Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s going on with working hours these days?

184 replies

CateringPanic · 17/07/2023 08:14

I work in the public sector. My working hours are broadly 9-5 although I can flex this if I want to eg. 8-4, with 30 minutes for lunch. Either way it’s 37.5 hours a week which I thought was standard for full time work. I’m reasonably senior so obviously I might sometimes choose to work late to get stuff done but these are my contracted hours.

BILs girlfriend is young, early 20s and in her second job out of uni (was only in first for 6m). Her old job was 9-6 and her current one is 8-5. She thinks this is normal - I think her employers are taking the piss.

She is salaried, not hourly paid, and these are low skilled, low stress administration jobs so no real need to work long hours at all.

AIBU to think this is more than full time work and she shouldn’t have to be working an extra 5 hours a week for crap money or am I just out of touch with how things are out there?

OP posts:
kikisparks · 17/07/2023 17:29

I’m public sector and standard work day is 9-5 with an hour lunch break. It means I can work 7-5 and have a day off with my DD. Can’t imagine working 7-5 for 5 days a week!

RufustheFactualReindeer · 17/07/2023 17:24

According to another recent thread, I thought young people were all getting "lazy jobs" now? So the hours look long on paper but they're out walking the dog with their phone on forward!?

really? What the fuck is wrong with some people 😳

dds hours are long on paper cos they are fucking long hours!!!

bonoslefteyebrow · 17/07/2023 17:16

According to another recent thread, I thought young people were all getting "lazy jobs" now? So the hours look long on paper but they're out walking the dog with their phone on forward!?

I work for a local authority. Existing contracts are 37 hours and to save money new ones are 35 (pro rata). We have flexi time and can accrue time off in lieu though generally it's 9-5 and 9-4.30 on Friday, or 9-4.30/4.

When looking for another job the lack of flexi is a deal breaker for me. So are 40 hour contracts. Work life balance is so important.

If I were your daughter I'd take my experience and shop around for an employer with a better work life balance who treat their staff like people not commodities.

FlowersareEverything · 17/07/2023 17:00

I’ve worked for the same employer for 23 years and my full-time contract is 35 hours, with flexible working. Our starting time core hours are 8-10, lunchtime core hours are 12 -2 (minimum lunch break 30 minutes and maximum 2 hours) and core finishing time 4-6pm. I normally work 8-4, which is ideal for me. Since Covid, hybrid working has been introduced and I work one day from home. We have a very low staff turnover.

Missfabulousat50 · 17/07/2023 16:56

Retail manager,salaried,made to work minimum 45 hours per week, can stretch to 55. Paid for 40.

Beezknees · 17/07/2023 16:51

My last job was 38 hours a week. 8am-4.30pm with half an hour unpaid lunch Monday to Thursday, then 8am-2pm Friday with no break. I was happy with that.

Notamum12345577 · 17/07/2023 16:48

CateringPanic · 17/07/2023 08:14

I work in the public sector. My working hours are broadly 9-5 although I can flex this if I want to eg. 8-4, with 30 minutes for lunch. Either way it’s 37.5 hours a week which I thought was standard for full time work. I’m reasonably senior so obviously I might sometimes choose to work late to get stuff done but these are my contracted hours.

BILs girlfriend is young, early 20s and in her second job out of uni (was only in first for 6m). Her old job was 9-6 and her current one is 8-5. She thinks this is normal - I think her employers are taking the piss.

She is salaried, not hourly paid, and these are low skilled, low stress administration jobs so no real need to work long hours at all.

AIBU to think this is more than full time work and she shouldn’t have to be working an extra 5 hours a week for crap money or am I just out of touch with how things are out there?

Probably hour unpaid for lunch. I used to do 08:30-17:30 with an hour unpaid for lunch. So 40 hour week.

Joey1976 · 17/07/2023 16:20

Don't know why as it's only 30 mins but I now wouldn't take a job which was 9-6. My contracted hours are 9-5.30 and I regularly work longer hours but I do get some flexibility to do the school run etc.
I think now knowledge workers expect flexibility.

LoobyDop · 17/07/2023 15:57

I can’t remember the last time I was given anything more specific than a total number of hours for the week, and I definitely can’t remember the last time anyone checked. I do know a few of my colleagues have “legacy contracts” with 35 hours full time instead of 37.5 and they hold onto them ferociously. Even though anybody actually counting would probably be in more trouble for bullying than they would be for skiving.

lastminutewednesday · 17/07/2023 15:51

I asked them why there was a new to start at 8.30 and they just said 'that's how it's always been' so....
It's managing marketing for older peoples retirement villages. On site office but it doesn't even open to the public until 10. No idea what I'd even do for the preceding hour and half

Hateitissues · 17/07/2023 15:47

lastminutewednesday · 17/07/2023 14:08

Ive just been offered a job 8.30-5.30.
I've turned it down. There would be zero need for me to be there at 8.30, (it's a marketing job, not a call centre with long hours or retail etc) and it would make it impossible with school runs to do, whereas 9 would be fine-so they've done themselves out of a good candidate there (if I say so myself 😂)

I think you need to give this employer the benefit of the doubt that they know what hours work best for their business. Afterall they could offer less hours and pay you less. Perhaps the 8.30 start is for admin?

lastminutewednesday · 17/07/2023 14:08

Ive just been offered a job 8.30-5.30.
I've turned it down. There would be zero need for me to be there at 8.30, (it's a marketing job, not a call centre with long hours or retail etc) and it would make it impossible with school runs to do, whereas 9 would be fine-so they've done themselves out of a good candidate there (if I say so myself 😂)

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/07/2023 13:52

I have always worked in the private sector and I have to say that sounds pretty normal tbh. You may be right in theory that they aren't work-friendly hours but I think the idea that employers are "taking the piss" is a bit unrealistic in this day and age. That's a very normal working day for white collar jobs.

The reality is many businesses in this environment need people working long hours to keep the lights on.

I theoretically work 9 to 6 but in practice my hours can fluctuate vastly either above or sometimes below this: sometimes I work 6am to 8.30am then log off until 10.30am and work until 4pm. Sometimes I start at 9am and log off at 4pm but back on again at 6.30pm.

It's long hours but mostly from home and I can do it in my own time. I'm trusted not to have to be at work during all contracted hours: I sometimes have to work much longer hours than most people and the trade off is that they don't nickle and dime me about when I'm working.

I'd much rather have longer hours but with flexibility as to when and where they are undertaken that a really rigid, clock-watching undertaking to stick to exactly 8 hours and have to be at a desk.

Bunnycat101 · 17/07/2023 13:46

@AvanGelist I think this bit is very true:

“The payoff is once you have all the foundational knowledge it's easy to draw on and you can sort of coast. Do the work in half the time of a junior :)

I know I can knock something out that is good quality I’m not very much time because of my experience which does enable me to be a bit more protective of my time. Also the more senior I’ve got, the less actual work I do.

KentishMama · 17/07/2023 12:51

I don't think that the standard 9-5 exists if you work for larger, global employers. For me, a good day is 8:30 to 6:30; if I start later than that, then I miss the opportunity to collaborate with team members in APAC; if I finish early, I don't have enough overlap with the US West Coast, where lots of colleagues are located. The expectation is that I work whatever hours are needed to get the job done. Nobody would complain if I took two hour lunch breaks to make up for it, but it's pretty impossible to get the job done in under 45-50 hours a week. Even if you're super efficient.

HamstersAreMyLife · 17/07/2023 12:50

Public sector so 37 hours contracted but I don't know many people who have fixed hours tbh. Surely you work til the work is done? For some roles for me that's been 55 hour weeks as standard and now I tend to do 40 to 45 depending on what the demands are. In our dept we're really feeling the squeeze of having more work but fewer people. I don't teach or do time specific work so I can be relatively flexible with start and finish times which is a bonus.

SpinCycles · 17/07/2023 12:44

Salaries are for the role. In many professional jobs that means "however long it takes". There are clauses in many contracts stating "reasonable overtime as required" (and bo extra pay for it!). "Reasonable" is very hard to challenge. For example, in my early career our standard hours per contract were 37: 9-5:30 with a one hour lunch. But the reality was that we worked 90-100 hours in busy periods and maybe 50-60 in the quietest part of the year. It's not healthy but there's not much you can do about it except research employers thoroughly and know what you are getting into and what the expectations will be.

AvanGelist · 17/07/2023 12:43

Bunnycat101 · 17/07/2023 12:31

It’s difficult because often when you’re young and have no dependents you’re building a career and do the hours to get on. Now I’m much more bullish about doing my hours unless the shit is really hitting the fan or it’s really needed.

I would say though that my example is appreciated by the people under me. One of my peers is doing ridiculous hours and burning out when she doesn’t need to. Her team is imploding with the stress and expectation and it’s all going a bit wrong.

I think there's a massive difference between extra work expected as 'standard', and people doing more to get on.
Of course it depends on the profession but in mine there's no escaping the hands-on work needed to build experience (and your market value!)
As a result those who do more of the right sort of work (not reporting or sitting in pointless meetings) can progress much faster with large salary increases.

I always say as a team the workload should be 'set' 9-5 but you can't stop people from going the extra mile if they want to. Of course, this makes it difficult for people like PT workers or with dependents but that is the nature of our profession.

The payoff is once you have all the foundational knowledge it's easy to draw on and you can sort of coast. Do the work in half the time of a junior :)

Bunnycat101 · 17/07/2023 12:31

It’s difficult because often when you’re young and have no dependents you’re building a career and do the hours to get on. Now I’m much more bullish about doing my hours unless the shit is really hitting the fan or it’s really needed.

I would say though that my example is appreciated by the people under me. One of my peers is doing ridiculous hours and burning out when she doesn’t need to. Her team is imploding with the stress and expectation and it’s all going a bit wrong.

Silvered · 17/07/2023 12:21

My contracted hours are 9-5 but I am salaried and it goes with the territory that 35 hours will be the minimum you do. However it is extremely flexible and I have control over my own time, as long as the work gets done. If I have a tough week I can follow it up - when I get a chance - with taking some time back as long as I am still contactable for emergencies. No OT payments and I am opted out of the WTD.

I have also worked 9-5.30 in the same sector. In my retail days 40 hours was the norm and shifts would be 9-6, with the store opening at 9.30 and closing at 5.30 so that there was time for prep and clean-up at either end.

fetchacloth · 17/07/2023 12:18

Private sector hours are generally longer, it's not unusual to see a 40 hour week. It's a sneaky way of employers getting more for paying less.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/07/2023 11:49

GeraltsBathtub · 17/07/2023 10:56

I’m 28. I’ve turned down all job offers that expect more than 9-5 with for standard hours (I don’t mind the odd bit of unpaid overtime during busy periods). That includes a few with 9-6 hours, one 8-6 and one which would be mostly 9-6 with 7-5 one day a week. I value having a life too much! I work in a well-paid public sector role, 35 hours. The roles I turned down were all private sector. They just don’t pay enough more to make it worth the loss of my free time.

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼everyone should be doing this.

GnomeDePlume · 17/07/2023 11:23

Private sector, 40 hours contracted is normal to me: 9.00 to 5.30 with 30 minute lunch. Reality is more like 8.00 to 6.30 or longer. In theory we are supposed to get a day off every other week to compensate. We are expected to be available on that day if there is a problem to deal with.

(I am actually on holiday today which is easier to defend)

FarmGirl78 · 17/07/2023 11:20

40 hrs a week is pretty normal. That's been my boyfriends typical hours for 20+ years, it's not a new thing.

I'm not saying it's nice to have to work that, but it's very very normal.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 17/07/2023 11:00

They seem to be normal hours to me.

I spent 20 years working in banking and 50 hour or more weeks were not unusual by the time I left. Overtime payments had been scrapped in the early 90's.

Our contracted hours were 9-5 but arriving for work after 8:30 would raise eyebrows as would leaving before 6. Working through lunch was also the norm.

When the EU working time directive forms were introduced we were simply told by our manager to lie! If you submitted a form with the actual hours you had worked that week you would be asked to fill a new one and reduce the hours.