Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Impact of SUVs in a crash

293 replies

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:48

Recently there was a terrible accident involving a 2 ton car
What stood out was the mention of the weight of the vehicle
So I did a couple of calcs
An SUV of 1972kg doing 30mph has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 38mph
A larger SUV of 2598kg has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 44mph
All these large SUVs doing 30mph create the same damage as a smaller car doing 38mph to 44mph
There must be enough maths & physics teachers on here to check this out
I did think of mentioning the small car and the big car types ?

But large SUVs (=large weight) are a much more serious danger to kids at 30mph than your small cars at 30mph

There is great emphasis on 30mph, perhaps we should enforce slower speeds for heavier vehicles if safety is the objective

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:22

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:13

You misunderstood me. My car/suv isn’t aluminum. But a lot of the small cars on the road seem to be.

In other words if you buy a tiny lightweight car don’t be surprised when everything on the roads outweigh you and you have shitty prospects in a crash

And how would you suggest pedestrians, cyclists and motorcyclists ‘plan accordingly’?

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/07/2023 06:16

But I don’t feel safe in a small car because of the big ones, so rather than put my family at risk I am getting a bigger car.

This is what I mean by arms race.

It's like driving position. If everyone drives a car where the driver is three feet off the ground, everyone can see. If someone chooses to be four feet off the ground they can see better but everyone else can't see any more.

Eventually everyone is driving cranes. It's ridiculous.

Pawpatrolsucks · 17/07/2023 06:00

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/07/2023 05:48

This is part of the issue. People who feel safer take more risks. Which is why following distances got shorter after anti-lock brakes came in. People 'correct' their behaviour to what they perceive to be an acceptable risk.

SUVs are more likely to be at fault in a crash because the drivers feel safer. It makes them worse. And worse drivers stay on the roads because the risk is someone else's. If my aunt (who is a shockingly poor driver) had to ride a motorbike, I guarantee she'd have stopped decades ago. But her BMV SUV means everyone else is at risk, not her. So she continues to drive. She feels safe.

Which means bigger vehicles on the roads with worse drivers. Unless we all want to eventually drive tanks, it makes sense to limit this arms race. Especially as there are lots of humans around without metal armour on. Cyclists, pedestrians, children.

It really is simple psychology and statistics, and as the OP says, mathematics. Do people want more pedestrian deaths or fewer?

I can see where you are coming from and agree to a point. I have a small car but am going to get something medium sized for my next one. I drive kids around all the time so want a bit more car around my family for safety. Especially as I was just about run into another car when a huge car didn’t see me. My dh has a huge truck like car and I wouldn’t drive something like that because I don’t have the skill, I wouldn’t let him get a Bull bar in case he hits someone. But I don’t feel safe in a small car because of the big ones, so rather than put my family at risk I am getting a bigger car.

Fucket · 17/07/2023 05:49

Cars will probably end up being taxed on weight soon enough anyway. How else are governments going to repair the wear and tear to roads caused by the increased weight of EVs and SUVs.

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/07/2023 05:48

Pawpatrolsucks · 17/07/2023 05:06

What about people that want to be safer in a crash?

This is part of the issue. People who feel safer take more risks. Which is why following distances got shorter after anti-lock brakes came in. People 'correct' their behaviour to what they perceive to be an acceptable risk.

SUVs are more likely to be at fault in a crash because the drivers feel safer. It makes them worse. And worse drivers stay on the roads because the risk is someone else's. If my aunt (who is a shockingly poor driver) had to ride a motorbike, I guarantee she'd have stopped decades ago. But her BMV SUV means everyone else is at risk, not her. So she continues to drive. She feels safe.

Which means bigger vehicles on the roads with worse drivers. Unless we all want to eventually drive tanks, it makes sense to limit this arms race. Especially as there are lots of humans around without metal armour on. Cyclists, pedestrians, children.

It really is simple psychology and statistics, and as the OP says, mathematics. Do people want more pedestrian deaths or fewer?

Moonmelodies · 17/07/2023 05:44

At least the modern SUVs are bristling with the latest collision avoidance tech to help avoid such tragedies.

hattie43 · 17/07/2023 05:43

CostelloJones · 17/07/2023 01:27

Oh another anti SUV thread, how original

Exactly . Another day another SUV bashing . I love my SUV and when it's due for renewal I'll buy another .
I had a crash in a mini which just crumpled. I feel safe in my SUV .

Moonmelodies · 17/07/2023 05:42

nocoolnamesleft · 17/07/2023 00:50

Don't forget that cars that sit higher above the ground are more likely to impact chests/heads, instead of legs, which alters survivability.

An impact to the legs often results in the head hitting the windscreen, which rarely ends well.

Jins · 17/07/2023 05:26

My compact SUV weighs 1035kg. Less than a mini. Similar to a basic corsa or fiat 500. Smaller footprint than a mini.

It's not always straightforward. Placing restrictions by size or weight would have to be across the board.

Pawpatrolsucks · 17/07/2023 05:06

What about people that want to be safer in a crash?

Wallywobbles · 17/07/2023 05:05

My EV is 1502kg.

Sparklfairy · 17/07/2023 05:04

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:27

And good luck to them. If I have to choose between something that keeps me safe and something that keeps other safer under certain conditions. Yeah it’s not something I’m going to spend a lot of time debating.

Exactly. They're touted as 'safer' so a lot of parents especially buy them but the thinking stops there. People think safer for themselves, without thinking about the damage they can do to others. And why should they? It'd be some weird sort of martyrdom virtue signalling to drive around in a cardboard box to 'keep others safer...'

HelplessSoul · 17/07/2023 04:58

Funny how the OP harps on about weights of SUVs, yet says nothing about the heavier weights of EVs that need more stopping distances to counteract the batteries they carry.

For examply, my relatives new Tesla Model 3 comes in at 2.4t (2400kg) - nearly 800kg MORE than my SUV.

Go figure.

But yeah, dont let FACTs get in the way of your bullshittery. 🤦‍♂️🤷‍♂️🙄

MissTrip82 · 17/07/2023 04:13

I think the bigger issue is that so many driving these vehicles appear to be extremely poor drivers who simply can’t handle a larger vehicle.

I assume that’s what the poster who made the disgusting suggestion that people not driving these vehicles should ‘plan accordingly’ meant - plan for appalling driving and a disgraceful selfish attitude.

110APiccadilly · 17/07/2023 01:38

Weight's not the only factor (though if we're really all supposed to be shifting to EVs, it's worth bearing their weight in mind). For instance, modern cars are designed with crumple zones to protect both occupants and pedestrians. So in your system, would old cars have to drive slower too?

Nat6999 · 17/07/2023 01:29

My SUV weighs 1600kg, is top rated for protection in accidents, automatically slows down if an obstacle is too close to the front of the car. I was driving on to the estate I live in when a child who was no more than 3 ran out in to the road, I was able to stop well before I would have run in to him. I will admit I had a few choice words for the child's mother who strolled along without a care in the world about keeping hold of him.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:27

Isthisreasonable · 17/07/2023 01:24

Yes your car will survive a crash, but the people you hit with it won't.

And good luck to them. If I have to choose between something that keeps me safe and something that keeps other safer under certain conditions. Yeah it’s not something I’m going to spend a lot of time debating.

FFSCarrieBradshaw · 17/07/2023 01:27

'We'

'Obscene'

'Grotesque'

There's some hyperbolic language right there.

Absolute full disclosure here, I've failed my driving test five times. I'm not someone who should be allowed on the road. I'm all for accepting one's limitations.

It does allow me some non-biased observations as a non-driver though.

Some people are terrible drivers, there are some people who I refuse to be a passenger in their car.

And it's not based on how massive their car is.

I actually understand why people who are quite safe drivers would like a massive car, because there are a lot of dangerous dicks on the road.

I also see, that some of the dangerous dicks also drive massive cars.

So.

It's a bit of an arms race.

There are dicks on the road.

I can afford a massive car which is less likely to get squashed in an accident.

I will therefore drive a massive car.

Because my family, who are immediate to me, matter more than a nebulous idea of something that may or may not happen.

I get why people drive massive cars. It feels safer than driving a small tin shack on a motorway at speed.

I've seen bad driving from both.

Terrible.

And, 'great news!', I, as a seasoned passenger call the police when I see erratic or dangerous driving. Be it a Ranger Rover, a Smart car or a wagon. I see you all!

CostelloJones · 17/07/2023 01:27

Oh another anti SUV thread, how original

Isthisreasonable · 17/07/2023 01:24

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:04

My SUV rates really well in crashes. Maybe others need to factor in their cars are made out of the equivalent of aluminum foil and plan accordingly.

Yes your car will survive a crash, but the people you hit with it won't.

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 01:22

When you see the massive explosion of SUVs on the road and the massive number that are used on school runs, it looks like a worrying trend
and I wonder if ppl realise the increase risk with increase in weight has, not on the SUV driver but on anybody they might infortunately hit

I think there is too much resistance from SUVers and maybe denial

OP posts:
MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 01:17

QuestionableMouse
I am not suggesting banning everything that is dangerous etc....
I am just remarking the explosion in SUVs and their increase weight has a potential consequence; an increase risk to pedestrians if you hit them with an SUV at 30mph rather than a Ford fiesta at 30mph

OP posts:
SpinCycles · 17/07/2023 01:16

Nothing is 100% fool-proof. The world is full of risk, it cannot be eliminated.

Perhaps requiring people to retrofit that technology would be a better solution then.

Lots of people do have genuine reasons for needing larger cars. And as I said EVs are often even heavier. And quiet so more risk of not realising one is there. Vans and lorries are necessary. You can't set different speed limits for different vehicles on single lane roads. So I am not sure what you expect to happen.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:13

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 01:08

saltinesandcoffeecups
how heavy is ur aluminium vehicle?
compare the kinetic energy in a crash with a car half its weight

You misunderstood me. My car/suv isn’t aluminum. But a lot of the small cars on the road seem to be.

In other words if you buy a tiny lightweight car don’t be surprised when everything on the roads outweigh you and you have shitty prospects in a crash

Swipe left for the next trending thread