Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you always ask for a doctor ?

72 replies

Karenkerr · 17/07/2023 00:46

Really really scared reading this. How can they let someone with only 2 years of experience anaesthetise people?

do you always check and make sure you’re being seen by a doctor? Think I need to start doing this…

Do you always ask for a doctor ?
OP posts:
mnitg · 17/07/2023 07:40

Yes a PP getting confused between PA's and ANP/ACP.
I guess in theory a nurse could become a PA, but would make more sense for them to go the ANP route.

ANP/ACP = clinical background, are regulated = usually good

PA = non medical background and unregulated = bad

Jigslaw · 17/07/2023 07:30

Puzzlepart · 17/07/2023 07:27

nope. As I say, I’ve worked with and know several, they are either ODP by background or nurses who have chosen to gain the physician’s assistant qualification.
The nurses also had theatre practitioner qualifications as well.
I know lots of ANPs too.

You are mistaken though, PAs changed to Physican Associates from assistances a while ago, and no they aren't nurses who have undertaken additional training; they are science grads who have done a 2 year course. ANPs are different.

Jigslaw · 17/07/2023 07:30

Puzzlepart · 17/07/2023 07:27

nope. As I say, I’ve worked with and know several, they are either ODP by background or nurses who have chosen to gain the physician’s assistant qualification.
The nurses also had theatre practitioner qualifications as well.
I know lots of ANPs too.

You are mistaken though, PAs changed to Physican Associates from assistances a while ago, and no they aren't nurses who have undertaken additional training; they are science grads who have done a 2 year course. ANPs are different.

Jigslaw · 17/07/2023 07:29

Puzzlepart · 17/07/2023 06:49

They are generally qualified to degree level in another way.
for eg, a qualified nurse with vast critical care or theatre experience, with additional qualifications in that area and then physicians assistant qualifications.
I know and have worked with a few.
They all had 10 years plus working experience within these areas, a degree, additional qualifications within their field and then gone on to do physicians assistant, so not green straight out of school.

More like 5 years plus of study and years of experience.

They are extremely highly respected, work exceedingly hard to get to where they are and are registered practitioners to begin with, with governing bodies to protect the public and themselves.

This thread is very misleading and scaremongering. Clearly no deeper investigation has gone in before posting.

You're mistaken, PAs can do a 2 year post grad straight from their sciences undergraduate degree. They don't need any previous healthcare experience and can well be straight from education, youre getting your not doctors but more or less claim to be roles mixed up. It's all good though, if you're genuinely happy for yourself or loved ones to be treated by someone with lesser qualifications, lesser on the job training, less understanding of aspects of the body that help in emergencies should something go wrong, don't have the same knowledge of medicines and how they work then that means more doctors for the rest of us.

Here the doctors wear lanyards which say DOCTOR and introduce themselves as such on first interaction with a patient.

Puzzlepart · 17/07/2023 07:27

nope. As I say, I’ve worked with and know several, they are either ODP by background or nurses who have chosen to gain the physician’s assistant qualification.
The nurses also had theatre practitioner qualifications as well.
I know lots of ANPs too.

Saschka · 17/07/2023 07:22

Puzzlepart · 17/07/2023 06:49

They are generally qualified to degree level in another way.
for eg, a qualified nurse with vast critical care or theatre experience, with additional qualifications in that area and then physicians assistant qualifications.
I know and have worked with a few.
They all had 10 years plus working experience within these areas, a degree, additional qualifications within their field and then gone on to do physicians assistant, so not green straight out of school.

More like 5 years plus of study and years of experience.

They are extremely highly respected, work exceedingly hard to get to where they are and are registered practitioners to begin with, with governing bodies to protect the public and themselves.

This thread is very misleading and scaremongering. Clearly no deeper investigation has gone in before posting.

@Puzzlepart It sounds like you are describing nurse practitioners (NPs), not physician associates (PAs) - very different training paths and capabilities.

Physician associates absolutely are not nurses - completely different professions.

knitnerd90 · 17/07/2023 06:53

It was at a specialist oral surgeon's. Here it can be given in non hospital settings. I do believe there are different rules for in office versus outpatient surgery centres though. One of my children needed dental work done under sedation, and for that he had to go to a surgery centre. That's also where another one got their tonsils and adenoids out. There's quite a push to do day surgeries out of hospital.

Oral surgeons in the US have quite a lot of additional training -- mine had an MD as well as the dental degree. That may be why they are allowed to do anaesthesia that regular dentists can't do.

Puzzlepart · 17/07/2023 06:49

They are generally qualified to degree level in another way.
for eg, a qualified nurse with vast critical care or theatre experience, with additional qualifications in that area and then physicians assistant qualifications.
I know and have worked with a few.
They all had 10 years plus working experience within these areas, a degree, additional qualifications within their field and then gone on to do physicians assistant, so not green straight out of school.

More like 5 years plus of study and years of experience.

They are extremely highly respected, work exceedingly hard to get to where they are and are registered practitioners to begin with, with governing bodies to protect the public and themselves.

This thread is very misleading and scaremongering. Clearly no deeper investigation has gone in before posting.

LadinLee · 17/07/2023 06:44

For example I had oral surgery and there was a CRNA in the office so they can offer full sedation.

@knitnerd90 was this at your dentist?
I'm in Scotland and GA for dental work can only be given in a hospital setting. It's not permitted outside hospitals due to lack of back up if things go wrong

middler · 17/07/2023 06:30

I was browsing jobs today and saw an anaesthetist role for 500k a year here in the US and recalled a doctor friend telling me they are the highest-paid docs over here because their training is so long and their job is so risky. So yes I would want a doc and they should be getting paid more in the UK by the way.

WilmaFlintstone1 · 17/07/2023 06:24

BBQlover · 17/07/2023 06:20

You can ask for someone fully qualified but what when the answer is no? Surely if using AAs is hospital policy they won't just produce an aneathetist because I say I want one. What then? Refuse surgery that I need? I just think resusing AA would get me sent home untreated. i am very worried by this and really want to know as I don't think the NHS just does what the patient demands!

From what I can gather AA are rare and always work with a consultant anaesthetist …so very very supervised. I’d probably be okay with one if there was supervision and an actual anaesthetist on hand as well.

BBQlover · 17/07/2023 06:20

You can ask for someone fully qualified but what when the answer is no? Surely if using AAs is hospital policy they won't just produce an aneathetist because I say I want one. What then? Refuse surgery that I need? I just think resusing AA would get me sent home untreated. i am very worried by this and really want to know as I don't think the NHS just does what the patient demands!

mnitg · 17/07/2023 06:18

I would like to point out that this isn't a snobbery about 'oo they're not doctors'- I have worked with some brilliant advanced nursing/clinical practitioners who are more than capable of independently assessing patients and making plans.
It's this PA route that is dangerous and unregulated.

mnitg · 17/07/2023 06:15

These 'associates' are a dangerous way of working.

'Empty ward rounds' were what we used to call them, as they didn't have the training to accurately understand what was required. On paper patients had been seen by a 'suitably qualified person' but in reality anyone can write a date, time, and 'continue current plan'

Not to mention the morale issues they cause for actual junior doctors who are being paid less despite much more training, responsibility and worse working conditions.

I would not accept care from a PA.

knitnerd90 · 17/07/2023 06:15

USA has had PAs for 50 years and Canada since the '90s. After a decade plus here I know when to ask for a doctor specifically rather than a PA or an NP. If they are used properly it's great. If they're not, well. There is a tendency here to say "provider" and try to smooth over the differences a bit. PAs can prescribe, as can NPs, but PAs always have to be under the formal supervision of a doctor whereas in many states NPs don't. The PA degree is entirely generalist and then they get experience in a particular speciality whereas NPs only ever train for one path.

the USA also has CRNAs (certified registered nurse-anaesthetists). It requires at least 3 years training past a nursing degree, either a masters or professional doctorate depending on when they trained, and is the hardest specialty for nurse practitioners as I understand it. They can't do all forms of anaesthesia and either work alongside doctors in hospital or in outpatient settings. For example I had oral surgery and there was a CRNA in the office so they can offer full sedation.

Prescottdanni123 · 17/07/2023 06:02

There was a thread on this not so long ago with an anaesthetist pretty much nagging people to ask for someone qualified

Hollyhead · 17/07/2023 05:51

I think the use of associates isn’t without its problems, but it’s 2 years post grad after a relevant undergraduate degree like biomedical science/physiology, sometimes nursing etc, so they have 2 years actual training but they shouldn’t be starting from a base of nothing.

I actually think the whole healthcare professional structure needs rethinking, there are a lot of inefficiencies in the way training takes place which in turn leads to some of the appalling conditions for junior drs etc.

Karenkerr · 17/07/2023 05:42

CoachBeardsJane · 17/07/2023 02:27

@Karenkerr you can request one 100% but I'd say your chance of encountering one is very minimal.

They should introduce themselves as not an anaesthetist because to be called an anaesthetist you need to do a lot of training (I'm simplifying here but you need to do loads of training and exams, and generally speaking all anaesthetists are consultants because of the training program in the uk)

if you do encounter one then say you're not happy to have them and you want an anaesthetist.

Genuinely though I'd be surprised if they weren't just doing clinics and planning for the surgery though and in that case you'd be seen by anaesthetist before surgery because I'd need to assess ease of access, ease of intubation, any co morbidities, any anxieties, any previous history of x y z, any family history of x y z... this would be done in clinic but best practice and frankly I don't know any clinician who doesn't check this themselves is to check again pre surgery because it's my gmc registration on the line if anything goes tits up and if any questions in clinic haven't been asked .

Don't be nervous.

Tell the clinician you are nervous and they will do their best to help and give you things to calm down

I've recently been a patient and I was an awful patient because I didn't tell them I was in pain and it got worse so don't be like me!

Thanks so much. You’ve made me feel a lot better !!

really sorry to hear you’ve not been well ☹️ wishing you a speedy recovery ❤️‍🩹

OP posts:
Medstudent12 · 17/07/2023 02:43

@CoachBeardsJane so sorry to hear that, I hope you’re getting good treatment and will be back on your feet soon. Don’t rush back to work, make sure you’re looking after yourself too x

CoachBeardsJane · 17/07/2023 02:30

@Medstudent12 that is terrifying.

I've been off work for 6 months with cancer so tbh I could be out of date already. I really wouldn't be comfortable in one looking after my patients, especially if they are like physicians assistants and they see the patients independently and draw up the drugs themselves.

It's my registration on the line at the end of the day if I'm 'mentoring' so I'd be anal and double checking everything.

PAs just make things harder in my experience as they miss things and don't realise

CoachBeardsJane · 17/07/2023 02:27

@Karenkerr you can request one 100% but I'd say your chance of encountering one is very minimal.

They should introduce themselves as not an anaesthetist because to be called an anaesthetist you need to do a lot of training (I'm simplifying here but you need to do loads of training and exams, and generally speaking all anaesthetists are consultants because of the training program in the uk)

if you do encounter one then say you're not happy to have them and you want an anaesthetist.

Genuinely though I'd be surprised if they weren't just doing clinics and planning for the surgery though and in that case you'd be seen by anaesthetist before surgery because I'd need to assess ease of access, ease of intubation, any co morbidities, any anxieties, any previous history of x y z, any family history of x y z... this would be done in clinic but best practice and frankly I don't know any clinician who doesn't check this themselves is to check again pre surgery because it's my gmc registration on the line if anything goes tits up and if any questions in clinic haven't been asked .

Don't be nervous.

Tell the clinician you are nervous and they will do their best to help and give you things to calm down

I've recently been a patient and I was an awful patient because I didn't tell them I was in pain and it got worse so don't be like me!

Medstudent12 · 17/07/2023 02:24

CoachBeardsJane · 17/07/2023 01:34

Im an anaesthetist, these are so rare it's extremely unlikely that you'll be looked after by these. I've never encountered any of them in 4/5 teaching hospitals I've worked in.

They're not common at all, and they are always constantly watched by an actual anaesthetist in pre op/ before surgery. (I have been on teaching sessions to learn about the role but I've never encountered any, it's also up to the anaesthetist as to whether they use them to assist).

I’m also a doctor (medic) and they’re becoming much more common, as are physician associates. Massive new push in the media from the govt about increasing the numbers of them.

If they’re anything like PAs on medicine they’ll push for more independence and consultants will prioritise them for opportunities over rotational “junior” doctors. They will stop wanting to do the basics and push for progression without formal training or exams. Or in the case of PAs they are not even properly regulated! It’s scary.

Medstudent12 · 17/07/2023 02:21

I’m a doctor. I find this terrifying. So do most of my colleagues. It’s the same with physician associates who are given too much free rein without the experience of a doctor. Anaesthetics is one of the most complex and difficult branches of medicine, I’m a medic not an anaesthetist and we all have tons of respect for their notoriously impossible post grad exams. AAs don’t sit post grad exams.

The govt are pushing these roles are they are cheaper than consultants. PAs and AAs get paid more than lots of doctors despite having less qualifications. Hence the striking.

Medstudent12 · 17/07/2023 02:18

Greybeardy · 17/07/2023 02:15

An awful lot of anaesthesia is delivered quite safely by non-consultant anaesthetists.

Yes by doctors who are not yet consultants or associate specialists. Not by people who don’t have a medical degree.