Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How close are you really to your siblings?

93 replies

Ann3216 · 17/07/2023 11:24

I’ve wondered often about this. People seem to be really close on tv and films etc. (I know not really life!). I have 3 siblings all older than me. I talk to two of them often, like 4/5 times in the week. But I don’t think we’re close in the sense that I see others such as no one did any celebrations for each other like milestone birthdays, baby showers, hen do’s etc. there’s a big age gap between me and the other 3. I’m 8 years younger than the 3rd child. The other 3 have an age gap of 1 and 2 years between them.

DH too doesn’t seem close with his siblings. Rarely sees them.

I feel sad when I watch films and tv programmes and hear about others making plans with sisters etc.

hiw can I endure my kids grow up close?

OP posts:
jackstini · 17/07/2023 14:34

My dsis is my best friend
Always been close apart from a couple of years age 10/12

DH has 2 brothers, close-ish to the older one, not really at all with the younger

Mamai90 · 17/07/2023 14:32

I'm really close to my sister she's my only sibling and we are best friends, we even have the same friendship circle and always have but we clashed a lot as teens even though we were close, we get on brilliantly now and rarely argue (probably the odd bicker once a year if that).

DH has one sister, they are close too and I'm very close to my SIL. I think a lot of it is down to personality and how close of a family you come from. I'm from a huge Irish family and all the cousins are close, my Dad has 9 siblings and they are super tight, my Mum is an only but she's close to he cousins and I consider them aunts/uncles.

I can't imagine my kids not growing up close. Both DH and I are easy going people,and our kids are likely to be the same. DHs Dad is quite highly strung and he and his siblings fall out a lot, for years, they are all of similar temperament so I think that plays a huge part whereas his Mum is very laid back and close to her 7 siblings. It really depends on their personality.

superplumb · 17/07/2023 14:30

1 older sister. Hard work who has convinced herself we had a awful childhood ( we didnt). Last saw around o years ago when my eldest was 6 weeks old. She hasn't seen him since or my youngest 7 year old.

Curseofthenation · 17/07/2023 14:29

I would go to the ends of the earth for my sisters. If they called me and said they needed me then I'd come running. However, they aren't great at maintaining regular contact. So it's a very deep connection but very low maintenance!

We were much closer up until our early 20s. We travelled together and have done a few breaks etc over the years. I sometimes wish we spoke more but I can't change the fact they aren't chatty people.

BounceyB · 17/07/2023 14:21

I get on okay with my sister now but very superficially. I don't trust her because she has been really nasty in the past and she thinks she's God's gift. My ex-h used to think she was a narcissist and I can see why he thought that. Once my mum dies I'm not sure we'll stay in touch at all. A colleague of mine used to work with her and she made it obvious she wasn't a fan.

Soakitup37 · 17/07/2023 14:10

I’m one of 7 and vv close to my siblings with a wide age range . I consider them part of my best friend group - any we get together whenever we can, we chat a lot and I’d do anything for any one of them.

I appreciate that’s quite unusual but I feel so lucky with my lot.

Maddy70 · 17/07/2023 13:56

I moved to a different country so that has made it more challenging but we get on fine

itsmyp4rty · 17/07/2023 13:53

Never got on and not close at all. Same for OH.

Creepyrosemary · 17/07/2023 13:51

We used to be close but it's less now. I'm not sure if it's because of busy families and middle age or because he's becoming a strict religious nut case. Still love him loads though.

DandelionBurdockAndGin · 17/07/2023 13:44

Not at all close to my siblings but that's as much them as me - and not helped by parents attitude mother wants everything though her - I've tried to get around that and forge own relationship but never been reciprocated and as they make little effort with my kids I've pretty much given up.

My own parents aren't close to sibling one due to marriage other due to emigration - IL would say they were but not really lots of point scoring and very few actual interactions - DH is wary about his uncles - DH is an only child.

I had my children close together encouraged interest in each other lives - they seem to get on whether that will be enough to have any kind of relationship in adulthood no idea.

ArcticBells · 17/07/2023 13:41

I speak to my sisters every week but it's often an effort. We close because we're siblings but I wouldn't be friends with them if we weren't related.

Mary46 · 17/07/2023 13:36

Not overly close all girls. Different life stages too. I envy close families. My friends have a sister they not close either. Maybe its rare close families lol

QueenCamilla · 17/07/2023 13:31

I have a twin brother. We're not close at all. We shared a womb, then a birthday, then a cot, a bunk, a bedroom... From college onwards we just went our separate ways. Basically there's a stranger in another country who looks like a tubbier version of me. 😳

hopeishere · 17/07/2023 13:29

I only have one sister and we are close.

DH has a sister and brother. They don't get on. DH is currently no / low contact with them both. They're stuck in childhood roles and can't treat each other like adults. His sister can be like Kevin the teenager! It's exhausting trying to navigate it as a third party!

WickedSerious · 17/07/2023 13:25

I have one sister,I've seen her once this year and I doubt I'll see her again before Christmas Eve.
That's quite enough for me.

Iloveanicegarden · 17/07/2023 13:18

Well, that was a revelation! It seems that our family is not that different after all. Nieces that have fallen out, SIL has regular fall outs with her sisters, niece's DH is NC with his sibling, other DH's P is NC with his parents and I was NC with mine......so just a regular family then.

Gratedpotato · 17/07/2023 13:12

I dont think its something you can ensure for your children, aside from avoiding things that often cause rifts in sibling relationships, like pitting them against each other constantly or comparing them unfavourably to each other. Otherwise it just seems to come down to whether they end up in similar places and they like each other enough to maintain a relationship.

I get on really well with my siblings but I am much closer to the two who live near to me and have children of similar ages because we have so much in common that it is so easy for our lives to interlink. We see each other all the time and the cousins all mix together.
I love my other siblings and we got on very well when we meet up. But its a lot less frequent.
Like my youngest brother and I will message on (or near) each others birthdays but I might not see him every year because he lives in another country and our 10 year age gap meant we didn't even really grow up together and he can't remember living with me. I love him and I care about him but we are not close and thats fine. There is no animosity and I imagine if we ended up living closer we would build a closer relationship again.

Floralnomad · 17/07/2023 13:10

You can’t ensure your children will be close . One of my sisters is my best friend, we speak most days and go out a lot together . She is much closer to my older sister than I am , although we are friendly . My adult son is very close to both of them , my adult daughter not so much .

CornishGem1975 · 17/07/2023 13:08

Not at all, didn't even invite my sister to my wedding. We are totally different people, nothing in common, never really liked each other growing up.

JustKeepSlimming · 17/07/2023 13:06

I'm fairly close to my sister, but we don't talk that much - FB messages every few days or so. She'd be the first person I'd turn to if I'm stuck though, and vice versa.

DH would describe himself as very close to his siblings, but tbh it seems to me more like co-dependency than closeness. They see each other all the time, holiday together etc, but actually there's a lot of "politics" and talking behind each other's backs etc. I much prefer the relationship I have with my sister.

I've never really understood the angst some people seem to have about being close to siblings though. There's nothing inherently "good" about being close to them - it happens or it doesn't, in my view.

I know siblings who proudly describe themselves as "close" but in truth they are all quite insular and incapable of making friends outside of their family. I think that's quite sad.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 17/07/2023 12:53

I am close by to my sisters, the two who are near in age to me particularly. We don’t live in each others pockets, but would do anything for each other and have a great time when we are together. We’ll always be around for each others special occasions. I often stay at theirs or they stay at mine and are close enough we would share a bed etc.
I’m the oldest of them and a lot older than the youngest (who’s close in age to my eldest dd), my relationship with her is a bit different, almost parental as parents were older when she was born and I did a lot of the more “fun” parenting type stuff my parents didn’t have the energy for with her.

im not as close to my brother, but quite close to my sister in law, but don’t see them as often.

LeviJeanQueen · 17/07/2023 12:34

I don’t see my brother at all now, I was never close to him growing up as we were always very different people. He’s not a nice person, believes men are superior, he treats his wife and step children terribly, he’s jealous of anyone with more money than him and is homophobic. A real gem.

I have very close friends though thankfully.

My own children are very close and I hope they stay that way.

SallyWD · 17/07/2023 12:30

I have two brothers. We're all in our 40s. We don't get to see each other a great deal because of distance but I'd say that emotionally were very close. We WhatsApp each other almost every day and have a very strong bond.

NeverThatSerious · 17/07/2023 12:30

Really close. I’m one of six and I genuinely like all of them and enjoy spending time with each individually and together. They are all very different so have different qualities and of course, my relationship with each other them differs from the others but I really feel lucky to have them as siblings and as friends.

EvilElsa · 17/07/2023 12:23

I have one sister who is my best friend. We are close in age and live within a 15 min drive. We message daily and see each other frequently. We have a shared hobby so that features a lot in our meet ups and our kids are similar ages too. Trust her implicitly with anything.
DH has a younger sister but is totally NC and has been for over 15 years now. They were not particularly close growing up and have nothing in common at all. It's not so much that they've had a huge falling out or anything, there's just no relationship there at all.