Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law issues - help!!

234 replies

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 09:47

Hi everyone.
I've been with my partner over a year, we're very serious and looking to move in together within the next year.
We live around 4hrs from his parents, and I've met them properly around 4-5 times now.
Background:
In short, his parents are very different to me. They are quiet and very traditional, don't drink at all, quite easily offended (I find it hard to have a 'laugh' with them) but all in all, I genuinely think they are really lovely people.
Because of the above, I have found it difficult to connect with them. We visited them last weekend and it was particularly hard for me - I felt like I was a spare part. They didn't ask me a single question all weekend and I just felt a little left out. To try and help the situation, and to seem appreciative of their hosting, I offered to cook on the Monday evening and I left feeling OK with how things went.

The issue:
I was working close to their house during the week so I left my boyfriend there for a few days whilst I worked away. When I picked him up, it had been clear that he had been crying. He wouldn't tell me what was wrong whilst we were there and waited until after the 4 hr journey home to tell me.
Once home, he told me why he was upset. Whilst I had been away, his mum had been really off with him. Before I arrived, he probed her as to why she had been acting the way she had.
She said that I had upset her for a number of reasons and these were the examples she gave him:

  • I was bossy in the kitchen when I cooked (I simply said "go and sit down and take a rest, I've got this") - I genuinely thought I was helping and doing a nice thing, but she's obviously taken this the wrong way.
  • I was rude because I didn't eat the cake she had made and only had a small slice of the one I made and bought to their house (I didn't eat her cake because it contained cream which gives me a dodgy tummy)
  • I only talk about myself in conversations (I've racked every conversation I had with her over the weekend and I really don't think this is true - like I said above, I've found that they take no interest with me and I was the one feeling like the spare part)

I don't know whether I am being deluded, and maybe I am a bossy, self indulgent rude person but I genuinely don't think I am. I've always been polite and appreciative when I stay, even feeling the way I do.

I don't know how best to approach this now. My boyfriend said he was going to have an in depth conversation with her this week. But how do I go about things my end? Should I ring/ message her, do I send flowers apologising (even though I don't agree!). I've never had this problem with anyone before and I feel genuinely cut up about the whole situation and questioning every part of my personality and who I am because of this. As you can imagine, it's taken a real toll on our relationship and I feel like (or maybe imagining) my boyfriend is questioning who I am as a person because of the things his mum has said.

Thanks for reading the lengthy post and help!!!

OP posts:
Youhadababy · 17/07/2023 20:15

CrazyArmadilloLady · 17/07/2023 19:53

Well, in hindsight, obviously this is what the OP should have done.

But no reasonable person could have predicted that the MIL would be SO mortally offended by the cake refusal, to foresee that such a step would be necessary.

I think the cream was in the cake.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 17/07/2023 20:11

jannier · 17/07/2023 20:00

Nothing to do with mil just good manners not to refuse your hosts cooking in preference to your own.

Well again, obviously - except when the alternative will make you unwell.

Yes, obviously, the OP should have taken the MIL’a cake and not eaten the cream.

But it shouldn’t have even been necessary, and it shouldn’t have caused such mortal offence as to be ^complained about’.

Manners are a two-way street, and I’m not seeing MIL’s.

GLC789 · 17/07/2023 20:05

Nofreshstarthere22 · 17/07/2023 10:00

Run for the hills!!! Not joking

What they said!

Your mother in law is toxic. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news. But, you have done absolutely NOTHING wrong. She's making an issue because she doesn't like that her darling son has another woman taking care of him.

Unless she changes her behaviour, you're in for a horrible ride with her x

jannier · 17/07/2023 20:00

CrazyArmadilloLady · 17/07/2023 19:53

Well, in hindsight, obviously this is what the OP should have done.

But no reasonable person could have predicted that the MIL would be SO mortally offended by the cake refusal, to foresee that such a step would be necessary.

Nothing to do with mil just good manners not to refuse your hosts cooking in preference to your own.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 17/07/2023 19:53

jannier · 17/07/2023 19:45

I'd have had her cake and left the cream as you had done the dinner to meet half way.

Well, in hindsight, obviously this is what the OP should have done.

But no reasonable person could have predicted that the MIL would be SO mortally offended by the cake refusal, to foresee that such a step would be necessary.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 17/07/2023 19:49

Mummy08m · 17/07/2023 16:01

I think all the commenters who have said you shouldn't have offered to cook are missing the point slightly.

Somewhere out there, OP, is a family who would love you as a DIL. They'd love you bustling in like a ray of sunshine with your jokes and laughs and cooking. "Go relax and sit down, I'll cook for you" - I'd love you as my Dil and I'd happily eat your cooking and your cake (only we're probably the same age and I don't have a son yet!). You'd have such a laugh with a certain type of extravert/lazy MIL who would value you helping out.

If you stay with this family you'll be constantly second guessing yourself and toning down your friendliness and your self esteem will be crushed. You'll turn into a meek shadow of yourself every time you visit them.

It's not just that the in laws don't value your bubbly personality, your Bf doesn't either.

What a waste, when you sound completely lovely. There's a family out there that would love you (and your cooking) to bits.

What a lovely post. Think hard about this, OP.

I would also be asking your DP a little bit more about why his relationship with his ex broke down. I would be asking someone gentle but direct questions - along the lines of whether his parents approved of her (and I’d be using the word ‘approved’, as it send a message to him that you’ve noticed this is a requirement).

But, TBH, even if they broke up for other reasons, I think you’ve got your work cut out for you, if you want to make this relationship work.

jannier · 17/07/2023 19:45

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 18:24

@jannier Just to clarify - I didn't refuse her cake and get my own out just for myself. I took a cake with me on the visit as a nice gesture, she had also made one (unknown to me) and after the meal I cooked on the Monday, they were put on the table for dessert. I didn't actually want any cake but I felt pressured to have some sort of dessert, so opted to eat a very small slither of the cake I had bought with me, rather than hers due to it having cream in it. I have told her previously that I try and keep away from too much cream, so didn't mention it again this time so she must've forgotten and took offence.

I'd have had her cake and left the cream as you had done the dinner to meet half way.

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 18:24

@jannier Just to clarify - I didn't refuse her cake and get my own out just for myself. I took a cake with me on the visit as a nice gesture, she had also made one (unknown to me) and after the meal I cooked on the Monday, they were put on the table for dessert. I didn't actually want any cake but I felt pressured to have some sort of dessert, so opted to eat a very small slither of the cake I had bought with me, rather than hers due to it having cream in it. I have told her previously that I try and keep away from too much cream, so didn't mention it again this time so she must've forgotten and took offence.

OP posts:
itsmylife7 · 17/07/2023 18:15

Really, truthfully ,OP this is never going to work with with the future inlaws.

This is your future visiting them and never being able to just " be you ".

Then if you both decide to have children...can you imagine the judgement from them.

The fact this Mother has the power to reduce her son to tears....very worrying.

As for taking over the kitchen...be my guest.

Mojoj · 17/07/2023 18:02

Run!! He was crying because his mammy doesn't like you? OMG, run!!!!!

jannier · 17/07/2023 17:41

Mummy08m · 17/07/2023 16:14

That works perfectly for you and your DIL but everyone is different.

When my MIL comes to see us she always brings a pie or lasagne she's made and she'll cook the sides in my kitchen too. I'm profusely grateful every time, there's no "my kitchen".

My point is just that everyone is different. If I had a DIL who blazed in and said "you relax I'll cook for you" I'd be like "say no more" and immediately put the telly on or even run myself a bath.

Op needs to find a family who do things her way

Why if everything else is fine why should one thing that has happened 4 or 5 times in 2 years spoil the rest of her life? It's very possible to adjust to doing things somebody else's way in their house because it's not your house. Your never going to find a family that does everything your way.....and refusing a cake someone has cooked in their home then diving into your bag and serving up your own is rude unless you give an explanation.
Why is it okay to order somebody about in their own home? Your the guest......I bet if the mil had been coming in and helping herself in Dils house telling Dil what to do the lynch mob would be out

billy1966 · 17/07/2023 17:17

@Mummy08m agree and with @Puzzledandpissedoff.

His repeating his parents issues instead of dealing with them there and then is off.

Who wants to hear that their boyfriends parents are so petty and disikes them?

The OP didn't fee he was particularly in her corner either.

He remained staying with his parents despite his mother's awful behaviour, why couldn't he pack and leave, or deal with it?

You may not choose your partner for your in laws but they invariably come as part of the package, and if your boyfriend shows signs of being hugely and unduly under their influence, then that will likely have blow back on you if you stay.

He sounds very much in their grip.

GabriellaMontez · 17/07/2023 16:34

ThirtyPercentRecycled · 17/07/2023 10:10

Leave him.
This is a him problem - his mother said all
that and he ended up crying? Did he stick up for you? Did he point out how ridiculous she’s being?

Do not settle for a life when a dp is torn between you and his mother, it will end badly at some point.

This. Listening to her then passing it all on to you is pathetic.

Mummy08m · 17/07/2023 16:29

BalletBob · 17/07/2023 16:19

I don't think many of us pick our spouse based on their family. Certainly if I was choosing on that basis, I wouldn't be married to my DH. It's not necessary to fit in with your in-laws to have a happy marriage.

The entire issue is how this impacts OP's boyfriend and the knock-on effect on her/their relationship.

I don't think many of us pick our spouse based on their family.

Not directly, no, but the culture and expectations get passed down. It probably shouldn't be true but it is, in pretty much every family I've met. If a man has tight lipped, stern parents who don't skip breakfast and are possessive about their kitchens (as an example) then chances are he will have similar values. If he comes from a casual, easy going, noisy family, then he'll be happy having a similar household later in life.

I know there are exceptions but they are rare.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 17/07/2023 16:25

It would have been so easy for him to defend/explain op's actions to his mum. But instead he passed on her criticisms which heavily implies that he agrees with them, at least partly, and wants her to address them

Exactly - or at the very least he may want her to pretend to be other than what she is so mummy can be placated

Except trying to placate people who go off about the least little thing rarely works; they just move onto the next thing so that control can be maintained

Hyggesaurus · 17/07/2023 16:25

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 12:51

According to him he was crying because of 2 things:
The situation that he has now been put in... I don't think he saw this coming. Our relationship so far has been amazing and maybe this questioned that and he feels very stuck at the moment.
And mostly (from what he has said to me) upset because of the way his mum made him feel in the days that I wasn't there. Apparently she hardly spoke to him and he could barely be in the same room as her...

I agree with other posts about the crying though... how is he going to be able to stand up for me if he's this sensitive at this stage

So why did he stay for days if he was treated like this? It’s not normal, he could have just said I’m not taking this crap, and left? Another huge red flag.

BalletBob · 17/07/2023 16:19

Mummy08m · 17/07/2023 16:14

That works perfectly for you and your DIL but everyone is different.

When my MIL comes to see us she always brings a pie or lasagne she's made and she'll cook the sides in my kitchen too. I'm profusely grateful every time, there's no "my kitchen".

My point is just that everyone is different. If I had a DIL who blazed in and said "you relax I'll cook for you" I'd be like "say no more" and immediately put the telly on or even run myself a bath.

Op needs to find a family who do things her way

I don't think many of us pick our spouse based on their family. Certainly if I was choosing on that basis, I wouldn't be married to my DH. It's not necessary to fit in with your in-laws to have a happy marriage.

The entire issue is how this impacts OP's boyfriend and the knock-on effect on her/their relationship.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 17/07/2023 16:19

You sound lovely, generous and understanding, OP - maybe a bit too understanding - and apart from sticking up for you or giving in totally to his mother there's actually a third way he could go. He could carry on trying to play the middle game, placating each of you iin turn and getting increasingly tearful while you both come to resent each other more and more

And no, there's nothing at all wrong with a man crying, but it's why he was crying that would bother me, and the "why" appears to be the unhealthy hold his mother has over him - something which I suspect has a very long history

You could of course wait until he's spoken to her again, but with what's gone before do you honestly think he'll challenge her behaviour in even the gentlest way? I'd suggest asking that you go together for a proper talk, but rather doubt there's much point even if he'd let you, which again I very much doubt

As so many have said, with attitudes like this the relationship's unlikely to be happy long term, so it may be better to cut your losses now and find someone who values you properly and as you deserve

Mummy08m · 17/07/2023 16:14

jannier · 17/07/2023 16:07

My Dil has had her own kitchen for 6 years. I'm happy to go and care for the grandkid make their food etc when I'm on my own but wouldn't dream of just putting the kettle on or dishing up etc if she's there. I'd ask but never insist I'd worry she thought I was judging her.

That works perfectly for you and your DIL but everyone is different.

When my MIL comes to see us she always brings a pie or lasagne she's made and she'll cook the sides in my kitchen too. I'm profusely grateful every time, there's no "my kitchen".

My point is just that everyone is different. If I had a DIL who blazed in and said "you relax I'll cook for you" I'd be like "say no more" and immediately put the telly on or even run myself a bath.

Op needs to find a family who do things her way

jannier · 17/07/2023 16:12

Sophieweston · 17/07/2023 16:01

Yes!! When we go to his parents there's always a lot of pressure to make plans for all of us every single day. I never get asked what I'd like to do, just expected to go along with it. Obviously I've only visited a handful of times so haven't questioned it but now you've said....

Isn't it normal when visiting someone to do things together rather than treat it like a hotel and go off on your own?

loislovesstewie · 17/07/2023 16:12

Actually, the minute you said 'church goers' I thought there is the problem. I know I'll be criticised but sometimes I think that they are the most judgemental people going. I've been there!

jannier · 17/07/2023 16:10

Nanny0gg · 17/07/2023 15:14

But then surely you'd just politely decline the offer and say that perhaps they could reciprocate when you visited them?

You don't know how the suggestion was put to mil by the boyfriend it may have been a X is doing rather than a shall we cook for you or they could have thought it was a take away .....very odd to cook in someone's home when you've only met them a handful of times.

Mummy08m · 17/07/2023 16:10

saraclara · 17/07/2023 16:06

It's not just that the in laws don't value your bubbly personality, your Bf doesn't either

Where do you get that from @Mummy08m ?

I get it from his reaction. It would have been so easy for him to defend/explain op's actions to his mum. But instead he passed on her criticisms which heavily implies that he agrees with them, at least partly, and wants her to address them.

But arguably there's nothing for op to fix. The in laws just don't like the way she is. She could change the way she is (difficult, upsetting, and probably futile) or move on and find a man and family who like the way she is

GrapeHyacinth · 17/07/2023 16:09

I wouldn't engage with this. I'd say "Oh dear, what a drama. I've never been criticised for this before. I noticed they showed no interest in me and I thought they'd like relaxing while I cooked. Oh well never mind" and then not mention it again. Your dh crying sounds a bit OTT

jannier · 17/07/2023 16:07

Candymay · 17/07/2023 15:01

I seem to be on my own here then. I would not be happy with any other woman taking over my kitchen. That would be a huge boundary issue for me. Maybe I’m the awful mil.

I think it’s ok for her not to like you at first and then hopefully she will grow to love you. It takes time.

My Dil has had her own kitchen for 6 years. I'm happy to go and care for the grandkid make their food etc when I'm on my own but wouldn't dream of just putting the kettle on or dishing up etc if she's there. I'd ask but never insist I'd worry she thought I was judging her.