Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s going on with working hours these days?

184 replies

CateringPanic · 17/07/2023 08:14

I work in the public sector. My working hours are broadly 9-5 although I can flex this if I want to eg. 8-4, with 30 minutes for lunch. Either way it’s 37.5 hours a week which I thought was standard for full time work. I’m reasonably senior so obviously I might sometimes choose to work late to get stuff done but these are my contracted hours.

BILs girlfriend is young, early 20s and in her second job out of uni (was only in first for 6m). Her old job was 9-6 and her current one is 8-5. She thinks this is normal - I think her employers are taking the piss.

She is salaried, not hourly paid, and these are low skilled, low stress administration jobs so no real need to work long hours at all.

AIBU to think this is more than full time work and she shouldn’t have to be working an extra 5 hours a week for crap money or am I just out of touch with how things are out there?

OP posts:
BiscuitsandPuffin · 17/07/2023 10:58

Word for word this exact thread was posted 2 months ago. Same working hours and everything.

Bitsyvonmuffling77 · 17/07/2023 10:57

9-5 is super rare these days, especially in the private sector. My official hours are 9.30-6pm with an hours lunch, on an annual salary. In fact I can only think of one job that was ever 9-5 and they changed the contracts around 10 year ago to add on half an hour.
The difference is (in my industry anyway) as we are very work based output. They don't mind what hours I work over what days as long as I am available for meetings where needed and pick my phone up between core hours of 11-4pm. I have peaks and troughs, some days I will arrive at the office for 11 and leave at 4, some times its busy and I will work until 7ish.

Ilikejamtarts · 17/07/2023 10:56

I was doing 9-18:00 mon-friday
Partner is contracted to do 7:30-17:30 mon-fri, usually ends up having to do a 7 start everyday though plus every other saturday. Add in travel and he is out the house from 6:30 til 18:00

GeraltsBathtub · 17/07/2023 10:56

I’m 28. I’ve turned down all job offers that expect more than 9-5 with for standard hours (I don’t mind the odd bit of unpaid overtime during busy periods). That includes a few with 9-6 hours, one 8-6 and one which would be mostly 9-6 with 7-5 one day a week. I value having a life too much! I work in a well-paid public sector role, 35 hours. The roles I turned down were all private sector. They just don’t pay enough more to make it worth the loss of my free time.

ohtowinthelottery · 17/07/2023 10:52

My DS started an office based job last year - public sector. Hours are 8.45 - 5.00 Mon to Thurs and 8.45 - 4.00 on a Friday.
DH also office based job - 9-5 although he does work outside of those hours at times but is supposed to take TOIL.

Leftbutcameback · 17/07/2023 10:48

I’ve worked a variety of office jobs, all between 35 and 40 hours per week. I would consider 40 hours the top end of a standard office hours week.

notforonesecond · 17/07/2023 10:38

My contract is 37 hours but it’s fully flexible between 7am and 8pm so there’s no actual set hours or lunch breaks. Public sector.

I tend to work 7am - 3pm with a half hour lunch. A few times a week I work til 4pm and claim the flexi so I can have day off every few weeks without using any annual leave.

Private sector hours seem to be longer and slightly flexible but not quite as flexible. I agreed with you that there’s no benefit to working longer hours just for the sake of it, but it does seem to be the way things are going.

My working hours are one of the perks of my job that I treasure the most.

Weddingpuzzle · 17/07/2023 10:31

DS is back at his gap year job over summer and their hours are eye watering - he does landscape gardening for £10.50 an hour and the core hours are 7am until 4pm and they are expected to attend the yard ten minutes early to load vans (unpaid). He has recently had jobs further away so has had 5am and 6am starts.

The boss is so rude to them - didn't even provide water in the 39 degree heat last year and moans about them stopping for food (they do such a physical job they need to eat breakfast, snacks and lunch). I don't know why they all put up with the working conditions but they do.

LimeCheesecake · 17/07/2023 10:25

@CateringPanic you said they are admin roles - so that’s normal for when I was working in the city as a PA, I was contracted 9-6 in most jobs, but expected to be in for 8:15/8:30am to cover any “meet and greet” for early meetings, set up meeting rooms, have paperwork printed out for presentations etc. the other end was to allow having stuff sorted for later meetings (usually happening with New York based people).

however in places like this, taking a 1.5 hour lunch break to go to the gym or shopping etc was perfectly acceptable.

C152 · 17/07/2023 10:25

YANBU in thinking this is more than what, until relatively recently, were standard full time working hours. (Although there has always been an expectation in the private sector companies I have worked in that all staff will work many hours free overtime per week, even though contractual hours were 9am-5pm, with an hour for lunch.) However, loads of job adverts I have seen over the last few months have similar hours advertised to those of your BILs girlfriend.

ismu · 17/07/2023 10:24

I've always worked either 37.5 hours per week in offices ( public and private sector) or in teaching- Scottish teachers' contract is very clear on this, although most people work far more.
Working more than an 8 hour day is counterproductive as the more hours you work the more entitlement you have to breaks and so it becomes quite complicated

AvanGelist · 17/07/2023 10:22

confusde · 17/07/2023 10:16

I’m surprised by these answers! I’m in my late twenties and in my working life post university, I’ve only ever worked 9-5 with an hour’s break (unpaid). We have flexibility around those hours e.g. our core hours are between 09:00-14:00 and we wfh most of the week! I would never accept a job with an 8-9am start & 5-6pm finish unless I had no choice! I work in finance for a bank. Very grateful.

I also work for a bank, on a 37 hour a week contract with flexibility etc.
Granted, there are a variety of different roles but I'd say your working hours depends on your role and manager.
I have signed away my rights to the working time directive and get no overtjme.

My work is peaks and troughs I can work 14 hour days, or 2 hours when it's quiet so I like it

KimberleyClark · 17/07/2023 10:21

TheFlis12345 · 17/07/2023 08:21

Most places in my industry (marketing related) are 9.30-6 including an hour for lunch.

I’m retired from a public sector job, worked 8.30-5.15 and it was frowned upon to take more than a 30 minute lunch break and felt I wasn’t pulling my weight by leaving at the time I did. A half day meant finishing at 1.30-2pm. They did away with core hours which actually resulted in less flexibility rather than more.

AnnaBegins · 17/07/2023 10:16

Everywhere I've worked in manufacturing head offices, a standard week is 40 hours and lunch is a luxury!

confusde · 17/07/2023 10:16

I’m surprised by these answers! I’m in my late twenties and in my working life post university, I’ve only ever worked 9-5 with an hour’s break (unpaid). We have flexibility around those hours e.g. our core hours are between 09:00-14:00 and we wfh most of the week! I would never accept a job with an 8-9am start & 5-6pm finish unless I had no choice! I work in finance for a bank. Very grateful.

missyounot · 17/07/2023 10:13

In my industry it's 8-5 but everyone does 9ish to 4ish

Oysterbabe · 17/07/2023 10:13

My full time hours are 35 a week. My previous employer was 40. There's a lot of variation company to company.

Tohaveandtohold · 17/07/2023 10:10

This is one of the reasons why I love my employer. I work in the private sector (a bank that’s hot on people having a work life balance) and full time hours is 35hrs a week. Some people do shifts based on the roles but those not working shifts do either 8-4 or 9-5 with one hour lunch so 35 working hours or 8-3:30 or 9-4:30 with 30 mins lunch and anything above that is overtime. Obviously as we do hybrid work and have a caseload, sometimes you log in at home to finish somethings but it’s not an expectation.
I remember when I was applying for a civil service job and saw that work is 37.5 for almost a similar pay, it felt so long, luckily I found another role with my current employer. So I feel those employers who expect people to work for 40hrs are just taking advantage

ElinoristhenewEnid · 17/07/2023 10:08

When I started work in the 70s public sector standard hours were 37.5 and private sector were 35 - I worked 34.75 in private sector AND all overtime was PAID at around 1.5 normal hourly rate. These were salaried posts

JennieTheZebra · 17/07/2023 10:03

@wholivesondrurylane I’m a mental health nurse. Practically all NHS community is 9-5. In practice this means that I get there at 8:30 so I have time to make a cup of tea before my first service user turns up. I manage my own diary so I don’t like booking in people later than 16:00 unless absolutely necessary. This then means I can leave on time. As I said, it’s pretty good. I do have to work a bit in the evening sometimes and I wish I was paid a bit more, but, really, I can’t complain.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/07/2023 10:02

I worked in private sectors in the 90’s in 3 different places

8.30 to 4:30, finish 2.30 on Fri
9-5
8.45-5.15.

All had an hour for lunch

Overthebow · 17/07/2023 09:59

It’s normal for private sector. A lot of public sector workers complain about salaries, but their terms and benefits are so much better. I haven’t ever worked a 37.5 hour job in the private sector.

wholivesondrurylane · 17/07/2023 09:58

CateringPanic · 17/07/2023 08:53

@Coronationstation the issue is the implication that work should be your whole day. If you finish at 6pm AND have a commute your evening is basically dead in the water before it starts. Couple that with the fact that productivity does not increase with hours worked it makes me feel like we are living in a capitalist dystopia…which to be fair we probably are!

why do you think people are fighting hard to stick with WFH when it's proven they are more productive and it benefit their employer?

It also allows for a decent work-life balance. When the job is office based and suitable for WFH - of course not all are - I am now guessing that the few misery guts whining because they want everyone back in the office to have a social life, these people must work part-time or reduced hours

wholivesondrurylane · 17/07/2023 09:54

I have never heard of any "9 to 5 job" anywhere else than MN. What are all these jobs?

It's always been 8 or 8:30 (rarely 9) to 6, and the more senior roles don't clock watch.

Only on MN are people leaving work so early there's always 2 people to deal with the kids diner, bath time and bed time. In the real world, it's hard enough for just one parent to be back home so early

Threenow · 17/07/2023 09:52

I've worked 40 hours a week for many, many, years. It's fairly standard here.