Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law issues - help!!

234 replies

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 09:47

Hi everyone.
I've been with my partner over a year, we're very serious and looking to move in together within the next year.
We live around 4hrs from his parents, and I've met them properly around 4-5 times now.
Background:
In short, his parents are very different to me. They are quiet and very traditional, don't drink at all, quite easily offended (I find it hard to have a 'laugh' with them) but all in all, I genuinely think they are really lovely people.
Because of the above, I have found it difficult to connect with them. We visited them last weekend and it was particularly hard for me - I felt like I was a spare part. They didn't ask me a single question all weekend and I just felt a little left out. To try and help the situation, and to seem appreciative of their hosting, I offered to cook on the Monday evening and I left feeling OK with how things went.

The issue:
I was working close to their house during the week so I left my boyfriend there for a few days whilst I worked away. When I picked him up, it had been clear that he had been crying. He wouldn't tell me what was wrong whilst we were there and waited until after the 4 hr journey home to tell me.
Once home, he told me why he was upset. Whilst I had been away, his mum had been really off with him. Before I arrived, he probed her as to why she had been acting the way she had.
She said that I had upset her for a number of reasons and these were the examples she gave him:

  • I was bossy in the kitchen when I cooked (I simply said "go and sit down and take a rest, I've got this") - I genuinely thought I was helping and doing a nice thing, but she's obviously taken this the wrong way.
  • I was rude because I didn't eat the cake she had made and only had a small slice of the one I made and bought to their house (I didn't eat her cake because it contained cream which gives me a dodgy tummy)
  • I only talk about myself in conversations (I've racked every conversation I had with her over the weekend and I really don't think this is true - like I said above, I've found that they take no interest with me and I was the one feeling like the spare part)

I don't know whether I am being deluded, and maybe I am a bossy, self indulgent rude person but I genuinely don't think I am. I've always been polite and appreciative when I stay, even feeling the way I do.

I don't know how best to approach this now. My boyfriend said he was going to have an in depth conversation with her this week. But how do I go about things my end? Should I ring/ message her, do I send flowers apologising (even though I don't agree!). I've never had this problem with anyone before and I feel genuinely cut up about the whole situation and questioning every part of my personality and who I am because of this. As you can imagine, it's taken a real toll on our relationship and I feel like (or maybe imagining) my boyfriend is questioning who I am as a person because of the things his mum has said.

Thanks for reading the lengthy post and help!!!

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 17/07/2023 15:21

BalletBob · 17/07/2023 14:54

There is nothing wrong with men who cry. It's a very normal human reaction, for both sexes, to extreme emotional discomfort. It's not a sign of weakness and in 2023 it shouldn't make another adult react with "ick" as one PP delightfully wrote. I agree that context is important, and clearly there are very unhealthy dynamics at play here, but there are plenty of PPs who absolutely are not making the distinction between him crying and the reason he is crying. Some people are purely commenting negatively on the idea of a man crying.

OP, I think there are a few things going on. You clearly have a more commanding demeanor than they are used to (or like) and I can see why that would be a source of friction. Whilst your intentions in cooking the meal may have been good, I can imagine lots of people would be unhappy about someone they've met 4-5 times taking over their kitchen and basically telling them to butt out. Again, your intentions may have been good but to lots of people this is overbearing and over-familiar behaviour. I think my MIL would be a bit 🤔 if I did this now, and I've been married to her son for 15 years. She is a grown up and ideally she should have spoken up in the first place. Clearly the way that she deals with conflict is completely unhealthy - she seems to entirely avoid saying "no" to someone outside of her sphere of influence (you) but then tries to manipulate and bully the people she feels she can control (your boyfriend). Whilst her treatment of her son is appalling and wrong, she will probably be resenting the fact she was put in the awkward position of having to either risk conflict with you by saying no to your request to cook for them, or put up with you taking over the kitchen. It's worth considering that not everyone likes to be thrust full-throttle into a very familiar dynamic with new people and whilst this might come from a good place, it can be off-putting. I'm not justifying her reaction or behaviour, but trying to offer a little balance.

As far as your boyfriend, he seems to be stuck in the FOG and his crying is not a sign of weakness, but of the extreme emotional impact of his mother's behaviour which will be something he's been conditioned to accept over a lifetime. He's not crying because "mummy told him off" as some particularly cruel PPs have said. The dynamics in a relationship like this are decades in the making and the intense anxiety that a parent like this can induce in their child is crushing. It's not an easy thing to break away from and there's no guarantee he ever will. Whether or not you feel this relationship is worth dealing with that, is up to you. It's going to be a long-term issue, though. And she almost certainly won't change so there are fairly limited ways for it to pan out, none of them particularly easy or pain-free for your boyfriend and, by extension, you.

Agree.

PinkIcedCream · 17/07/2023 15:19

If you were my daughter, I’d be hoping you end the relationship with your current boyfriend and focus on enjoying your life, friendships and building your career.

Too many women get sucked into this depressing role of the fixer and trying to mend their broken partner and his unhealthy relationship with his parents. If he’s really not happy, it’s entirely his responsibility to change the situation. No-one else needs to be involved.

Listen to the other posters on this thread who have sadly wasted years trying to dial down their own personality to appease their partner and his crappy parents. It never works. You’ll be left unhappy, frustrated and will probably feel a growing resentment as the years pass you by.

There are millions of wonderful men in the world and kind in-laws too. I love it when either of my adult DC. or their partners cook a meal in my kitchen. Sitting together chatting and eating a shared meal is one of life’s greatest pleasures. 🥰

Youhadababy · 17/07/2023 15:18

He cried and asked for examples instead of drawing boundaries and sticking up for you?

Hand on heart, this is not going to work.

His mum sounds like a piece of work. The list of complaints is petty but the smoking gun for toxicity here is the fact that he's had to endure her being cold to him (he's hyper vigilant and she's manipulative) before he had to bring it up (but she had the conversation cued up and ready to go) and then he's gone to pieces at the thought of you not being pleasing to her. It hasn't occurred to him to reassure you. This is not a mature individual - you will regret it if you ignore this.

FreeRider · 17/07/2023 15:16

About 10 years ago I made the mistake of going on a weekend away with the inlaws (and a few of their relations). I wasn't well before we left, wanted my then boyfriend to go alone, but he told me that me cancelling 'wouldn't go down well' with his father...I forced myself to go. After nearly 8 hours of travelling (we went from one end of the country to the other) they all stayed up all night getting drunk, I went to bed about midnight feeling like hell ...boyfriend finally came up to bed at 8am (!). He was then unconscious for the rest of the day, to about 6pm...the rest of them went out on a day trip (involving drink driving by some of them, they hadn't actually been to bed either so..).

Anyway already very long story shorter, I was admitted to hospital 3 days after we got back with double pneumonia. Boyfriend went around to see his parents on the Sunday, they were supposed to be going to an aunts for lunch. He'd hardly got in their door when his father had a right go at him about how 'badly' I'd behaved over the weekend...purely because I wouldn't stay up all night drinking. Boyfriend pointed out I was already fucking ill at that point ... didn't matter. Prior to this weekend boyfriend had always been saying to me that his parents liked me .... but as a divorced 42 year old woman at the time, I knew they didn't - sometimes you know straight away. I wasn't actually that arsed either, we weren't going to be having children so while I would have preferred to have a good relationship with them, I didn't see it as mandatory, more of a bonus.

Boyfriend said I should 'just apologise to his dad' err, for what? Being ill? None of the rest of his family knew until I was admitted to hospital that I was already ill during that weekend.

That was 9 years ago. I went to his parents once after that weekend, just before Christmas (boyfriend was working actual Christmas) - we had moved 200 miles away so were staying for 2 nights. The minute I walked in his father disappeared to their bedroom...and stayed there all weekend. It was the rudest, most upsetting interaction I've ever had with a partner's parents. When we left on the Sunday I told my boyfriend that was the last straw, I wasn't going to have anything to do with them ever again....and I haven't. I've not seen them since. No regrets.

BeautifulWar · 17/07/2023 15:14

Run for the hills!!! Not joking

I agree. I get that you love him and your relationship is otherwise good. You'll probably think his parents behaviour is not his fault - I certainly did, but it's likely that eventually it'll sour your relationship. These things tend to get worse rather then better.

Nanny0gg · 17/07/2023 15:14

Candymay · 17/07/2023 15:01

I seem to be on my own here then. I would not be happy with any other woman taking over my kitchen. That would be a huge boundary issue for me. Maybe I’m the awful mil.

I think it’s ok for her not to like you at first and then hopefully she will grow to love you. It takes time.

But then surely you'd just politely decline the offer and say that perhaps they could reciprocate when you visited them?

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 15:13

JustMarriedBecca · 17/07/2023 15:11

Do you know why his previous relationship broke down? Any chance that MIL caused issues and he's realising this relationship might suffer for the same reasons? My husband has got upset over the relationship I have with MIL. He feels trapped. It's taken the best part of 20 years, two kids and me not giving a damn but we're now able to joke about how we don't agree and would kill each other if we had to spend any serious length of time together.

In terms of what happened this weekend, leave it to him to sort. You didn't do anything wrong. I'd probably take a cake next time and say "sorry, I bought my own. I have an allergy to cream which is why I couldn't eat your SCRUMMY looking cake last time". I'd not address it now but do it subtly.

Boys and their Mums are bloody weird. Strange dynamics. I'm probably going to be as weird when I'm a MIL though so, soz in advance to the world.

From what he's said to me, his relationship broke down due to moving in together during the pandemic. I've heard lots of people say the same so I never really questioned it further. However now this has happened, I'm also wondering if his parents had anything to do with it...

OP posts:
JustMarriedBecca · 17/07/2023 15:11

Do you know why his previous relationship broke down? Any chance that MIL caused issues and he's realising this relationship might suffer for the same reasons? My husband has got upset over the relationship I have with MIL. He feels trapped. It's taken the best part of 20 years, two kids and me not giving a damn but we're now able to joke about how we don't agree and would kill each other if we had to spend any serious length of time together.

In terms of what happened this weekend, leave it to him to sort. You didn't do anything wrong. I'd probably take a cake next time and say "sorry, I bought my own. I have an allergy to cream which is why I couldn't eat your SCRUMMY looking cake last time". I'd not address it now but do it subtly.

Boys and their Mums are bloody weird. Strange dynamics. I'm probably going to be as weird when I'm a MIL though so, soz in advance to the world.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 17/07/2023 15:11

edenhills · 17/07/2023 15:03

I'm really shocked at the attitude to him crying on here. So unbelievably sexist. His mum had a go at him and slagged off the woman had loves. This shocked and upset him. He didn't go crying to op, she could just tell he had been crying. If my mum did the same I might have a cry (I'm a woman) Men are not robots, they are allowed to cry sometimes FFS.

Absolutely!

carrotsfortea · 17/07/2023 15:11

I don't think the issue is so much about the meal and kitchen. People can be very possessive and also may even be anxious about people taking over their kitchens. So it might be a bit of a faux pas on your end there. However, the bit that worries me is not speaking to him for days due to these perceived slights from you. What on earth is that about? Not a grown-up way to behave and incredibly difficult to deal with for your bfriend and yourself. I wouldn't necessarily ditch him over the whole matter but I would maybe have a serious talk with him about what on earth is going on and what is or isn't appropriate. I am also concerned he's just reporting all she said to you wholesale. Ideally he should deal with it and just go to you maybe over any misunderstandings you could clear up. But he doesn't seem to be able to communicate effectively with his mother or work out really what is wrong.

I just wanted to say OP you sound really nice actually. Don't feel bad or question yourself too much. Even if you were a bit domineering in the kitchen so what? She could have had a quick word with your bfriend if shy or she could have said something at the time to you if not so shy. But it's hardly a days of being sent to coventry offence. That she is doing the silent treatment to her son sounds like she is trying to control him. Perhaps she doesn't like your religious stance. Whatever it is, I wouldn't break up just because of this if you like your bfriend. But you do need to know he's going to be a bit better at dealing with it all and protecting you from it if she is going to continue with this sort of treatment as it doesn't sound at all reasonable how she is behaving to me.

BalletBob · 17/07/2023 15:10

GerbilsForever24 · 17/07/2023 14:56

There is nothing wrong with men who cry.

What on earth are you on about? of course there's nothing wrong with a man crying. there is a LOT wrong with anyone, man or woman, crying because their mother made a few comments about their new partner.

Did you bother to read the rest of my comment? Doesn't really sound like it.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 17/07/2023 15:09

Ok so I've been in this situation, although with some details the other way round, I was the quiet one, the in-laws were the ones asking all the questions and in my experience overstepping e.g bringing my father's cancer up at the dinner table etc.. Anyway, it didn't end well. My MIL was way too close to her favourite youngest son (my fiance), it was weird. It all came out when MIL exploded after we told her of our wedding plans. Turns out she didn't like me, we had no idea as we both thought they liked me! She revealed who she really was, a nasty, malicious controlling cow and tried her very best to break us up during our engagement and immediately after our wedding!!

She listed off a load of reasons, not too dissimilar to yours. It got worse and worse and worse until I had had enough and we went no-contact.

I've not seen or spoken to them in over a decade. It was the only way, otherwise our marriage would not have survived their incessant need to dictate to us despite us being grown adults in our 30's at the time.

It's very very difficult and it will most certainly strain your relationship.

Sugargliderwombat · 17/07/2023 15:08

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 14:46

I disagree on this one- they are Christian and go to church regularly but they have never pushed their beliefs on me and although they'd take my other half to church when he was a child, they've never forced their beliefs on him as an adult.
I don't see the clash in religious beliefs being the issue here although I know it can be a major problem with other relationships with their in laws x

Yeah this is nonsense. My own mum is Christian and is married to an atheist. I'm an atheist. My partner is an atheist. It's fine.

Op you sound lovely and the mum just sounds like a fruit loop. Personally I think knowing from the beginning is a bit better. I loved my MIL for the first 4 years, she only went loopy and territorial after I had a baby. So I wouldn't write the relationship off just yet x

edenhills · 17/07/2023 15:03

I'm really shocked at the attitude to him crying on here. So unbelievably sexist. His mum had a go at him and slagged off the woman had loves. This shocked and upset him. He didn't go crying to op, she could just tell he had been crying. If my mum did the same I might have a cry (I'm a woman) Men are not robots, they are allowed to cry sometimes FFS.

Candymay · 17/07/2023 15:01

I seem to be on my own here then. I would not be happy with any other woman taking over my kitchen. That would be a huge boundary issue for me. Maybe I’m the awful mil.

I think it’s ok for her not to like you at first and then hopefully she will grow to love you. It takes time.

GerbilsForever24 · 17/07/2023 14:56

There is nothing wrong with men who cry.

What on earth are you on about? of course there's nothing wrong with a man crying. there is a LOT wrong with anyone, man or woman, crying because their mother made a few comments about their new partner.

BalletBob · 17/07/2023 14:54

There is nothing wrong with men who cry. It's a very normal human reaction, for both sexes, to extreme emotional discomfort. It's not a sign of weakness and in 2023 it shouldn't make another adult react with "ick" as one PP delightfully wrote. I agree that context is important, and clearly there are very unhealthy dynamics at play here, but there are plenty of PPs who absolutely are not making the distinction between him crying and the reason he is crying. Some people are purely commenting negatively on the idea of a man crying.

OP, I think there are a few things going on. You clearly have a more commanding demeanor than they are used to (or like) and I can see why that would be a source of friction. Whilst your intentions in cooking the meal may have been good, I can imagine lots of people would be unhappy about someone they've met 4-5 times taking over their kitchen and basically telling them to butt out. Again, your intentions may have been good but to lots of people this is overbearing and over-familiar behaviour. I think my MIL would be a bit 🤔 if I did this now, and I've been married to her son for 15 years. She is a grown up and ideally she should have spoken up in the first place. Clearly the way that she deals with conflict is completely unhealthy - she seems to entirely avoid saying "no" to someone outside of her sphere of influence (you) but then tries to manipulate and bully the people she feels she can control (your boyfriend). Whilst her treatment of her son is appalling and wrong, she will probably be resenting the fact she was put in the awkward position of having to either risk conflict with you by saying no to your request to cook for them, or put up with you taking over the kitchen. It's worth considering that not everyone likes to be thrust full-throttle into a very familiar dynamic with new people and whilst this might come from a good place, it can be off-putting. I'm not justifying her reaction or behaviour, but trying to offer a little balance.

As far as your boyfriend, he seems to be stuck in the FOG and his crying is not a sign of weakness, but of the extreme emotional impact of his mother's behaviour which will be something he's been conditioned to accept over a lifetime. He's not crying because "mummy told him off" as some particularly cruel PPs have said. The dynamics in a relationship like this are decades in the making and the intense anxiety that a parent like this can induce in their child is crushing. It's not an easy thing to break away from and there's no guarantee he ever will. Whether or not you feel this relationship is worth dealing with that, is up to you. It's going to be a long-term issue, though. And she almost certainly won't change so there are fairly limited ways for it to pan out, none of them particularly easy or pain-free for your boyfriend and, by extension, you.

Pallisers · 17/07/2023 14:52

but I'm questioning whether this is a family I want to be part of. This weekend alone has taken a massive toll on my mental health, so I can't risk this happening on a regular basis :-(

I think you've answered your own question here OP.

Tophy124 · 17/07/2023 14:52

I agree with previous posters that this may be culture clash. I don’t swear around my in-laws, tone down my loudness and wouldn’t dream of speaking to them in the way I joke around with my friends about things. I maintain a politeness like I would with a friends parents too. My in-laws (other than my SIL) culturally don’t appreciate swearing or drinking and so I wouldn’t do it around them. Me asking them to leave the kitchen even politely would not go down well at all either. I think if you’re in someone else’s home it’s normal to adapt your behaviour. My husband adapts his around my family too.

Tophy124 · 17/07/2023 14:49

I’d break up with him. She isn’t your MIL as you aren’t married, she is your boyfriend of a years mother. Him crying and telling me all this would be the end for me. He acted like an asshole here by telling you all this and by crying rather than setting boundaries with his mother on how she speaks about a guest he has brought to their home. I would find it rude if someone told me to leave my own kitchen but I also wouldn’t make a big deal out of it nor upset my son over it. Their relationship sounds odd. And no this isn’t them being conservative or religious as my in-laws are from the Deep South and as religious as you can get and my husband still wouldn’t tolerate them bitching about me.

Zood · 17/07/2023 14:47

Well, if you are committed to a long term relationship with this person, I'd send flowers with a lovely note, thanking them for their kindness and hospitality. Rise above it and just be pleasant, otherwise it will eat away at you, undermine your confidence and eventually erode your relationship with your partner. Kill them with charm & kindness.

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 14:46

DemonicCaveMaggot · 17/07/2023 14:43

If they are devout Christians and you are atheist I think there will always be a problem.

I disagree on this one- they are Christian and go to church regularly but they have never pushed their beliefs on me and although they'd take my other half to church when he was a child, they've never forced their beliefs on him as an adult.
I don't see the clash in religious beliefs being the issue here although I know it can be a major problem with other relationships with their in laws x

OP posts:
DemonicCaveMaggot · 17/07/2023 14:43

If they are devout Christians and you are atheist I think there will always be a problem.

heckmuffin · 17/07/2023 14:40

Him crying is a bit of an issue, though. Not sure I could get past that.

If it wasn't for that, I think they would probably get used to you and find things about you they really like. Because you do seem so nice!

I haven't met my partner's parents yet as they live abroad. We do talk over whatsapp and I certainly tone things down for his mum – and I'm going to have to rein in my casual swearing when we finally meet 🤐

Moveoverdarlin · 17/07/2023 14:39

My in-laws sound very similar, but my husband agrees that they’re hard work and unbearable so we don’t have an awful lot to do with them. Maybe see them 4-5 times a year and they live an hour and a half away. They never make conversation and I’ve given up, so our meetings consist of ‘lovely day isn’t it?’ ‘Mortgage rates are set to go up I see? Oooh yes, it’s terrible.’ It’s so awkward. I would never dream of offering to cook at their house, they would be aghast at that.