Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband has walked out

217 replies

changingmyname143 · 16/07/2023 18:14

Half way through me making dinner. We have been having problems for a while - mostly about (my) overbearing mother. I am trying to hold it together for the children. He works away a lot so "daddy's gone to work" is a feasible line for them. I am just numb and in shock. There's no AIBU here I've just seen similar things posted with people sending virtual hugs. Which I need. I can't call any of my friends til the children are asleep because it's all I can do to hold together

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
changingmyname143 · 18/07/2023 22:38

justasking111 · 17/07/2023 20:53

Aigghh you need to disentangle the child care. Does she sleep over @changingmyname143

Yep. And the cost (£ free) of that is starting to be clear. We can afford to spend more on childcare so we will. All hard but I really do appreciate the perspective this has given me

OP posts:
SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 17/07/2023 23:35

changingmyname143 · 17/07/2023 18:41

Hi - I clocked out last night because despite the many lovely supportive and thoughtful comments (and tough love) there were quite a few harsh ones which I couldn't cope with.
To answer some questions: he didn't walk out when we were all at the table, I was just making dinner. No fuss, no traumatising of the kids etc. it's pretty normal for one or both of us to stay overnight in London for our jobs - one of the reasons that DM is so involved because we rely on her for childcare, she will come and stay as she's retired. He stayed with a friend last night and came back home at lunch and we talked. A LOT. We both want to work through this and have agreed that DM needs to take a step back, and for good. Thank you for all the advice.

Excellent news, keep a regular time for communication, we have a sit down for half an hour every week to see how family are feeling.
Sometimes the weekly rush can seem like the other person is too busy or doesn't care as they juggle life.
We find a meeting makes time, it took reaching breaking point for us to make this change.
Wish you success and happiness

justasking111 · 17/07/2023 20:53

Aigghh you need to disentangle the child care. Does she sleep over @changingmyname143

Exasperatednow · 17/07/2023 19:33

That's really good news. I hope it works out for you.

Isitautumnyet23 · 17/07/2023 19:22

Good news and hope you can work through it and come out as a stronger team. Agree with other suggestions that maybe looking at different childcare would be better in the long run.

Roselilly36 · 17/07/2023 19:21

Wishing you all the best OP Flowers

ilovesooty · 17/07/2023 19:18

That's good news. I hope things work out well for you both.

billy1966 · 17/07/2023 19:17

Glad to read this.

Unfortunately for some, offering generous childcare can get wrapped up in interference, and the price can be too high.

Alternative childcare will be less costly than a split!

Wishing you the best.

Mayhem3 · 17/07/2023 19:09

I’m glad you’ve talked things through.

I would focus on trying to change things so your mum doesn’t need to babysit as often.
The less she’s there, the less she’ll interfere.

It may be worth both or one reducing your hours whilst they’re little so you don’t need childcare as often.

NameChange245 · 17/07/2023 19:06

Glad things are resolving OP 💐

My mum could be a bit of a nightmare! But I remember, in a weird moment of lucid insight that she had never shown before, and has never shown since, she said to me, "if you ever have to pick between me and your DH. Pick your DH".

That's the most thoughtful and least selfish thing I'd ever heard from her, but she was right.

Prioritise your DH. Deep deep down that's what your mum would want too, if she genuinely wants what's best for you

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 17/07/2023 19:03

changingmyname143 · 17/07/2023 18:41

Hi - I clocked out last night because despite the many lovely supportive and thoughtful comments (and tough love) there were quite a few harsh ones which I couldn't cope with.
To answer some questions: he didn't walk out when we were all at the table, I was just making dinner. No fuss, no traumatising of the kids etc. it's pretty normal for one or both of us to stay overnight in London for our jobs - one of the reasons that DM is so involved because we rely on her for childcare, she will come and stay as she's retired. He stayed with a friend last night and came back home at lunch and we talked. A LOT. We both want to work through this and have agreed that DM needs to take a step back, and for good. Thank you for all the advice.

I'm glad you had a good chat. Fair play to you both for doing that.
I think what you need to do now is really listen to him. There are endless posts here about men who won't stand up to their (overbearing) mothers and so the woman walks away. If you want to work through this, you need to be a united front. It might be hard, and cause disagreements with your DM, and be uncomfortable for a while but you need to decide how to move forward together.
It may be difficult as she is your childcare. Is there anything you can compromise on?

ReadingSoManyThreads · 17/07/2023 19:00

@changingmyname143 that's good news. Good luck and I'm glad you're both going to work through it x

weirdoboelady · 17/07/2023 18:58

Great news. Good luck to you both in working things out x

WickedSerious · 17/07/2023 18:52

Good luck OP,I hope your mum can be persuaded to back off.

changingmyname143 · 17/07/2023 18:41

Hi - I clocked out last night because despite the many lovely supportive and thoughtful comments (and tough love) there were quite a few harsh ones which I couldn't cope with.
To answer some questions: he didn't walk out when we were all at the table, I was just making dinner. No fuss, no traumatising of the kids etc. it's pretty normal for one or both of us to stay overnight in London for our jobs - one of the reasons that DM is so involved because we rely on her for childcare, she will come and stay as she's retired. He stayed with a friend last night and came back home at lunch and we talked. A LOT. We both want to work through this and have agreed that DM needs to take a step back, and for good. Thank you for all the advice.

OP posts:
TheHandbag · 17/07/2023 16:06

WickedSerious · 17/07/2023 14:23

I know a woman who made it her mission in life to make sure her daughter stayed single because she was terrified of being asked to move out of the house her daughter(an only child,also an only grandchild)was set to inherit from her grandparents.

It's another form of emotional abuse and coercive control that people won't fully admit to because a woman is responsible. It makes no difference to me whether the abuser is male or female but people should acknowledge that women can do it too. These marriage breakers are dangerous and people should wise up to them fast. They break up families, marriages all for the power trip, very narcissistic!

justasking111 · 17/07/2023 15:14

Well if @changingmyname143 caves into mum and let's him go there's nothing stopping mum from kiboshing partner number two and three. Mummy wants complete control in cases like this.

5128gap · 17/07/2023 14:43

User1789 · 17/07/2023 07:10

It is really, really interesting to me (and slightly enraging) that so many people have completely failed to engage with the reason OP has given that her husband has given for walking out: his MIL.

It seems the only legitimate reason for ending a marriage on here is a man with an 'other woman'. Then it is pages and pages of 'don't do the pick me dance,' 'do the freedom programme' etc, but it is quite gobsmacking how many on here find the idea that somebody would end a marriage over interfering in laws odd. It is a very myopic view, and one that seems a little detached from reality.

You must be on a different thread from me! There's been countless posts telling the OP to put her husband first and blaming her for the situation.
When people want to leave relationships, particularly if that involves leaving their children, they frequently try to absolve themselves of any blame by giving the reason as something their partner (or in this case her mother) has done wrong. Blowing it up out of proportion to excuse themselves.
While this may not be the case, its still a possibility. Yet some posters refuse to consider anything other than taking the husband at his word, and urging the OP to change.
Why should the OP not be offered a range of perspectives to decide for herself what resonates?

WickedSerious · 17/07/2023 14:23

TempleHill · 17/07/2023 14:18

@WickedSerious @TheHandbag
I also know many women who are still single thanks to their mother. It is possible to break free from the cycle. Their siblings put their foot down and don't let their mothers get in their way.

I know a woman who made it her mission in life to make sure her daughter stayed single because she was terrified of being asked to move out of the house her daughter(an only child,also an only grandchild)was set to inherit from her grandparents.

TempleHill · 17/07/2023 14:18

@WickedSerious @TheHandbag
I also know many women who are still single thanks to their mother. It is possible to break free from the cycle. Their siblings put their foot down and don't let their mothers get in their way.

TempleHill · 17/07/2023 14:15

You make me laugh. The majority MN live in a different world as me. They think everyone works in a job in the same location 100% of the time. Many tradespeople need to work away during the week. Do a 6hr a day round trip to the construction site, or stay close the site, or onsite if they really want to save £, and go home in the weekend.

billy1966 · 17/07/2023 11:15

I think if the OP is honest enough to describe her own mother as "overbearing" in the OP, then we can assume her husband does have a point.

She also says that things blow up, her mother backs off, but things then blow up again.

That definitely reads to me as if her mother was overly involved in their marriage.

Parents have absolutely no business telling their children how to raise their grandchildren nor sticking their nose into their childrens families.

The OPs mother has caused stress for a while now and has not been firmly enough told to take her overbearing behaviour away.

Neither me nor my husband would ever tolerate an overbearing parent sticking their nose into our family, not for 5 minutes.

I feel very sorry for the OP, but I think she needs to be very honest with herself about this and what her priorities are.

Is her mother more important than her marriage and her children having a happy dad living with them?

None of my friends would have tolerated such interference in their home like this for a minute.

Conversely, could he be using this as an excuse to leave?
Is this the final straw in an otherwise happy marriage?

TheHandbag · 17/07/2023 11:01

I also know of someone whose mother has broken 2 of his marriages and attempted to break up his sister's relationship until she moved to Australia.

WickedSerious · 17/07/2023 08:01

User1789 · 17/07/2023 07:10

It is really, really interesting to me (and slightly enraging) that so many people have completely failed to engage with the reason OP has given that her husband has given for walking out: his MIL.

It seems the only legitimate reason for ending a marriage on here is a man with an 'other woman'. Then it is pages and pages of 'don't do the pick me dance,' 'do the freedom programme' etc, but it is quite gobsmacking how many on here find the idea that somebody would end a marriage over interfering in laws odd. It is a very myopic view, and one that seems a little detached from reality.

It happens a lot more than some people realise.My nephew couldn't take any more of his MIL's interference so he gave his wife an 'it's me or your mother' ultimatum,she chose her mother.
He's happy with someone else now while his ex MIL is very busy making sure that her daughter remains single and under her control for as long as possible.

I also have a friend whose mother has managed to drive away two husbands

5128gap · 17/07/2023 07:48

My advice OP, is to discount entirely the advice of those people who are telling you to take one side or another, husband or mum. There's a lot of 'stand by your man' going on, but this is very irresponsible from people who know nothing of the character of the people concerned. Mothers from hell exist, but so do controlling unreasonable men who try to estrange their partners fron their families. Who don't treat their children properly leaving mothers feeling they have to say something. Both are extreme and we don't know if either or neither apply here.
We know nothing about your situation and these people other than what you have chosen to tell us. Which really boils down to your mum 'interferes' with the children, which is so vague it could mean anything from saying they shouldn't eat chocolate, to high level ctiticism of his parenting. You have also not told us if you agree with her, which you may well. We don't know.
On the other hand you have a husband who has walked out on you and his children. Perhaps it is indeed the last straw, and you have allowed your mother to behave inappropriately to him. Equally, perhaps he is looking for an excuse. Again we don't know.
The only person to understand this situation is you. Only you know which of the two is the most supportive and caring of you and your children, and has your best interests at heart. If it does come down to a choice, you need to think very carefully about that before severing ties with either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread