Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s going on with working hours these days?

184 replies

CateringPanic · 17/07/2023 08:14

I work in the public sector. My working hours are broadly 9-5 although I can flex this if I want to eg. 8-4, with 30 minutes for lunch. Either way it’s 37.5 hours a week which I thought was standard for full time work. I’m reasonably senior so obviously I might sometimes choose to work late to get stuff done but these are my contracted hours.

BILs girlfriend is young, early 20s and in her second job out of uni (was only in first for 6m). Her old job was 9-6 and her current one is 8-5. She thinks this is normal - I think her employers are taking the piss.

She is salaried, not hourly paid, and these are low skilled, low stress administration jobs so no real need to work long hours at all.

AIBU to think this is more than full time work and she shouldn’t have to be working an extra 5 hours a week for crap money or am I just out of touch with how things are out there?

OP posts:
ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 18/07/2023 17:51

Both minimum wage and no overtime or shift allowance

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 18/07/2023 17:48

DS officially works 10-7 - but they have a rule that they have to stay until all orders are complete - if he is lucky he gets to go at 6 or 6.30, but some days he is still there at 9 pm

They are allowed to request to leave early if they have a specific event on one evening - but outside of that it makes it difficult for him to plan anything .

His GF works shifts and now has a set pattern but previously her hours have been worked as an average per month and she hasn't actually been given her shifts until the end of the previous week - so some weeks she would be on 5 or 6 long days or evenings and other weeks she would only have 3 short days work .

Both of their working patterns would make it difficult to arrange child care if needed in future.

MRex · 18/07/2023 17:31

TrueScrumptious · 18/07/2023 15:52

No, you cannot legally opt out of the statutory break. You can choose to work through it if you like, but that doesn’t mean you can shorten your day by putting the break at the end, not the compulsory 20 minutes anyway.

If your hours are flexible because the role requires an unspecified number, then yes you can absolutely choose to leave early. You're using the public sector / shift work attitude, where hours and breaks are mandated. Lots of roles don't have specified hours in that way, the individual has more control over them. They might choose to work through hours or leave early.

If one of my team had a report to do and chooses to get up at 3am then finish for the day at midday or 1pm, I genuinely don't care, it's their work to organise however they see fit.I'm not going to be checking in, nor running around at 9am to see if they took a break, and the legislation doesn't require me to. Same if they are working with the US and find it easier to work 1-9pm, that's totally up to them and they can have a break or not, at whatever time, also up to them. If they have too much work then they say so, if they have time then they say so, they're employed as responsible adults

TrueScrumptious · 18/07/2023 15:52

MRex · 18/07/2023 15:44

There is a difference between workers having a right to take a break if they want, and workers being forced to take a break when they would rather finish early.

No, you cannot legally opt out of the statutory break. You can choose to work through it if you like, but that doesn’t mean you can shorten your day by putting the break at the end, not the compulsory 20 minutes anyway.

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 18/07/2023 15:50

I think it’s fair enough as long as they are clear what the working hours are when they advertise the role. Then it’s up to people whether those hours work for them and if they want to apply.

if the hours aren’t clearly advertised then yes it’s crap.

MRex · 18/07/2023 15:44

TrueScrumptious · 18/07/2023 11:06

That wouldn’t be legal, though. You have to take at least a 20-minute break after six hours’ work.

There is a difference between workers having a right to take a break if they want, and workers being forced to take a break when they would rather finish early.

TrueScrumptious · 18/07/2023 11:06

ManateeFair · 18/07/2023 10:15

My guess is that her employer would claim she is working a 40-hour week, not a 45-hour week, because her 9-hour day includes an hour's unpaid lunch break. That's what my first employer used to claim (until we pointed out that as we weren't being paid for the lunch break, we should be allowed to forego it to eat at our desks and finish at 5pm instead, and they compromised by making our hours 9am to 5.30pm).

That wouldn’t be legal, though. You have to take at least a 20-minute break after six hours’ work.

ManateeFair · 18/07/2023 10:15

My guess is that her employer would claim she is working a 40-hour week, not a 45-hour week, because her 9-hour day includes an hour's unpaid lunch break. That's what my first employer used to claim (until we pointed out that as we weren't being paid for the lunch break, we should be allowed to forego it to eat at our desks and finish at 5pm instead, and they compromised by making our hours 9am to 5.30pm).

Bouncyball23 · 18/07/2023 10:13

I can do 7.30-4.30, 8-5 or 9-6 hour lunch.

PurpleGreenandWhiteAreTheNewPrimaryColours · 18/07/2023 10:01

It's just a massive piss take when you consider salaries have flat lined or near flat lined on most jobs. More hours for less pay, what a life!

ArcticBells · 18/07/2023 09:46

Private sector and my contract states 37.5 hours but it is really frowned upon to do so few. Most people do about 45 as we are expected to stay until business closes

Augustus40 · 18/07/2023 09:34

Ds works in an American warehouse hours 830 am to 5 pm finish. He gets two half hour breaks. Quite often there is a lull where there is nothing to do. For example towards the end of the day but they must stay in work until 5pm.

NotTerfNorCis · 18/07/2023 09:08

I think I've always been expected to work a minimum 7.5 hours a day. It used to be a rigid from... to.... but now it's now flexible, which is great.

Iwishmymumwouldbemymum · 18/07/2023 08:27

I'm 45, working in offices since I was 20. It's never been 9-5, always 8.30-5.30, or 9-6.

SecretVictoria · 18/07/2023 08:24

Comedycook · 18/07/2023 07:41

Why are so many people saying it's normal therefore it's fine. I don't think it's fine. Ok some jobs may require longer hours but most dont. I understand if you're ambitious and trying to climb the career ladder but why should a bog standard administrator be in the office until 6pm. It's not necessarily...it's a petty move by employers. We should be working less not more. Getting home from work at 7/7.30pm is absolutely soul destroying and limits you so much. There no time for anything after work. I used to have a job which finished at 5pm..it made a huge difference to my quality of life.

It’s why I prefer working shifts. Can’t be forced to stay on (unless retail, never finished on time).

I’ve worked in jobs, where even as the lowest-level admin, I couldn’t flex my hours even 30 minutes either way, which made a huge difference in terms of catching trains and getting home. As you say, it’s so hard to do anything outside of work.

I do have a theory, lots of jobs don’t need to be full time. A few years ago I had a f/t job that I could have easily done on 3 days, I suspect I’m not alone in that. However, our society is set up that everything is so expensive, that you need a f/t wage to pay for it.

Comedycook · 18/07/2023 07:41

Why are so many people saying it's normal therefore it's fine. I don't think it's fine. Ok some jobs may require longer hours but most dont. I understand if you're ambitious and trying to climb the career ladder but why should a bog standard administrator be in the office until 6pm. It's not necessarily...it's a petty move by employers. We should be working less not more. Getting home from work at 7/7.30pm is absolutely soul destroying and limits you so much. There no time for anything after work. I used to have a job which finished at 5pm..it made a huge difference to my quality of life.

Comedycook · 18/07/2023 07:25

Yellowlegobrick · 17/07/2023 19:22

A lot of sectors are trying to do this. I used to be on 35 hrs and got pushed over time to 37.5 as fewer places had 35 as standard. Its stealth inflation as they rarely pay the extra 7% for the longer hours .

I strongly object to hours creep, it forces women out of the workforce, especially around London, because its not reasonable to leave a young child in daycare for such long hours when factoring in the typical 1 hour commute each way - doing 8.30- 5.30 you'd be putting a little one in 7.30- 6.30 every day.

All its meant is I've dropped a day a week and now do 30 over 5 days.

Yes I absolutely agree. I stopped working when my dc were babies/toddlers because I worked in central London with one hour commute. Therefore my 9-5.30 job meant I needed childcare from just before 8am until 6.30pm. Many jobs work even later than that. Childcare that is open during those hours is hard to find and gets even harder to find at school age.

Threenow · 18/07/2023 01:17

Nowitstarts · 17/07/2023 19:13

Lots of full time weeks are 39 or 40 hours per week. It might not be right, but an 8 hour day plus lunch break isn't unusual.

Why isn't it right? - that is standard where I live (not UK) and has been for years.

Hawkins0001 · 17/07/2023 21:54

CateringPanic · 17/07/2023 08:31

It’s also really worrying to me if young people are just accepting of this in terms of workplace culture moving forward. When all the research points towards working fewer hours improving productivity it seems crazy

Because the research is in theory, in practice some still take the biscuits even with shorter hours, so to balance out this some companies have the hours they do.

FinallyHere · 17/07/2023 21:52

it seems like it’s just about keeping her there

This makes me think that your comment is about having to be 'on the premises'. Is that the point?

Very different to how many hours are actually worked and different again yo be some support roles where it matters to be on call.

Yellowlegobrick · 17/07/2023 19:22

A lot of sectors are trying to do this. I used to be on 35 hrs and got pushed over time to 37.5 as fewer places had 35 as standard. Its stealth inflation as they rarely pay the extra 7% for the longer hours .

I strongly object to hours creep, it forces women out of the workforce, especially around London, because its not reasonable to leave a young child in daycare for such long hours when factoring in the typical 1 hour commute each way - doing 8.30- 5.30 you'd be putting a little one in 7.30- 6.30 every day.

All its meant is I've dropped a day a week and now do 30 over 5 days.

Hateitissues · 17/07/2023 19:16

lastminutewednesday · 17/07/2023 15:51

I asked them why there was a new to start at 8.30 and they just said 'that's how it's always been' so....
It's managing marketing for older peoples retirement villages. On site office but it doesn't even open to the public until 10. No idea what I'd even do for the preceding hour and half

Catch up on your admin, do your online grocery shopping, holiday research and get paid!
chances are though - there will be work of some kind

Nowitstarts · 17/07/2023 19:13

Lots of full time weeks are 39 or 40 hours per week. It might not be right, but an 8 hour day plus lunch break isn't unusual.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 17/07/2023 18:59

I work 9-6 loosely, but since my team is all over the world, I tend to work 7-10 with bigger breaks.
This is perfectly normal.
Office work is 30% chatting and coffees anyways 😂

DitheringBlidiot · 17/07/2023 17:50

I'm 34 and never worked more than 37.5 hours full time. I know plenty who do though. My current contract is 35hours which is considered full time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread