Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Impact of SUVs in a crash

293 replies

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:48

Recently there was a terrible accident involving a 2 ton car
What stood out was the mention of the weight of the vehicle
So I did a couple of calcs
An SUV of 1972kg doing 30mph has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 38mph
A larger SUV of 2598kg has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 44mph
All these large SUVs doing 30mph create the same damage as a smaller car doing 38mph to 44mph
There must be enough maths & physics teachers on here to check this out
I did think of mentioning the small car and the big car types ?

But large SUVs (=large weight) are a much more serious danger to kids at 30mph than your small cars at 30mph

There is great emphasis on 30mph, perhaps we should enforce slower speeds for heavier vehicles if safety is the objective

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:46

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/oct/07/a-deadly-problem-should-we-ban-suvs-from-our-cities

passangers are 11% more likely to die in an suv crash according to this which surprised me. Maybe because they’re more likely to roll?

A person is 11% more likely to die in a crash inside an SUV than a regular saloon. Studies show they lull drivers into a false sense of security, encouraging them to take greater risks. Their height makes them twice as likely to roll in crashes and twice as likely to kill pedestrians by inflicting greater upper body and head injuries, as opposed to lower limb injuries people have a greater chance of surviving.

'A deadly problem': should we ban SUVs from our cities?

Statistically less safe than regular cars and with higher CO2 emissions, campaigners argue the heavily-marketed cars have no place in urban areas

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/oct/07/a-deadly-problem-should-we-ban-suvs-from-our-cities

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:45

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:41

Well duh, if you have a higher centre of gravity it’s basic physics that you’re more likely to roll. Obviously even with a non SUV there will be some impacts which could cause it to roll but there is hard evidence that with the same impact an SUV is more likely to roll under certain conditions inc a side swipe. But feel free to believe your hubby.

Oh I will thanks.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:41

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:18

Well the vehicle that side swiped her at a high speed maybe just had a little bit to do with the accident. But you’re probably right it was the SUV that just randomly decided to flip on it’s back like a turtle 4-5 times.

I’m sure your an expert and all but I’ll trust my husband’s years of accident experience and first hand knowledge of the situation.

Well duh, if you have a higher centre of gravity it’s basic physics that you’re more likely to roll. Obviously even with a non SUV there will be some impacts which could cause it to roll but there is hard evidence that with the same impact an SUV is more likely to roll under certain conditions inc a side swipe. But feel free to believe your hubby.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 15:41

Margrethe · 17/07/2023 15:38

Electric cars are on average 33% heavier than their fossil fuel equivalents on the road. While they are a good thing for air quality, there are already concerns about the strain they will put on old bridges, etc.
Perhaps the safety of other road users should also be considered.

There's also concerns over the rubbish quoted by people on the internet.

There is no such concern about EV's, except for the anti EV press. If bridges were a concern, government would've legislated for SUV's and the general increase in vehicle size long before EV's came about.

Margrethe · 17/07/2023 15:38

Electric cars are on average 33% heavier than their fossil fuel equivalents on the road. While they are a good thing for air quality, there are already concerns about the strain they will put on old bridges, etc.
Perhaps the safety of other road users should also be considered.

jc12689 · 17/07/2023 15:22

oi0Y0io · 17/07/2023 13:54

Goodness me, you sound very stressed!

Maybe because they actually live in the real world.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:22

ForTheSnarkWasABoojumYouSee · 17/07/2023 15:19

"Bigger than they need"

There are a lot of rules and regulations over larger commercial vehicles. Nobody in their right mind is going to routinely drive one that's bigger than necessary for the purpose.

I think you missed the point. I’m sure a lot of people would say they need the safety on an SUV when driving next to large commercial vehicles. Who knows, my cousin may still be alive today if was in one when hit by one. IIRC There we’re survivors in other types of vehicles that were involved in the same crash.

midgetastic · 17/07/2023 15:22

"Bigger than you need"

Does anyone really need a car ?

What do we mean by need ?

Be able to do what we want when we want? To take the job we want? To go shopping? To pick up a bag of crisps ? I mean we should mostly be able to do that by walking or cycling or taking public transport ( even if it does take longer /cost more )

ForTheSnarkWasABoojumYouSee · 17/07/2023 15:19

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:09

So the nanny state is going to ban commercial vehicles then?

"Bigger than they need"

There are a lot of rules and regulations over larger commercial vehicles. Nobody in their right mind is going to routinely drive one that's bigger than necessary for the purpose.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:18

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:12

If she hadn’t been driving an SUV she probably wouldn’t have rolled it. There’s a lot of research about how they’re more likely to roll.

Well the vehicle that side swiped her at a high speed maybe just had a little bit to do with the accident. But you’re probably right it was the SUV that just randomly decided to flip on it’s back like a turtle 4-5 times.

I’m sure your an expert and all but I’ll trust my husband’s years of accident experience and first hand knowledge of the situation.

FloydPepper · 17/07/2023 15:16

Yes, large SUVs are worse for those outside of them in an accident but (probably) better for those inside.

I guess most owners know that and feel increased safety for them is worth the reduction in safety for others?

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 17/07/2023 15:13

EVs being mentioned as heavy, maybe, but they're also all new so likely to have advanced safety tech. Mine is not heavier than my previous similarly sized diesel people carrier but stops much quicker and more reliably. I have had cause to do a sudden emergency stop recently, at speed, to avoid killing a pedestrian doing something stupid.

They're also very easy to drive at 20 due to no gears.

Justbecause19 · 17/07/2023 15:13

Child car seats are absolutely huge now and with recommendations to rear face for as long as possible people with young families need bigger cars. I am soon to have 3 in car seats and the only vehicles I could find to allow this (3 full seats across the back) are MPVs or vans.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:12

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 13:28

But do they fit all the things I need in them? Nope…so I choose an SUV.

Beyond that I’m in the unusual position that my husband has responded to a vehicle rollover crash involving my model of SUV. The woman rolled multiple times and she walked away with minor scrapes and bruises. Coupled that and my old SUV (same type) was donated to the local fire department for training and I witnessed them swearing and cursing while they worked to ‘extricate’ the trading dummy from my vehicle and how hard they had to work to cut through the support posts.

All of those things combined I’ll be fine with my choice. You can choose whatever you want without comment or judgement from me.

If she hadn’t been driving an SUV she probably wouldn’t have rolled it. There’s a lot of research about how they’re more likely to roll.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:09

ForTheSnarkWasABoojumYouSee · 17/07/2023 15:05

Which is why you need legislation. If you've got into an arms race where people are actively choosing to drive cars larger than they need purely because they're larger than other people's and thus more likely to come off better in an accident, regardless of the price to pedestrians, other vehicles and the environment then that's the sort of destructive spiral where the nanny state needs to step in because game theory is pushing people to behave in everyone's worse interests.

So the nanny state is going to ban commercial vehicles then?

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 15:07

@SamanthaCaine

Driving more slowly would have been dangerous in itself to him and to other road users.

I’ve seen some terrible accidents on this particular road from risky overtaking and some of those who were being overtaken have been caught up in those accidents.

There is a good reason that driving too slowly is dealt with in the Highway Code. It is dangerous.

My DH was driving at a sensible speed well within the speed limit but not too slowly to irritate other road users or to be pulled over by the police.

ForTheSnarkWasABoojumYouSee · 17/07/2023 15:05

Sparklfairy · 17/07/2023 05:04

Exactly. They're touted as 'safer' so a lot of parents especially buy them but the thinking stops there. People think safer for themselves, without thinking about the damage they can do to others. And why should they? It'd be some weird sort of martyrdom virtue signalling to drive around in a cardboard box to 'keep others safer...'

Which is why you need legislation. If you've got into an arms race where people are actively choosing to drive cars larger than they need purely because they're larger than other people's and thus more likely to come off better in an accident, regardless of the price to pedestrians, other vehicles and the environment then that's the sort of destructive spiral where the nanny state needs to step in because game theory is pushing people to behave in everyone's worse interests.

LlynTegid · 17/07/2023 15:03

@Oreosareawful you have taken a test with the vehicle you drive and a trailer. So you are the 1 in 100 who has reason for a larger vehicle, what about the other 99?

Most of the SUVs that are allegedly necessary for the steep 1 in 25 slope on a half mile journey are driven by people who took a test in something the size of a Nissan Micra. The figures for cars used for journeys to and from school were that a third only went home-school-home, and that was figures before wfh was a possibility, so possibly more.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 14:58

Oreosareawful · 17/07/2023 14:55

Are you serious? I should get rid of my much loved equine pet so I can have a small car to drive near the school?
My point was that an SUV is the ideal vehicle for me, as it is for a lot of people, which is why car manufacturers sell so many of them.

So no complaints then about your horse, it didn’t somehow hold you hostage until you bought an SUV to take it for long drives in the country 🤣

Oreosareawful · 17/07/2023 14:55

oi0Y0io · 17/07/2023 14:21

I think her life would be much easier if she could get rid of the horse which has been imposed upon her 🤷
That did appear to be her chief complaint, that she has to have the SUV because of the horse obviously the solution is get rid of the horse, it sounds like a complete nuisance!

Are you serious? I should get rid of my much loved equine pet so I can have a small car to drive near the school?
My point was that an SUV is the ideal vehicle for me, as it is for a lot of people, which is why car manufacturers sell so many of them.

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 14:54

@justteanbiscuits only if you go to the catchment school. Our catchment school is 7.5 miles away. My DS goes to the second closest 8 miles away in the opposite direction.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 14:47

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 13:58

@SamanthaCaine yes he bloody did have time to react because he’s very aware as a driver. This is an A road 40 miles from London, not the highlands of Scotland. Driving at 30 on a 60 road in normal conditions is dangerous because people become annoyed and overtake in dangerous places causing accidents.

And he wasn’t driving at the speed limit anyway so stop being so judgmental.

I'm being judgemental because you're making terrible excuses, not just for owning an SUV, butfor your husband when it's obvious driving more slowly is the answer. I live by the M1 in Buckinghamshire, so what. Deer deer don't just live in the Highlands.

The most obvious flaw in your continuous defense of your husband, is that a slower speed could've prevented the accident entirely. So what if people want to risk overtaking. Let them shoulder the risk. I don't, and is probably why I've not nearly died.

justteanbiscuits · 17/07/2023 14:27

Dibblydoodahdah · 17/07/2023 14:10

@Sigmama the headteacher at our local primary told people in our hamlet (1.5 miles from the school) not to walk our children to school as it is a 60mph road and he doesn’t consider it safe. I think he’s right. As there’s no school transport or public bus, we can either dice with death or drive. What would you do?

My oldest DS’s secondary school is 8 miles away and there is no school transport. The school bus starts after nine. How do you suggest he gets to school?

I thought there was an obligation for transport to be provided if school is more than 3 miles away?? I grew up rural and I know school buses had to be provided from the villages more than 4 miles away.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 14:22

oi0Y0io · 17/07/2023 14:21

I think her life would be much easier if she could get rid of the horse which has been imposed upon her 🤷
That did appear to be her chief complaint, that she has to have the SUV because of the horse obviously the solution is get rid of the horse, it sounds like a complete nuisance!

I must have missed her complaining about the horse. Where was that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread