Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to handle judgment as a mother

215 replies

Gotthejob · 17/07/2023 00:55

I have apparently committed 3 cardinal sins - I had an epidural, ended in a c section and have been unable to breastfeed.

And it seems everyone sees fit to pass opinion on this (SIL won’t be having an epidural and therefore won’t need a c section) and the consensus is I didn’t try hard enough (I nearly died so no c section = no mum or baby). I

My baby is so lovely, happy and chilled but even that has been put down to formula feeding? Like I’m cheating the system or something. So many comments like ‘well obviously you’re not breastfeeding so…’

Looking for non confrontational ways to shut down these opinion. And it really seems to be the people with most opinions are women who don’t even have kids yet! I have found other mums to be very supportive.

OP posts:
GC1 · 17/07/2023 18:17

Aw god I got this especially from InLaws. My SIL was textbook mum.... Everything done right and by the book..... I done everything opposite... She has kids that never sleep don't eat a think and are rude and tantrum ALL the time. Isn't allowed sugar but gets treats to shut them up then there hyper ect ect. I got told by my FIL that I need to breastfeed... Told him straight I'll do what's best for me! And noone will tell me how I raise my kids .. case closed there's nonice way sorry xxxx

hiding5675687 · 17/07/2023 18:15

Try to ignore them and definitely do not let them upset you. You are right that a happy, healthy baby and mum are the most important things. The only important things. Just say how happy you are that your baby is happy and doing well - unless they had nightmare births, then I guess let it slide and change the subject. I agree with a comment above that their interest and obsession is creepy.

I do not get this competitive natural childbirth thing. The person I know who really went down this route and her sister have a child with life long birth injuries (NICU), another with SN that may have been related to a home birth and injuries to themselves.

As my DC gets older the most judgemental. annoying comments are from a relative who does not have kids.

madeleine85 · 17/07/2023 18:15

Congratulations on your baby! Enjoy your peaceful little one. Everyone has an opinion on babies and birthing, especially mums, which is just bonkers. I liken it to people commenting on pregnant women's bodies. I had a friend who had one very easy baby, they said when pregnant with the second that they were prepared for a harder second experience (the first was a "trick baby"), but then it turned out the second was even easier than the first. It is just pot luck. Meanwhile i'm wrangling my children like they are ferral animals😆.

xogossipgirlxo · 17/07/2023 18:13

Don't tell them, it's no one's business. If they tell their opinion anyway:

-Who?
-Who what?
-Who asked what you think?

SouthLondonMum22 · 17/07/2023 18:10

I largely ignore it and refuse to take part in these silly 'mummy wars'. In my experience, it is usually other mothers that judge the most.

I have formula fed from birth, sleep trained, sent baby to nursery from 3 months etc all of the ultimate 'sins'.

elliejjtiny · 17/07/2023 18:03

I hate judgy comments and they always make me doubt myself. Most parents are doing their best and that should be enough. I've been judged for not homeschooling, sending ds to mainstream school, "letting" my eldest do a b-tech instead of a - levels and not disciplining my children enough. Oh and not disciplining them enough.

JupiterFortified · 17/07/2023 18:01

I can honestly say that neither I or my friends (child free or with children) could give a crap about how someone gave birth or whether they breastfeed or not. Who cares?

Maybe you’re hanging round with the wrong people OP. Don’t let morons drag you down.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 17/07/2023 17:57

I told someone I expressed my milk and that was met with judgment. People can have their opinions but they are not the ones doing the grafting that I was doing. My best advice is don't talk about it.

itsmylife7 · 17/07/2023 17:57

Just tell them to shut up with their silly opinions.

LimePi · 17/07/2023 17:56

Just tell people to get lost! Judgemental F**s

Lacucuracha · 17/07/2023 17:51

My baby is so lovely, happy and chilled but even that has been put down to formula feeding? Like I’m cheating the system or something. So many comments like ‘well obviously you’re not breastfeeding so…’

People like this do need to be shut down though. I would tell them dd is happy and chilled because I'm a great mum.

Thosepeskyseagulls · 17/07/2023 17:30

Anyone who said those things needs punching in the fanny. I’ll be interested to hear what actually ends up happening to SIL when she gives birth. You deserve a better support network than this. Can you send them a link to an article about PND and not judging people’s birthing choices?

changeyerheadworzel · 17/07/2023 17:27

So did I...4 times! Shoot me!

Personally I couldn't give a donkey's knob what anyone thinks of that.

Yorkshiredolls · 17/07/2023 17:18

Hello OP I feel like you’re judging me too because I have had two c sections and ended up formula feeding them both. I didn’t think there was a problem with that but you seem to think there is?

It wasn’t my plan, if I had it my way Id have not needed and emergency c section and baby would not have had reflux and she would have latched like a dream, and I wouldn’t have ended up with PND and then GDM in my second pregnancy, but thats the cards I was dealt.

Where are you finding these judgy knobheads? My eldest is 6 and I have never met anyone whos openly judged me about how I gave birth or fed or even give a shit really, most people too concerned with their own business.

you deal with it by you doing you and nit giving a damn What they think, if they are nasty enough to judge verbally and openly they are not worthy of your time or attention, they are not friends

Amber2023 · 17/07/2023 17:03

Fellow sinner here! EMCS plus formula fed after failed attempt at breast feeding. I’m also having an ELCS this time around! The shame. I keep getting comments why don’t you try for a “natural birth” nah I’ll pass thanks. Don’t beat yourself up you do what’s right at the time for your family.

MALJA · 17/07/2023 16:34

Deep breaths, count to 10 and ignore anyone’s comments/opinions/judgements that aren’t the same as yours. Honestly if you respond to everyone you get you’ll exhaust yourself!

it’s very difficult not to give a shit about what other people think but nobody knows what they’ll do in any situation until they’re actually in it so be confident in your decisions and move on from it as quickly as you can!

Doone21 · 17/07/2023 16:25

Honestly don't know why you give a shit what other mums think. Have you come across people that have directly said anything to try to make you feel bad? Pity their ignorance or laugh at them if you feel a response is necessary but I would not even stoop to their level tbh
Well done you BTW, had emergency section myself and they're no picnic

Foundthestrength · 17/07/2023 15:54

Ignor them your baby your way. You will find someone will always have a opinion about everything . The most important thing is that you and baby are safe and healthy. You had a epidural and a C-section that saved both your lifes. Your SIL says she is not having a epidural and that's easy for us all to say when we are not in active labour also does she not know that even if she doesn't have a epidural it doesn't mean she will definitely not have to have a C-section. I have 3DC my first labour I had just gas and air. My second I had gas and air and pethidine injection. With my last I had gas and air, pethidine injection and begged for a epidural but it was too late for an epidural. With my first and second I didn't produce enough milk to breastfeed with my last DC I had a great milk supply and I tried to breastfeed but baby was born with tongue tie and could not latch I pumped to start with but with 3DC it was becoming too time consuming spending time pumping then the time it took to bottle feed so they too ended up on formula. All 3 are healthy and thriving.
Don't let them dull your shine. Let it go over your head, because no matter what you do there will always be someone who doesn't agree or thinks your wrong. Enjoy your baby (they don't stay small for long) and most importantly do it your way.

ohdamnitjanet · 17/07/2023 15:22

I had an elective c section and all I ever said to anyone who questioned it was “ if you want to squeeze an 8 pound lump out of your fanny, go ahead. I’m not doing it.” Mainly ended the conversation.

Moanyoldmoan · 17/07/2023 14:46

Honestly in a couple of years no one will ask or care so don’t let it get to you. It’s a new mum thing where everyone is obsessed with the baby bubble and thinking their baby is some kind of superior genius. We are all in the same boat by the time they’re 3 and are little cretins

WeatheredMum887 · 17/07/2023 14:00

There's always going to be a myriad of opinions and judgements handed out to you as a parent. Learning how to graciously (or not) deal with them is part of parenting! In my experience those who are particularly judgy are usually the most insecure or worried of their own decisions and its easier to be forgiving or unbothered by others judgements when you think about the reason why they need to forcefully exert them. I find a breezy "everyone's families and babies are different, that's great you've found what works for you" shuts down the negative nillys without discouraging people from sharing their experiences.

With respect to your SIL is she currently pregnant? Could well be she was terrified by your experience/birth story and not surprisingly she would self soothe herself by proclaiming she would make different choices or seeking to find a reason why it happened that is within her control.

Mamai90 · 17/07/2023 13:57

It's very easy for people without kids to say they'll have a pain free birth and they'll take to breastfeeding like a duck to water, you play with the hand that you are dealt, many women need c sections because a vaginal birth will be impossible due to the shape of their pelvis, so not having an epidural won't make any bloody difference.

Some women aren't able to breastfeed, that's just how it is. I had a c section and I didn't breastfeed but I've never experiences any negativity towards this, it's only on here do I hear of ridiculous people commenting on other people's birthing and feeding experiences, it's bizarre. Next time your SIL says anything give a wry smile and say, yeah, we'll see!

SummerDawn2000 · 17/07/2023 13:47

I hear you Op. why can’t people wind their necks in? Babies are born in all sorts of different ways, fed in different ways. Can the judgement of mothers stop now ?

sometimew breast isn’t best. Sometimes formula is the better option.

sometimes a c section is the best option and sometimes an epidural is needed.

Birthing and mothering aren’t black and white experiences.

MOGMOGMOG85 · 17/07/2023 13:36

My birth and feeding journey was so traumatic and interventional and I felt acutely aware I had "failed". Throw in undiagnosed pnd and I felt exactly like you do. Honestly for me antidepressants helped me care not one iota what people think. There will never be the perfect put down, and you can't control people's idiotic opinions. Breastfeeding in particular brings out strong opinions. All that matters is that all babies have to eat, formula keeps babies alive and healthy, as does breastmilk, some people choose to and succeed in breastfeeding, some can't manage for any number of reasons, some don't want to. What works for you and your baby is none of anyone's business. Motherhood is hard, all aspects of it, and we all have different experiences. We should be supporting each other not judging or saying everyone should do x, u, z or whatever worked for me should be for everyone!

My advice, stop caring as soon as possible. If someone says something to me, I think privately "what a moron" and move on. If I can think of something to say to highlight how absurd it is I will, if not no big deal (although it's possible my face gives it away).

I would personally limit your time with these people as far as possible and try to surround yourself more with your tribe! Pnd is such a real problem for a lot of new mums and no-one needs people affecting their self esteem as mothers in those crucial early days! As I see it your job as a new mum now is to look after your mental health, your confidence, and your bond with your baby and keep all the haters out of your head! Good luck, it used to drive me insane too. I couldn't gaf what people think now - it takes practice! Xx

Forestfriendlygarden · 17/07/2023 13:34

In the face of such rudeness, occasionally I ask people if they have seen the film Paddington. Then I give them Paddington's hard stare.

Paddington - Hard Stare

In The Paddington Movies, He Did A Hard Stare At Mr. Brown And Knuckles And They Fell Hot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aS4w0Y1Kif4