Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Impact of SUVs in a crash

293 replies

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:48

Recently there was a terrible accident involving a 2 ton car
What stood out was the mention of the weight of the vehicle
So I did a couple of calcs
An SUV of 1972kg doing 30mph has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 38mph
A larger SUV of 2598kg has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 44mph
All these large SUVs doing 30mph create the same damage as a smaller car doing 38mph to 44mph
There must be enough maths & physics teachers on here to check this out
I did think of mentioning the small car and the big car types ?

But large SUVs (=large weight) are a much more serious danger to kids at 30mph than your small cars at 30mph

There is great emphasis on 30mph, perhaps we should enforce slower speeds for heavier vehicles if safety is the objective

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
LoisPrice · 17/07/2023 09:32

My dh is 6f8 and he can drive a vw up but it makes it a 3 seater as no one with legs can sit behind him

tt9 · 17/07/2023 09:31

not sure if this has already been mentioned but EVs/hybrids also weigh loads more because of the batteries... not that I am against EVS just something to consider. I recently had to drive a volvo xc40 as a replacement for my vw polo (nothing else was available) and the difference in mass really struck me. braking distances are much longer and you really feel it when you have to brake suddenly.

KimberleyClark · 17/07/2023 09:27

I actually understand why people who are quite safe drivers would like a massive car, because there are a lot of dangerous dicks on the road.

when I passed my test in the 80s I was quite happy to drive a Nissan Micra. But there were no monster cars on the road then. These days I feel safer in a medium sized car (A3).

SUVs are also a bloody nuisance in older MSCPs which are simply not designed for vehicles that size.

bibbityboppityboo · 17/07/2023 09:26

Worldgonecrazy · 17/07/2023 09:11

<deploy sarcasm mode>. We should all drive around in Fiat 500s. 😎 That way no one can go fast, and will feel so unsafe they will pay extra attention. It will also discourage people having two homes as the thought of a 500 mile round trip will become too horrendous to imagine.

This thread has to be one of the most ridiculous i have seen in a good while!

I'd cry, I can't even fit in one 😂

My DHs SUV is ten times more efficient than my little coupe. Unfortunately his car is also way more comfortable and practical where we live, we'd never be able to both fit in a fiat500 or drive one more than a mile.

Maybe we should only allow selling cars by height?! Or weight? Or some other wild factor.

Oakbeam · 17/07/2023 09:21

Not to mention that cars are generally designed for “reference man” who is 70kg and 170cm.

Fifth percentile women are also considered. So are 95th percentile men. The end result is usually something that suits neither perfectly.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 09:21

Worldgonecrazy · 17/07/2023 09:11

<deploy sarcasm mode>. We should all drive around in Fiat 500s. 😎 That way no one can go fast, and will feel so unsafe they will pay extra attention. It will also discourage people having two homes as the thought of a 500 mile round trip will become too horrendous to imagine.

This thread has to be one of the most ridiculous i have seen in a good while!

Not really. There's a huge range of cars that are more sensible and offer a diverse choice, none of which pose an irrational amount of extra risk for everyone else.

I guess we should all still smoke in pubs, restaurants and the workplace? Or allow people with dangerous jobs to drink at lunchtimes like we used to?

Rules/laws are introduced to protect people and improve safety. SUVs have been proven to kill more people and are a hazard. As an engineer they go against everything that I've been trained to do and what my job entails. It's precisely why I don't work in automotive as there's zero point spending a career on safety, for it all to be undone by packaging it up in an SUV body. It's the ultimate in insanity.

mum11970 · 17/07/2023 09:19

SisterAgatha · 17/07/2023 09:12

This could happen to anyone, but had she been in a smart car, the damage would not have been so great. That’s the point. It’s not the individual (heartbreaking) case, it’s the standard for dangerous vehicles becoming standard but being held to outdated laws/regulations which don’t account for their size.

Had the fencing between the road and school been stronger it could never have happened whatever the size of the vehicle. How about we look at improving ways of keeping pedestrians and vehicles apart, whatever their size?

dontchaknow · 17/07/2023 09:19

Cars are huge these days, whether SUV or not. They don't really fit into UK car park spaces any more, save for perhaps Costco. I drive a very small car and I am the only person on our street who parks inside their garage, the rest simply do not fit. But when these houses were built back in the 70s, average cars did fit in.
I'm very much in favour of a 20 mph speed limit in residential areas and around schools etc; whilst I rarely get out of second gear in our cul de sac, some treat our road like Brands Hatch. Slower speeds make a huge difference to the outcome in accidents no matter what the car size, but especially for the monsters people drive these days. And don't get me started on the terrible state of the roads - the heavier vehicles cannot be helping there, can they?

Catspyjamas17 · 17/07/2023 09:18

My dad bought a large MPV - a Sharan- because it was the only car he could get in, in his final years of life. He wasn't large at all but had poor mobility and a blue badge, and needed a high up seat and plenty of room to get in.

He passed away a few years ago and it's now my car. And fantastic because we can get five of us in, our big dog and cases.

We have another little car which we nip about in and DD1 drives.

But if people only have one car, there is little point them buying a tiny one that all the family plus cases don't fit into when you go on holiday, even if it's infrequent that you all get in it at once.

That said, I have only ever rarely driven any car at all in London. Would do almost anything else to avoid it!

But lots of other places have shit public transport. The trains are good where I live but we have no scheduled bus services at all, and the council tried to cut about 2/3 of school buses recently - it was only because parents were up in arms about it that the bus routes were kept on.

WaitingfortheTardis · 17/07/2023 09:16

Worldgonecrazy · 17/07/2023 09:11

<deploy sarcasm mode>. We should all drive around in Fiat 500s. 😎 That way no one can go fast, and will feel so unsafe they will pay extra attention. It will also discourage people having two homes as the thought of a 500 mile round trip will become too horrendous to imagine.

This thread has to be one of the most ridiculous i have seen in a good while!

Oh I used to love doing long journeys in my little Fiat 500, it was so lovely to drive and I'd just pootle along taking it fairly slow. That was before I had a family though, I don't think it would have been the same with passengers!

mum11970 · 17/07/2023 09:16

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 09:11

There's a huge amount of myth and misinformation when it comes to EV's.

My BMW i3 has a lower mass than most similarly sized hatchbacks (1300kg).
A Tesla model 3 is similar to a similarly sized BMW 3 series.
A Nissan Leaf is 1500kg-1800kg. A lot of modern hatchbacks are the same nowadays.

It's true that larger EV's are heavy but a Hyundai IONIQ 5 is about 2200kg. Similar to a Range Rover or similar sized SUV.

Regards to your OP, I've not done the calcs to validate but as an engineer I'd imagine you're not far off and in theory, you're spot on. It's precisely why I buy small, low mass cars.

So a Range Rover Evoque at 1787kg is lighter than a 1800kg Nissan Leaf! Size and weight are not always as obvious it seems

Polis · 17/07/2023 09:12

They don't drive them because they are worse in every measurable way, compared to regular cars.

In every measurable way? Ground clearance. Load capacity. I could go on.

SisterAgatha · 17/07/2023 09:12

This could happen to anyone, but had she been in a smart car, the damage would not have been so great. That’s the point. It’s not the individual (heartbreaking) case, it’s the standard for dangerous vehicles becoming standard but being held to outdated laws/regulations which don’t account for their size.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 09:11

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 01:01

SpinCycles
I hadnt thought of EVs when I posted, but good point

Also I know that anybody can have a seizure
It was that the article pointed out the weight of the vehicle
and that is the damaging factor + speed

We have controls on speed but none on weight + speed

If we did then maybe we wouldnt have so may SUVs

There's a huge amount of myth and misinformation when it comes to EV's.

My BMW i3 has a lower mass than most similarly sized hatchbacks (1300kg).
A Tesla model 3 is similar to a similarly sized BMW 3 series.
A Nissan Leaf is 1500kg-1800kg. A lot of modern hatchbacks are the same nowadays.

It's true that larger EV's are heavy but a Hyundai IONIQ 5 is about 2200kg. Similar to a Range Rover or similar sized SUV.

Regards to your OP, I've not done the calcs to validate but as an engineer I'd imagine you're not far off and in theory, you're spot on. It's precisely why I buy small, low mass cars.

Worldgonecrazy · 17/07/2023 09:11

<deploy sarcasm mode>. We should all drive around in Fiat 500s. 😎 That way no one can go fast, and will feel so unsafe they will pay extra attention. It will also discourage people having two homes as the thought of a 500 mile round trip will become too horrendous to imagine.

This thread has to be one of the most ridiculous i have seen in a good while!

mum11970 · 17/07/2023 09:10

Catspyjamas17 · 17/07/2023 08:54

The best thing to manage the risk is to not hit any pedestrians with your car. Most drivers manage not to.

This exactly. Far more passengers are involved in car accidents than pedestrians and at much higher speeds so it makes sense to opt for the vehicle that is safer for the passengers. Stronger barriers between the road and open spaces where pedestrians are likely to be makes more sense.

OMG12 · 17/07/2023 09:09

C8H10N4O2 · 17/07/2023 08:38

But what is an SUV? When my kids where small the vehicle everyone liked to demonise on discussions was the MPV, despite most of them being externally no bigger than a standard family estate car. Both are vehicles largely used by women trying to juggle kids, schedules and work.

There is no agreed definition of an SUV, its largely become a meaningless category dreamed up largely by marketing. If you want to categorise by something objective such as weight or external measurements then kiss goodbye to EVs and standard family estate and other large family cars as well.

I agree with you on EVs and the environment - the greenest car is still one that you keep until it drops, not the latest and greatest EV or hybrid. Its a lot greener to wait on the EV or hybrid until you absolutely have to change a car.

I guess when I say SUV I’m talking about a specific shape, generally higher than a saloon car, usually 4 wheel drive (or has 4 wheel drive versions) something that looks a similar shape to a range rover. It’s one of those, you’ll know it when you see it. For me more than anything it’s the height of these cars for the reasons I set out in my previous post.

Yes I agree with the keep cars till the drop= the best environmentally. Well actually walking/public transport is but that’s not as good for the economy.

WaitingfortheTardis · 17/07/2023 09:08

Great, I've now realised I am both taller and heavier than the average man. 😕

sweetgingercat · 17/07/2023 09:08

There is absolutely no need for most people to have SUVs especially in cities. SUVs are more dangerous, their height also means they are more likely to hit a person on their torso where their organs are than their legs. They use more fuel, obstruct clear vision on the road and take up parking space room.

mymycherrypie · 17/07/2023 09:06

Catspyjamas17 · 17/07/2023 09:03

Not to mention that cars are generally designed for “reference man” who is 70kg and 170cm.

About like me then, as a woman.

If the average man is 11st there are an awful lot of men kidding themselves.

This is my size too. Perfect then, I don’t need to buy a monster truck after all!

(no one does btw)

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 09:05

mum11970 · 17/07/2023 08:51

The higher driving position of an SUV offers better visibility than that available to the driver of a car much lower to the ground and they can generally spot hazards way further ahead. I tend to find those who moan most about big vehicles are the worst drivers and have absolutely no knowledge of cars or any interest in them and no I don’t drive an SUV before you jump to that conclusion.

It's the driver that spots things further up the road. I did an IAM course and none of the instructors drove SUV's but are better drivers than most of us.

They don't drive them because they are worse in every measurable way, compared to regular cars.

WaitingfortheTardis · 17/07/2023 09:04

We've just gone for a Tiguan, I have to sit in the back for various reasons and none of the estate cars gave me enough leg room with enough boot space. It isn't a 4x4 but will be quite a change as we've only ever had tiny cars before, but it is what we need. I'm sorry you think we are now the enemy. I'm more bothered about people using their phones to text while driving, which I still see regularly.

Catspyjamas17 · 17/07/2023 09:03

Not to mention that cars are generally designed for “reference man” who is 70kg and 170cm.

About like me then, as a woman.

If the average man is 11st there are an awful lot of men kidding themselves.

mymycherrypie · 17/07/2023 09:02

No need for them at all in the north London borough I live. Alexandra Palace is our most rugged terrain.

I hate hearing how safe they are - yes for you. Not for anyone you hit. I cannot wait for the expanded ULEZ to come in to play so we have fewer of these.

This is why schools have a 20mph zone and beware, if you park on the zigzags, I’ll happily report you all day long.

Catspyjamas17 · 17/07/2023 09:00

Though FWIW, I would like to see everyone driving golf buggies/simple cheap electric vehicles/bikes/scooters around populated areas/for shorter journeys with a speed limit of 20mph and only using actual cars for longer journeys. But the car industry would never allow it.