Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fuming with lifeguard/safe guarding officer at gym

380 replies

Dinoswearunderpants · 16/07/2023 19:24

I'm beyond livid and just wondering if I should see things from a different point of view.

My DS is 2 and has been taking swimming lessons since 8 weeks old at our local gym.

I take him swimming 2-3 times a week as he loves the water. It's a great activity for him.

He swims without arm bands for a short distance 3-5 meters then holds onto me or the side of the pool.

He loves swimming, extremely confident and understands the safety in the water i.e never goes to the water without an adult, holds onto the side or adult when in the water.

I took him today and was approached by a lifeguard (who also said she's the safe guarding officer) I've never seen before who said she was 'deeply concerned' about him swimming and him drinking too much water.

I explained we take lessons here and he is holding his breath for the 3-5 meters he's swimming. He wasn't coughing or in any distress.

He would jump in from the side, swim to me, I'd hold him an explain he needs to wait a moment (so he can catch his breath) then he'd swim to the side and jump back in. All this done on his own accord and a big smile on his face.

I asked the lady to speak with his swim instructor, who was there at the time. She said she'd spoken to another lifeguard who had concerns.

Both lifeguards don't have kids and are in their early 20s.

I explained what happened to the swim instructor and her words were 'I'm disgusted they said something, I'm so sorry'.

I appreciate not many 2 years can swim however he can as I've always wanted to ensure he's safe in the water.

I think I'm going to raise a complaint as they say no evidence of distress. My son wasn't coughing or anything. He was having a great time as he usually does.

It makes me not want to take him there any more but I'm still tied into a contract with them.

OP posts:
WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 20:58

LAMPS1 · 16/07/2023 20:57

What exactly was the outcome of your dialogue with them after they said they were deeply concerned? How did the conversation end ?
I’m asking as something must have been said by the life guard /safe guarding officer for such a strong reaction from you as to not want to go again when your baby son clearly loves his sessions in the water.
Did she argue her point and not accept your explanation that you felt he was safe as he was smiling and hadn’t swallowed water or choking ? Was she intimidating ?
If you have back-up from the swim instructor, I think you should discuss the exact concerns with her and take it from there. It would be sad to stop going If your little one enjoys it and you are always there to keep him safe.

She said she was disgusted in the colleagues opinion 🤥 and then everyone clapped

kierenthecommunity · 16/07/2023 20:57

I'm beyond livid and just wondering if I should see things from a different point of view.

Or not 🤣

LAMPS1 · 16/07/2023 20:57

What exactly was the outcome of your dialogue with them after they said they were deeply concerned? How did the conversation end ?
I’m asking as something must have been said by the life guard /safe guarding officer for such a strong reaction from you as to not want to go again when your baby son clearly loves his sessions in the water.
Did she argue her point and not accept your explanation that you felt he was safe as he was smiling and hadn’t swallowed water or choking ? Was she intimidating ?
If you have back-up from the swim instructor, I think you should discuss the exact concerns with her and take it from there. It would be sad to stop going If your little one enjoys it and you are always there to keep him safe.

Titfortat78 · 16/07/2023 20:55

CurlewKate · 16/07/2023 20:44

I have a real issue with this "water safety" thing- not in this context in particular but in general. Being able to swim a little in a warm swimming pool is very little help in most dangerous situations when the water is cold and you have clothes on and you fall in unexpectedly. People thinking swimming a little will help here are very wrong and might even take more risks that they would
with a complete non swimmer.

They learn the basics first before being able to actually swim which is being able get to the surface and to float. Which are important life skills and why swimming instructors tell parents to dunk they’re child under water. When doing water sports in open water life jackets have to be worn anyway. You would be very silly not to wear one. They also do safe swim with children in open water.

NadjaCravensworth1 · 16/07/2023 20:55

Thank you for providing a valid response. I will take onboard what you've said. Finally some decent response without being bitchy.

You mean 'finally someone has said what I want to hear'

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 20:55

Are you a qualified life guard OP? The woman was doing her job. Agree with commenters re ageism

And for what its worth I do not believe for one second the woman said she was disgusted in her colleague. Nope. Not a chance.

Going by your conduct on here I imagine the two of them were very much in support of one another and pleased to see you leave.

Starlightstarbright2 · 16/07/2023 20:52

AmITooOldToDoThis · 16/07/2023 19:35

Isn’t there a risk of secondary drowning?

This is what I assumed they are concerned about .. they are safeguarding - many reports will be made if you have a clumsy child .

my D’s did water babies so did learn to swim under the water but I would never have been offended someone questions this

Thosepeskyseagulls · 16/07/2023 20:51

I’d much rather they are over cautious and annoy parents by checking on non-emergencies than be negligent and let a child drown. Let it go.

Instawars · 16/07/2023 20:51

id much rather that they raised things when they were concerned rather than just ignored them. I think they’ve done a good job

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 16/07/2023 20:49

Blimey, over reaction much? How was she to know he had swimming lessons and you were doing something he could handle? Maybe with kids that age they’re ok for a bit and then sink like a stone after getting tired and she wanted to make sure everyone was safe and knew what they were doing. It probably takes courage to approach parents and check so please don’t complain. Because next time it might cause her to not check and there might be a bad outcome

FOJN · 16/07/2023 20:48

It sounds like they were doing their job. I think you feel your parenting choice are being judged and that's why you want to complain. If you are confident in the choices you have made then just be happy that they are conscientious about doing their jobs.

Sallyh87 · 16/07/2023 20:48

I think what your son can do at his age is very impressive. I was a lifeguard in a previous life and grew up in a seaside community so very familiar with the water.

They raised a concern you explained all fine. I think YABU to complain. They are doing their job and as I said it is objectively unusual and potentially dangerous if your son didn’t have advanced abilities at swimming for his age.

I think you just need to realise they had his best interests at heart and be glad you go to a pool with vigilant lifeguards!

waldpbal · 16/07/2023 20:47

Thanks OP, the responses on this thread have given me a good laugh.

JenWillsiam · 16/07/2023 20:47

Hold his breath and going along under water isn’t swimming.

wirehearts · 16/07/2023 20:47

This. He doesn’t look competent to them - thus looking like he could be drinking too much water. They did the right thing.

Lessons here don’t encourage distance at the expense of technique, they learn good technique first.

kierenthecommunity · 16/07/2023 20:46

Like bollocks did the swimming teacher say that 🤣

Our local David Lloyd had a terrible tragedy about four years ago where a small boy drowned as staff took their eye off the ball. I’d far rather have overly concerned life guards any day of the week.

They weren’t to know your child is exceptionally talented are they?

WandaWonder · 16/07/2023 20:46

Complain about someone doing their job? Are you seriously asking?

Titfortat78 · 16/07/2023 20:46

deveronvalley · 16/07/2023 20:26

When my son was 7 I got told off by a lifeguard for allowing him to swim off to the deep end by himself as all under 8s must be accompanied. He had finished all the swimming lesson levels and was about to try out for the club and was a far better swimmer than me. I couldn’t keep up with him so was really embarrassed and we left (son moaning!). Another time aged about 5 he got ‘rescued’ - he was practicing treading water and the lifeguard thought he was struggling while I just ignored it! It’s really hard for lifeguards- I’m pleased they err on the side of caution even though it’s made me feel like a tw@t a few times! They can only go by what their eyes tell them.

My daughter used to when she went with her support worker. She could swim and they knew that. The staff knew her SW as she has worked as a lifeguard and teaching children to swim. But because she has a disability has to stay in the shallow end. Which she found boring so she would jump in the deep end so she could tread water and laughed when a lifeguard jumped in to get her out. 😂😂😂

CurlewKate · 16/07/2023 20:44

I have a real issue with this "water safety" thing- not in this context in particular but in general. Being able to swim a little in a warm swimming pool is very little help in most dangerous situations when the water is cold and you have clothes on and you fall in unexpectedly. People thinking swimming a little will help here are very wrong and might even take more risks that they would
with a complete non swimmer.

Efficaciou5 · 16/07/2023 20:44

Fuming and beyond livid ?

I think your post probably somewhat backfired as you wanted everyone to respond in awe as to how amazing your DS is for being able to swim a few metres unaided.

You're in for a rocky road.

EVHead · 16/07/2023 20:43

Don’t be a twat.

wholivesondrurylane · 16/07/2023 20:43

SweetSakura · 16/07/2023 20:37

Especially if his teacher doesn't have kids yet Hmm

😂😂

countdowntonap · 16/07/2023 20:42

I’d got my mile badge by age 6, and was - of course - a lifeguard for my first job whilst at college and university. My council run swimming baths took safeguarding VERY seriously and we were frequently reminded of the legal consequences of negligence. Young lifeguards are often very good swimmers - and not underestimating your child’s ability as they were THAT child themselves.

BunnyBettChetwynd · 16/07/2023 20:40

KatsuYum · 16/07/2023 20:33

Can we all just be clear that a child holding their breath for 3-5 metres is not ‘swimming’.

It’s great a young child is confident in the water and comfortable putting their face in / doing a few strokes but taking a big breath, launching and then needing to hold on to someone whilst they catch their breath is most definitely not ‘swimming’. It would be far safer to get a noodle on them and teach proper technique.

I came on to say exactly this. Unless the little lad learns to breathe or swim his ability to be safe in the water will be limited to a pool the distance he is able to hold his breath, i.e. slightly less than 5 metres.