Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband has walked out

217 replies

changingmyname143 · 16/07/2023 18:14

Half way through me making dinner. We have been having problems for a while - mostly about (my) overbearing mother. I am trying to hold it together for the children. He works away a lot so "daddy's gone to work" is a feasible line for them. I am just numb and in shock. There's no AIBU here I've just seen similar things posted with people sending virtual hugs. Which I need. I can't call any of my friends til the children are asleep because it's all I can do to hold together

OP posts:
formulaonecar · 17/07/2023 07:43

User1789 · 17/07/2023 07:10

It is really, really interesting to me (and slightly enraging) that so many people have completely failed to engage with the reason OP has given that her husband has given for walking out: his MIL.

It seems the only legitimate reason for ending a marriage on here is a man with an 'other woman'. Then it is pages and pages of 'don't do the pick me dance,' 'do the freedom programme' etc, but it is quite gobsmacking how many on here find the idea that somebody would end a marriage over interfering in laws odd. It is a very myopic view, and one that seems a little detached from reality.

I agree. If the OP was a man and his wife was doing this noone would be suggesting an affair, it would be "I dont blame her one bit!". I dont think people realise how insidious and destructive third party interference can be in a marriage. It can be unbearable.

Mylovelygreendress · 17/07/2023 07:13

As the OP hasn’t been back it’s hard to know exactly what has happened.given the very limited information she gave.

User1789 · 17/07/2023 07:10

It is really, really interesting to me (and slightly enraging) that so many people have completely failed to engage with the reason OP has given that her husband has given for walking out: his MIL.

It seems the only legitimate reason for ending a marriage on here is a man with an 'other woman'. Then it is pages and pages of 'don't do the pick me dance,' 'do the freedom programme' etc, but it is quite gobsmacking how many on here find the idea that somebody would end a marriage over interfering in laws odd. It is a very myopic view, and one that seems a little detached from reality.

Babsexxx · 17/07/2023 06:58

You really should of sorted your mum out a while ago this hasn’t manifested over night! Just like mums like to point out mil and “man children” this doesn’t appear any different! I’d like to think he might not be being serious but he could well be!

Outside family members can put a huge strain on relationships when boundaries are crossed and they don’t feel there spouse is really dealing with the main source of the problem aka your mum! She shouldn’t have a opinion on your parenting but I suspect it’s far more than that!

JenWillsiam · 17/07/2023 06:51

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 22:41

Right back at you. DFOD.

What’s a proper normal job?

BrandonFlowersTurkeyTeeth · 17/07/2023 06:29

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 19:03

He works away a lot

At least one in 3 women on this board has a husband that 'works away'. I don't get it and have never come across in real life. He's met another woman, guarantee it, while he's been working away. The argument is a convenient excuse to end it. However if your mother has been interfering and you haven't soundly put her right in her place, you can't blame someone for leaving. Sounds like you needed to go NC with your mother to save your marriage, but I think it's too late now.

Not helpful at all and also a load of crap!

jolaylasofia · 17/07/2023 05:46

@BathroomOnTheRight don't be ridiculous. you can't travel daily to an oil rig lol they get helicopters and work 15 days on 15 off. same those working in petroleum in middle east.
construction workers are sent all around the country for long stints. don't know what cloud you are living on? do all the people you know work in asda or something?

TempleHill · 17/07/2023 04:21

That was precisely my thought when I was reading this.
I am sorry that OP has to go through this. Big Hug
Can you put your foot down and tell your mum to back off from now on?

I have an overbearing IL family. They tried to interfere with our lives but guess what? They can't. DH knows I would vote with my feet like OP's DH. I confronted them first and now on non-talking terms with those who made racist, sexist comments. Thinking back, DH really should have done that without me initiating it.

To all MN who think working away is a red flag. Both DH and I work away a lot and keep two homes. Some colleagues have three. Much nicer than being stuck in a hotel room. Working in multiple locations is unavoidable in many professions.

MysteryBelle · 17/07/2023 03:34

I would be very upset if my husband allowed his mother to dictate or complain about how we manage our own family.

MysteryBelle · 17/07/2023 03:33

No marriage can withstand a third person butting in. Op, you could resolve this, or you could have resolved this long ago, by looking your mother in the eyeballs and telling her, not another word telling my husband or me how to raise our children, it’s not your call.

No reason to have had any arguments at all, have you been relaying to your husband everything your nosy mother has been saying? Foolish. Nip in the bud, why haven’t you?

RLmadmum · 17/07/2023 02:59

Sending you a virtual hug ❤️

Dibbydoos · 17/07/2023 02:18

Hi OP, I'm so sorry you're going through this, I'm sending a big hug x

It might be too late, but I hope it isn't - you need to prioritise your family ahead of your mum.

You need to be crystal with her that her interference has led to your DH leaving you.

Talk to your DH.

Good luck, I hope you can sort this x

WallaceinAnderland · 17/07/2023 01:30

Well, he's voted with his feet that's for sure but it might not be too late. Is it just your mum that's that problem or is there more to it?

Mamanyt · 17/07/2023 00:35

None of my advice will do the least bit of good, so I'm sending you those hugs you needed, lots of them, and over the next several days.

JFDIYOLO · 17/07/2023 00:27

PLEASE can we stop the irrelevant sidewar about men working away? It's not what this thread or the original request is about.

OP whether the evening has improved or not I hope you've had some food, maybe a chat with friends and some sleep and be refreshed tomorrow to make some decisions.

First one is - do you want him back? Is he worth taking back?

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 17/07/2023 00:20

Lots of grand standing here by people critical of a not fully understood situation and doubtful of full facts.

Having had to work away for periods of time to keep food and bills paid- it wasn't a jolly with my mates.
It was lonely in hotel rooms phoning home and feeling you had missed out to do the right thing.

I have had unwanted interference in my family and it boils down to couple making their own decisions.

Maybe the wife is led by her mother, maybe the husband is intolerant-who knows.
Maybe there are mental heath issues 🤔

Whatever happens the children should not be stuck in the middle of a warzone.

Write a letter to each other, don't send it on it's way until you have fully considered the content and not heat of the moment.

Wishing best outcome for children with parents who communicate- whether they are together or not.

swg1 · 17/07/2023 00:14

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 19:18

I wouldn't tolerate a family man working away. If he can't get a normal proper job I'd call it quits. There seems to be a mass epidemic of women on here who have husbands/partners who work away. Most of the time on here, surprise surprise (or not surprise to me) it turns out he was leading two lives. It's bizarre to me. I wouldn't tolerate it and I cannot think of many jobs where it would be legitimately needed to work away except perhaps army/navy, even then I think those jobs aren't conducive to family life so should really only be for single people.

I'd love to see how it went if an army man went in to announce he was quitting due to finding a partner.

swg1 · 17/07/2023 00:12

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 19:50

Where I am they travel to these places, they aren't stupid hours/days away from home so they, like any other worker, drive to and from work. People close to power stations etc... work at the power station. They don't travel hours/days and stay there.

There's entire caravan sites full of workers around Sellafield that say otherwise. Cheap way to live - they buy an old static and live and work there during the week and travel back on weekends. I suspect because of the lack of jobs locally that aren't related to Sellafield.

Cornchip · 17/07/2023 00:08

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 23:02

Of course not every job is 9-5. However there is a difference between long hours, shifts and what have you, and working away for weeks at a time which imo takes the piss and is just a way to out out of family responsibilities. So excuse me for wanting my family unit (speaking in general now) to live as an actual family unit, and not split up. I think when you settle down with a family that's it, you live as a family unit and get a job that enables that. I didn't have children to raise as a part-time single parent while my husband is 'offshore' or 'away' somewhere, and if he couldn't be an equal husband and father our marriage would be over. I would never accept a husband that worked away. Never. He's not a single man anymore. I expect my husband to be there at nights and mornings. As a family unit. So sue me for having a different outlook of what family life looks like. I have a firm and unwielding view of this, formed by friends and people on this site, and it's my opinion. Now I won't reply anymore as I don't want to derail OP's thread, she clearly has enough going on.

Yes, she does have enough going on. She really didn’t need you to have a second recital of how her marriage to her husband is essentially so shit because of his job.

You really don’t know how to read a room, do you?

JFDIYOLO · 17/07/2023 00:07

A lot of readers aren't going to like this but here goes:

There are some jaw dropping accounts here about the behaviour of mothers and mothers in law.

We often hear about 'women with a DH problem', ie when husbands fail to stand up to their mothers.

This may be a man with a DW problem.

Do you side with your mum against him?

Do you just stay quiet instead of speaking up and leave him to be the bad guy?

Does he feel ganged up on? No say in how his children are brought up?

You, your husband and children are a unit. Everyone else is outside the bubble, and having someone encroach in on those boundaries can be very difficult.

If she is an ever present interferer, this never works well.

I think there's a lot more going on here and this is the last straw - it may be that he's had it up to here and is desperate.

My brother finally left when his daughters were grown up after years of interference from MIL and his wife totally sidelining his wishes and needs.

You don't describe him, your marriage etc so no way if knowing if he's worth keeping. Is he a good husband, father, lover? Is he kind, respectful, your soulmate, your friend? Basically - do you want him back? If yes, he's told you he can't do this any more, so 'this' has to change.

Whether he's come home or not, you need urgent talks. Calm, controlled adult conversation. You need a united front, shoulder to shoulder, agreeing your policy and attitude to your mum. And stick to it.

swg1 · 17/07/2023 00:03

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 19:03

He works away a lot

At least one in 3 women on this board has a husband that 'works away'. I don't get it and have never come across in real life. He's met another woman, guarantee it, while he's been working away. The argument is a convenient excuse to end it. However if your mother has been interfering and you haven't soundly put her right in her place, you can't blame someone for leaving. Sounds like you needed to go NC with your mother to save your marriage, but I think it's too late now.

That's more a sign of your economic status than real life. Plenty of people work away. You've got the long distance lorry drivers and the offshore rig workers and you also get people who do building work who frequently travel to wherever the site is. I used to have to travel to London regularly for work and knew that if I got the train there or back at certain points on Mondays or Fridays it would be full of guys who only lived there during the week.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/07/2023 23:47

I'm very sorry OP and have a handhold from me. It's an awful time and whatever happens with your husband and your mum you will be OK. And put the gormless rants about working away from home to one side: these people should know better.

Hugs to you OP, whatever is happening, it shall pass.

fghj149 · 16/07/2023 23:09

Hand hold OP ❤️ my husband has also walked out today after blowing a tiny argument out of proportion once again. It’s not the first time either. Trying to work out whether this is worth it any more.
don’t know what to say but hugs from me xxxx

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 23:02

Cornchip · 16/07/2023 22:53

You are being one though.

How are you so naive to realise that not every single job is a nice little 9-5 Monday to Friday job?

In certain industries, working away is the norm. In other industries, working shifts is the norm. Some jobs involve working night shifts. Others involve working weekends.

The OP hasn’t came on here to complain about her husband working away, so I don’t understand why you think it’s particularly relevant to bring up when OP hasn’t. If OP brings it up later down the thread, that’s fine. People can add in their commentary then. But until OP does, you really do need to stop being so judgemental.

The economy is a tough one at the minute. Many people are having to compromise on what their “ideal” job would be. Some of us don’t get to pick and choose.

But sure, go ahead. I can’t wait to see your plan for only “single” people to be in the armed forces or working off shore. Should pilots be single too? How would you ever get to go on holiday? And what about doctors and nurses? Their hours aren’t overly family friendly- should all doctors and nurses retire as soon as they meet a partner?

You’re delusional.

Of course not every job is 9-5. However there is a difference between long hours, shifts and what have you, and working away for weeks at a time which imo takes the piss and is just a way to out out of family responsibilities. So excuse me for wanting my family unit (speaking in general now) to live as an actual family unit, and not split up. I think when you settle down with a family that's it, you live as a family unit and get a job that enables that. I didn't have children to raise as a part-time single parent while my husband is 'offshore' or 'away' somewhere, and if he couldn't be an equal husband and father our marriage would be over. I would never accept a husband that worked away. Never. He's not a single man anymore. I expect my husband to be there at nights and mornings. As a family unit. So sue me for having a different outlook of what family life looks like. I have a firm and unwielding view of this, formed by friends and people on this site, and it's my opinion. Now I won't reply anymore as I don't want to derail OP's thread, she clearly has enough going on.

Cornchip · 16/07/2023 22:53

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 22:41

Right back at you. DFOD.

You are being one though.

How are you so naive to realise that not every single job is a nice little 9-5 Monday to Friday job?

In certain industries, working away is the norm. In other industries, working shifts is the norm. Some jobs involve working night shifts. Others involve working weekends.

The OP hasn’t came on here to complain about her husband working away, so I don’t understand why you think it’s particularly relevant to bring up when OP hasn’t. If OP brings it up later down the thread, that’s fine. People can add in their commentary then. But until OP does, you really do need to stop being so judgemental.

The economy is a tough one at the minute. Many people are having to compromise on what their “ideal” job would be. Some of us don’t get to pick and choose.

But sure, go ahead. I can’t wait to see your plan for only “single” people to be in the armed forces or working off shore. Should pilots be single too? How would you ever get to go on holiday? And what about doctors and nurses? Their hours aren’t overly family friendly- should all doctors and nurses retire as soon as they meet a partner?

You’re delusional.