Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My mother keeps shaming my DS, AIBU?

87 replies

madamdoodle · 16/07/2023 20:51

Sorry for the incredibly long post.

Basically, as the title says- my mother keeps shaming my DS and we’ve fallen out after I brought this to her attention. AIBU?

She generally has a very good relationship with my 3yo DS and has looked after him once a week since last Christmas and he loves her to bits. The only thing is is that she regularly shames him.. examples being she has held him in front of a mirror when he was crying as a 1yo and said “look how ugly you are when you cry” or when he has thrown a toy at her dog, instead of talking to him about unacceptable behaviour she will say things like “that was weird. You’re really weird” in a really bitchy tone or call him “uncool”.

I brought this to her attention as kindly as possible when out for coffee explaining that I thought shaming was a learned safety mechanism also used by my grandmother and my mother was doing it subconsciously without malice- she said that if she was damaging him so badly she wouldn’t ever look after him again and left. We’ve had a brief text since and she said that I have been very clear about how I thought she was a bad mother and so it’s very painful that I was also calling her a bad grandmother.

She was not a good mother to me or my siblings- had children by accident v young at the start of a v promising future. She’s professionally brilliant and was always very driven and didn’t want her children to get in the way of that. My father would beat us with a wooden spoon when we were little, we had 7 different nannies over the years and she went to work in another city 4 days a week when I was 12. They would party all weekend taking class As for days which I got into at a young age because of them and because I was struggling with childhood sexual abuse- i would take drugs with my parents from the age of about 15. I got expelled from school at 16 and went off the rails. My parents set no boundaries and I would often be out of contact for weeks on end which wouldn’t bother them.

Even with such terrible modelling she was always very disappointed that we didn’t excel at anything and would always criticise and shame us which left me furious at how she could behave so badly yet try and make us feel so terrible. I’ve always been angry at her and she’s always felt that I was a horrible DD- when I’ve tried to talk to her about my childhood, she’d blow into a emotional hailstorm and lock herself in her room or call me a little bitch saying that “other people had it much worse and you weren’t burnt with cigarettes!”

Fast forward a few years and she’s cleaned up her act and is now an activist and for the most part doesn’t party anymore. I have spent many years in therapy sorting my life out and getting to a good place and always tried to maintain a relationship with my family. My DS doesn’t really have a relationship with my DF as he’s uninterested in DCs and my MIL is dead so I want to nurture this relationship but I can’t let history repeat itself with her shaming my DS.

AIBU for calling her out on this as my DF says I am. Am I letting my own childhood and subsequent anger get in the way of their otherwise lovely relationship?

OP posts:
allthewaytobeanotown · 16/07/2023 22:41

Read this paragraph that you wrote over and over and over again until it sinks in, OP:

"She generally has a very good relationship with my 3yo DS and has looked after him once a week since last Christmas and he loves her to bits. The only thing is is that she regularly shames him"

Don't be your mother. You're a better parent than that.

Schoolchoicesucks · 16/07/2023 22:38

Missing out on having a grandmother in a child's life is far far less harmful to them than having an emotionally damaging one involved in their lives.

It sounds as though you have done amazingly well to overcome your childhood and to break the cycle for your DC. Do not let your wish to have healed and have wider family involvement risk this. If you have found therapy helpful in the past then I think you would benefit from exploring why you have been so keen to build the relationship between your mother and your DC and why you are questioning yourself now that you see the issues with the way your mother behaves with your DC.

Boomboom22 · 16/07/2023 22:34

She's not and can't be that person sadly. If you want any relationship maybe you must lower your expectations as she can't be a good mother and grandmother. It sucks. Better for your ds that you parent as you wish you had been and hopefully help heal a bit.

Oioicaptain · 16/07/2023 22:32

I have similar issues with my mother. I do stick up for my kids. She tries to push their buttons when they are overtired, upset, stroppy/having a tantrum etc. She accuses me of 'pandering to them' when I intervene and tell her not to provoke the situation further. She cannot stand to be, what she sees as being, 'disrespected' by me for calling her out on her behaviour. She is a very defensive and reactive person. I see that she was raised in a very similar way. She used to drink heavily and my sister is currently an alcoholic with end stage liver failure. She didn't do the best job of nurturing us, particularly in our teenage years. She tried, but for various reasons was unable to as was not coping with my father's infidelity, losing the family home and his sudden death. She obviously feels a lot of guilt, hence why she's so defensive. However, she criticises me for standing up for my children. I do pick them up on their behaviour, but I am certainly not going to push them when they're going into meltdown mode. They are extremely well behaved incredible children, who occasionally get upset/difficult when very overtired. I know that she adores them and generally they have a very good relationship with her. But I will always pick her up on her behaviour, whether in front of the children or not. The children have a great sense of justice so can see when she's acting unfairly and they will stick up for themselves too/stand their ground. I know that I'm doing a great job of parenting and have done all I can to break the cycle. Unfortunately she is unable to change the way that she acts. She often goes away and clearly thinks about it/reflects on it. But rarely is she able to bring herself to apologize.

AIBot · 16/07/2023 22:30

You have the perfect opportunity to distance yourself. There is no need to cut yourself off entirely from her unless you want to. You are in control as your DS’s mum.

Jongleterre · 16/07/2023 22:26

Activist?

In other words a selfish individual wanting to impose her beliefs on others by force.

Horrible, toxic woman.

Buninthecorner · 16/07/2023 22:24

From one unloved daughter to another - please break this cycle of abuse. Your mother is toxic and vile. My mum is too. I limit contact between her and my DS. I haven't gone no contact but I've definitely disengaged from the drama and the bullying. She lost interest when I stood up to her a few times. Just mainly blanks me and never calls or responds to messages. I keep in touch because of my DF. It is tough, but you recognise this isn't right.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 16/07/2023 22:21

Your DM is evil and sadistic
She was abusive to you as a child and she's repeating it with your DS
Why would you want to nurture their relationship just because she's a biological GM
If you're trying to gain her approval please don't as you never will
What do you gain from having her in your life?
Protect your DS at all costs and also protect your heart and mind

BeagleMum1 · 16/07/2023 22:20

Floppyelf · 16/07/2023 21:07

Also because you were neglected at such a vulnerable age, a part of you will always seek maternal familiarity or parental familiarity. You should remember that you already have someone amazing in your life…. You. You survived and broke the cycle. You don’t need anyone’s approval and save your DS as well.

This.

Medusaismyhero · 16/07/2023 22:18

Why on earth would you leave your toddler with a woman who allowed you to be physically and sexually abused, neglected you, took class A drugs in your presence and has generally been a horrific parent? Catch a grip OP. Some family relationships are better dead and buried. Nothing good can come of her having access to your DS.

billy1966 · 16/07/2023 22:17

Delighted to read you are moving away.

I wouldn't allow her mind a cat, not to mind a precious child.

You poor woman.

Your childhood sounds horrific.

sentinent · 16/07/2023 22:09

*does

sentinent · 16/07/2023 22:09

It's difficult to accept that your DS will not have the relationship you hoped for with your mum. If he owes, the cycle will not be broken.

thaegumathteth · 16/07/2023 22:06

Honestly don't understand why she's ever had unsupervised contact with your ds. This can be an ideal reason to stop that. I know it must hurt but don't pass down the trauma.

madamdoodle · 16/07/2023 22:06

Thanks for your responses although painful to read most of them. I was hoping she was different now and would have a different relationship to the one we had… I wanted something better for him but I have stopped the regular childcare and am actually moving away so she won’t be seeing us as much. It makes me really sad to think we’re all missing out on having a mother/grandmother in our lives but you’re right I probably need to process this more in therapy.

OP posts:
pimplesquisher · 16/07/2023 22:01

Why are you letting her look after him??

Marshmar · 16/07/2023 22:00

I would drop my hours at work or pay anything but leave your poor child with your mum. You don't even know what happens when you are not present.

She sounds terrible and there has been no change. RUN and take your child with you!

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 16/07/2023 21:59

Your relationship with your mum only goes well when things go her way. When you do things she likes when you talk about things she seems worthy.
You have to tiptoe around her otherwise she isn't interested or explodes.

Fuck that.

Don't nurture this.

Startyabastard · 16/07/2023 21:59

I have a very dysfunctional mother that abused me. An author called Peg Streep writes books on this very thing and they are very good.
I never knew anyone else had this problem growing up because people used to ask me if I was sure or not and my dad used to pretend it wasn't happening.
If I had a child (I'm too damaged to do so), then I wouldnt let them near her.
People can change but it has to be on their own terms and it is generally quite rare.

10HailMarys · 16/07/2023 21:59

Neither your DS or you should be anywhere near your parents. They’re vile and abusive.

FlowersInTheSky · 16/07/2023 21:57

There is absolutely no way this woman should be anywhere near your child. I can’t believe she did that to him when he was 1 and two years later she has him regularly unsupervised.

What are you thinking?

WandaWonder · 16/07/2023 21:55

So you are repeating issues by using her as a baby sitter?

DeeLasVegas · 16/07/2023 21:55

So after being raised by a bloody awful mother you thought it was a good idea to let her around your DS?

Remember - circumstances change, people don’t!!

continentallentil · 16/07/2023 21:54

She sounds cracked.

Fond alternative childcare. By all means let her see him but supervised with very short bursts alone.

Tell her clearly what’s acceptable and what isn’t, and tell him the same in age appropriate language, and keep an eye on it.

Hibiscrubbed · 16/07/2023 21:52

She really damaged you. Don’t let her damage him.