Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to handle judgment as a mother

215 replies

Gotthejob · 17/07/2023 00:55

I have apparently committed 3 cardinal sins - I had an epidural, ended in a c section and have been unable to breastfeed.

And it seems everyone sees fit to pass opinion on this (SIL won’t be having an epidural and therefore won’t need a c section) and the consensus is I didn’t try hard enough (I nearly died so no c section = no mum or baby). I

My baby is so lovely, happy and chilled but even that has been put down to formula feeding? Like I’m cheating the system or something. So many comments like ‘well obviously you’re not breastfeeding so…’

Looking for non confrontational ways to shut down these opinion. And it really seems to be the people with most opinions are women who don’t even have kids yet! I have found other mums to be very supportive.

OP posts:
Bossmum94 · 17/07/2023 13:31

easiest way to shut these people up is by cutting them off :)

Peach0123 · 17/07/2023 13:11

Don't be around them at the moment. You've had a traumatic birth, feeling judged at one of the most vulnerable times of your life. Speak openly to your DH and explain this is just too much just now. If you visit them, make it for a short period of time or let DH take baby when your ready to leave them. Look after yourself too, your doing everything for your wee baby and sound like a good mum.

Cutlosses · 17/07/2023 12:56

I found just nodding along and thinking it was best. then laugh along with them when they admit that they didn’t have a clue once they’ve actually done it 😉

I was a fantastic Mother Earth parent before having children. Weren’t we all.

MarkCrorigan · 17/07/2023 12:51

Just ignore them. People are the worstttttt.

Catspyjamas17 · 17/07/2023 12:48

I'd say breezily about the c-section "Well personally I preferred not to die and have a happy healthy baby also."

Like when people thought I was being a selfish career woman in going back to work "Personally I prefer being able to pay the mortgage."

JudgeJ · 17/07/2023 12:42

Total silence & a small smile at best.

Don't forget the look at their off-sping and the slightly raised eyebrows, gets them every time! Never, ever respond verbally, being ignored is simething that really winds people up, remember passive aggression is a winner!

CurlewKate · 17/07/2023 12:41

It's important to make sure you distinguish between judgement and conversation! Yes, some people do judge. But quite often completely innocent small talk can feel like judgement if it's phrased slightly awkwardly or if you're feeling vulnerable. It's usually best to smile and move on. You know what you did was right for you.

boymumma1923 · 17/07/2023 12:39

Hit button too quick 🙈 to carry on...

Breast feeding is hard work and not plain sailing which I think most people take for granted you will be able to do before motherhood. The reality is quite different.

Take care of you and your baby that's all you need to focus on. They will sympathise one day when they have children of their own

boymumma1923 · 17/07/2023 12:36

When I had my 1st... I managed to breastfeed... My friend who had her daughter after... Tried to breastfeed as well... It was making her ill due to a number of different things, so she went on to formula. We were both out and I was breastfeeding...she was bottle feeding and the looks we both got were outrageous. Can't do right for doing wrong as they say.

However, the point of this is you are never going to make everyone happy. You do you. Regardless of formula or breastfeeding, as long as you are both in a good place and healthy that's all that matters. You know how hard it was for you to bring your baby into the world. They don't. So take no notice of the ignorance etc. Its

LaMaG · 17/07/2023 11:58

Just hope SIL has post birth incontinence so you can tell her how amazing it is to have a good laugh at her without pissing yourself 😁

If your unlucky your SIL like mine will have a 'beautiful' natural birth, latch immediately so she can say 'why dont people tell you how easy it is' and sleep all day and night because she had a 'good routine'. Silly me, I must have wanted to have flat nipples and a baby who never slept, if only I had been as clever and superior as her. I learned to rise above it, as PPs say its a very short little time, although I clearly remain a little bitter!!

5128gap · 17/07/2023 11:07

For starters, remember the way you gave birth and how you feed your baby are a tiny part of the lifelong role of parenting. I had 3 epidurals, BF one, mixed fed another, bottle fed another. Now all grown up, none of that made the slightest difference to any of them, and has no relevance to our lives. I have to think hard to even remember it all in the context of their upbringing as a whole.
I think I'd just respond with a disinterested 'mm' or two when they're waxing lyrical about how they're going to do it all differently. Given it really doesn't matter.

Jigslaw · 17/07/2023 11:02

Just remember to tell yourself and others that you are proud of yourself and you're doing a great job.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 17/07/2023 10:57

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 17/07/2023 09:06

My baby is so lovely, happy and chilled

In other words, the baby has judged and found you to be absolutely fine.

Forget the other judgements. They don't count.

Best wishes - from someone who has committed the same three cardinal sins as you!

❤️❤️❤️

Beautifully put and absolutely right!

RagingWoke · 17/07/2023 10:49

I don't think you need to shut it down. Everyone can have their own opinions, whether you engage or not is up to you. And to be honest beyond the first few weeks after birth no one gives a shit how the baby was born. Good luck to your SIL though, clearly very aware of how birth works 🙄

I do find on feeding the fight often comes from FF parents who get defensive then the bf side gets defensive and it spirals when actually the only response should be 'you're doing great'. But honestly, it doesn't matter. The baby is fed and at an individual level it makes no difference. Line 30 5 year olds up and you can't tell which were bottle or breastfed.
This new mum infighting is infuriating, we should all be helping and supporting each other. It's fucking hard enough without being attacked.

lastminutewednesday · 17/07/2023 10:37

Just don't give what other people think another thought. None of this stuff has any relevance on how good a parent you are or how your kid turns out. I've got 4 kids all of whom have lots of friends. I've no idea how any of their mates were born or fed and I wouldn't give a fig. I know these things are heightened when you have a baby but please believe me that they just have no relevance in life later on and shouldn't now either.

WeetabixTowels · 17/07/2023 10:32

When I read threads like this I think “but has anyone REALLY told you you didn’t try hard enough”? Have they used those words, or are you interpreting it that way because you don’t like someone and they made a comment? Because IME no one ever gave a shit how anyone else gave birth or fed. Dare I say it, I think some people judge themselves and tell themselves that it’s other people

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/07/2023 10:08

These from a PP are perfect replies:

Ignore them completely. Look at them blankly and say "why are you commenting on my birth experience - that is so weird?"

Or say to SIL "I hope it all works out for you" and refuse to engage after that.

Curtains70 · 17/07/2023 10:06

I just don't associate with people like this to be honest. The only place I ever see such comments is Mumsnet.

Peony654 · 17/07/2023 10:03

I think best to ignore. You and baby are alive and well, and baby is fed. Nothing else matters. No parenting is perfect

MammaTo · 17/07/2023 10:02

I had an epidural and only bottle fed. To be honest I think it depends on your circle of friends/family, my friends thought I was mental for trying to go naturally and not pushing for a c section so I could have a set date when baby would be here.

Just smile and nod and be happy with your lovely baby.

At the end of the day I refused to make a martyr out of myself, breast feeding seems tedious and so limiting - it took me ages to get over the guilt of feeling like I was being selfish for not having a go but I was able to get out and about with my baby sooner then most people who breast feed and my life doesn’t revolve around pumping/feeding.

Also bottle feeding doesn’t cheat the system at all, it’s just you have been blessed with a chilled baby - mines been bottle fed since day one and is 7 months old and has never slept through the night.

Pilgit · 17/07/2023 10:02

Not sure there is a non-confrontational way of shutting it down. If they haven't had kids yet they have no experience to back up their ill informed opinion so ignore. My BIL used to be like this - wound me up no end. I ended up saying to him the only way of dealing with it in the end was to tell him to fuck off every time he did it. MIL used to defend saying he means well - to which my response was always that i don't care to feel criticised by someone with 0 experience in parenting. Since having children he's been a lot better.

StormShadow · 17/07/2023 09:25

Gotthejob · 17/07/2023 00:55

I have apparently committed 3 cardinal sins - I had an epidural, ended in a c section and have been unable to breastfeed.

And it seems everyone sees fit to pass opinion on this (SIL won’t be having an epidural and therefore won’t need a c section) and the consensus is I didn’t try hard enough (I nearly died so no c section = no mum or baby). I

My baby is so lovely, happy and chilled but even that has been put down to formula feeding? Like I’m cheating the system or something. So many comments like ‘well obviously you’re not breastfeeding so…’

Looking for non confrontational ways to shut down these opinion. And it really seems to be the people with most opinions are women who don’t even have kids yet! I have found other mums to be very supportive.

Laughter.

Also, is this SILs first? It may well be that she gets the birth she wants, but either way she'll learn soon enough that most people are much better parents before having a baby than they are when faced with the actual reality.

YeaGads · 17/07/2023 09:25

Well you will still be honeymoon fresh as they say.

Learning to not give a shit regarding others opinions is one of the best skills you can ever learn.

Babyboomtastic · 17/07/2023 09:19

Welcome to early motherhood!

Basically new parents have taken on a new life changing, all encompassing project, everyone is a bit knackered and a side effect of this sells to be judginess!

I chose an ELCS, and chose to bottle feed. I totally got judged this.

Then there is cosleeping, cloth vs disposable nappies, vaccinations, weaning methods, sleep training, babywearing, forward vs rear facing (prams and car seats), TV, extended breastfeeding etc.

The first few years seem full of these sorts of debates, which often turn into judginess or slanging matches.

The earlier you pressed not to cassette and just post your way without caring what others think, the better.

The good news is it does eventually mostly pass!

NeverThatSerious · 17/07/2023 09:10

Reallybadidea · 17/07/2023 07:59

Try and ignore but maybe also hold a mirror up to what they're doing by saying something like "the thing that has most surprised me about motherhood is that everyone else has an opinion on your parenting - from giving birth to feeding - everyone feels entitled to make judgements. I've had to develop a really thick skin, because it can be so hurtful. I'm just trying to do my best, as is every other mother."

If you do it in a general way, rather than in response to something they've said, they might reflect on what they've been saying without realising it's aimed at them.

This is probably a very good way to handle it. I admit my first thought was a sharp ‘fuck off’ but that’s not exactly non-confrontational I guess. I did also scoff at people with a ‘don’t be so thick’ which tended to stop people going on in any case.

I had a C-section, due to medical reasons but ultimately elective, and I haven’t felt bad about that for a second. If ignorant prats want to judge me for that, fine, but I know I did the right thing for me and for baby and frankly, recovery was a walk in the park.

A friend of mine, altho not actively judgemental, is very pro natural anti anything else and she ended up nearly dying and having a C-section under general… yet seems to feel guilty about it?!?! Make it make sense.