Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my 2 y/o watch so much iPad?

133 replies

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 17:47

I’m expecting some flames…and I will listen to it. I know it’s not great. But I’m also curious if people have non-judgemental views about iPad use?

Our DD is nearly 2.5 and watches A LOT of iPad every day. Hours of it. It’s the go-to for her otherwise very present and engaging and loving and affectionate father.

But, here’s the thing…I think she’s actually pretty advanced in language and numeracy. She can name all but 3 or 4 letters of the alphabet (which we haven’t actively taught her). She knows how to count actual objects, up to about 5 or 6 (we’ve taught her this mostly. But it’s been reinforced by YouTube videos). She knows how to say three colours in Spanish (we’ve not taught her this)

She can also now independently type in the first two or three letters of something specific she’s looking for, and choose the correct auto-suggested word from the search list.

She gets lots of other activities and time outside, lots of mummy and daddy time and crafts etc. So we’re not awful parents. I don’t think!

But interested to hear if we’re still rotting her brain and social abilities, or if she’s getting the pay off from so much learning (and evident enjoyment)

runs and ducks for cover

OP posts:
Maireas · 16/07/2023 18:35

@Fairislefandango - a very good point - why more and more schools are banning phones.

Fairislefandango · 16/07/2023 18:32

There is increasing concern that smartphone, internet and social media use are damaging adults' attention spans, mental health and ability to be present and interact fully with the world and people around them, never mind 2 year-olds'. Using devices a lot from such an early age cannot be a good idea.

Helena7319 · 16/07/2023 18:28

Sorry but my view is that this is lazy parenting and is probably effecting your child's development. I'm astounded by the amount of kids I see on their devices in all sorts if scenarios, not interacting or playing. Just sat staring at a screen.
I also think that leaving the volume up in public places is super rude and annoying but that's another issue.

Maireas · 16/07/2023 18:22

She sounds fine, but you're right to think about curtailing it.

babbscrabbs · 16/07/2023 18:18

The guidelines in the USA - which isn't a country I associate with particularly high standards - is an hour max a day until age 6. There are certainly days my DC have done more at that age, but it's the exception not the rule.

Is he also watching it with her?

What is she watching?

What's her posture like while she watches?

I think it really impacts attention especially if short, fast paced videos. You could try some older TV shows which are generally slower, eg sesame street from the 70s.

Kids that age are so soooo easy to entertain in hindsight. They don't need screens for hours (no kids do, to be fair)

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 18:18

Chasetherainblownfearsaway · 16/07/2023 18:11

The go-to entertainment for a 2.5 year old is a park/playground/garden. It's not even that much extra work!

Yes, we do that too. Every day.

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 16/07/2023 18:17

I know that you shouldn't have to help your h but have you considered brainstorming together and coming up with specific tasks that they can do together? For example she can probably help cook meals like breakfast and lunch. For example if you have toast she can pop a slice in the toaster and press the button or she can put a tea bag into the mug or the filling into a sandwich. 2.5 year olds are often happy to help with household chores. She can sort out the cutlery from the dishwasher or help sort the laundry. She'd probably enjoy being handed a sponge to clean the car or do the food shop with him. He could give her a list to hold and have her help point out where items are.

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 18:16

BoohooWoohoo · 16/07/2023 18:11

How are her other areas of development? For example does she walk as far as her peers? How good is she at climbing, riding a bike, scooting? How is her imagination?
I understand why the winter months might mean more screens, especially on weekday evenings when it gets dark so early but this is an age where they are happy to get wet (I am assuming you have some rain where you are) and they are easily impressed with free activities so I'd be making the most of that before the autumn/winter. Entertaining a pre-schooler if you're not used to playing is hard but doing something like going out might be much easier for your h who doesn't sound very engaged at all. What are his interests and hobbies? Can you preschooler join in? Whether it's music or sport, it will do your dd well to broaden her interests.
Im not flaming you but there's a good reason why tech leaders like Jobs and Gates didn't give their kids access to devices until mid teens and they still didn't get hours on it. They know that they are designed to be addictive and the younger they start, the better for those who make money out of it. It's good that she is watching age appropriate content but hours a day is just laziness. Sorry. Is your h even watching with her or is he on his own device watching something else ?

She can walk to and from the shop or park (about a mile and half in total probably - don’t know if that’s as far as her peers do?), her imagination is great as far as I know: she plays “shop” with me, pretends to be a doctor, pretends to be a monster, pretends she’s selling me ice cream or making me soup! Lots of imaginative play, and she describes it all to me in full sentences.

She loves her scooter and climbing everything. She would love to have a go on a bike but she doesn’t have one yet.

She loves to sing nursery rhymes and dance as well. She’s defitnley not neglected!

but I do hear you all. It’s not good for her. I think I just need extra incentive and evidence to have the chat with her father as we curtail it.

OP posts:
Freepo · 16/07/2023 18:16

Wisterical · 16/07/2023 17:51

@Freepo oh come on, it's neither irrational nor sanctimonious to think a toddler should not have hours of screen time every day.

Never said it was, but the tone of some comments on such threads often is - saw one recently where someone said cocomelon was literally rotting children’s brains

FilthyforFirth · 16/07/2023 18:16

Yabu. I have a 2.5 year old and no way would he be getting any tablet time, especially not for hours a day. Sorry you aaked, it's just awful.

At 2.5 does it really matter that she can identify different colours or know's the alphabet? She should be playing and learning about the world around her through play. There is plenty of time for the academic stuff.

Hard judge from me, sorry!

Housenoob · 16/07/2023 18:13

But how many hours on average? 2 or 10? Makes a big difference

Chasetherainblownfearsaway · 16/07/2023 18:11

The go-to entertainment for a 2.5 year old is a park/playground/garden. It's not even that much extra work!

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 18:11

Jubaju · 16/07/2023 18:09

Does she watch tv too or is just iPad for hours a day?

Ironically, very little - if any - TV.

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 16/07/2023 18:11

How are her other areas of development? For example does she walk as far as her peers? How good is she at climbing, riding a bike, scooting? How is her imagination?
I understand why the winter months might mean more screens, especially on weekday evenings when it gets dark so early but this is an age where they are happy to get wet (I am assuming you have some rain where you are) and they are easily impressed with free activities so I'd be making the most of that before the autumn/winter. Entertaining a pre-schooler if you're not used to playing is hard but doing something like going out might be much easier for your h who doesn't sound very engaged at all. What are his interests and hobbies? Can you preschooler join in? Whether it's music or sport, it will do your dd well to broaden her interests.
Im not flaming you but there's a good reason why tech leaders like Jobs and Gates didn't give their kids access to devices until mid teens and they still didn't get hours on it. They know that they are designed to be addictive and the younger they start, the better for those who make money out of it. It's good that she is watching age appropriate content but hours a day is just laziness. Sorry. Is your h even watching with her or is he on his own device watching something else ?

Jubaju · 16/07/2023 18:09

Does she watch tv too or is just iPad for hours a day?

almostoverthehill · 16/07/2023 18:03

What ever happened to books 🤷🏻‍♀️

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 18:03

Lostthetastefordahlias · 16/07/2023 17:59

Is it because her father thinks he either has to directly entertain her or put the tv on? Can you teach him how to involve her in normal life, getting things done alongside her, encouraging independent play by setting out interesting toys, having quiet time so they can both rest etc? Not that you should have to but I found this didn’t come as naturally to DH as me (having been on mat leave) & once he got the hang of it he didnt need the tv so much.

This is EXACTLY it. He’s a wonderful father and loves spending time with her. But thinking of ways to spend time with her doesn’t come as naturally to him as it does to me. They either have to be actually “doing” something (park, museum, class etc) or it’s the iPad. There’s not much in between with him.

Whereas she’ll happily potter about the supermarket with me, I’ll be gardening and she’ll be playing nearby. She and I will do some drawing or crafting or imaginative games together etc. it’s just easy for me. Not so much for him.

OP posts:
MisschiefMaker · 16/07/2023 18:02

The huge problem is attention span. Screens give you all these quick endorphin hits and train your brain to expect quick wins every few seconds. You are damaging her brain's ability to function well over the long term. It's an awful, awful thing to do to a young child.

It is also true that the programs can be educational but that doesn't balance out the damage that they do.

QueenOfWeeds · 16/07/2023 18:01

Of course there are educational ways to use it, but the time limitations suggested aren’t just about stimulation and brain development - there is also research into the impact on children’s eyesight and certainly (anecdotally) the school I work in, and colleagues in other schools, see a correlation between very poor distance vision and the amount of time spent looking at a close screen like a phone or tablet.

Hermione101 · 16/07/2023 18:00

None of these “advances” actually matter at her age though. My 6-year old uses it as an adjunct to learning (about 20 minutes a day) and only started using it at home this year. The lack of an iPad when he was younger hasn’t hampered his leaning in any way.

My concern would be your DD’s default on using it as entertainment, she will probably use it more for that as she gets older to the exclusion of other activities if her time isn’t limited now.

Hugasauras · 16/07/2023 18:00

'It’s the go-to for her otherwise very present and engaging and loving and affectionate father.'

Can you see the oxymoron in this statement? Hours in front of the iPad is the go-to for an engaging parent?

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 17:59

Brk · 16/07/2023 17:56

Yes. Screentime (ipad and tv) does something weird to young children. If mine have more than an hr a day they become bad tempered, rude and over-emotional. All of my friends and relatives have noticed the same as their children. You won’t get information on that from google though, because google is swamped with sponsored ‘articles’ by the tech companies saying it’s all fine 🤦‍♀️ However the World Health Organisation recommends no more than an hour per day, and they do so for a reason.

I don’t know if it’s because of the constant fast-paced images going into their brain at a pace they can’t control, or if it’s merely because hours of screentime is hours of missed real world two-way social interaction, but either way; yes, it is damaging to give a lot of screentime to young children.

Sure your kid may learn the alphabet/numbers faster, but that isn’t important at this age, what you want is healthy brain growth and emotional development and hours of screentime is not going to give that.

That’s a useful and measured response, thank you.

OP posts:
Lostthetastefordahlias · 16/07/2023 17:59

Is it because her father thinks he either has to directly entertain her or put the tv on? Can you teach him how to involve her in normal life, getting things done alongside her, encouraging independent play by setting out interesting toys, having quiet time so they can both rest etc? Not that you should have to but I found this didn’t come as naturally to DH as me (having been on mat leave) & once he got the hang of it he didnt need the tv so much.

FlowersInTheSky · 16/07/2023 17:59

This is absolutely unacceptable. Why would you allow this? Because it keeps her quieter so you have an easier life?

I have a 2.5 year old too. There’s no way I would even dream of letting her have a tablet yet, let alone use it for hours every day.

wholivesondrurylane · 16/07/2023 17:59

I don't know, I never let mine until they started Primary school, partly for lazy reason, because they don't miss what they don't know so we never had argument about screen or tablet. They didn't seem behind any one else.

If you like them using the tablet, it's your call. I don't believe the educational aspect, kids without screens know just as much and learn just as quickly.

We keep complaining that kids start school far too early, but some parent seem keen on pushing their children to know how to read, write and count as early as possible, it's weird. The others catch up quickly in reception.

Swipe left for the next trending thread