Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Impact of SUVs in a crash

293 replies

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:48

Recently there was a terrible accident involving a 2 ton car
What stood out was the mention of the weight of the vehicle
So I did a couple of calcs
An SUV of 1972kg doing 30mph has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 38mph
A larger SUV of 2598kg has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 44mph
All these large SUVs doing 30mph create the same damage as a smaller car doing 38mph to 44mph
There must be enough maths & physics teachers on here to check this out
I did think of mentioning the small car and the big car types ?

But large SUVs (=large weight) are a much more serious danger to kids at 30mph than your small cars at 30mph

There is great emphasis on 30mph, perhaps we should enforce slower speeds for heavier vehicles if safety is the objective

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 13:02

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 12:53

@justteanbiscuits but they don’t seem to be able to understand that people who have SUVs sometimes have to drive into towns/cities. I have to five days a week to take my children to school.

Someone up the thread suggested that it should only be farmers that have them!

Ah private school I presume to have to drive that far.

The huge suv's blocking all the commuting roads around me on their way to the local private schools on roads very much not designed for them cause an utter nightmare. 3 times in the past year people driving these, unable to easily see both sides have hit cars parked in my street trying to save that precious 30 seconds on their commute.

manontroppo · 17/07/2023 13:01

FrangipaniBlue · 17/07/2023 12:11

I'm not saying in your particular case, but yes, when your choice to drive a vehicle negatively impacts on the rest of the community, then yes, you should need to justify it, or pay extra.

@manontroppo

I do pay extra:

  • it cost more to buy than the average family car
  • my VED is higher (despite the actual emissions being lower than a car with the same engine size, it's higher by virtue of being "a van")
  • my insurance premium is higher
  • if I ever use toll roads the fee is higher

What else should I have to pay "extra" and who exactly should I have to justify my vehicle choice to?

Well, because we don't live in an ultra-liberal society, there's quite a lot people have to justify.....

Your van must clearly have value to you, otherwise I assume you wouldn't pay the financial penalty associated with it.

Lizzt2007 · 17/07/2023 13:00

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:56

KajsaKavat
hi I wasnt aiming at vans and light good vehicles, they are obviously heavier but they in the main have a reason for their size and weight; to carry gods etc...

But your argument was that the weight was the relevant point, not the use, so you can't have it both ways. Either higher weight = lower speed limits for all vehicles or you're targeting SUV's purely for the reason being they're suv's and not because of weight.

manontroppo · 17/07/2023 12:59

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 12:46

@SamanthaCaine I don’t care what the article says, it’s the point about about much damage a deer can cause. My DH was travelling well within the speed limit and he breaked as soon as he saw the deer. A deer hit another, smaller, car on the same road at the weekend. The car was written off. I am hoping that the occupants were OK.

My SUV escaped with a damaged bumper and bonnet. Had my car been lower down, the deer would have gone through the windscreen and hit my DH and DS.

This is the main road between my village and the nearest city. Driving at very low speeds is not an option.

Driving at a lower speed is an option, you just don't want to.

I live in deer country, the road between our village and the nearest town is routinely subject to deer crossing. And yet collisions are very few and far between, because a) the hazard is signposted and b) everyone generally doesn't drive like a twat.

And whilst we're talking about deer, drivers are far more likely to come across cyclists. Yet you don't seem to care about the impact your car has on someone who's almost guarenteed to come off worse, should you hit them.

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 12:53

@justteanbiscuits but they don’t seem to be able to understand that people who have SUVs sometimes have to drive into towns/cities. I have to five days a week to take my children to school.

Someone up the thread suggested that it should only be farmers that have them!

justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 12:47

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 12:25

Just one of the reasons I have a SUV:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6430541/Terrifying-moment-31stone-deer-smashes-windscreen-car-Poland.html

Had my DH and DS not been in our SUV when a deer hit them last year they probably wouldn’t be sat next to me on the sofa right now.

There’s also the matter of not being able to get out of my lane in ice and snow without four wheel drive. Not all roads are gritted in the winter.

As usual, there’s a distinct lack of understanding of rural life in this thread.

I think most people have an understanding of the difference and why SUV's are needed for some.

But I live in London. The number of MASSIVE suv's here is utterly ridiculous and simply not needed. They are nothing but a status symbol often driven by those who have no idea how to drive them.

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 12:46

@SamanthaCaine I don’t care what the article says, it’s the point about about much damage a deer can cause. My DH was travelling well within the speed limit and he breaked as soon as he saw the deer. A deer hit another, smaller, car on the same road at the weekend. The car was written off. I am hoping that the occupants were OK.

My SUV escaped with a damaged bumper and bonnet. Had my car been lower down, the deer would have gone through the windscreen and hit my DH and DS.

This is the main road between my village and the nearest city. Driving at very low speeds is not an option.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 12:40

whatdoidonowffs · 17/07/2023 12:18

Driver monitoring systems aren’t always perfect
I drive a truck with an auto braking system on it, I was following a car about 20m behind it the other day when the truck decided to slam the brakes on
the car behind went straight into me
I know he should have been further behind but it was an incident that didn’t need to happen if I was in control I would have braked gentler and slower giving everyone time to react

That’s not driver monitoring, that’s auto emergency braking. And the fault was the driver behind - entirely. The systems aren’t perfect, yet, but the only reason you had a crash is because the driver behind wasn’t obeying the 2 / 4 second rule.

Driver monitoring is coming in soon, and will be able to tell if you’re looking at your phone, or tired, or drunk / high, or having a medical emergency. Initially it will warn you, and eventually it will be used to take over control of the car, making it stop.

Popworld · 17/07/2023 12:37

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:48

Recently there was a terrible accident involving a 2 ton car
What stood out was the mention of the weight of the vehicle
So I did a couple of calcs
An SUV of 1972kg doing 30mph has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 38mph
A larger SUV of 2598kg has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 44mph
All these large SUVs doing 30mph create the same damage as a smaller car doing 38mph to 44mph
There must be enough maths & physics teachers on here to check this out
I did think of mentioning the small car and the big car types ?

But large SUVs (=large weight) are a much more serious danger to kids at 30mph than your small cars at 30mph

There is great emphasis on 30mph, perhaps we should enforce slower speeds for heavier vehicles if safety is the objective

What car do you drive?

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 12:36

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 12:25

Just one of the reasons I have a SUV:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6430541/Terrifying-moment-31stone-deer-smashes-windscreen-car-Poland.html

Had my DH and DS not been in our SUV when a deer hit them last year they probably wouldn’t be sat next to me on the sofa right now.

There’s also the matter of not being able to get out of my lane in ice and snow without four wheel drive. Not all roads are gritted in the winter.

As usual, there’s a distinct lack of understanding of rural life in this thread.

That's an amazing leap, pardon the pun. From the article:

The stunning creature refuses to slow down as it approaches the wide road before making an enormous leap over the road.

Amazing logic there about the deer not slowing down 😂. What next, teaching deer the green cross code 🤦

I actually live in deer country and the most stupid thing you can do is to drive at that speed. The entitlement is astonishing. If you want to share space with deer, you need to accept that you cannot drive at speeds that'll result in death. I can't imagine how you'd feel killing something so beautiful and an SUV makes absolutely no difference. In fact the height probably makes it worse. My 2 seater would've just driven underneath that for starters.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 12:34

justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 12:07

MPV's with lower bumper are much more sensible an option than suv's. But the car industry insists we all want SUV's!

The only reason we are being pushed SUVs is that in America (one of the largest car markets in the world, and so the driver of design) SUVs are considered trucks - ie commercial vehicle.

This means they pay a lower rate of tax for the emissions and they don’t have to pass the same safety tests
as consumer cars.

All that means the OEMs make more money on SUVs than ‘regular’ cars.

It is, like everything else, all about money.

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 12:25

Just one of the reasons I have a SUV:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6430541/Terrifying-moment-31stone-deer-smashes-windscreen-car-Poland.html

Had my DH and DS not been in our SUV when a deer hit them last year they probably wouldn’t be sat next to me on the sofa right now.

There’s also the matter of not being able to get out of my lane in ice and snow without four wheel drive. Not all roads are gritted in the winter.

As usual, there’s a distinct lack of understanding of rural life in this thread.

Terrifying moment a 31stone deer smashes through windscreen of a car

The deer ran out of woods in Olszyn, Poland, and died on impact. Three people were in the car and were all taken to hospital. The driver of the Honda suffered a broken spine and is in a coma.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6430541/Terrifying-moment-31stone-deer-smashes-windscreen-car-Poland.html

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 12:24

mum11970 · 17/07/2023 08:28

The kerb weight of a 2023 MINI COUNTRYMAN Cooper S E Untamed Edition ALL4 is 1760 kg; the kerb weight of a Range Rover Evoque is 1787 kg. Nobody would moan about the Mini and there is very little difference in weight; but gees they never stop moaning about the RR and SUVs. I drive a 5 seater saloon that has a kerb weight of 1695 kg.

If you’re so sure of your argument, why give the max Countryman weight (1760kg) and the minimum Evoque weight (1787kg)? The max weight of the Evoque tops 2157kg.

The mini starts at 1490kg.

So comparing entry level mini and Evoque, there is a 3 quarter of a ton difference. That’s a lot when it’s travelling at 30 mph.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 12:19

rampagingrobot · 17/07/2023 12:10

I assume you mean it rates really well in crashes for the occupants 🤦

What about the people you crash into?

It's not so much about weight, more about bonnet height, which is far more dangerous for pedestrians and cyclists. SUVs are vastly more dangerous to others than a normal car is.

Absolutely.

It's also worth mentioning that an SUV may well perform ok in a crash test but not relative to an car equivalent. For instance, the Ford Puma is based on the Fiesta platform but with jacked suspension and a higher body. The difference in safety is notable. The same applies to other SUV's from other manufacturers.

SUV's also roll, due to the higher centre of gravity. So whilst a car may skid, an SUV will roll and introduce more dangerous problems for passengers.

People should note that NCAP tests are highly specific and real life is far from. Having worked with people who have spent time in the automotive industry, many just design their cars to perform well in these circumstances, because NCAP stars sell.

whatdoidonowffs · 17/07/2023 12:18

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:36

As are their smaller, lighter, lower non-SUV counterparts.

At least very soon driver monitoring systems will be mandatory so all the god awful useless drivers will be overruled by their cars.

Driver monitoring systems aren’t always perfect
I drive a truck with an auto braking system on it, I was following a car about 20m behind it the other day when the truck decided to slam the brakes on
the car behind went straight into me
I know he should have been further behind but it was an incident that didn’t need to happen if I was in control I would have braked gentler and slower giving everyone time to react

justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 12:18

bibbityboppityboo · 17/07/2023 12:09

@justteanbiscuits

I think height and weight are an important way to see if people fit, but wont work for everyone. I'm many stone lighter than your brother and it won't fit me, and my DH is quite a few inches taller than your brother and it won't fit him either 😊

I've tried (many times) on different models, I have a very long legs short body situation, so my legs can't fit into under the wheels safely, as the seats don't drop far enough down. Annoying as I thought it would be the perfect town car for going into the cities!

I'm the opposite - short with short legs! I tend to not be able to see over the bonnet of estate cars 😂 I did look at the Fiat 500L yesterday - it was very strange!!

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 12:15

I don’t know why estates have fallen out of fashion so much. Big cars, plenty of space, yes they might still be heavier than a small car but probably not as heavy as an suv and have lower bumpers. I have a big estate, weighs 1500kg.

FrangipaniBlue · 17/07/2023 12:11

I'm not saying in your particular case, but yes, when your choice to drive a vehicle negatively impacts on the rest of the community, then yes, you should need to justify it, or pay extra.

@manontroppo

I do pay extra:

  • it cost more to buy than the average family car
  • my VED is higher (despite the actual emissions being lower than a car with the same engine size, it's higher by virtue of being "a van")
  • my insurance premium is higher
  • if I ever use toll roads the fee is higher

What else should I have to pay "extra" and who exactly should I have to justify my vehicle choice to?

rampagingrobot · 17/07/2023 12:10

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:04

My SUV rates really well in crashes. Maybe others need to factor in their cars are made out of the equivalent of aluminum foil and plan accordingly.

I assume you mean it rates really well in crashes for the occupants 🤦

What about the people you crash into?

It's not so much about weight, more about bonnet height, which is far more dangerous for pedestrians and cyclists. SUVs are vastly more dangerous to others than a normal car is.

bibbityboppityboo · 17/07/2023 12:09

@justteanbiscuits

I think height and weight are an important way to see if people fit, but wont work for everyone. I'm many stone lighter than your brother and it won't fit me, and my DH is quite a few inches taller than your brother and it won't fit him either 😊

I've tried (many times) on different models, I have a very long legs short body situation, so my legs can't fit into under the wheels safely, as the seats don't drop far enough down. Annoying as I thought it would be the perfect town car for going into the cities!

justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 12:07

SocialLite · 17/07/2023 08:30

Where do you propose large families/those with disabilities shove the extra people or equipment?

There are lots of reasons people may need larger cars.

MPV's with lower bumper are much more sensible an option than suv's. But the car industry insists we all want SUV's!

justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 12:04

bibbityboppityboo · 17/07/2023 09:26

I'd cry, I can't even fit in one 😂

My DHs SUV is ten times more efficient than my little coupe. Unfortunately his car is also way more comfortable and practical where we live, we'd never be able to both fit in a fiat500 or drive one more than a mile.

Maybe we should only allow selling cars by height?! Or weight? Or some other wild factor.

My 6ft2 23 stone brother comfortably drives his daughters Fiat 500!

justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 12:00

BunnyBettChetwynd · 17/07/2023 08:53

Even minis aren't small any more. See one parked next to the new Discovery and there's not much in it. Most people, most of the time don't need big cars.

I've also noticed how much noisier big cars are on the road that passes my house.

Well, the discovery is about twice the size!! Mini's are certainly not mini anymore, but still a lot smaller than a Discovery!

Catspyjamas17 · 17/07/2023 09:34

because there are a lot of dangerous dicks on the road.

Yes. Yesterday a car came out of nowhere at speed, tried to undertake me as I was indicating and beginning to move left to exit the roundabout, sounded his horn at me, then went off at the same exit, weaving in and out of cars in front.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 09:32

mum11970 · 17/07/2023 09:16

So a Range Rover Evoque at 1787kg is lighter than a 1800kg Nissan Leaf! Size and weight are not always as obvious it seems

Now pick me another scenario where the 1500kg Leaf is lighter than the heaviest 2157kg variant. If you actually compare like for like, the Evoque is consistently ~300kg heavier. That's basically 4 passengers.

Selective use of figures isn't a great look is it?

Besides, an Evoque is a useless handbag of a vehicle. Boot space is 591 litres with the rear seats up, and 1,383 litres with them down. The Leaf is 435 litres and 1,176 litres. So you can't even say that it's usefully bigger, considering the difference in vehicle class. You're talking one large suitcase.

Swipe left for the next trending thread