Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Impact of SUVs in a crash

293 replies

MassiveCars · 17/07/2023 00:48

Recently there was a terrible accident involving a 2 ton car
What stood out was the mention of the weight of the vehicle
So I did a couple of calcs
An SUV of 1972kg doing 30mph has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 38mph
A larger SUV of 2598kg has the same Kinetic Energy of a small car of 1221kg doing 44mph
All these large SUVs doing 30mph create the same damage as a smaller car doing 38mph to 44mph
There must be enough maths & physics teachers on here to check this out
I did think of mentioning the small car and the big car types ?

But large SUVs (=large weight) are a much more serious danger to kids at 30mph than your small cars at 30mph

There is great emphasis on 30mph, perhaps we should enforce slower speeds for heavier vehicles if safety is the objective

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
AIBot · 17/07/2023 08:08

Lower speed limits for heavier vehicles sound sensible. And maybe exclusion zones around schools for vehicles over a certain size unless it’s a delivery vehicle.

Farmers who drive SUVs for work won’t mind any of that as they are used to driving slower vehicles anyway.

AvanGelist · 17/07/2023 08:01

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/07/2023 06:16

But I don’t feel safe in a small car because of the big ones, so rather than put my family at risk I am getting a bigger car.

This is what I mean by arms race.

It's like driving position. If everyone drives a car where the driver is three feet off the ground, everyone can see. If someone chooses to be four feet off the ground they can see better but everyone else can't see any more.

Eventually everyone is driving cranes. It's ridiculous.

Exactly so the only way is to heavily discourage or control them.

Rockybooboo · 17/07/2023 08:01

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:27

And good luck to them. If I have to choose between something that keeps me safe and something that keeps other safer under certain conditions. Yeah it’s not something I’m going to spend a lot of time debating.

How bloody callous after the death of those young girls! What a vile person you are. It doesn't matter if people are killed or maimed as long as I'm alright.

Cyclistmumgrandma · 17/07/2023 08:00

SpinCycles · 17/07/2023 01:07

Ultimately accidents will sometimes happen, sad as it is. Teaching people better road safety would be good - cyclists and pedestrians as well as drivers! And as technology improves increasingly new cars have systems where they will break/ stop automatically if there is an obstacle, overriding the driver if necessary/ if they are unresponsive, which should improve things substantially once older cars without this functions are phased out.

The problem with safety systems is that they are not suitable in all situations. Our vehicles both have an "emergency lane keeping" system. (Most modern cars do.) I live rurally and it regularly mistakes the side of the lane for the edge of a lane and tries to steer the car away from the side of the road. This has the effect of trying to steer me into the path of the milk tanker or tractor coming the other way... It has to be switched off EVERY time I start the car.

Schoolchoicesucks · 17/07/2023 07:50

hattie43 · 17/07/2023 05:43

Exactly . Another day another SUV bashing . I love my SUV and when it's due for renewal I'll buy another .
I had a crash in a mini which just crumpled. I feel safe in my SUV .

The crumpling is designed in though. That's what's meant to happen - the car body crumpling absorbs the impact so the passengers don't.

Sirius3030 · 17/07/2023 07:25

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:04

My SUV rates really well in crashes. Maybe others need to factor in their cars are made out of the equivalent of aluminum foil and plan accordingly.

I think you are missing the point of the post. If you drive a tank you are going to survive. It is everyone else on the road that should be concerned.

blushpear · 17/07/2023 07:18

And there are just so, so many. I didn't think so many people felt the need to compensate.

blushpear · 17/07/2023 07:17

I wouldn't have thought it was a concern before moving to central london (westminster/victoria). With badly laid out tiny pavements (due to history) packed with commuters and tourists and these massive land/
range rovers ramming through all the other cars and crowds, yes you do feel their size and how stupidly inappropriate they are for city based people.

manontroppo · 17/07/2023 07:16

Swrigh1234 · 17/07/2023 06:40

Typical lazy thinking. Ban everything. Lucky that there are far smarter people out there in industry than the hard of thinking on this thread who invent their way out of problems.

Or we could just look at cities like Amsterdam and Ghent where they have completely deprioritised car traffic for a better experience for everyone?

It will never happen here, as evidenced by all the selfish twats bleating about their rights to drive whatever they like, wherever they want and hang the consequences.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 07:15

Porridgeislife · 17/07/2023 07:04

It’s a BMW EV so lots of bells and whistles.

I’ve never understood why people turn off the drive assist options. We also have a mk 8 Golf so VAG’s first gen attempt at driver assist and despite that, it’s never been an annoyance. People seem to be affronted that their driving is being questioned by their car!

I do a lot of miles up and down motorways and you see a lot of poor lane discipline, both keeping centred in their lane and leaving adequate space in front. The sooner drive assist is compulsory the better.

Slightly unfair of you to compare a £15k basic hatchback with your £70k SUV regarding safety, but I agree with everything you say about driver assist.

Tontostitis · 17/07/2023 07:10

I've always thought that speeding fines should be relative to car size. 35 in a 30 in an i10 slap on the wrist in a Range Rover 6points instantly.

Porridgeislife · 17/07/2023 07:04

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:47

Hard to properly evaluate without knowing the model you drive, but there are extra points awarded by Euro NCAP for things like automatic emergency braking. This might be the explanation for the better rating. Of course, it’s an optional feature that many people turn off. I assume you keep it on, which is great - but until it’s mandatory and cannot be disabled, it doesn’t supersede the dangers of size & shape.

It’s a BMW EV so lots of bells and whistles.

I’ve never understood why people turn off the drive assist options. We also have a mk 8 Golf so VAG’s first gen attempt at driver assist and despite that, it’s never been an annoyance. People seem to be affronted that their driving is being questioned by their car!

I do a lot of miles up and down motorways and you see a lot of poor lane discipline, both keeping centred in their lane and leaving adequate space in front. The sooner drive assist is compulsory the better.

Goldbar · 17/07/2023 07:04

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:04

My SUV rates really well in crashes. Maybe others need to factor in their cars are made out of the equivalent of aluminum foil and plan accordingly.

I find this comment unbelievably crass given what has just happened to those poor girls.

How should they have 'planned accordingly' for being hit by essentially a small tank?

The issue isn't just collisions with other vehicles.

Worldgonecrazy · 17/07/2023 06:51

Volvos are heavier because of their additional safety features, which include pedestrian safety features and external airbags.

Though I did once see a specialist stating if we all drove small cars with a spike in the middle of the steering wheel, road safety would dramatically improve!

Conkersinautumn · 17/07/2023 06:50

Cars are very wasteful, they take up lots of room for each largely unnecessary journey, sit around be under utilised for hours at a time. Then people frequently replace them before the end of their usable life.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:47

Porridgeislife · 17/07/2023 06:36

My SUV has a substantially better pedestrian safety (“vulnerable road users”) rating than a Fiat 500.

Hard to properly evaluate without knowing the model you drive, but there are extra points awarded by Euro NCAP for things like automatic emergency braking. This might be the explanation for the better rating. Of course, it’s an optional feature that many people turn off. I assume you keep it on, which is great - but until it’s mandatory and cannot be disabled, it doesn’t supersede the dangers of size & shape.

CalistoNoSolo · 17/07/2023 06:45

It's not the cars that are the issue, it's the drivers. And the people most likely to have/cause a fatal car accident are young men who don't tend to drive suvs. The Wimbledon accident has been widely reported because its an outlier. There are lots of 20mph limits around here in villages but as they are not enforced (bugger all police in rural areas) there is little point in them.

Swrigh1234 · 17/07/2023 06:40

Typical lazy thinking. Ban everything. Lucky that there are far smarter people out there in industry than the hard of thinking on this thread who invent their way out of problems.

sleepyscientist · 17/07/2023 06:40

You need to think about kinetic energy at the time of impact not at the speed limit. Breaking system and preventive technology can be used so by the time the SUV reaches the point of impact it's actually traveling slower than the little super mini on rubbish breaks. The Disco has a pedestrian airbag aswell which is an improvement over the super mini, I'm surprised they haven't become standard technology to be honest.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:38

hattie43 · 17/07/2023 05:43

Exactly . Another day another SUV bashing . I love my SUV and when it's due for renewal I'll buy another .
I had a crash in a mini which just crumpled. I feel safe in my SUV .

It’s supposed to crumple. That’s what takes the energy - and thus danger - out of a crash. What you want to look at is the intrusion into the passenger area. All modern cars fair really well on this.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:36

Moonmelodies · 17/07/2023 05:44

At least the modern SUVs are bristling with the latest collision avoidance tech to help avoid such tragedies.

As are their smaller, lighter, lower non-SUV counterparts.

At least very soon driver monitoring systems will be mandatory so all the god awful useless drivers will be overruled by their cars.

Porridgeislife · 17/07/2023 06:36

Isthisreasonable · 17/07/2023 01:24

Yes your car will survive a crash, but the people you hit with it won't.

My SUV has a substantially better pedestrian safety (“vulnerable road users”) rating than a Fiat 500.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:35

Moonmelodies · 17/07/2023 05:42

An impact to the legs often results in the head hitting the windscreen, which rarely ends well.

Nonsense. That’s exactly what you want in the crash. By the time the head hits the windscreen, the body should have been slowed right down by the distance travelled across the bonnet + crumple zones.

What you definitely don’t want is the soft tissue and vital organs of the torso being hit first when the crash velocity is highest. And then you definitely don’t want the person being pushed under the wheels of the car and squashed by 1-3 tons of car.

Hitting the head on the windscreen is the least worst option in a car - pedestrian collision.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:28

HelplessSoul · 17/07/2023 04:58

Funny how the OP harps on about weights of SUVs, yet says nothing about the heavier weights of EVs that need more stopping distances to counteract the batteries they carry.

For examply, my relatives new Tesla Model 3 comes in at 2.4t (2400kg) - nearly 800kg MORE than my SUV.

Go figure.

But yeah, dont let FACTs get in the way of your bullshittery. 🤦‍♂️🤷‍♂️🙄

EVs are a big problem because of weight, but they aren’t as big a problem as either fossil fuel SUVs or electric SUVs. Body shape and height also matter in terms of injury outcomes. But yeah, don’t let facts get in the way of your bullshittery.

Bingbangbongbash · 17/07/2023 06:25

saltinesandcoffeecups · 17/07/2023 01:27

And good luck to them. If I have to choose between something that keeps me safe and something that keeps other safer under certain conditions. Yeah it’s not something I’m going to spend a lot of time debating.

That isn’t the choice. There are plenty of non-SUVs that will keep you and your family safe.