Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Impact of SUVs in a crash

293 replies

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:48

Recently there was a terrible accident involving a 2 ton car
What stood out was the mention of the weight of the vehicle
So I did a couple of calcs
An SUV of 1972kg doing 30mph has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 38mph
A larger SUV of 2598kg has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 44mph
All these large SUVs doing 30mph create the same damage as a smaller car doing 38mph to 44mph
There must be enough maths & physics teachers on here to check this out
I did think of mentioning the small car and the big car types ?

But large SUVs (=large weight) are a much more serious danger to kids at 30mph than your small cars at 30mph

There is great emphasis on 30mph, perhaps we should enforce slower speeds for heavier vehicles if safety is the objective

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:36

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 16:32

I don't need credentials, but as an engineer that understands physics I'm questioning his as a firefighter, given it's a specialised field.

Stating the bleeding obvious, the car that hit the SUV is the cause of the rollover, as cars rarely roll on their own. But the propensity is increased in an SUV, specifically because of the high CoG. To say otherwise is why people are questioning his credentials.

Stating the bleeding obvious, the car that hit the SUV is the cause of the rollover, as cars rarely roll on their own. But the propensity is increased in an SUV, specifically because of the high CoG.

Psst nobody (including me) has said otherwise.

I actually don’t even know what you are arguing about with me about at this point. Perhaps you should step away unless you want to insult me or “hubby” some more which is all you seem to want to do.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 16:32

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:21

Your credentials, now that I know them you are clearly the expert to be deferred to. I’m wanting to hear more of your assessment of this crash.

I don't need credentials, but as an engineer that understands physics I'm questioning his as a firefighter, given it's a specialised field.

Stating the bleeding obvious, the car that hit the SUV is the cause of the rollover, as cars rarely roll on their own. But the propensity is increased in an SUV, specifically because of the high CoG. To say otherwise is why people are questioning his credentials.

ClaudiaWankleman · 17/07/2023 16:30

Nope you assume mansplaining because he’s a man.

No I observed mansplaining and have explained why it is mansplaining. You presented a man's opinion in order to end the debate.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:27

towriteyoumustlive · 17/07/2023 16:20

It entirely depends what you are crashing into!

Momentum (mass x velocity) is just as important as the kinetic energy.

Impact force is proportional to the rate of change of momentum. F = (mv)/t

So if you're crashing into a wall, a car that is double the mass will have to undergo double the change in momentum, which will double the impact force. The only way to lessen this is to increase the time period (e.g. have a bigger crumple zone at the front).

BUT... if we're talking head on collisions, then a smaller car will not come out well. Momentum is conserved, so if they're doing the same speed, the bigger car will end up pushing the smaller car back the other direction, so the smaller car will experience a bigger change in momentum and therefore a bigger impact force.

(Physics Nerd🤓)

I love physics :) The world explained in easy to understand formulas.

-signed
a wanna be physics nerd 🙂

Biker47 · 17/07/2023 16:23

Swapped to an SUV back end of last year, love it, will get another one after this one.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:21

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 16:19

Say what earlier? Your post makes no sense at all.

Your credentials, now that I know them you are clearly the expert to be deferred to. I’m wanting to hear more of your assessment of this crash.

towriteyoumustlive · 17/07/2023 16:20

It entirely depends what you are crashing into!

Momentum (mass x velocity) is just as important as the kinetic energy.

Impact force is proportional to the rate of change of momentum. F = (mv)/t

So if you're crashing into a wall, a car that is double the mass will have to undergo double the change in momentum, which will double the impact force. The only way to lessen this is to increase the time period (e.g. have a bigger crumple zone at the front).

BUT... if we're talking head on collisions, then a smaller car will not come out well. Momentum is conserved, so if they're doing the same speed, the bigger car will end up pushing the smaller car back the other direction, so the smaller car will experience a bigger change in momentum and therefore a bigger impact force.

(Physics Nerd🤓)

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 16:19

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:10

Oh my gosh why didn’t you say this earlier. I should have absolutely agreed with your assessment earlier of this situation. Well color me embarrassed. I will absolutely defer your extensive experience in this particular crash.

Please tell me what you think the impact the weather conditions played on that day? How about the alertness of the drivers? The other vehicles involved? Speed?

Say what earlier? Your post makes no sense at all.

Mummyof287 · 17/07/2023 16:15

Agreed...its ridiculous.Nobody needs the bloody things- its all just for status and appearance sake.They mostly don't seat any more people than a smaller car anyway, and if someone needs the bigger boot for a dog/fishing stuff/golf clubs/carrying furniture or whatever else, why not just get an estate!
I saw a massive brand new huge landrover discovery the other day carrying an elderly couple who couldn't park the thing for the life of them! WHY?! 🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:15

Where* (damn autocorrect) (I hope that wasn’t too much of a hysterical outburst)

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:13

ClaudiaWankleman · 17/07/2023 16:07

Mansplaining is a symptom of sexism. It is not sexist to call out sexist behaviour. You have parroted mansplaining - calling in your husband's views to end the debate is just that.
Maybe you have a point about the 'soothing' but, on the other hand, reading through your posts you don't seem that rational. 'Other road users should pre-empt me mowing them down and blame themselves for not sitting in a large SUV-surviving vehicle...'

Nope you assume mansplaining because he’s a man. That is sexist. And you’ve just called me an irrational woman because I have a different opinion than you. So ah…yeah sexist again.

The weird quote thing was a nice touch. I forgot what’re I wrote that, can you help me out?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:10

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 16:03

So are firefighters now collision analysts nowadays? I thought that was the job of highly specialised teams within the police force. Typically it's a degree level forensics job. It's something I could've done when doing my degree but preferred aero.

I've no doubt he's an expert in extrication but that's different to investigating the physics of an accident.

Oh my gosh why didn’t you say this earlier. I should have absolutely agreed with your assessment earlier of this situation. Well color me embarrassed. I will absolutely defer your extensive experience in this particular crash.

Please tell me what you think the impact the weather conditions played on that day? How about the alertness of the drivers? The other vehicles involved? Speed?

HelplessSoul · 17/07/2023 16:09

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:28

EVs are a big problem because of weight, but they aren’t as big a problem as either fossil fuel SUVs or electric SUVs. Body shape and height also matter in terms of injury outcomes. But yeah, don’t let facts get in the way of your bullshittery.

Yes, go ahead and conveniently ignore all the fossil fuel powered machinery in places across Africa digging out the precious metals needed for your woke virtue signalling overpriced milkfloat.

Same old tripe from you sorts of climate paranoid people.

ClaudiaWankleman · 17/07/2023 16:07

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:02

So far

  • I’ve been called a frantic woman that “hubby” has had to soothe -Sexism
  • ”hubby” is a mansplainer -sexist
  • I am a mansplainer ‘apologist’ -sexist

Did I get all of them? I admit I may have missed some.

Mansplaining is a symptom of sexism. It is not sexist to call out sexist behaviour. You have parroted mansplaining - calling in your husband's views to end the debate is just that.
Maybe you have a point about the 'soothing' but, on the other hand, reading through your posts you don't seem that rational. 'Other road users should pre-empt me mowing them down and blame themselves for not sitting in a large SUV-surviving vehicle...'

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 16:06

Bewilderedandhurt · 17/07/2023 16:00

If pedestrians and cyclists increasingly wear headphones or pods it really doesn't matter if the vehicle is electric and quiet or combustion engine and noisy.
I think it's insane that so many people are happy to block off one of their essential senses and massively reduce their spacial awareness.

It's more important that people in charge of a few tonnes of heavy machinery, take the responsibility seriously and read the road (like they were trained to). Pedestrians and cyclists wearing headphones is not something I do but shouldn't make much difference to whether cars run them over or not.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 16:03

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:52

Or he’s a firefighter with decades of accident experience, was on the scene, spoke with all of the people involved in the accident (including the driver who was not seriously injured), and the police.

But you’re right I’m sure “hubby” was just making it all up to pacify my delicate sensibilities.

Yes vehicles with a higher center of gravity will roll more often than those without. But you all seem awfully invested in trying to convince me that you know better than someone who was there.

So are firefighters now collision analysts nowadays? I thought that was the job of highly specialised teams within the police force. Typically it's a degree level forensics job. It's something I could've done when doing my degree but preferred aero.

I've no doubt he's an expert in extrication but that's different to investigating the physics of an accident.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 16:02

So far

  • I’ve been called a frantic woman that “hubby” has had to soothe -Sexism
  • ”hubby” is a mansplainer -sexist
  • I am a mansplainer ‘apologist’ -sexist

Did I get all of them? I admit I may have missed some.

Bewilderedandhurt · 17/07/2023 16:00

If pedestrians and cyclists increasingly wear headphones or pods it really doesn't matter if the vehicle is electric and quiet or combustion engine and noisy.
I think it's insane that so many people are happy to block off one of their essential senses and massively reduce their spacial awareness.

ClaudiaWankleman · 17/07/2023 15:58

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:55

Are you always this sexist?

This isn't the sexism you are (wilfully) misconstruing it to be.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:55

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:48

Exactly but hey, let’s believe the man rather than the evidence. It’s bad enough with mansplaining in general without women promoting mansplaining.

Are you always this sexist?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 15:52

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 15:46

Twice as likely to roll. Naturally all situations are different but all things being equal, an SUV is much more likely to roll.

Hubby is likely quietly trying to prevent wife from panicking and will say anything. Either that or knows little about physics or accidents.

Or he’s a firefighter with decades of accident experience, was on the scene, spoke with all of the people involved in the accident (including the driver who was not seriously injured), and the police.

But you’re right I’m sure “hubby” was just making it all up to pacify my delicate sensibilities.

Yes vehicles with a higher center of gravity will roll more often than those without. But you all seem awfully invested in trying to convince me that you know better than someone who was there.

longtompot · 17/07/2023 15:52

oi0Y0io · 17/07/2023 13:42

There are too many cars and they are all too big, it should be illegal to drive distances of less than five miles imo

Ableism at its finest.

We have a suv, only recently bought. The reason we chose it was because with two dds with chronic pain conditions, a car ride to the GP or hospital was incredibly difficult for them, never mind if they wanted to go somewhere for fun. We tested several before we bought the one we did, to make sure they were comfortable. The relief for one of my dds to not have the chronic pain in her feet made worse by road vibrations was immense.

The worst drivers we have here, a small city, are some drivers of BMW, Audi, and Volvo family cars, not the 4x4s.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:48

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 15:46

Twice as likely to roll. Naturally all situations are different but all things being equal, an SUV is much more likely to roll.

Hubby is likely quietly trying to prevent wife from panicking and will say anything. Either that or knows little about physics or accidents.

Exactly but hey, let’s believe the man rather than the evidence. It’s bad enough with mansplaining in general without women promoting mansplaining.

Alltheshoes74 · 17/07/2023 15:48

Was a passenger in a 4x4 stationary at a junction a number of years ago. Boy racer pulled off at speed on a wet road and spun and the speed and impact he hit me at was insane. Police advised I would have been likely to have suffered catastrophic injuries in a normal sized car. I get your point but although I currently don’t drive one I totally get the point of them. People drive like lunatics a lot of the time.. I’d rather walk out of an accident.

SamanthaCaine · 17/07/2023 15:46

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 17/07/2023 15:41

Well duh, if you have a higher centre of gravity it’s basic physics that you’re more likely to roll. Obviously even with a non SUV there will be some impacts which could cause it to roll but there is hard evidence that with the same impact an SUV is more likely to roll under certain conditions inc a side swipe. But feel free to believe your hubby.

Twice as likely to roll. Naturally all situations are different but all things being equal, an SUV is much more likely to roll.

Hubby is likely quietly trying to prevent wife from panicking and will say anything. Either that or knows little about physics or accidents.