Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or should I refuse to put up with my neighbour’s husband’s aggressive behaviour triggered by our house repairs?

39 replies

workingtowards · 16/07/2023 21:17

We are from London, but four years ago bought a property in Suffolk to be closer to my husband’s family who live here. Being ‘London wankers’ as the locals affectionately say, we were expecting some antagonism, but instead of that, we have found people kind, welcoming and have made some really good friends. We are really happy here.

However, our house had been neglected for several years. The woodwork on the roof needed repairing and there was a party wall that was falling down.

Our problem is with the husband nextdoor, whose drive runs alongside our house. His wife is lovely and I talked to her about the situation saying that we might need access to their drive to fix our roof at a later date. I asked if they would like to talk to the builders when they came to work on a (separate) job.

She said yes, but on the day, rather that her coming out, her husband came. His face was puce and his fists were balled up in anger. I am only 5ft 1, but luckily had the builders with me. He was so angry, he was walking in circles and gesticulating and not really making any sense. I eventually managed to stem his flow of fury to explain that we didn’t even know yet if the work needed to be done, we just wanted to let him know what might need to happen. We did receive an apology by text later, saying that he had misunderstood what was going on.

Roll on to this week, and the repair of the party wall. We are paying for it all, as he made it clear that he would not contribute, despite it being joint responsibility according to the deeds. To be honest, I am willing to accept that, as we are paying an amazing local guy who builds flint walls. It will be slow and expensive, but we will end with something we are proud of.

I set up a group what’s app with him and his wife and showed them plans and told them who the builders were. We took them round our garden, explained everything and adjusted plans to accommodate his wishes (low at the back, so the sun hits his veg patch). Fundamentally, I bent over backwards for him, despite them not paying towards it. They agreed access via their side (we are semi attached on the other side).

So, first day of building, he went absolutely beserk, haranguing the builders. (The trigger was his wife allowing the builders to park on their drive) I had 2 hours of incoherent angry text messages and photos when he got back from work, despite immediately dealing with any issue he raised. The photos literally just show the wall being taken down and a couple of stray leaves and rocks.

So, the builders no longer access from his side, just because of his temper, and I am bracing myself to face his red faced fury when I get back.

My gut instinct is to just draw a line and say that I am not willing to be spoken to in this way. Do I need to keep trying to engage with him and put up with his abuse? He is so aggressive, I worry for his wife.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Canisaysomething · 24/07/2023 23:31

If this wall straddles the boundary then it's a "party fence wall" and you need to have issued a party wall notice for works which grants you access to his land to maintain it. If it's your own wall entirely on your land then you don't have the same access rights. You need some proper advice from a party wall surveyor asap before this escalates because if it's a "party fence wall" and you haven't issued the notice your neighbour can legally put a stop on the work.

Xiaoxiong · 24/07/2023 23:11

If you are trying to build up evidence to show the police or get an injunction, you have to warn him off every time and for the police to do anything you have to show that you're afraid he's going to cause damage. If you just go and say "my neighbour's been in my garden 15 times" they'll say "and what happened when you asked him not to?"

I'd be sending him the picture immediately and saying please don't enter my garden or touch the wall that my builders are repairing. If it happens again you'll be hearing from our lawyers and liable for any damage to the wall.

Then if he does it again you warn him off again and again and he can't say that he thought you wouldn't mind, that he was invited, that he wasn't aware his presence was unwanted etc. And after it's happened a few times, solicitor letter and police to warn him (if afraid he will damage the wall), and potentially a fine.

YesitsBess · 24/07/2023 23:10

workingtowards · 24/07/2023 22:58

My reply technology seems to be failing me. That first response was to YesitsBess and the second to Katsuyum. Thank you both. X

My pleasure. Offer stands. I'll dig out my red wellingtons and fishing rod.

I would offer you serious advice but loads of people have done that so I'll stick with semi-aggresive weirdness 🙂

Zepherine · 24/07/2023 23:10

workingtowards · 16/07/2023 22:46

Just to share the pain of what he has had to put up with. Here is one of the photos he sent us to complain (bearing in mind a whole wall had been removed).

I would have replied with a laughing emoji if he’d sent me that!

workingtowards · 24/07/2023 22:58

My reply technology seems to be failing me. That first response was to YesitsBess and the second to Katsuyum. Thank you both. X

OP posts:
workingtowards · 24/07/2023 22:52

I think that you are right about not tolerating his behaviour and that if we do he will think it’s ok.

OP posts:
workingtowards · 24/07/2023 22:50

Ah bless you! That has made me laugh for the first time in ages. 🤣

OP posts:
YesitsBess · 24/07/2023 22:41

Do you want me to come and sit in your garden like a malevolent gnome and glare at him? Because I am bored and I will. 😎

KatsuYum · 24/07/2023 22:31

Evidencing everything is the way to go but just consider at what point to intervene. Right now he will continue to do this as there is zero consequence to his actions and it’s kind of like you are allowing it by not addressing it as and when it happens. He may then claim “he thought it was ok as I always went in their garden to check stuff previously and there was no issue”.

I would like think quite soon a cease and desist type letter might be appropriate?

workingtowards · 24/07/2023 21:07

SmirnoffIceIsNice · 24/07/2023 20:59

Well done OP for being prepared to stand up to this man and not be intimidated. Please tell me you're going to notify him that you have evidence of him trespassing in your garden and he is not to enter your property or touch your wall ( your wall now you're paying for it) again.

He sounds like a nightmare. Hate to think what his wife must have to put up with.

Thank you Smirnoff. I am trying to sound confident, as I hate bullies, but a bit of back-up means a lot. xx

OP posts:
workingtowards · 24/07/2023 21:01

My feeling is to keep my tinder dry. If I just confront him with the photos, he will be more aggressive and obstructive and we still have a damp wall caused by his over-high drive to fix. I have asked the builders to let me know if there is any damage though and if so, I will have no choice but to proceed to legal action.

I have kept a diary of his behaiour to date and screen shot the conversations between us and the poor builders who have had to deal with him over the past two weeks. We have others who have witnessed his earlier behaviour too and now the photos of him trespassing. I am trying to build up enough evidence to show the local police officers that this isn't just a neighbours' spat. The problem is that he is well-established in the neighbourhood, so I think he feels he is untouchable.

OP posts:
SmirnoffIceIsNice · 24/07/2023 20:59

Well done OP for being prepared to stand up to this man and not be intimidated. Please tell me you're going to notify him that you have evidence of him trespassing in your garden and he is not to enter your property or touch your wall ( your wall now you're paying for it) again.

He sounds like a nightmare. Hate to think what his wife must have to put up with.

SchoolShenanigans · 24/07/2023 20:54

workingtowards · 24/07/2023 20:39

Update: our builders no longer use our neighbour’s driveway for access because of his aggression. He then got angry because they weren’t using his driveway (what?!). Our friends have now sent us photos of him trespassing in our garden and interfering with the wall. Unbelievable behaviour.

"is this you neighbour? Please can we ask that you ask permission before entering our garden. We have done nothing wrong in getting the wall fixed. We have paid the full cost and have tried to be as fair as possible when it comes to designs and the building work.

We will not be intimidated by your behaviour. If you continue to trespass and send petty messages, we will have to get the police involved. We want to remain civil, please don't make that difficult for us."

MXVIT · 24/07/2023 20:46

Time for the police I think!!

workingtowards · 24/07/2023 20:39

Update: our builders no longer use our neighbour’s driveway for access because of his aggression. He then got angry because they weren’t using his driveway (what?!). Our friends have now sent us photos of him trespassing in our garden and interfering with the wall. Unbelievable behaviour.

Or should I refuse to put up with my neighbour’s husband’s aggressive behaviour triggered by our house repairs?
OP posts:
Annaishere · 18/07/2023 00:09

I’m not doing anything I’m just living a normal life and I don’t even have young children or pets

beethecrackon24995 · 18/07/2023 00:07

annaishere your post screamed nightmare neighbour to me. Completely oblivious as to the impact of your behaviour on poor unsuspecting neighbours. I'd be moving if I lived beneath you that's for sure

msbevvy · 17/07/2023 23:23

Annaishere · 16/07/2023 21:35

I have a mental downstairs neighbour. He wanted me to walk quieter. I have young nieces and nephews in very occasionally and they run around. I ended up telling him that is just what it sounds like when you live in flats and he went crazy screaming and running off in a big tantrum. The next time he came to my door I told him straight off in no uncertain terms to ever come back. He never has although still bangs the ceiling aggressively and shouts if I slam a door etc. Some people just believe the world revolves around them and you can’t reason with people like that. Certainly not if they are aggressive

It is not necessarily what it sounds like when you live in flats. We lived in ours in peace for 20 years until new people moved in upstairs.

They installed wooden flooring and walked around in shoes. The noise in our flat was horrendous. It was 10x worse when kids were running round. They woke me up in the middle of the night with their footsteps and I became seriously sleep deprived.

Maybe your neighbour is at the end of his tether and was exasperated by your unsympathetic position
.

KatsuYum · 17/07/2023 23:08

workingtowards · 16/07/2023 22:46

Just to share the pain of what he has had to put up with. Here is one of the photos he sent us to complain (bearing in mind a whole wall had been removed).

Tell me you replied “sorry, can’t see what I’m looking at here. is it Timmy Mallet’s sunglasses?”

Codlingmoths · 16/07/2023 23:22

I would go over and tell them both clearly that you are putting up cameras and if he keeps aggressively shouting you will call the police, you don’t have to put with abuse in your own home from people who lived with an unsafe wall and aren’t even paying to fix it. I’d probably add and if you’d gotten off your bum and fixed it before we moved in you wouldn’t have to deal with us fixing it so go have a look in the mirror and say I chose to not fix it so my neighbours have to now, if I’d gotten off my bum anytime in the past 3 years I wouldn’t have my neighbours fixing it now. I will also call the police on you if you are abusing my builders, they do not deserve to have to put up with that at work. I bet when you get to work nobody comes up into your face and yells at you, don’t do it to my builders.

and order cameras stat and call the police if he does. No negotiating and trying to be nice here.

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 16/07/2023 23:16

Annaishere · 16/07/2023 21:35

I have a mental downstairs neighbour. He wanted me to walk quieter. I have young nieces and nephews in very occasionally and they run around. I ended up telling him that is just what it sounds like when you live in flats and he went crazy screaming and running off in a big tantrum. The next time he came to my door I told him straight off in no uncertain terms to ever come back. He never has although still bangs the ceiling aggressively and shouts if I slam a door etc. Some people just believe the world revolves around them and you can’t reason with people like that. Certainly not if they are aggressive

What does noisy children running round have to do with the OP's situation?

You should stop with the ablist language as well.

Nodeepdiving · 16/07/2023 23:14

Save every message he sends you and keep dated notes of everything he does. Do not be bullied and intimidated into thinking that you're in the wrong, just because he is upset. That's what he's relying on/ hoping for. Remain factual and firm but polite.

We were bullied by our downstairs neighbour for daring to be a family in an upstairs flat. Of course there is noise but we're not actually breaking any rules, let alone laws. She just had a complete hissy fit about it and would slam the doors as soon as our toddler cried, even if we'd been out all day and it was the first time he cried. It was awful, but we always remained polite to her. One day, she tipped me over the edge and I told her we do not respond to bullying and intimidation tactics. Of course she threw her toys out of the pram, I was so rude and she was surely allowed to close her doors, which were sticky, in her own house, why didn't I focus on my child, who was clearly unhappy (not the first time she had a go at him) yada yada yada. I told her we'd be complaining to the council if she carried on bullying us and, lo and behold, she suddenly packed it all in. This was a few years ago and she is nice as pie to us now. Pity I'll never be able to forgive her for insulting my children I've kept every single message the bitch sent me

StaunchMomma · 16/07/2023 23:02

I think you need to make it clear that you won't engage with him any longer.

It sounds like the wife is reasonable so maybe message her and point out that you have been very fair, discussed all plans, changed plans to what they wanted, agreed to pay for all of the work even though it's a jointly owned wall etc but that her husband's behaviour is not acceptable and you will not be tolerating it any longer.

You're going to have to stand up for yourselves here, I think. Definitely start writing down everything that happens and save all of his messages in case you have to get the Police involved further down the road.

catscalledbeanz · 16/07/2023 22:58

The problem is you can't reason nor argue with crazy. And based on his incoherent shouting and messages as well as that photo- he's full crazy. I'd go for as much distance as possible with all communication written only.

adhdpunchbag · 16/07/2023 22:55

What @JennyForeigner says. And if the builders can't have access to his side how are they expected to do a nice job of building and pointing the flint wall as they'll be working overhand l... what a shame it'll look crap on his side...

Swipe left for the next trending thread