't restless. (That applies to long car journeys too.)

Holidays: we usually holidayed in this country. We had a jumbo suitcase which held enough for all three of us for a week (buying nappies on arrival). Many holiday lets can supply travel cot/highchair. Having a half hour train connection was not a bad thing - she could run off a bit of energy in the station.

We did A&E on the bus twice, for injuries. It turned out to work really well - she fell asleep in the pushchair and was then rested and cooperative when we actually got to see someone.

Some positives:
You get to have so much more communication with your baby/toddler sitting next to their buggy on the bus than you do when you're driving and they're rear-facing in the back of the car.
You can feed them on the bus (when my parents gave us a lift to a family event, it was a bit of a shock to me that we had to be up early enough to feed her before we left!).
Mine had all her naps in the pram (pushchair later) - often falling asleep on the way home from baby groups and then stayed asleep when we got home. That might work less well for you if you have stairs to your flat, though.

TropicalTrama · 17/07/2023 13:21

JohnFinlaysNewTeeth · 17/07/2023 13:06

LRI in Leicester wouldn’t let me leave carrying my child. (We had a non-removable car seat). Literally stood in front of me and made me put her back into the little bed to wheel her outside in incase I fell over. She needed to be in a car seat I was told. I picked her up as soon as the wheels of that bed were out the door. I had to roll that little bed over loads of bumps / blind markers on the path which I refused and was way worse than just carrying her. The dog of a nurse barking at me about insurance and safety couldn’t answer when I said why was I allowed to walk around with her carrying her in the hospital then? If we’re all this massive hazard? No answer. This was when I was transferring to a MLU for aftercare, where they laughed when I asked if I was allowed to carry her in as I wasn’t allowed to carry her out of the hospital. I was made to feel like a fucking idiot by the midwives in the hospital, the car was maybe 10 seconds by the door and I was physically blocked. I only complied so I could get her out the doors without a scene. I wanted to complain to PALS but didn’t have the energy in the early days.

2 different things no? A no carrying the baby in your arms policy is one thing and I get why they might say that even though yes it’s daft. My London hospital also had that policy. That does not equate to you must have an infant carrier car seat and you’d be held hostage if you attempt to leave with baby in the pram.

JohnFinlaysNewTeeth · 17/07/2023 13:06

TropicalTrama · 17/07/2023 12:53

Really?? Which hospital and what did they actually say to you?

Most people I know took black cabs home and you don’t remove baby from the pram in those, one friend of mine walked and another took the bus as it was only a couple of stops, other people I know have fixed carseats not baby carriers like we do. Never heard of anyone being held hostage or even having it questioned. I personally had a nice chat with the midwife about how nifty the YoYo is!

LRI in Leicester wouldn’t let me leave carrying my child. (We had a non-removable car seat). Literally stood in front of me and made me put her back into the little bed to wheel her outside in incase I fell over. She needed to be in a car seat I was told. I picked her up as soon as the wheels of that bed were out the door. I had to roll that little bed over loads of bumps / blind markers on the path which I refused and was way worse than just carrying her. The dog of a nurse barking at me about insurance and safety couldn’t answer when I said why was I allowed to walk around with her carrying her in the hospital then? If we’re all this massive hazard? No answer. This was when I was transferring to a MLU for aftercare, where they laughed when I asked if I was allowed to carry her in as I wasn’t allowed to carry her out of the hospital. I was made to feel like a fucking idiot by the midwives in the hospital, the car was maybe 10 seconds by the door and I was physically blocked. I only complied so I could get her out the doors without a scene. I wanted to complain to PALS but didn’t have the energy in the early days.

Needmorelego · 17/07/2023 12:59

@Marcos56 do you live in a place with decent and reliable public transport, a decent and reliable local taxi company, a place that delivery companies have no issues delivering to and a small co-op type shop in walking distance?
If you have that then you will be fine with no car.

2bazookas · 17/07/2023 12:56

Marcos56 · 17/07/2023 12:08

I don't drive and just wondered if anyone's in this situation, and if they manage ok?

I did. I had a second hand pram that accommodated two, then a (cheapest Motherccare folding) push chair that accommodated one sitting and one standing. We also had a Mothercare baby backpack; and at one time I had a baby seat on my bicycle. We took our children everywhere.
Back then, many families had either no car or only one car. Just like now.

It's all do-able.

WildGeece · 17/07/2023 12:54

A car seat is a good idea, as others have said, both for taxis & car hires. I have heard of people leaving hospital with baby in a sling or pram- perhaps just get it on your notes/birth plan so all health care professionals are aware.

ElFupacabra · 17/07/2023 12:54

Dh drives but works through the week. Bus, walking, train etc. All options. You’re city centre based so public transport should be decent. Try avoid busy times if you can, and get a pram you can fold and carry one handed if there isn’t space. Carrier was my preferred option under 6 months, as we had a bassinet pram that couldn’t be folded and she was dinky so easy to pop in and out. It’s obviously easier with a car but it’s not the soul sucking experience a PP describes either. Plus kids love the bus.

TropicalTrama · 17/07/2023 12:53

Circumferences · 17/07/2023 12:40

It was at my hospital, in London, the only place in the world.

Really?? Which hospital and what did they actually say to you?

Most people I know took black cabs home and you don’t remove baby from the pram in those, one friend of mine walked and another took the bus as it was only a couple of stops, other people I know have fixed carseats not baby carriers like we do. Never heard of anyone being held hostage or even having it questioned. I personally had a nice chat with the midwife about how nifty the YoYo is!

WildGeece · 17/07/2023 12:52

We live in a city of ½ million (not London) with good buses. No car with 1 DC & it's rarely a problem. Use online shopping, buses, slings alot when DC was small, made sure the buggy fot onto buses & could fold easily, bike seat & now DC cycles a bit too. We do use a car through (car club or insured on a family member's car) for some day trips & holidays.

Merrow · 17/07/2023 12:50

I live in Manchester with a baby and no car! It's a bit more annoying than when I lived in London with our first baby and no car, because there are some places that are just impossible to get to by public transport, but I can live without going to Dunham Massey. I have found it useful to have a car seat anyway for when people visit with a car / I go to visit others, but it's not used in my day to day life.

TropicalTrama · 17/07/2023 12:46

We have a car but use it so infrequently that we’re contemplating selling it. Kids are 2 and 6 and in London it’s easier to get around on the bus/tube with the odd taxi and not worry about parking or traffic (buses and taxis using bus lanes save so much time versus your own car!). I know the answers here are disproportionately from Londoners but unsurprising as it is the biggest city by a considerable margin and the points being made translate well to any other city with decent public transport e.g. Manchester.

I also think the car seat hospital thing is myth people like to band around on here. I pushed mine out in the pram and no one questioned it. And our baby car seat is a fixed convertible one anyway that doesn’t leave the car so even if they’d asked, they wouldn’t have been able to see it!

Peony654 · 17/07/2023 12:45

depends where you live. I know plenty of parents in London who don’t have a car. Can see it would be harder in a rural location.

bananaboats · 17/07/2023 12:44

I can drive but don't have a car by choice as don't really need one. Live nowhere near London, town in Scotland but get about just fine. I'm a 10 min walk / 2 mins by bus from the town centre. Manchester City centre you will manage just fine!

Hufflepods · 17/07/2023 12:44

Circumferences · 17/07/2023 12:40

It was at my hospital, in London, the only place in the world.

Why would you need a carseat to bring a baby out of the hospital if you aren't travelling in a car?
So their policy is to just force you to remain in the hospital indefinitely if you don't purchase a carseat you don't need?

Feel free to share this hospital policy. Otherwise I'm going to assume its BS.

B1993 · 17/07/2023 12:43

Not me personally but SIL hasn't passed her test. My BIL works away Monday-Friday (about a 4-5hr commute) so she's on her own with preschooler (almost 4) and baby (10.5 months). She stays home with baby most of the time and the eldest is with a family member/nursery through the week. She relies on lifts if she needs to go somewhere and can't walk. We live in a town so there are buses.