Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable - gift

121 replies

ThatFraggle · 16/07/2023 22:55

Not about me, but friends. Person's partner bought them a gift set for a birthday. Think of something like a 'star sign' bundle. (The bundle is bought complete, and it was not someone shopping for different things to make a bundle).

Some of the things were bath bombs etc, which say things like 'grapefruit scented for a feisty Leo' or whatever, but can of course be used by anyone, but other things are, e.g. a Leo candle, a card that says strong Leo etc.

Except - 1.
They got the date wrong somehow and it's for the wrong starsign.

And - 2.

The person receiving the gift thinks horroscopes are a load of bollocks.

The person giving the gift says that they should be grateful/thankful to have been given a gift, and they spent like £50 on it.

The recipient says that the gift shows how little they think of them, and know them so little, that they are thinking of ending things. No kids involved. A couple of years relationship.

OP posts:
TheCatsMama · 17/07/2023 10:06

If your 'friend' the 'recipient' thinks that astrology is a load of bollocks (which it is), then why is she/they/whatever all steamed up about the partner getting their 'star sign' wrong? Sounds a bit high-maintenance. If it was my partner I might just laugh, note that it was £50 worth of stuff, and maybe even think they were being ironic (which I like). Better than a bunch of flowers and a big bar of Galaxy from a petrol station. Even better still if it was a half price offer and I liked the stuff. Still, everybody's different...

Alarae · 17/07/2023 09:59

I get this. It is genuinely not about the gift itself, but the thought that is behind it.

The thought on this one isn't personalised for their partner- it sounds like they've never professed to being interested in horoscopes so it becomes generic. The fact they also got the horoscope wrong is a whole other thing, as either they knew the right one but chose the wrong one by accident (forgivable, but doesn't sound like that happened here) or they didn't put enough research into it to get the right one. So it is a bit of a lazy present.

Your friend is not remiss for feeling disappointed. Her partner's reaction is understandable as he paid out for the present- but perhaps needs a calm conversation with your friend that she can say while she appreciates receiving a gift, she is a bit upset that the thought behind it is a bit careless.

moulsated · 17/07/2023 09:57

I think after 2 years the gift buyer should have known better. My partner is a functional gift buyer, not romantic in the least but I appreciate the gifts. Hook for removing wellies, a Creuset casserole dish, a ring doorbell, a wine carafe.

ThatFraggle · 17/07/2023 09:52

KT1995 · 17/07/2023 09:49

But you have just shown yourself to be ungrateful in your post! You GAVE away a gift your H had lovingly bought you. How rude.

He "accepted what I did" Didn't have a choice did he?

Why not be honest in the first place and tell him, save him wasting his money - twice.

If you don't notice that the perfume is unused by the person you live with, then you're paying zero attention.

And relationships are all about paying attention.

OP posts:
KT1995 · 17/07/2023 09:49

Dibbydoos · 17/07/2023 02:49

We are an entitled and ungrateful lot aren't we?

Our 1st Christmas together and my DH bought me perfume the shop assistant liked, it was heavy and cloggy - I hated it. But I didn't say anything because I didnt want to hurt his feelings. When he bought a srcond bottle 🙄 even though I'd never worn it. I then told him it wasn't my type of perfume but I knew someone who'd like it. He was upset I was giving it away, but accepted what I did. Your DF could do the same with her pressie.

But you have just shown yourself to be ungrateful in your post! You GAVE away a gift your H had lovingly bought you. How rude.

He "accepted what I did" Didn't have a choice did he?

Why not be honest in the first place and tell him, save him wasting his money - twice.

WilkinsonM · 17/07/2023 07:58

If my DH had bought this for me I'd be disappointed. Firstly it sounds like a waste of money; overpriced tat which someone has curated and packaged and added £25 for the pleasure. Secondly it's the wrong star sign. I don't believe in astrology but I wouldn't mind getting a Leo themed gift, but if I got the wrong one I'd think that was quite shit. This isn't a good gift at all; but breaking up over it is crazy behaviour.

Oysterbabe · 17/07/2023 07:55

I bet he got it cheap or free and just didn't worry about the fact that the sign was wrong.

FrivolousTreeDuck · 17/07/2023 07:52

It's a disappointing gift, but if other aspects of the relationship are good, it's an overreaction to end things because of this. If it's a 'last straw' situation in a bad relationship, fair enough.

I'd say (when his birthday was coming up) 'why don't we choose presents together from now on' to avoid the same thing happening next year.

Shelby2010 · 17/07/2023 07:51

I agree with a previous poster that it is unlikely that he spent £50 on it. No one would pay that much for generic smelly stuff.

I also agree that getting the star sign wrong could be funny under some circumstances. But why on earth should she be grateful for something she doesn’t want when he clearly put no thought into it. I’d be hurt too. And his attitude would make it worse.

ThatFraggle · 17/07/2023 07:45

Applesarenice · 17/07/2023 07:32

It’s just a birthday present. I don’t get what the big deal is

It's an opportunity to show care and affection.

Fine if you don't do birthdays, but you should then be then doing 'birthday equivalent things' throughout the year: I bought this book I thought you would like; here are tickets to that comedian who made you wet yourself laughing.

OP posts:
notanotherclairebear · 17/07/2023 07:33

Dibbydoos · 17/07/2023 02:49

We are an entitled and ungrateful lot aren't we?

Our 1st Christmas together and my DH bought me perfume the shop assistant liked, it was heavy and cloggy - I hated it. But I didn't say anything because I didnt want to hurt his feelings. When he bought a srcond bottle 🙄 even though I'd never worn it. I then told him it wasn't my type of perfume but I knew someone who'd like it. He was upset I was giving it away, but accepted what I did. Your DF could do the same with her pressie.

This ☝🏼

My DH has bought some truly shit presents over the years, which makes him an arsehole according to MN shit at buying presents - no more, no less. He's still kind, and supportive, and funny, and shows that he knows me in less superficial ways than buying me perfect presents ffs.

So the partner has bought a terrible present, so what?! They've made one less-than-perfect judgement over the course of a two year relationship so the recipient should LTB?! Lunacy

Applesarenice · 17/07/2023 07:32

It’s just a birthday present. I don’t get what the big deal is

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 17/07/2023 07:16

The gift probably isn't the issue, it'll be the straw the broke the camel's back. It'll come after a couple of years of not being listened to and not being priorities.

Needmorelego · 17/07/2023 07:15

Did the set come from an American website where the dates are the wrong way around.
Date of birth (for example) January 8th…
In English 8.1
In American 1.8
So you would get the wrong Starsign if you typed the date in.
Personally if their relationship is good in general this is something to laugh about.

Weregoingthroughchanges · 17/07/2023 07:07

If there are no other relationship issues then I think it a bit much to end the relationship over, but it might be the straw that broke the Camel’s back 🤷🏻‍♀️

Aprilx · 17/07/2023 07:04

I generally am not that fussed over presents, DH and I don’t bother much any more but I generally think it is the thought that counts. But I have to say, this does seem particularly crap and I would not be pleased if my husband could not remember the date of my birthday or my star sign (even though neither of us are particularly interested in horoscopes). So the buyer has been a bit rubbish here.

ThatFraggle · 17/07/2023 06:56

Dibbydoos · 17/07/2023 02:49

We are an entitled and ungrateful lot aren't we?

Our 1st Christmas together and my DH bought me perfume the shop assistant liked, it was heavy and cloggy - I hated it. But I didn't say anything because I didnt want to hurt his feelings. When he bought a srcond bottle 🙄 even though I'd never worn it. I then told him it wasn't my type of perfume but I knew someone who'd like it. He was upset I was giving it away, but accepted what I did. Your DF could do the same with her pressie.

even though I'd never worn it.

That's where the laziness shows. He doesn't care to notice his gift was unopened, and has now become 'your gift'.

OP posts:
Shoxfordian · 17/07/2023 06:06

It’s quite a thoughtless present, I wouldn’t be impressed with this either

hattie43 · 17/07/2023 05:58

It's a shit gift .
The moral of the story is always give men a steer at gift buying .

PickledPurplePickle · 17/07/2023 04:48

rwalker · 16/07/2023 23:00

They took the time to get a gift they got the star sign wrong surely they got the date right as they gave them a gift on there birthday

I’d find it funny but by the sounds of it things aren’t great so they will be looking for anything to find fault and have a go

This

DreamTheMoors · 17/07/2023 02:53

My ex always got me the worst gifts. Once he got me a paperback book for my birthday.
I mean, from the market. In the bag. With the receipt. No thought, no care, nothing.

So he suggested that I choose my gifts and he’d get them.

He didn’t put any more thought or care into them but I got the best gifts after that.

Dibbydoos · 17/07/2023 02:49

We are an entitled and ungrateful lot aren't we?

Our 1st Christmas together and my DH bought me perfume the shop assistant liked, it was heavy and cloggy - I hated it. But I didn't say anything because I didnt want to hurt his feelings. When he bought a srcond bottle 🙄 even though I'd never worn it. I then told him it wasn't my type of perfume but I knew someone who'd like it. He was upset I was giving it away, but accepted what I did. Your DF could do the same with her pressie.

ImNotReallySpartacus · 17/07/2023 02:46

I could overlook the rubbish gift more easily than being told I should be grateful for it.

Winter2020 · 17/07/2023 02:35

I wouldn't determine how I felt about a relationship from one birthday gift.

This in the context of a bad relationship = bad. In the context of a good relationship = no big deal.

toffeeappleglow · 17/07/2023 02:30

I don't think I'd end a relationship over a gift of that sort, though it would annoy me that he spent so much on crap he should have known I wouldn't like (and wasn't bright enough to even get the right sign). If this is the tip of the iceberg and he's lacking in other ways, however, it's not really about the gift.

Maybe they're just not right for each other. He may not care as much about gifts as she does and feel that she's being demanding and overly critical. Not everyone is good at gifts, and that doesn't necessarily mean they don't care and can't be good partners in most other ways.