Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How close are you really to your siblings?

93 replies

Ann3216 · 17/07/2023 11:24

I’ve wondered often about this. People seem to be really close on tv and films etc. (I know not really life!). I have 3 siblings all older than me. I talk to two of them often, like 4/5 times in the week. But I don’t think we’re close in the sense that I see others such as no one did any celebrations for each other like milestone birthdays, baby showers, hen do’s etc. there’s a big age gap between me and the other 3. I’m 8 years younger than the 3rd child. The other 3 have an age gap of 1 and 2 years between them.

DH too doesn’t seem close with his siblings. Rarely sees them.

I feel sad when I watch films and tv programmes and hear about others making plans with sisters etc.

hiw can I endure my kids grow up close?

OP posts:
mrlistersgelfbride · 14/11/2023 13:50

I was close to my brother as children, there's less than 2 years between us...I'm older.
We drifted apart a bit as teenagers and in our 20s but closer now, we get on and talk maybe once a week, message in between.

However the problem is he's a (recovering?) drug addict. He doesn't see my DD. He texts me regularly asking for money, same to my parents and I don't respect him. Also if we ever go out for a meal/coffee. I always have to pay for everything and it gets tiresome.
So I see him maybe 3 or 4 times a year.

My partner is very close to his siblings, they are like best friends.
It's so variable.

Dotjones · 14/11/2023 13:48

I didn't go to my brother's wedding, but would love to go to his funeral.

If you want your children to be close then raise them properly but accept that may not be enough. A lot of my hatred for my brother is because he was an abusive bully, but clever enough not to get caught. My parents refused to believe me when I tried to tell them so I stopped trying. My best advice is be on the lookout for abuse and don't use a lack of evidence as a reason not to come down like a ton of bricks when allegations are made.

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2023 13:45

We have a if you need me call me and we will fix whatever it is together, if you’re good that’s good don’t call. Kinda relationship.

I could probably count on both hands how much my children have seen him and my oldest is 14. I’m not fussed and nor is he, no falling out just his him and I’m me.

My dh and his sister omg I used to swear she would sit in his pocket if possible, used to message him every day about what she was having for dinner or asking what he was. Would call him at work for bugger all reason just to chat and be mad if he didn’t answer. It was totally to much, he would moan to me about it yet still respond, then when he started ignoring her messages it was apparently my fault 😂🤦🏻‍♀️

Greenpolkadot · 14/11/2023 13:45

Im closer with my younger sister than i am with my older sister and half brother,
My db is quite odd really, he hasnt had any contact with me for years, He had some contact with my younger ds but then took offence at something and now is nc with her.
I love my younger ds, she is the one i turn to in a crisis and vice versa,

shivawn · 14/11/2023 13:44

Not close at all, don't live in the same country. My husband has 6 siblings and is very close to all of them which I think is lovely. I have some friends who have siblings as their best friends and share the same social groups. It's nice when families are close but there's no guarantees they will be.

PartnersInCrime · 14/11/2023 13:42

A very superficial but cordial relationship - we are very different people.

Mary46 · 14/11/2023 13:36

We ok Im one of 3. Our mother is big work so alot of stress is caused by her. 80s. We good at minute (all girls)

Circularargument · 14/11/2023 13:24

You can't ensure it and imo shouldn't try. Me and sis get on much better now our late mum isn't trying to force it all the time. We still have little in common and disagree on many important moral and political issues, and aren't friends really.

Cornflowers35 · 17/07/2023 16:52

I was really close to my brother growing up.

Now NC as he basically spoke about me to my cheating abusive ExH (in a non complimentary way).

Also db slagged me off to a friend of his, who was a mutual friend of Ex, who kindly repeated everything. (Both claim a "moral high ground" as devout Christians, high up in their respective Churches).

Also they haven't bothered with birthday or Christmas presents for my DC for the past few years, despite I never not bought gifts for my niece / nephew.

Also last gift they gave one of my DC was a regift from another family member. (They were the one to tell me as they were quite upset themselves).

AlltheFs · 17/07/2023 16:49

Not close at all.

I see my DB about 8 times a year, mostly at birthdays, Easter and Christmas. We Whatsapp probably once a week or a bit less. It’s fine, I love him but we are very different people and don’t actually have anything in common. We have each others back though, we’d do anything for each other. But we don’t really socialise and when our parents have passed away we will likely not see each other often.

DH is completely NC with his 2 siblings, has been for 30 years. There was no issue specifically but they were moved abroad and gradually lost all contact (DH was left in UK-long story).

My mum isn’t close to her sister though, and my Dad almost never sees his brother so perhaps it’s learned behaviour. There’s no issue between them but they live a long way away and have nothing in common.

DD is an only and I think that’s no bad thing!

sassyduck · 17/07/2023 16:39

My big sister died when she was 49. I was 8 years younger. I feel so sad that we weren't closer. I don't really have many childhood/teenage memories of her.

AgnesX · 17/07/2023 16:38

I love my siblings to bits but close? No. We all bounce off each other after a few hours together so it doesn't happen very often (we live 100-300 miles apart).

mrlistersgelfbride · 17/07/2023 16:35

I see my brother 3 or 4 times a year for a couple of hours each, we live about 20 miles apart. Chat on the phone averaging once a month.
We always got on in terms of having similar taste in music and sense of humour but we've taken very different paths in life.
He's a (recovering ?) drug addict with no money and it's frustrating always paying for lunch/coffee or drinks when we meet.
I love him but I do keep him at arm's length. He's only met my daughter (5) twice and I can't see us getting any closer.

Oopsididitagaintomorrow · 17/07/2023 16:03

Very close to my sister, she's a year older than me. Speak every day and meet up on weekends, sometimes in the week. Myself and DH regularly go on weekend trips with my sister and her partner.

My brother not so close to, but we've always got each other's backs and I know I can call on him if needed.

Holly60 · 17/07/2023 15:18

I'm close to my brother. See each other lots and talk lots. Know we are always there for each other

Runnersandtoms · 17/07/2023 15:14

I've never fallen out with my brother and we get on fine when we happen to meet at my mums but we rarely interact on a one to one basis. The ocassional text but not chatting just asking a specific question for example. We just lead separate lives.

My kids are super close right now, I hope they have a closer relationship as adults than me and my brother.

carduelis · 17/07/2023 15:03

I used to get on really well with my brother but he’s too busy and important to bother with me or his nephew and niece now. They only live about 90 minutes away, but we only see his family twice a year (I invite him to birthdays but he never replies) and even then I don’t talk to him, I catch up with his kids instead.

Motherofalittledragon · 17/07/2023 15:02

I've a half brother who I was never close to, but now NC which is quite a relief as he's a horrible human.

BubblinTrouble · 17/07/2023 15:00

We’re quite close. Speak daily mostly about the kids and how they are. We see each other once a week with the kids too.

DH rarely talks to his older siblings (4 years and 8 years older than him). No falling out just distance. His family are 3 hours away and when he goes back it’s very busy and full on so he tries to keep it quiet when he’s visiting. 4 siblings in total but he does speak to his sister daily via a WhatsApp group that I’m also on with DH, SIL, MIL and myself. The chat is mainly what we’re eating or updates on the kids!

We try and go back to see his family twice a year and that’s when he will catch up with siblings.

nokidshere · 17/07/2023 14:58

I have 5 sisters. We get on fine. 2 live abroad so we see them rarely, the rest of us scattered around Uk and see each other occasionally. But we all speak every day on messenger or via FaceTime. And we all help each other out instantly if there are any problems.

mindutopia · 17/07/2023 14:56

I have an older half brother. I haven't seen or spoken to him in 20+ years. I only vaguely know what country he lives in from Facebook stalking out of curiosity. We were not close when I was growing up (he was an adult) and I've never had any desire to have any sort of relationship with him as a grown up (plus he was a manipulative arse when our dad died).

Dh and his brother hated each other until they were around 18. Now they are very close. Only see each other a few times a year as do not live close, but speak most days.

There's nothing you can do other than to give them a stable, happy, loving home, which will make it more likely they'll have close times to their family generally. Some siblings are very similar and close (like dh and his bro) and some are like oil/water but can get along at family gatherings - both are fine.

cptartapp · 17/07/2023 14:44

My brother lives a hour away. I haven't seen him in two years. We have never really got on - he was a bully growing up and I can't forgive and forget it. You don't get rewarded with a sibling relationship for that behaviour.
No other siblings and parents deceased.

erikbloodaxe · 17/07/2023 14:44

I'm very close to my eldest sister. 8yr gap. I adore her and her me. She is my person and life would be much smaller without her. We talk most days.

Other 4 siblings I don't bother with at all. They are close with each other though.

Paxosnaxos · 17/07/2023 14:44

We are close enough, live in the same city and speak very regularly. One of them I see weekly, the other every 3 or 4 weeks.
My mother however has made such a big deal of ‘family’ and ‘being close’ that we would probably have been closer earlier without her interventions

Gatehouse77 · 17/07/2023 14:38

My siblings and I are very close in age and relationship. Because of certain family situations we've been united against a common 'enemy' at various stages but we also spend time together and make the effort to do so.
It's not all roses and we still argue and piss each other off at times. One key factor though is that I'm the only one with a family. They're all single although one was married at one point.